Monday, August 22, 2005
This one's a little old -- over a week! -- but I just noticed it and thought it deserved some attention. Colbert King wrote in the Washington Post warning the mainstream left off of the divestment issue. Interesting because it comes from a mainstream Democrat viewpoint, pointing out how fatally divisive this issue is amongst traditional left-of-center allies.
Washington Post: Making an Investment in Unity
It's enough just to be concerned about the cohesion of our country, especially during a time of war. The question should concern us all, because the divestment issue is not a struggle waged between fringe groups. This is a fight that's straining relations between two American pillars that are historical allies on basic social and humanitarian causes and political issues: the national bodies of mainline Protestant churches and key Jewish groups...
...The churches, for their part, say they aren't out to delegitimize or economically weaken Israel. They maintain that they are committed to the state of Israel but are opposed to activities that contribute to the Israeli occupation, such as investment in companies that profit from the occupation by selling equipment or materials used to tear down Palestinian structures. Churches, they contend, are using their economic leverage as a moral tool for peace. But what if the effect will be just the opposite?
Here's an additional thought. In another professional incarnation, I traveled to the Middle East several times (but not to the Palestinian territories or Israel). Take it from me, my brothers and sisters of the New Testament, when it comes to Israel, the milk of human kindness does not flow freely through the bosoms of her Arab neighbors. Israel-bashing is a cottage industry among Islamic nations, some of which would just as soon see the Jewish state pushed into the sea. To pretend otherwise is foolish.
From where I sit, the Israel divestment debate is one of those wedge issues that the leaders of the mainline churches and the organized Jewish community need to dispose of quickly. If this divestment fight is allowed to percolate down into the pews and at the grass-roots level, it could precipitate a rupture in Christian-Jewish relations that will set back the interfaith movement for years to come...
It's quite good, and worth reading in full. The mainstream left ought to avoid the temptation to align themselves with feel-gooders talking about divestment, who's roots are really in a far more radical place. They also ought avoid trying to use the far Left for its energy, while hoping they can keep the uglier aspects sanitized and out of sight -- Cindy Sheehan and her friends being a prime example.
I was also particularly pleased to see King quoting from a MEMRI report, the same one I posted a screen-grab of back here.
Now, warring parties, that ought to concentrate the mind wonderfully.
Excellent. Seeing this in the Washington Post coming from a "liberal" is a great sign.
Nice to see, but I wonder if anyone is really listening.
I was pleasantly surprised by this in the Washington Post.
It does seem frustrating that people don't appear to be listening. The only thing to do is say it over and over again until they do.