Wednesday, February 10, 2010
Sorry, I couldn't quite decide on which of Col. Travers' statements are the most outrageous. The fact that this guy was one of the four principals of the report betrays once again how wicked it was from the start. Here are some highlights: New Revelations About the UN Goldstone Report that Seriously Undermine its Credibility
Col. (ret.) Desmond Travers was one of the four members of the UN Fact Finding Mission that produced what is widely called the Goldstone Report. The Mission investigated Operation Cast Lead in the Gaza Strip between December 27, 2008 and January 18, 2009. Travers joined the Irish Defense Forces in 1961 and retired after forty years. As the only former officer who belonged to Justice Richard Goldstone's team, he was the senior figure responsible for the military analysis that provided the basis for condemning Israel for war crimes.
After following his repeated public appearances with the other mission members in July 2009, and especially in light of his most recent interviews, serious flaws have now become evident in the methodology he followed, in his collection and processing of data, and in the conclusions he draws. In the past, the flaws in the Goldstone report, and especially its lack of balance, have been criticized by the London Times, the Washington Post, the Wall Street Journal, and the Economist, but the fundamental problems of its military analysis have not been fully addressed. In the material presented
here, this becomes evident in four specific ways:
1. A Fundamental Bias against the Israel Defense Forces
During the Mission's collection of testimonies from Palestinian psychologists in the Gaza Strip, Travers asked them straight out to explain how Israeli soldiers could kill Palestinian children in front of their parents. In an interview with Middle East Monitor, on February 2, 2010, he asserted that in the past Israeli soldiers had "taken out and deliberately shot" Irish peacekeeping forces in Southern Lebanon. Both of these statements by Travers are completely false. It should be stressed that one of the most vicious and unsubstantiated conclusions in the Goldstone Report is the suggestion that Israel deliberately killed Palestinian civilians...
...Travers comes up with a story that the IDF had unmanned aerial vehicles (UAV's) that could obtain a "thermal signature" on a Gaza house and detect that there were large numbers of people inside. Incredibly, he then suggests that with this information that certain houses were "packed with people," the Israeli military would then deliberately order a missile strike on these populated homes. The primary technical problem with his theory is that Israel does not have UAV's that can see though houses and pick up a thermal signature. More importantly, Israel used UAV's to monitor that Palestinian civilians left houses that had received multiple warnings, precisely because Israel sought to minimize civilian casualties, a fact that Travers could not fathom, because of his own clear biases...
There's more, but here's the predictable:
...Travers most recent interview also had a disturbing additional element. When addressing the role of British officers in defending Israel's claims, Travers suddenly adds: "Britain's foreign policy interests in the Middle East seem to be influenced strongly by Jewish lobbyists." Travers implies that British Jews have interests that differ from Britain's own national interests and that Prime Minister Gordon Brown's government is influenced by these considerations. This statement, unless corrected, places Travers is a position in which his views are suspect of being motivated by anti-Semitic prejudices. Even without this last statement, he clearly emerges as an individual who is not qualified to take part in any serious fact-finding mission and the U.N. should not seek his services in the future...
Also see Haaretz: Goldstone co-author: Hamas fired 'something like two' rockets before Gaza war
Update: David Bernstein at Volokh: Goldstone Report Co-Author is a Nutter?
...Here's the full text of the interview [PDF] from which these quotes are derived. All the quotes check out, but the quotes recounted above don't begin to illustrate Travers's hatred of Israel, unwillingness to credit anything Israel says or question any Hamas assertions, and general nuttiness. To get the full sense of it, you have to read the whole thing. For example, did you know that there is no evidence that Hamas used human shields or intimidated the civilian population? In fact, according to Travers, any such allegations are likely an artifact of "Israeli combat troops specially trained to operate in the Occupied Palestinian Territories in civilian attire. They worked as 'franc-tireurs' (literally 'free shooters') and could have been in a position to cause confusion among the population."...
Update2 from Sophia: Who knew? And here we have been imagining that thousands of rockets have hit Israel in the past few years, dozens on Christmas Eve alone!
All that scrap metal from the sky must have been an illusion! And likewise the explosions, the sirens, the traumatized children, the dead people, the injured animals, the bomb shelters, the burning fields - all a dream! Like Tevya's imaginary vision of the graveyard in "Fiddler On the Roof!"
Oh those silly Israelis.
Or maybe, Desmond Travers, a retired Irish army colonel meant to say, 2 rockets in the last 10 minutes before the war? Or something?
...He's also claims that "Jewish lobbyists" have influenced British foreign policy and "doesn't believe" Israeli photographs showing weapons storage in Gaza mosques.
Wow. The Goldstone Report looks more objective all the time!