Amazon.com Widgets

Saturday, May 7, 2005

The group pushing for divestment in the city of Somerville, Massachusetts (see many entries by searching for Somerville in the box at left) is back at it again, in spite of having their first try voted down by the city's Board of Aldermen - now they're resurrecting the effort as a ballot initiative. And I thought Leftists were supposed to understand that "No means No."

Part of their effort has involved a letter-writing effort in the Somerville Journal. Here's my contribution:

Dear Editor,

Reading the various pro-divestment letters in your publication purporting to educate the public on the realities of life in Israel reminded me of the propaganda coming out of the old Soviet Union which purported to describe life in the United States wherein every micro-story of murder and racial discrimination was taken in isolation, blown up to the macro and used to give a distorted view of the nature of justice and government in America as compared to the old Worker's Paradise. The propagandists had to take a microscope to America's barnacles because anyone who actually stood back and compared the two societies in toto would find the portrayal of America and its comparison to the Soviet Union laughable. Thus it is with Israel's critics. Your Mayor is to be congratulated for going to Israel and seeing things - in the macro and the micro - for himself. Israel is an ally, a friend and a democracy. Is Somerville getting a good return on its investment? That's the only question that needs answering.

The bottom line here is that the divestment campaign is the effort of a group of anti-Israel hobbyists for whom the World Championship Red Sox and Patriots hold insufficient appeal. Their interest is not Somerville and its community - if that were the case they would have taken "no" for an answer the first time rather than resurrecting and flogging this poor dead horse. Somerville the community is merely the stepping stone for feeding their pet effort - delegitimizing Israel. Nothing else matters.

The war against Israel has caused untold suffering across the Middle East. No good can come from this fight. In spite of what some people seem to want, let's leave that conflict over there...and out of our Massachusetts communities.


Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Somerville Divestment Again.

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.solomonia.com/cgi-bin/mt4/mt-renamedtb.cgi/4241

» Somervillians Oppose Israel - Who Cares? at the blog Carpundit

I respect and admire the measured, reasoned tone Solomonia uses to express disagreement with those anti-Semites in Somerville who want the city to divest from Israel. Read More

2 Comments

If this does make the ballot I'll most likely vote "No". But there's nothing fundamentally illegitimate about using an initiative petition process to to bring an proposal before citizens for a vote after a legislative body has rejected that proposal. That's why the petition process exists at all.

Letters to the editor of the Somerville Journal can be sent to:

kpowers@cnc.com

They have been printing letters from outside of Somerville, mostly from anti-Israel types.


[an error occurred while processing this directive]

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Search


Archives
[an error occurred while processing this directive] [an error occurred while processing this directive]