Amazon.com Widgets

Friday, January 11, 2008

Too controversial? Feminist Magazine Rejects Ad Featuring Israeli Women

Jewish leaders are reeling after what they say was a decision by Ms. magazine to refuse to accept a full-page advertisement featuring three prominent Israeli women. The advertisement, submitted to the feminist publication by the American Jewish Congress, featured photographs of three women who hold leadership positions in Israel, including the president of the Israeli Supreme Court, Dorit Beinisch; Israel's foreign minister, Tzipi Livni, and speaker of the Knesset, Dalia Itzik. Underneath the photographs, the advertisement included the text, "This is Israel."

Officials from the American Jewish Congress said they were shocked by the magazine's decision, which they said amounted to anti-Israel sentiment.

"For a magazine that I believe has stood for empowerment and supporting women in high positions of society, it was just stunning," the group's president, Richard Gordon, said. "Clearly, there is an anti-Israel sentiment here that is being exhibited, because there is no other possible rationale for making a decision like this."

The magazine's executive editor, Kathy Spillar, offered a different reason in an interview with the Jewish Telegraphic Agency. She said that because two of the women photographed belong to the same political party, the advertisement showed favoritism. She added that an upcoming issue would feature a two-page profile of Ms. Livni. Officials at the American Jewish Congress said they conceived of the advertisement this past fall, when a member of its board suggested the group publicize the accomplishments of the three women. They first contacted the magazine in October about placing the advertisement, and they were working on its final details in mid-November when the magazine decided against running it...

Lame excuse. Tzipi Livni isn't exceptional because she's a prominent female Israeli figure, Israel is exceptional in her region because females are prominent (and in Israel, their gender is unexceptional). [h/t: Fred]

Update: Here's the ad [PDF] and the America Jewish Congress's report.

3 Comments

So... does anyone READ Ms Magazine? I haven't seen it for years. Until I started seeing this pop up all over the place today - I didn't even know it was still being published.

This might be the reason I lost interest in it nearly immediately when it was first published. They are putting out a very narrow magazine aimed at some very narrow minded people. With limited narrow minded content. It's probably better for the American Jewish Congress that Ms. didn't take the ad. What a waste of money it would've been.

On the one hand, "The Lebanese government has apparently blocked the Beirut-based Daily Star from running the Simon Wiesenthal Center’s advertisement, which calls for the United Nations General Assembly to convene a special session on suicide terror."

On the other hand,

"Ms. magazine ... refuse to accept a full-page advertisement featuring three prominent Israeli women... the advertisement included the text "This is Israel."

This illustrates perfectly the quote I use on my blog's heading:

"Capitulation to dogma over open inquiry leads to the very totalitarianism that the proponents of dogmatism most fear--thus we have the book-burners of both left and right joined in common cause."

I want to state the obvious, just for the record:

1) The editors of Ms. know that their true motivations for refusing to take this ad are unacceptable, hence the sorry excuse.

2) That true motivation, the primary one, is fear of backlash from the left-lib political elites.

3) It follows that saying anything positive about Israel is now literally taboo in those circles.

4) Taboo is sexy. It should be possible to work something positive out of this dynamic.

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Search


Archives
[an error occurred while processing this directive] [an error occurred while processing this directive]