Tuesday, December 5, 2006
Cynthia Ozick has an excellent review of the play...and the life and death...of Rachel Corrie, here. Here's a snip, but the whole thing is worth reading:
Rachel Corrie is portrayed as selfless by her advocates, and as a naïve dupe by others. Yet after some fleeting hesitation--"I'm really new to talking about Israel-Palestine, so I don't always know the political implications of my words"--by the time she is placed in Gaza she is a complicit enthusiast. Arriving in Tel Aviv, coached beforehand on how to elude security, she records "very little problem at the airport"; she has come forearmed by her recruiters with a referral to an "Israeli friend,"...
...Her training--she accepts the term willingly--takes place in Jerusalem. Escorted by Palestinians while waiting "to get to Rafah to join the other internationals trying to prevent the demolition of civilian homes," she observes "blue stars of David spray-painted on doors in the Arab section of the old city." She concludes, "I am used to seeing the cross used in a colonialist way." Once in Rafah, she is under military orders. "The neighborhoods that have asked us for some form of presence are Yibna, Tel El Sultan, Hi Salaam, Brazil, Block J, Zorob, and Block O." The new recruits are called on to stand as human shields before arms caches or shooter hideouts. If through some mishap a young foreigner should be hit, all the better: fuel for international outrage. She imagines "the difficulties the Israeli army would face if they shot an unarmed US citizen."
But in fact the "civilian homes" are weapons depots; or else they are outlets, sometimes with complicit families still in them, concealing tunnels dug from Egypt to Gaza. The tunnels smuggle guns, rocket launchers, explosives; and the Israeli Defense Force (IDF) is there to stop the flow of arms intended for assaults on Israeli citizens, and to uncover the launchers secreted in olive groves and farms, where the gunmen also hide, or in the houses, where the gunmen hide among women and children. Rachel Corrie is in a war zone. She cannot not know that she lives and acts among guns and gunmen, or that the children who are everywhere live and play among guns and gunmen...
The piece, and another in TNR, Girlish Figure - The Staged Legacy of Rachel Corrie by James Kirchik, are so good, in fact, that the ISM sent an email alert to its network calling people out to bombard TNR with emails and comments. Read what they're upset about.
Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Martyr.
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.solomonia.com/cgi-bin/mt4/mt-renamedtb.cgi/6947
When I was a young confused college student, trying to find myself in an academic urban jungle, like a lot of people my age, I kept a journal -- what I did, where I went, a comment about what I... Read More
As usual, Ozick and Kirchick's articles have been attacked by the hard leftists who flock to TNR specifically to attack the Zionist views of Peretz, etc. A fool code-named Kaboom had the temerity to savge Ozick's entire reputation. The woman is one of our greatest living writers, period. If there is a prophetic Jewish voice these days, it belongs to Ozick. (Read her acidic article on The Diary of Ann Frank and bow down before her.) I'm also happy (not to harp on my pet subject again) to note that Kirchick is a young gay liberal (*not* "progressive.) As I've written here before, I see gay men and lesbians at the forefront of the anti-sharia/radical Muslim agenda here and in the UK. Pity about the moribund, PC feminist establishment.