Thursday, January 19, 2006
The folks at Holocaust Museum Watch got themselves a nice write-up in the New York Sun following their panel discussion last night.
U.S. Holocaust Museum Comes Under Fire For Failing to Address Arab Anti-Semitism
"There is anti-Semitism emanating from parts of the Muslim world, and this is not a problem which should escape the concern of the Holocaust Museum," Mr. Engel said in a statement to The New York Sun. "I think it is time that the museum consider intensifying its focus on this continuing concern."
"It's unbelievable," the rabbi of the National Synagogue, Shmuel Herzfeld, told the Sun yesterday. "They won't talk about Egypt, about Syria, about Saudi Arabia - it's like the big elephant in the room."...
"They are not talking about the major issues because they upset certain political niceties in Washington," Rabbi Herzfeld said. "That's fine if you're the State Department, but if you're tasked with preserving the memory of the Shoah, and you deal with it in a callous political fashion, that's deeply offensive."...
...One example of misplaced focus, Ms. Greenwald said, is a video documentary about Christianity's role in the Holocaust, addressing historic episodes such as anti-Semitic violence after medieval passion plays and the writings of Martin Luther. "Given that they don't have any hesitation about having a movie like that," Ms. Greenwald said, "they should have a movie or an exhibit that talks about the role extremist Islam is playing in spreading religious and racial hatred."
The museum's unresponsiveness to such criticism, Ms. Greenwald, drove her to establish Holocaust Museum Watch. Her inability to get the museum to include some mention of the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, Haj Amin el-Husseini, who conspired with Hitler to liquidate the Jewish population of British Palestine, was particularly irksome, Ms. Greenwald said...
i don't think Facing History has a segment on arab genocidal anti-semitism either. the issue reflects the problem that liberalism has with jewish suffering. past suffering (pogroms, the holocaust) we can discuss and deplore; but future suffering, threats of the magnitude of the nazis, we can't discuss because it would mean "demonizing" the "other."
the parallels btw now and the 30s are distressing... not only in terms of the venom spewing from the jihadis, but also the determination not to talk about it, from the western press. as late as 1939, the BBC refused to allow some people (including churchill) to speak on their programs because they were "too anti-german."
rl
Indeed. I've often mentioned that while it's all well, good and ncessary to memorialize dead Jews, amazingly, it takes actual guts to keep the live ones living.