Saturday, July 24, 2010
I finally had a chance to watch the video of the entire event, as the Muslim American Society/Islamic Society of Boston's M. Bilal Kaleem took on M. Zuhdi Jasser of the American Islamic Forum for Democracy at the Ford Hall Forum and I'm glad I did. Jasser is terrific and understands exactly what the problems are that need to be faced as Islam comes to America. Highly recommended. Here is the entire debate:
If you wish to watch at YouTube, click here to start with Part 1. Jasser begins his remarks in Part 5 if you want to skip right to that.
James Carroll is the moderator but don't let that deter you. He's fine here.
The debate is amicable enough, but Dr. Jasser doesn't hesitate to call out MAS's Kaleem on what he feels are their failings. Jasser gets to the heart of the matter, aiming his remarks as an internal criticism of Islam's issues, while Kaleem's remarks on the wonderful ecumenical truths of Islam would be better suited to a sermon in some of Islam's less enlightened places (the spots that really need the lessons in Islam's tolerant nature). In this situation and before this audience his remarks simply serve to avoid the issues -- issues Jasser goes to with razor efficiency. Considering Kaleem's organization, not Jasser's, just built the Northeast's biggest mosque, this is a little bit disturbing.
Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Video: "A Modern Islam?" (Boston's Ford Hall Forum- April 22, 2010) - Bilal Kaleem vs. Zuhdi Jasser.
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.solomonia.com/cgi-bin/mt4/mt-renamedtb.cgi/18385
Boy am I behind. Sorry for the lack of posts yesterday and into today? Miss me? (Don't answer.) You won't mind if the next few entries are more link than comment, OK? Hot on the heels of the release of... Read More
Martin - are you aware of an MP3 for the audio only? I find it difficult to watch these sequential videos. I like to listen to these things on my one-hour commute. (Ugh!)
Thoughts?
Allan
No, I don't know. I wouldn't be surprised if there were a fairly easy way to extract the audio from the downloaded video (using the RealPlayer plugin for instance), but I'm not sure because I've never done it.