Friday, April 22, 2005
A sad day. You knew they were going to do it.
Israel universities - statement by AUT general secretary Sally Hunt
The executive committee will issue guidance to AUT members on these decisions.
Council delegates also referred a call to boycott the Hebrew University of Jerusalem and the executive committee will investigate the background to this and will report in due course.
Council delegates also agreed to circulate to all local associations a statement from Palestinian organisations calling for an academic boycott of Israeli institutions.
Despicable, but I'll be honest, there isn't a lot the rest of us can really do about it but prattle on is there? The ball is really quite firmly in academia's court now isn't it? What are the UK professoriat who didn't agree going to do about this? What are their American colleagues going to do about it? Do actions have consequences? Will the AUT feel any? Where are all those who screamed on and on about the likes of Ward Churchill to offend and countenance murder? Will they speak out now for academic freedom? What am I bet? Some of those people too afraid to take a stand are going to have to say something. Silence=Death.
At least someone's speaking up:
Don't Boycott Israeli Universities: Academics Sign Letter of Protest
ADL: Decision of British Academics to Boycott Israeli Universities 'Misguided and Ill-Timed'
"The Association of University Teachers has launched a direct assault on academic freedom," said Abraham H. Foxman, ADL National Director. "We condemn this misguided and ill-timed decision to boycott academics from the only country in the Middle East where universities enjoy political independence. It is ironic that the British academics called for an end to dialogue at a time when Israelis and Palestinians are engaged in dialogue seeking a framework for peace...
At a time when the Israeli Government is expending tremendous political capital to withdraw from Gaza and offering concessions and a continued willingness to facilitate a Palestinian State in the West bank, these efforts (like those of the PC(USA) and others) strike me as being akin to the Soviet Union declaring war on Japan the day after the Hiroshima Bomb was dropped. At least Stalin figured to get something for his efforts (territory), it didn't emanate in particular from something darker and more sinister as with these people.
Update: Norm points out this piece - in The Guardian of all places: The sins of the few (worth reading in full)
Miriam, whom I've known for many years, is the former head of Amnesty International in Israel and a well-known peace activist. Baker, by the way, was not the first to call for a boycott of her academic work. Israeli rightwingers had been irked by her signature on some petition and had called upon students at Israeli universities to refrain from attending classes given by her and others of her ilk. Unlike Baker, they at least had a case: they wanted to boycott Miriam because of her views...
...Which brings me back to the question that has bothered me ever since I was a kid. Why did the god of the Hebrews (and for the sake of disclosure, I'm a Hebrew myself) smite the first-born of Egypt? The answer that I've come up with is not very flattering: I think he did it mainly because he was lazy, wrathful and just. Lazy, because instead of trying to work out a reasonable solution and finding out who was really to blame, he opted for the easy way out. Wrathful, because it's no fun discovering that your Chosen People have been dispossessed and oppressed. And just, because he is God, and Gods, like so many academics I've met in my life, are always just - or at least, they're always convinced they are.
BTW, remind me. How many universities were there in Gaza and the West Bank prior to 1967?
At Mona Baker's website you can find a page with notable quotes.
One of the quotes of Ariel Sharon is the blatantly false propaganda quote where he supposedly says (paraphrased) "don't worry about the United States we own them" etc...
If life is just this will only come back to haunt this hypocrite...
We'll be asking if she's going to boycott Egyptian Universities for playing the Protocols, or Chinese Unis for torturing political prisoners and Christians, Russian Universities for the conflict in Chechnya, Syria Universities for the Protocols playing on television and for being a police state?
OH, one could go on and on...
Is she boycotting Pali Universities like the main one, for teaching rejecitonism, irredentism and terror? for making displays glorifying suicide bombings with Jewish bodyparts hanging out of it?