Thursday, March 20, 2008
Roz Rothstein, director of StandWithUs was in Geneva yesterday, testifying before the UN Human Rights Council on behalf of UN Watch. She had three minutes to speak, but Egypt and Iran couldn't let her get through it without choking. I guess she must have been saying something right.
[I'll be updating this post later when video is available.]
Via email, yesterday, from StandWithUs:
Each representative has 3 minutes to make their presentation.
On Monday, Arab countries defended the government of Sudan, and praised it for coming a long way in dealing with the genocide in Darfur. The EU countries, the US and including Canada challenged the notion that the Sudan is doing "enough".
In testimony today, Rothstein provoked the ire of Egypt and Iran when she addressed issues of racism in Darfur and Holocaust denial by Iran's President Ahmadinejad.
Rothstein's speech was interrupted by an objection from the Egyptian representative, a leader in the Arab and African blocs, after she dared to mention the killings in Darfur. The President allowed her to continue. When she resumed speaking, her mention of anti-Semitism by Iran's leader was quickly interrupted by the Iranian envoy, who formally objected to any mention of Iran on a discussion of racism.
As a result of the repeated objections and the chairman's caution, Rothstein was denied the right to read her section on the anti-Semitic incitement of Hamas and Hezbollah and the murder of 8 students from Jerusalem while Hamas distributed candy in Gaza. However, the full written statement will form part of the official U.N. record. Interruptions of NGO statements are rare, and generally indicate acute sensitivity on the part of the objecting party.
"What we saw today from Iran is that the truth hurts," said Hillel Neuer, UN Watch executive director. "Our statement dared to speak truth to power. It is a sad day for free speech and the founding principles of the United Nations when NGOs are denied the right to name racists in a debate supposedly dedicated to the subject of racism."
Here is her speech and where it was interrupted:
UN Watch Oral Statement Agenda Item 9: Review of Mandate of UN Special Rapporteur on Racism Doudou Diène
As a representative of UN WATCH, Roz Rothstein, international director and CEO of StandWithUs gave the following speech today, March 19, 2008
Thank you, Mr. President.
We strongly support renewing the mandate against racism. We wish to address the draft resolution that is before us.
For me, the issue of racism is not academic. My parents survived the Nazi Holocaust. Eighty of my relatives were murdered.
Mr. President, I know what racism, hatred and anti-Semitism can lead to. What began with racist words, ended with genocide.
The United Nations and its Commission on Human Rights were created to prevent such evil from ever happening again. Tragically, however, it has happened-in Cambodia, Rwanda, and today in Darfur.
(INTERRUPTION BY EGYPT)
Equally, the evil of anti-Semitism continues to rear its ugly head, and it is rightly addressed in the proposed resolution. There are many examples. Iran's President Ahmadinejad actively promotes Holocaust denial, and calls for eliminating the Jewish state. We salute the expert on racism for condemning this.
Hamas and Hezbollah, (INTERRUPTION BY IRAN)
DID NOT READ THE FOLLOWING: (UN WATCH stopped her due to fear of another interruption which would shut down the remainder of her speech)
Hamas and Hezbollah however, systematically promote the same kind of genocidal
anti-Semitism in their sermons, websites and media broadcasts. A terrorist translated this incitement into deed in Jerusalem two weeks ago, murdering eight young Jewish students in a religious school.
And in Gaza, the Hamas government-whose Charter openly advocates killing Jews and destroying the Jewish state-passed out candy to celebrate.
RESUMED HERE:
Organizations such as Stand With Us are doing vital work to educate against hatred. But the UN, and all nations gathered here, must do more to fight words that kill.
At Durban in 2001, a conference meant to combat racism saw some of the worst displays of anti-Semitism since the Holocaust. Leaflets were distributed with Hitler's picture, calling for the destruction of Israel.
As this Council prepares the 2009 follow-up conference, its noble goals must not be hijacked by the forces of intolerance. Nations must rise to defeat words that kill.
For all these reasons, we support a strong mandate to combat racism.
Thank you, Mr. President.