Tuesday, August 11, 2009
Another front page piece about the Israeli Consul's leaked letter: Israeli minister rebukes consul
Israel's foreign minister said yesterday that the consul general in Boston should resign if he can't support Israeli government policies - but stopped short of saying he would fire Nadav Tamir over his internal memo criticizing his country's approach to US relations.
Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman, speaking in Jerusalem, was quoted as telling a meeting of officials in the Foreign Ministry that "if someone is not happy and can't live with government policy, the way is not to criticize and leak but to resign. With all due respect to the consul . . . it is not his job to express political positions.''
Lieberman has ordered Tamir to return to Israel this week to explain his memo critical of Israel's handling of its relations with the United States, which caused a firestorm in Israel after it was leaked to the media last week. Lieberman faults Tamir not only for the content of the memo but for distributing it internally, making it all but certain to be leaked.
It was evident that Tamir, who is respected by mainstream Jewish groups in Boston as well as colleagues in Israel's foreign ministry, has become entangled in a larger debate among Jews in Israel and the United States over which country is responsible for the growing tensions between them...
The Globe editorial board, not surprisingly, comes out on Tamir's side: Called out for telling the truth.
They also quote from several blogs in the VoxPop section of the Opinion page, including Jonathan Tobin, Carl in Jerusalem and Richard Silverstein who continues to earn undeserved fame for what Alan Dershowitz has called "the talking dog" factor (Why do so many Israel-hating Israelis and Jews get so much attention? They're oddities...the equivalent of talking dogs.)
With a tip of the hat to Hillel Stavis, with whom I just discussed this, this little episode is revealing of the true dual loyalties factor. The dual loyalty is not a tension between loyalty to Israel and loyalty to America -- I've never felt the two at odds -- the real dual loyalties many American Jews are increasingly having to wrestle with is with their identity as Jews and supporters of Israel on the one hand, and their loyalty to the Democratic Party on the other. That's the true dual loyalties question of our time, and we're seeing where many of our leaders are falling out. Their quotes are all over the Boston Globe.
Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Front Page Nadav Tamir Flap Continues.
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.solomonia.com/cgi-bin/mt4/mt-renamedtb.cgi/16710
So says that story in the North Shore Jewish Journal: Consul General Reaches Out to Constituents After Memo Flap The uproar over Israeli Consul General Nadav Tamir's leaked three-page memo in which he criticizes the Netanyahu government blew over more... Read More