Tuesday, December 6, 2005
Straight-shooting Interior Minister Nicolas Sarkozy has come out strongly in defense of French philospher Alain Finkielkraut:
France's Sarkozy backs beleaguered Finkielkraut over Muslim riot comments
The minister was asked about Finkielkraut because several reporters saw similarities between the conservative views the philosopher expressed about the recent riots in France and the tough stance the minister took in dealing with the agitators who took to the street night after night...
...Sarkozy appeared ready to take on the media. He had been following the attacks on Finkielkraut for two weeks and was waiting for a suitable opportunity. "What do you want of him?" he asked the media representatives. "M. Finkielkraut does not consider himself obliged to follow the monolithic thinking of many intellectuals, which led to Le Pen winning 24 percent in the elections. The philosophers who frequent the salons and live between Cafe de Flor and Boulevard St. Germain suddenly find that France no longer bears a resemblance to them."
This is an unprecedented attack on the left wing by the very person who is seen by many French as being the only one capable of preventing the disintegration of the republic. The cafes and bistros of Boulevard St. Germain and the narrow alleyways of St. Germain-des-Pres were traditionally frequented by members of the left, led by Jean-Paul Sartre and Simone de Beauvoir, who would take their morning coffee and read the newspapers there. When the socialists came to power under Francois Mitterand in 1981, the celebrations there were legendary. But of late, the area has lost some of its left-wing color...
Update: H/T to Michael B. in the comments for the pointer to this excellent article at Transatlantic Intelligencer that sheds even more light on the subject (and puts heat back on Haaretz and Le Monde): Is Freedom of Thought Under Threat in France? BY Michel Gurfinkiel
Good on Sarkozy. About time.
(Sorry for the serial commenting streak. I'll leave off for a bit now.)
J. Rosenthal at Transatlantic Intelligencer has translated an article by Michel Gurfinkiel dealing with the Alain Finkielkraut issue and beyond: Is Freedom of Thought Under Threat in France?.
Beaupeep, comment as much as you like.
Michael B, thanks for that pointer. It's very good and is connected in a way also to Emanuele Ottolenghi's piece, above.
http://tobeafriend.bitacoras.com
Blog in Spanish