Sunday, July 31, 2005
This story of the young MIT student who committed suicide is certainly a tragedy and I wouldn't normally comment on it, but I was struck by the judge's decision to allow law suits to go forward against individual administrators for negligence. Would it be better that schools expell depressed students in the fear of their own liability? And why was the girl allowed to remain at school so long even after her self-destructive tendencies were discovered?
Lawsuit allowed in MIT suicide
Judge Christine M. McEvoy ruled that the parents of Elizabeth Shin, who committed suicide in 2000, had grounds to continue with their $27 million lawsuit against Massachusetts Institute of Technology psychiatrists and two administrators who are not mental health professionals.
Nonclinicians are not usually considered responsible for preventing suicide, but McEvoy wrote that, in this case, Shin's housemaster and a student life dean had a ''special relationship" with her, requiring them to protect her, because they ''could reasonably foresee that Elizabeth would hurt herself without proper supervision."...