Thursday, May 1, 2003
Clifford D. May on Abu Mazen on National Review Online
Skipping down a bit:
If it's the latter, what does he think would be more effective?
In his Tuesday inaugural, Mazen emphasized "the importance of the question of refugees … we are speaking of millions of Palestinian refuges around the world." He added that a "solution to the refugee problem consistent with international law (particularly U.N. Resolution 194) will be the basis of peace and coexistence."
That's a reference to the "right of return" which is code for the destruction of Israel by demographic means. Under Resolution 194, "refugees wishing to return to their homes and live at peace with their neighbors should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date."
If Israel were to accept that, there would be an influx of — as Mazen says — "millions of Palestinian refugees" demanding Israeli land and citizenship. Israelis would become a minority in their own country. Israel would cease to be a Jewish state — and, in fact, would cease to exist.
It's unlikely that Abu Mazen will have a difficult time persuading the U.N., the European Union, and Russia — three of the four members of the "Quartet" that is meant to orchestrate the peace process — to support this formula. None of those entities have been anything but hostile toward Israel for years. (Significantly, they've been decreasingly cordial to the U.S. as well.)
But it is impossible to imagine Ariel Sharon or any other Israeli leader regarding Abu Mazen's proposal as anything but surrender — not least because roughly half Israel's people are Mizrahis, Jews (or the children of Jews) who fled oppression in the Arab countries they had called home for centuries.
According to early reports, the "Road Map" presented Wednesday to Abu Mazen and Sharon does not mention Resolution 194. Nevertheless, it would useful if President Bush were to make clear to Abu Mazen and the Quartet that if they see Arab immigration into Israel as the path to "peace," they are heading for a dead end.
Damn right. If anyone thinks millions of Arabs are going to be welcomed to stream back into Israel to live (where?), they ought to have their heads examined.
Dead end indeed.