Saturday, January 23, 2010
Via various emailers, the New York Times reports that Israel's official response to the Goldstone Report is finally nearing completion: Israel Poised to Challenge U.N. Report on Gaza
The Israeli military is completing a rebuttal to a United Nations report accusing it of grave violations of international and humanitarian law in its Gaza invasion a year ago. Its central aim is to dispel the report's harsh conclusion -- that the death of noncombatants and destruction of civilian infrastructure were part of an official plan to terrorize the Palestinian population...
...Maj. Gen. Avichai Mandelblit, the Israeli military advocate general, said in an interview that those assertions went beyond anything of which others had accused Israel.
"I have read every report, from Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International, the Arab League," he said at his desk in the military's Tel Aviv headquarters. "We ourselves set up investigations into 140 complaints. It is when you read these other reports and complaints that you realize how truly vicious the Goldstone report is. He made it look like we set out to go after the economic infrastructure and civilians, that it was intentional. It's a vicious lie."...
How over-the-top was the report? Even the usual suspects think it went too far:
While many here think that the Goldstone report failed to expose of the practices of Hamas, they are more concerned about their own army's conduct. Still, virtually no one in Israel, including the leaders of Breaking the Silence and the human rights group B'Tselem, thinks that the Goldstone accusation of an assault on civilians is correct.
"I do not accept the Goldstone conclusion of a systematic attack on civilian infrastructure," said Yael Stein, research director of B'Tselem. "It is not convincing. But every incident and every policy has to be checked by an independent body because the military cannot check itself. They need to explain why so many people were killed."
It's taking a long while, but the result should be good to read. Fortunately, this time, Israel has had some very serious friends doing a bang-up job responding with publicly available information: Understanding the Goldstone Report.