In his recent Guest Viewpoint, Geoff Browning raised an intriguing question: “Is the Presbyterian Church (USA) Anti-Semitic?” In a dazzling display of rationalization he suggests “that the accusation of unfairness or anti-Semitism” relies upon “the very logic used by anti-Semites.” As innovative as that line of reasoning might be, I am persuaded that it dodges the actual criticism being leveled against the PC(USA). While we as Presbyterians may want to seriously and prayerfully explore our true motivations, the rest of the world is unconcerned with such self-examination. Those who level a charge of anti-Jewish bias are speaking of the actions and public statements of official bodies of the Presbyterian Church (USA). There is a strong temptation to dismiss such criticisms without examination, breathing a sigh of relief and feeling comfortable that we oppose the “real” anti-Semites. After all, we recognize that anti-Semitism is a real problem in our communities – indulged in, no doubt, by some regressive, neo-Nazi named “Bubba”. We, on the other hand, are progressive, compassionate, and concerned with justice. I hope and pray that we will not so easily let ourselves off the hook. It would benefit us to ask why someone might label us in that manner. I can see two reasons: our policies on Israel and Palestine, and our more blatantly anti-Jewish pronouncements...