Amazon.com Widgets

Friday, November 30, 2007

Or, 'How Federman visited a War Zone and couldn't figure out why there were walls everywhere.'

Local Jewish Voice for Peace leader, Marty Federman, the "religious Jew" who spent a recent Sabbath denouncing Israel and has his letters published in the local Jewish Advocate on a regular basis far out of proportion to the percentage of Jewish opinion he represents, was recently on a trip to Israel with a "Cambridge delegation" and has had his journals published online starting here: Marty Federman's 2007 Visit Journal - Entry # 1. He must have been travelling with some nefarious characters as he expresses surprise that more of them weren't delayed entering the country.

...The plane was not full so I had empty seats on both sides of me and basically read the Sunday Times and slept a little. The only other thought of note. A few rows behind me, across the aisle, was a noticeably Jewish family (the father had a medium length beard and a large knit Kippah (Yarmulke/Skullcap). 38 years ago I would have felt an instant bond with this family, all of us going to Israel. This time – and I have to be careful about how I say this – I’ve spent the last many years speaking out against making judgments about people based on stereotypes and looks – but the sad truth is that I not only felt no desire to "bond" with these fellow-Jews, but could not help but wonder what they would think if they knew why I was going to "Ha’aretz" and what I would be doing when I got there. And even as I type these words my innate paranoia makes me wonder what my entry this time will be like if, somehow, someone at Ben Gurion Airport was actually able to access this entry...

In fact, Federman was given a bit of extra attention when he got there. Maybe on his next trip he'll get a bit more. Lots of talk about walls and difficulties, no talk at all about the reasons the walls (a recent phenomenon) were built.

From Part 4:

...Marwan goes off at one point stressing that when they talk about Israelis or Zionists they do not confuse that with "Jews." They have, he tells us, no problem with Jews, his problem is with Israelis and (this, I thought, was insightful) although they sometimes may talk about what the "Jews" are doing to them, they don’t mean Jews as in those who follow Judaism, they mean Israelis. We don’t spend any time talking about how Israeli leadership and the institutional Jewish community in the U.S. have conflated the two for their own tactical reasons and then shout "anti-Semite" when the other side blames "Jews."...

It's only those uppity-Jews they have a problem with -- Jews who have the temerity to express the same nationalist aspirations as anyone else. It never occurs that what he's really saying in being against "Zionists," is that he's (and many others that Federman meets) against the existance of the state next door. Zion's existence, after all, is no longer theoretical. And that his desire to see that state destroyed leads he and his neighbors, even if they themselves don't throw the bombs, to sit back and do nothing when others do the dirty work for them. And so the wall goes up, and these guys pose as peaceniks to useful tools just because they personally don't pull the trigger.

No wonder they're suffering. They're in the middle of war they're doing nothing to stop.

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Marty's Adventures in Wonderland.

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.solomonia.com/cgi-bin/mt4/mt-renamedtb.cgi/13778

The local Jewish Advocate newspaper has done a front page story on the Boston Globe email scandal that Hillel Stavis broke here a couple of weeks ago. See: Emails Reveal: Boston Globe Reporter Sucks Up to the Cambridge Peace Commission.... Read More

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Search


Archives
[an error occurred while processing this directive] [an error occurred while processing this directive]