Wednesday, November 30, 2005
While Western intellectuals sit about debating reasonable solution amongst reasonable people, there is a legitimate question as to how many people there are on the other side with the same reasonable goals.
JPost: The phantom Arab moderate
They do not face the reality, taught by many decades of experience, that the most "moderate" of the Arabs (who might have a hand in setting the policies of their people) do not differ, in their view of what Israel's future should be, from the manifestly immoderate mainstream Arabs. They differ only on the method, or process, by which the elimination of the Jewish state is to be accomplished...
...The outlook of such phantom moderates has not been kept secret. It comes to the surface from time to time from quite authoritative quarters.
In December 1980, shortly after Israel's peace treaty with Egypt was signed, a former prime minister of Egypt, Mustafa Khalil, delivered a guest lecture at Tel Aviv University. There, speaking - as he said - "frankly and scientifically," he pointed out that the Arabs do not "regard the Jews as a nation at all, but as a religion only. "When it come to nationality," he declared, "a Jew can be an Egyptian Jew, a French Jew or a German Jew." Egyptians, he said, wanted to be good neighbors with Israel, but they expected the Jews "to change."
Five years earlier, another leading Egyptian intellectual, Boutros Boutros Ghali, cabinet minister and subsequently secretary-seneral of the United Nations, gave equally cultured utterance to the same idea, but then gave voice also to its underlying threat. He told a Cairo journal that if Israel maintained "its Jewish character" and did not assimilate in the Arab homeland, "then we will have no integration of Israel with this region." Indeed, if Israel defended its right to sovereignty, he added, "I think you can have no peace in this region."...
[Hat Tip: Andrew Bostom]
It's frightening to realize that Arafat, and the current group of PLO "leaders" may be the most moderate of all.
If this is true, it´s very depressing.
It also shows that, just as many Arabs in France, Britain, etc., demand that their differences be respected, other Arabs are not willing to do the same in or near their home turf.