Monday, October 6, 2003
A reader has sent the following letter to NPR and forwarded me a copy. This brings up the issue of Western journalists' use of sources and voices who live in societies where speech is not protected, and either failing to inform the audience of the fact, or failing to provide any voice in counterpoint. The news consumer needs to be so very savvy these days. It's very dangerous to let any particular program or even a particular source inform one's views.
Despite my google skills I cannot find the names of the murdered editors.
Contemporary discussion of Lebanese press freedom seems to be about minor trivia in a system that is entirely subservient to the Syrian secret police.
===
Dear Ms. Wertheimer:
Sunday morning 10/5/03 you interviewed Ziad Haidar, a Lebanese "journalist" based in Damascus.
As you surely must know, the free lebanese press was annihilated in the 1970's by Syrian secret police/Ba'ath party death squads that operated with impunity inside Lebanon in the period immediately preceeding that country's civil war.
In particular, the two leading moderate democratic newspaper editors/publishers--pillars of Lebanon's multi-cultural society-- were abducted and tortured to death. And unlike the situation in Argentina, where the torturers carefully concealed their crimes out of concern for world opinion, the Syrian death squads actually advertised their unspeakable actions. They dumped the bodies in downtown Beirut so that the marks of torture were plain for all to see. The rest of the press had to chose either flight or collaboration.
And now a generation later, here you are on NPR stepping over the mutilated bodies of those editors so you can interview one of the collaborators. By presenting this Quisling to your listeners as a free journalist you create a grossly misleading impression of Arab society, and you defile the memory of those Lebanese editors who gave their lives for freedom of the press.
Addendum:
Before I could finish composing this letter, you did it again. Bob Edwards interviewed Rami Khouri--an EDITOR in Beirut. No doubt these Lebanese "journalists" are articulate, urbane and seemingly moderate.
And this apparently is sufficient for you to ignore the fact that they serve at the pleasure of those who butchered their predecessors in full view of the world press.
-[x]
Salem, Oregon
My own Googling turned up the following interesting item from CAMERA which also provides some informative reading.
In the Palestinians’ Pocket: Journalists doing PR for the PA:
Cristiano asked that Palestinians be informed that it was a rival Italian network, the privately owned Mediaset, that had shot and broadcast the footage. He assured the PA that his network would never act in such a way:[...]