Amazon.com Widgets

September 2005 Archives

Thursday, September 29, 2005

Black Hearts and Red Spades: The Media Gets the "Intifada" Wrong by Richard Landes

In his book on The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, Thomas Kuhn cites an experiment to illustrate the problem that people have registering information that contradicts their expectations (what he calls "anomalies" to the prevailing paradigm). The subject sat and watched pictures of playing cards flashed on a screen in front of him and identified them. In the deck were some cards with red spades and black hearts. Initially subjects ignored the anomalous data and read the cards as normal ones. Only when the picture was held up for long periods of time could the subjects identify the anomaly. Only once they readjusted their expectations did they then recognize these cards.

We have a similar phenomenon, only far more serious in its consequences, in the way that the media handled this picture that was taken five years ago today in Jerusalem.

AP: "An Israeli policeman and a Palestinian on the Temple Mount."

The AP caption, repeated by the NYT, identifies the bloodied civilian as a Palestinian, the policeman brandishing a club – implicitly the author of the youth’s wounds – as an Israeli, and the location as the Temple Mount. I guess one out of three IDs isn’t bad for AP when it comes to the Middle East conflict, although the thrust of the errors literally transforms the meaning of the photo. What the AP did with this caption is to impose upon it the firm expectations of their Politically Correct Paradigm: since the Palestinians are the David and Israel the Goliath, then a bloodied civilian near an Israeli with a club must be the soldier’s victim. And since Ariel Sharon’s visit to the Temple Mount the day before had provoked Palestinian rage to which the Israelis had responded with deadly force, the injuries must have been inflicted on the Temple Mount.

What happened differs radically. The victim, Tuvya Grossman, was an American seminary student in Jerusalem whose taxi-driver went through an Arab neighborhood of Jerusalem where rioting crowds dragged him from the car, beat and stabbed him nearly to death. He managed to escape and reach the place where this Israeli soldier protected him from his pursuers. This story here actually illustrates the Jihad Paradigm, not the Politically Correct Paradigm. Palestinians, whipped into a rage by false rumors that Sharon had desecrated the al-Aqsa mosque, broke into wild rioting, which Israelis, as much as possible, constrained with non-lethal weapons (like this baton). The Jewish civilian here is the victim, and the Israeli David, scantily armed, stands up to the Palestinian mob.

(Nota Bene: The very term intifada illustrates the way in which the Palestinians themselves – part of the greater Arab world (300 million) and Muslim world (1 billion) – view the relationship of forces. The word, before it became a term for uprising, means to shrug off, as in the way a camel or a horse shakes its hide to chase away a fly.)

It took the NYT 4 days to acknowledge the error identifying the victim as "Tuvya Grossman, an American student in Israel" and a week to do a story on the beating. But by then the damage had been done. Not only was the PCP firmly set in place, but the picture had become an emblem of Palestinian victimization. (This incident triggered the formation of the media watchdog group, Honest Reporting).

This subsequent retraction, and a successful lawsuit against both AP and the French paper Libération, had little impact on those who wanted to believe in Israeli villainy. As in the case of the poison accusations of 1983, Palestinian and Arab media, like the Egyptian Government and their Post Colonial Paradigm supporters, have continued to use the picture as part of their Palestinian victim narrative. To this day, Tuvya Grossman's picture adorns a poster calling on everyone in the world to boycott Coca Cola in order to stop Israelis from killing Palestinians.

No picture better illustrates the mood of the media at the outbreak of the intifada. "Already already listening" as Werner Erhardt might have put it. The storyboard was up, they just needed the material to start pinning to it. On September 29, it was Tuvya Grossman. The next day, it was Muhamed al Durah.

Horrors of the Iraqi Occupation

DoD: U.S. Builds Water Treatment Plant in Dibis, Iraq

...The newly resurrected Military Water plant not only supplies water to the 3,000 Iraqi soldiers at K1, but also to the nearby Kirkuk Regional Air Base, where 10,000 U.S. Air Force and Army personnel currently are garrisoned.

Both Kirkuk and the town of Dibis benefit from the enhanced capacity, but the biggest winners are the roughly 25,000 residents living in 13 nearby villages and settlements who had never known the luxury of running water. Some of these communities have only 25 homes; two consist solely of tent-dwellers; and two areas are home to 5,000 internally displaced people each.

The individuals responsible may never have the opportunity to see their work nor to be acknowledged by those who have benefited; security concerns in the Kirkuk area mean visitors and villagers alike are at risk.

But 25,000 more Iraqi people now have access to fresh water.


Russia: Arming Iran as fast as they can

This is not a surprise.

Russia in a Hurry to Sell Weapons to Iran — Paper

Russia is intensifying efforts to sell weapons to Iran while such sales remain legal amid mounting pressure on the Islamic state over its controversial nuclear program, the daily Kommersant said on Monday.

Moscow “has stepped up military-technological cooperation with Tehran,” the business daily said, citing an unidentified source.

It said top officials within Russia’s military-industrial complex decided to concentrate on arms sales to Tehran for two reasons.

“Firstly, as many weapons as possible must be sold to Iran before an international embargo against this country comes into force.”

Secondly, should the United States decide to go to war in Iran, Russia wants Iran to be well-armed to ensure that U.S. forces become at least as bogged down there as they already are in Iraq, the daily said.

“In either case, such a policy carries a high risk of creating a major international scandal, at the very least,” the newspaper commented...

Scandal? C'mon. It's never mattered before. Who is there to hold Russia accountable?

Somerville Divestment Effort Fails...Again

The attempt by backers of the effort to get the City of Somerville, Massachusetts to divest itself of its Israeli investments has once again failed. After the Board of Aldermen dismissed the effort last December, the same group turned toward putting together a ballot initiative. Now the city has refused to certify the petitions they put together due to irregularities in the forms they used and a failure to comply with the timing window they were given in which to collect the signatures. This is good news.

Somerville Journal: Divestment backers lose case

The Somerville Divestment Project packed its campaign into boxes last week, unsure of its next step in trying to get the city to give up bonds in Israel.

The group, which opposes the city's investment in Israel and military equipment companies that do business there, said it collected about 4,500 signed petitions to place a nonbinding question about divesting the bonds on the Nov. 8 ballot.

But Julian Houston, a Middlesex County Superior Court judge, ruled Thursday that the Somerville Elections Commission had the right to refuse to certify the petitions because SDP did not follow instructions from the commission about the wording of the petition and the collection timeline...

Congratulations to all those, like Jon Haber at Somerville Middle East Justice, who were working hard on defeating the effort, although it appears that in the end the SDP's own sense of personal specialness and entitlement defeated them. A flawless victory would have been the citizens of Somerville recognizing the inherent bigotry of that group of rogues and refusing to sign altogether (it's understandable that they didn't at this juncture, of course), but this will do.

The Presbyterian Divestment Story

Will Spots, a Presbyterian Church (USA) Elder and proprietor of the Truth in Love blog has released his report on the PC(USA) divestment effort. This is a detailed -- 26 single-spaced pages plus appendices -- view from the inside by a friend who's uncomfortable with his church's efforts against Israel and the Jews. This report is an amateur effort and solely a labor of love and Will is to be deeply congratulated for creating it.

All those interested in both the mainline Protestant efforts to divest from Israel, as well as those interested in divestment generally should seek the report here.

A Letter They'll Never Read

Yossi Klein Halevi has an excellent "Letter to Palestinians" that you should read. Very difficult to excerpt. Of, course, very few of the rhetorical audience will read it, but that doesn't mean that you shouldn't.

...The dark side of the Muslim reconciliation with death, of course, are the suicide bombers. But I learned, too, that acceptance of mortality can be the basis for a religious language of reconciliation. Repeatedly, Palestinians would say to me, "Why are you and I arguing over who owns the land when in the end the land will own us both?" That wise ability to place our earthly claims and struggles in the context of our shared condition of mortality gave me hope that peace between us may some day be possible.

But I learned too, during numerous candid conversations with Palestinians at all levels of society, that, in practice, few within your nation are willing to concede that I have a legitimate claim to any part of this land. I will cite one telling example...


[hat tip: mal]

Wednesday, September 28, 2005

Five Years

Lynn points out that today is the fifth anniversary of the launching of the Palestinian Arab terror war against Israel. What a waste.

In the Mail Bag: My War by Colby Buzzell

I just received a review copy of Colby Buzzell's My War: Killing Time in Iraq. "CB" had one of the best soldier blogs live from Iraq. The writing was fresh and natural. Real good stuff. I've got a lot of books on my shelf waiting for my time, but I'll likely make reading this one a priority.

Assad tells Hamas, Jihad to increase attacks

Here's an object lesson in how dysfunctional Arab leaders and societies use the Palestinian/Israeli conflict as a tool to further their own ends. Free societies would have an interest in resolving the conflict. Fear societies have an interest in keeping it going.

JPost: Assad tells Hamas, Jihad to increase attacks

Syrian President Bashar Assad requested from Hamas and Islamic Jihad commanders in Damascus to increase their terror activities against Israel, essentially giving them a "green-light" to commit terror acts, according to a Palestinian Authority intelligence report revealed on Wednesday.

Assad met with Hamas and Islamic Jihad commanders two weeks ago and told them that since the international community was hounding him, he wanted attention to be more focused on the Palestinian plight, according to the report obtained by Army Radio.

Assad's statement to Hamas and Islamic Jihad was reportedly the reason for the emergency meeting between Assad and Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak earlier this week.

In the meeting Mubarak allegedly told Assad not to interfere in the Palestinian conflict, Israel Radio reported.


Giant Squid Wrangling

OK, this is cool. That thing would make one hell of an order of Salt and Pepper Calamari at the local Mandarin joint.

WaPo: In a First, Camera Catches Live Giant Squid

Using a digital camera dangling from a line nearly 3,300 feet long, scientists for the first time have photographed a live giant squid, the tentacled deep-sea monster that is the largest invertebrate on Earth.

Researchers Tsunemi Kubodera and Kyoichi Mori, reporting in the British journal Proceedings of the Royal Society B, said a giant squid about 26 feet long attacked a baited jig, or lure, trailing below a marker buoy about 500 miles south of Tokyo, near the Ogasawara Islands in the Pacific...

...Despite the stories, however, very little is known about the giant squid. The first complete specimen, a dead animal captured by fishermen off Newfoundland, was found in 1874. Subsequent remains, either washed up on beaches or trapped in fishnets, have appeared occasionally in high latitudes -- Canadian and Japanese waters, or off Tasmania and Australia...

..."Four hours and 13 minutes after becoming snagged, the attached tentacle broke, as seen by sudden slackness in the line," the authors wrote. Once on the surface "the recovered section of tentacle was still functioning," they continued, "with the large suckers of the tentacle club repeatedly gripping the boat deck and any offered fingers."

Germany's Road Map Folly

John Rosenthal's re-vamped Transatlantic Intelligencer has an excellent article by German scholar Matthias Kuntzel on the history of Germany's involvement with the "Roadmap for Peace." It's a lengthy but worthwhile refresher course on just how damaging and counter-productive European involvement in the Middle East has been. (Also note this past entry here: Matthias Kuntzel: National Socialism and Anti-Semitism in the Arab World)

A Dubious Achievement: Joschka Fischer, the Road Map, and the Gaza Pullout

...It is tempting to ridicule the Hamas Chart[er] as lunacy, just as in the past Hitler’s ravings were ridiculed. However, it is precisely such demonization of Jews as the source of all evil that transforms the murder of Israeli civilians into an act of liberation and that provides the phantasmagorical reason for Hamas’ ambition to destroy Israel. This is why an uncompromising combat against anti-Semitism in Palestine and the Arab world is a key precondition for any genuine peace in the Middle East.

But on precisely this point, German foreign policy under the direction of Joschka Fischer has not merely refused to join the battle. It has deliberately turned a blind eye, proceeding as if hating Jews were a normal feature of the Oriental world – like hookahs or mosques. Consequently, the “red-green” government has not treated the militants of Hamas and Islamic Jihad as combatants waging war on Israel. Islamist suicide terror has instead been presented as a false, though, in the final analysis, comprehensible reaction to poverty and hopelessness. “It is not the violence of the second Intifada which has caused the failure of the peace process,” the Green Party member of parliament Christian Sterzing remarked in a discussion of the Fischer proposal, “it is rather the failed political process which has caused the violence.”...

John's site is well worth having a peek through if you haven't seen it before, BTW.

Vet Haunted by the Past

But not in the way you think.

NE Republican is trying to help out a twenty-year Marine Vet who's story of his treatment at the hands of police department hirers -- and an unstable jilted lover's unsubstantiated allegations -- sounds pretty darn unfair. It's worth taking a look and lending a little support.

Zapatero's Allies

Last year he disinvited the Americans, but this year Zapatero will be sure to have his real friends on hand to march in the Columbus Day parade...Cuba and Venezuela.

Sabeel's Smash Israel Month

Below I discussed the ADL getting involved with Sabeel, and all the groups supposedly cooperating with the ADL to achieve peace and understanding, while at the same time sponsoring a Sabeel conference. Well here is a major Sabeel conference taking place next month, being held in a Presbyterian Church that I don't think anyone could mistake as being about anything like peace and reconciliation. The list of presenters is a veritable rogue's gallery of far-Left smash Israel professionals. You cannot have anything to do with this and still be taken seriously trying to masquerade as being for two states -- Israel and Palestine -- living side by side in peace. No how, no way.

Tuesday, September 27, 2005

Sifting the trash for treasure

Israeli archaeologists are continuing to find treasure amidst the rubble discarded by the Waqf in charge of the Temple Mount.

JPost: First Temple-era seal discovered

A First-Temple period seal has been discovered amidst piles of rubble from Jerusalem's Temple Mount, an Israeli archaeologist said Tuesday, in what could prove to be an historic find.

The small - less than 1 cm - seal impression, or bulla, discovered Tuesday by Bar-Ilan University archaeologist Dr. Gabriel Barkay amidst piles of rubble from the Temple Mount would mark the first time that an written artifact was found from the Temple Mount dating back to the First Temple period.

The 2,600 year old artifact, with three lines in ancient Hebrew, was discovered amidst piles of rubble discarded by the Islamic Wakf that Barkay and a team of young archaeologists and volunteers are sifting through on the grounds of a Jerusalem national park...

...The seal was found amidst thousands of tons of rubble discarded by Wakf officials at city garbage dumps six years ago, following the Islamic Trust's unilateral construction of an mosque at an underground compound of the Temple Mount known as the Solomon's Stables.

After the Antiquities Authority voiced disinterest in thoroughly sifting through the rubble discarded by the Wakf, Barkay applied -- and eventually received –a license from the Antiquities Authority to sort through the piles of earth thrown into the garbage dump in search of antiquities, and has since found scores of history-rich artifacts, from the First Temple Period until today amidst the rubble, including a large amount of pottery dating from the Bronze Ages through modern times, a large segment of a marble pillar's shaft, and over 100 ancient coins, among them several from the Hasmonean Dynasty...


Richard Landes: Muhamed al Durah

Thanks to Solomonia for inviting me to participate as a guest at his blog. For my first post, I'd like to announce that we'll be putting up the footage available for the Muhamed al Durah case at our website -- The Second Draft -- on the fifth anniversary of the event, September 30, 2005. As those who have visited our site and looked at the material we've made available about Pallywood might guess, we're suggesting, only suggesting, that it may be faked. We also plan to put up a fair amount of material that treats how the media could have been fooled (?) by such a (transparent?) fake and take so long (five years and running) to reconsider their error.

(I note that Solomonia does not have "media" as a primary category.)

Please come and view the material yourselves, send us your thoughts, and start rethinking the way we, in the West, were informed about the "intifada" by our credulous (?) media.

Please Welcome My Guest Blogger, Richard Landes

Second Draft proprietor and BU Professor, Richard Landes has kindly agreed to do some guest blogging here at Solomonia for the next week or two or whenever...please give him a warm welcome.

He'll be posting about, well, whatever he'd like, as frequently or infrequently as he'd like.

The info contained in his first post is a real doozy (I'm setting the clock back on this post so his appears above it)!

Welcome to the blogosphere, Professor Landes!

(Oh, and I should mention that Professor Landes is only responsible for what he himself writes. Anything doofy or irresponsible that comes off of my keyboard is on my head alone, of course.)

Monday, September 26, 2005

ADL steps in on Sabeel

The "ecumenical group" that traveled to Israel for fact-finding purposes has returned. The ADL is reporting:

New York, NY, September 26, 2005 … American Jewish and mainline Protestant officials concluded an unprecedented joint mission to Israel saying they were heartened by a new trust that developed among the participants, who are now pledging to work together to seek peace between Israel and Palestinians...

Yeah, right. Good luck on that.

...Jewish participants expressed the hope that the mission would lead to concrete steps by the leadership of the Protestant churches to cancel their divestment campaign against Israel and instead focus on positive opportunities to invest in the many hopeful programs that enhance peaceful co-existence between Palestinians and Israelis...

Someone should tell all those denominations that are sending representatives and sponsoring the Friends of Sabeel conference in Canada next month. All attendees must agree to the conference mission "To reach out to organizational representatives of churches, CROs and NGOs around the globe who are interested in learning about economic strategies as they pertain to ending the Israeli occupation and promoting a just peace for Israel and Palestine." It's on the registration form.

It is good to see the ADL taking further steps to make Sabeel poison to the touch...

...During the mission, the Jewish leaders also challenged a leading Palestinian Christian cleric "who refused to back off from previous anti-Semitic writings and statements," said Rabbi Gary Bretton-Granatoor, Director of Interfaith Affairs for the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) and one of the leaders on the trip.

The cleric, Rev. Dr. Naim Ateek, is Director of the Sabeel Ecumenical Liberation Theology Center, which, according to ADL, has been the driving force behind the scenes pushing mainline Protestant denominations to adopt a policy of divestment against companies doing business with Israel...

..."We accept it may not be his intent to disseminate anti-Semitism, but we made it clear that was what has been done," added the rabbi. "We hope that he may reconsider his language and imagery. But the significance of this is that those people and those churches that use Sabeel's writings and theology to support their political point of view potentially may be considered accessories in the advancement of anti-Semitic theology."...

In other words, we're not going to wrangle over (arguably) the mind-reading necessary to determine whether Ateek himself is an intentional anti-Semite, but whoa be to those groups who get too close -- we're letting you know you'll have no excuse.

According to the ADL, mission participants included: Alliance of Baptists, Christian Church (Disciples of Christ), Episcopal Church USA, Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, National Council of Churches, Presbyterian Church USA, United Church of Christ, and the United Methodist Church -- many of whom are helping to sponsor (either themselves or have participating affiliates) the Sabeel conference.

(Links via UCCTruths.com)

Blues By The Beach - Documentary Film on the Mike's Place Bombing

There is a documentary film that -- unintentionally -- came to be about the Mike's Place suicide bombing. It is undergoing a limited showing in the US in order to qualify for a 2005 Academy Award nomination. The film will show in West Hollywood, New York City, Denver, San Francisco and Boston. I will definitely seek it out during its Boston showing.

A trailer is available here: From Israel to New York, Blues by the Beach Gets Top Reviews

Tragedy put in its appearance at Mike's Place in, Tel Aviv, Israel after midnight on Wednesday, April 30th, 2003.

Death and injury came in the twinkling of an eye, intruding on the idyll the filmmakers had begun to capture: a suicide bomber exploded himself on Jam Nite. Yanai Weiss and Ran Baron, two musicians, and Dominique Hass, a waitress who had emigrated from France, were killed. Among the dozens injured in the powerful blast are: Avi Tabib, the security guard, who heroically saved everyone inside the bar by pushing the bomber out the doorway; and one of the three filmmakers - Jack Baxter, an American documentary producer and investigative journalist, who came to Tel Aviv and found a story to tell about present day Israel at Mike's Place.

...Pavla and Joshua continued to film, showing it all from the eye of the hurricane.

They attended the daily Mike's Place "family" gatherings till the early mornings, visited the injured in hospital, recorded the vibrant original live blues of Mike's Place, and followed preparations for the memorial service that marked the reopening of the bar. Blues By The Beach not only has footage of a suicide bombing; the film illustrates the effects of terror, the aftermath and moving on. Pavla and Joshua see a real-life dramatic script writing itself before their camera and understand that the emotional upheaval in their personal relationship is an integral part of the Israeli Experience and the story of the Mike's Place bombing.

Show times and locations are in the extended entry.

Continue reading "Blues By The Beach - Documentary Film on the Mike's Place Bombing"

Hate Crime Per Capita

Smash Scopes Al Awda

Citizen Smash was at an anti-war protest out in California. Here's an interesting description that includes tell of a group that's come up here many times, Al Awda:

...JAMAL KANJ, a fiery Palestinian from a group called Al-Awda, takes the podium. “We Palestinians,” he begins, “have been subjected to GENOCIDE at the hands of the Israelis for generations." He rants on. "In 1948, they forced us out of our homes, and today we must DRIVE THE JEWS FROM PALESTINE!”

Suddenly, a middle-aged man wearing a black “F the President” T-shirt rushes the stage, screaming at Kanj, “I’m TIRED of this CRAP! You people keep bringing this up! This is supposed to be an ANTI-WAR rally, not an ANTI-ISRAEL rally!”

Kanj yells back, into the microphone. Others in the crowd stand up and join in the shouting match.

The Arab-Israeli conflict has arrived in San Diego.

Red-vested “peace monitors” converge on T-shirt Man, trying to contain this sudden outburst of dissent. They are followed closely by the San Diego Police Department, who quickly take control of the situation and lead the man away.

As T-shirt Man exits stage right, ANSWER front man Carl Muhammed enters from stage left, strutting in front of the platform and waving a large Palestinian flag. Carl and his radical Palestinian posse face down the angry Israel supporters, and the entire rally begins to descend into chaos.

In an effort to regain control of the rally, CodePink maven Barbara Jaffe-Rose takes the podium, declaring her solidarity with the Palestinian cause. “As an anti-war Jew, I support the Palestinian Right of Return, and demand the end of U.S. aid to Israel.” She attempts to lead the crowd in a cheer: “Not one penny, not one dime, U.S. out of Palestine!”

It flops...

(via LGF)

Joseph Massad Likely to Receive Tenure

According to the NY Sun, "anti-Israel" Columbia Professor Joseph Massad, who was criticized by an internal Columbia report last March, is still on the tenure track.

NYSun: Alleged Intimidator of Jewish Students Likely To Achieve Tenure at Columbia

Joseph Massad, whose fiery writings attacking Israel and alleged intimidation of Jewish students have made him the most polarizing figure on the Columbia University campus, is likely to be awarded tenure, according to a professor in his department.

Mr. Massad, an assistant professor of Arab studies, easily cleared the hurdle of his fifth-year review in the spring and is undergoing a tenure review this academic year, a complicated process that often takes more than six months to complete.

While Mr. Massad's future at Columbia poses a problem for an administration seeking to shed a reputation among Jewish groups, alumni, and donors that the university is a base for anti-Israel scholarship, such concerns are unlikely to outweigh several factors in his favor, a professor of Hebrew literature in Mr. Massad's department of Middle East and Asian languages and cultures, Dan Miron, said.

By denying tenure to Mr. Massad, Columbia president Lee Bollinger and the university's trustees would risk a backlash from faculty members who would accuse Columbia of yielding to pressure from the press and from Jewish groups, Mr. Miron said...

A snip of background on Massad here:

...Academic freedom for Massad is being able to freedom to teach without challenge that “Established scholarship enumerates all [Israel's] racist flaws and institutional racist practices” which he says render the Jewish state “a racist state by law.” But any disagreement, Massad says, can be safely discarded as Zionist ideology, part of the conspiracy “propped up by the likes of Campus-Watch, the David Project, and the ADL [Anti-Defamation League],” who “make it...their business to attack scholarly criticisms of Israeli policy.” Failing to discard studies by “Israel's apologists” amounts to “shutting down the educational process in favor of religious theories of creationism.” Evidently America can learn from Palestinian society’s principled anti-racism and passion for historical truth...

We shall all look forward to a bright future of more anti-Semitic screeds writen under the Columbia imprimatur.

Sunday, September 25, 2005

Smart politicians stay out of the muck

Joan Vennochi completely misses the point in her piece today, taking the Democrats to task for being too timid on Iraq.

Democrats still fear dissent on Iraq

AGAINST SUPREME Court nominee John Roberts. For the war in Iraq. How long can Democrats like Hillary Clinton walk that political line?

Fearful of the peacenik label, Democrats are still reluctant to challenge President Bush on Iraq, no matter how ugly the news from Baghdad. Opposing Roberts is much easier. It shows that when it comes to social issues like abortion, left-leaning interest groups still hold sway with Democrats who would be president...

Democrats are able to stand against Roberts because the interest groups opposing him, while extreme, still have goals that characterize the mainstream of the party's activist base. On Iraq, the fact is that they can't articulate a vision because they have none that's any different from what the Administration is already doing that the vast middle of America will accept -- a phased, objective-oriented stand down that preserves whatever it is we've achieved (a subject for another post). Standing up with Cindy and the "anti-war" movement puts mainstream politicians in with the worst elements of the extreme Left -- the America-haters, the anti-Semites, the defeatists...and worse if you can believe it. There's simply very little respectability out there where politicians who want to be critical on Iraq can hang their hats. It's not cowardice, it's self-preservation -- and a surprising measure of wisdom.

That's why, quoting Vennochi, "Only two Democratic officeholders -- Representatives John Conyers of Michigan and Cynthia McKinney of Georgia -- planned to be anywhere near the antiwar rally scheduled this weekend in Washington." McKinney is an anti-Semitic America-hater. Conyers a Leftist with a large Arab constituency. No national figure who watched what happened to John Kerry would get anywhere near it, and that's as it should be.

The press tries to paint over the flaws of the groups that stage these rallies and constitute the foundation of the anti-Iraq War movement by cropping the photos and white-washing the worst elements. It doesn't work as well as it once did, though, and the truth does find a way of getting out. No politician wants to be photographed with people holding "No blood for Israel" banners, nor do they want to be associated with groups who's membership is made up of such people. The press whitewash only achieves so much.

When I did my post "A Judenhass Horse," on Cindy Sheehan's anti-Semitic connections, which was very widely linked in the "conservative" blogosphere, only ONE lefty blog was dumb enough to link and fisk it, and that was a very small outfit with few hits. I thought when I wrote it that it might attract a bunch of negative comments and attempts at refutation...but facts are facts, and the Cindy supporters know that the only defense was for as few eyes as possible to fall on it.

So it is with mainstream politicians and the "anti-war" movement -- such as it is. "The movement" is a cesspool of hate and bizarro pathologies all the King's horses and all the King's psychologists couldn't sort out. It soils anyone uncautious enough to get near it.

You want politicians to be stronger and more outspoken against the War? Articulate a message that fills your numbers with regular, respectable people and doesn't attract flies, allowing you to push aside the weirdos, not use them and imagine you can air-brush them out and hope no one will notice. The fact that this has not been done, and I believe cannot be done, is a very important indicator to those of us who believe we need to keep up the fight -- that we are right.

Vennochi chastises the politicians for being "reluctant to challenge President Bush on Iraq, no matter how ugly the news from Baghdad," but the fact is that the news is not all ugly from Baghdad -- though Globe readers may not be aware of that fact -- and those trying to peddle that stilted line have lost much of their credibility, while those twisting the news and focusing only on the negative for political gain risk losing votes, donations and respect.

Jacoby Defends Mitt

Jeff Jacoby eloquently defends Mitt Romney's common sense in the pages of the Globe:

Common sense on terrorism

...if Americans want to protect themselves from Islamist terrorism, monitoring the mosques that foment it must be a priority. Needless to say, this must be done legally. Romney isn't proposing to do away with safeguards like judicial oversight and warrants issued only for probable cause. ''I don't want to change the rules," he emphasized in an interview last week. ''You can wiretap only when you comply with the Constitution."

The evidence that some radical mosques have been perverted into terrorist hatcheries has been mounting for years. The notorious Finsbury Park mosque in London incubated jihadists for holy wars worldwide; among its alumni are Zacarias Moussaoui, the alleged 20th hijacker, and shoe bomber Richard Reid. Brooklyn's Al-Farooq Mosque is where Sheik Omar Abdul Rahman, a rabid Egyptian cleric, incited his followers to bomb the World Trade Center in 1993.

Just last week, Hamid Hayat of Lodi, Calif., was indicted on federal terrorism charges; he is one of five suspected jihadis arrested earlier this year. All five attended the same Lodi mosque, and allegedly took direction from its two imams, Shabbir Ahmed and Adil Khan -- both of whom have now been deported to Pakistan.

Romney's position is the only responsible one. We will never be safe from terrorism so long as enemies within our borders keep spreading the plague of Islamist violence. Homeland security depends in part on monitoring those enemies and knowing what they're saying. Even when they're saying it in a mosque.


Gaza Chaos

Israeli artillery has moved up to the Gaza Strip in response to the launching of 40 Kassam rockets from there into its territory. It has also taken the gloves back off (at least as much off as they usually are off) by going back to targeted killings and arrests (although it was already making arrests at a much lower level, see: Haaretz: IDF air strike on car in Gaza kills top Islamic Jihad militant).

JPost: PM 'frees' IDF to respond to attacks

...Prime Minister Ariel Sharon responded strongly to the firing of over 40 Kassam rockets over the weekend.

Sharon told ministers at the start of Sunday's weekly cabinet meeting that Israel would do everything in its power to prevent the firing of Kassam rockets at southern Israel.

"There are no restrictions on the use of any measures in order to strike at the terrorists, their equipment and where they find shelter," Sharon said at the opening of Sunday's cabinet meeting. "The instructions are unequivocal; we do not mean a one-time action here." He said the only limitation on the IDF was its "regular objective " of "not hitting civilians."
According to Sharon, "This is not a one-time thing; we are preparing for a prolonged operation."

Defense Minister Shaul Mofaz said he gave the IDF the green light to use all means at the IDF's disposal, including artillery fire, to create a buffer zone in areas – such as the northern Gaza Strip – from where the Kassam rockets were fired...

Hamas had been launching Kassams into Israel all along (an under-reported fact), but really heated things up after a truck they were parading around exploded on them.

A pickup truck loaded with Kassam rockets blew up during a Hamas rally at the Jabaliya refugee camp in the Gaza Strip on Friday, killing at least 19 Palestinians and injuring another 120. A number of senior Hamas operatives were killed in the explosion, which was apparently caused when explosives in the truck were accidentally triggered. Of the dead, at least three were children under 15. Nineteen of the wounded were also minors, the Palestinian Health Ministry said Saturday...

The Palestinian Authority, surprisingly enough, was quick to condemn Hamas for the explosion, and even Al Jazeera doesn't seem to be buying the Hamas excuse (hat tip to Larry for the link) that "Israel did it."

Hamas in their blood zeal, of course, after blaming the Israelis for their own murderous screw up, had to step-up their "operations" against the little Satan, which has simultaneously forced Sharon to respond in an appropriately serious manner and provided the opportunity to give Abbas the choice he hasn't wanted to make: of trying to make Abbas fear him more than he fears fighting Hamas.

Following the Hamas parade disaster, Abbas was making some noises in the direction of getting Hamas to at least get off the streets, but he has little credibility in this regard, and while there are reports that some public opinion was finally turning against Hamas, we've heard that before, and there's little guarantee that Abbas will hold firm and/or that Hamas's shifting of blame to Israel for the incident won't start to take hold.

In the mean-time, Sharon has little choice but to take muscular action as his citizens are shelled and threatened with an up-tick in suicide murder.

Interestingly, one of the targeted strikes killed a group of Islamic Jihad men Israel says are responsible for the murder of Tali Hatuel and her family, though I thought those men had been killed shortly after the event. Maybe these guys are being held responsible for the planning -- IJ leaders that they are.

IAF kills Jihad leaders in Gaza

Only 24 hours after the last Kassam fell on their town, residents of Sderot were once again on full alert following the targeted assassination of Islamic Jihad terrorists in Gaza on Sunday night.

An IAF combat helicopter flying over Gaza fired a missile towards a vehicle carrying the Palestinian terrorists.

According to an initial Zaka report, three people were reported killed in the air-attack, while two were said to be wounded.

The army announced that its forces carried out an interception of a car that was transporting Khalil and another man, Aya Latif Sheikh Khalil, who were the heads of Islamic Jihad in the Gaza Strip.

According to the IDF, the killed terrorists were responsible for the murder of the Hatuel family in May of 2004.

Tali Hatuel and her four young daughters were gunned down at point blank range on the Kissufim road.

Hamas's militant parading and triumphalist promises to continue to cut throats (so to speak) seems to be moving up the story line entitled "consquences for the withdrawal" swiftly. We'll watch as it's written.

Update: Meryl fisks the media coverage.

Massachusetts Hate Crimes against Jews up 35 percent

Interesting not only for what it says about anti-Semitism, but also for what it says about the difficulty of prosecuting Hate Crimes. Generally speaking, I'm against a separate class of laws and punishments for "Hate Crimes," but in favor of tracking the statistics as to the natural or special character of crimes -- for instance, noting when an incidence of vandalism or violence is motivated by racial factors, even if they are not necessarily punished differently...something that could be left up to judge or jury.

The Jewish Advocate: Incidence of hate crimes against Jews up 35 percent

BOSTON – Jews in this state have been the victims of anti-Semitic attacks 35 percent more often than they were in 2003. However, the number of these incidents that have been investigated and prosecuted as hate crimes has dropped to an all-time low, according to crime reports obtained by the Advocate.

Local police departments filed 58 incident reports in which Jews were subjected to possible hate crimes in 2004 – a victimization rate 35 percent higher than the rate in 2003, making Jews, after blacks, the most frequently victimized minority group in Massachusetts, data collected by the state Executive Office of Public Safety show. At the same time, the State Police office received the smallest number of hate-crime incident reports from police departments from around the state in the last five years. Additionally, Boston’s nationally acclaimed Community Disorders Unit in 2004 investigated fewer hate crime cases than it has since 1995, the first year for which records were available.

For detectives, prosecutors and officials at the Anti-Defamation League contacted by the Advocate, the fact that anti-Semitic incidents have rarely resulted in hate crime charges, let alone verdicts, against perpetrators reflects the complex nature of proving hate crimes in court...


Hunting Alois Brunner, meeting the family

The great-niece of Nazi War Criminal Alois Brunner writes about her meeting with, and death of, Simon Weisenthal:

...Maybe some readers feel uncomfortable about a great-niece of Alois Brunner writing in an Israeli newspaper on the occasion of Simon Wiesenthal's death. But since the newspaper asked me to do so, I want to publicly thank this impressive personality, Simon Wiesenthal, for his persistence in searching for war criminals and Nazi perpetrators like Alois Brunner.

I want to do so not only as a relative of one of the criminals he was trying to bring to justice, but also as an Austrian citizen who had often wondered why it was he and not official bodies that were occupied with such cases. What he did was needed not only from a juridical and political point of view; his mere presence and intervention also constituted a most important contribution to public discourse and private concern...

Alois Brunner has been sheltered by Syria for years, where he lived or still lives. Eric Sheie has a must-read post on this, where he quotes:

The arrest and conviction of Alois Brunner remains the top priority of leading Nazi hunters and war investigators but Brunner has successfully eluded justice. During his many years hiding out reportedly in an apartment on Haddad Street in the Syrian capital of Damascus, he openly assisted the Syrians in establishing their own secret police.

The Syrian authorities have covered and continue to cover Alois Brunner and he may never pay for his crimes. Germany, Austria, Slovakia, France and Poland currently seek his extradition, but the Syrians have been totally uncooperative in response to all these requests.


British Academics Gearing Up

For another whack at the old divestment ball, that is.

Haaretz: U.K. group renews attempts at academic boycott of Israel

Students and teachers at British universities are working to revive the academic boycott against Israel. The British Committee for Universities of Palestine (BRICUP) recently began organizing an open forum of British university campuses in an effort to place the academic boycott against Israel and the status of universities in the Palestinian Authority back on the public agenda.

BRICUP was created in response to a Palestinian call for the boycott. It also lobbies on behalf of Palestinian universities and against the Israeli occupation. It has scheduled public discussions on campuses in London, Birmingham, York and Sussex.

"The boycott is moving on extremely well judged by the amount of support coming into us and the willingness of universities to set up meetings to discuss it," Dr. Hilary Rose, one of BRICUP's founders, said in a September 20 interview with England's The Guardian.

On Friday, a conference called "Fear of the Other and the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict" began at London University's School of Oriental and African Studies (SOAS). The conference was called in part to discuss the boycott and was organized by an organization called The Faculty for Israeli-Palestinian Peace. The organization does not itself support the boycott, but it encourages people to visit the PA's universities in order to see for themselves the difficulties faced by students and teachers there...

While they're visiting "Palestine," perhaps they'll take a side trip over to Sderot, where the schools there have been shut down due to a rain of rockets from UNoccupied Gaza.

Haaretz: Sderot municipality to shut down schools after Qassam attacks

The Sderot municipality and the Sha'ar Hanegev regional council announced Saturday night its plans to suspend school on Sunday due to the deteriorating security situation. In addition, the city-run market will not be operating in its regular capacity.

In an official statement, the municipality said the closures are the result of the security assessments that were passed onto Sderot mayor Eli Moyal during a meeting with heads of the defense establishment. Municipality heads will reconvene on Sunday to decide on further steps.

Three Qassam rockets landed in Sderot on Saturday afternoon, injuring four people...


Friday, September 23, 2005

Editorializing Defeat to Beat the Clock

Foxman on Divestment

This story at The Layman (a Presbyterian paper), "Ecumenical group travels to Mideast in wake of divestment controversy," about yet another interfaith fact-finding trip to the mid-east where everyone already has all the facts but pretends to open their minds one more time caught my attention -- not so much for the story, although the list of participants is interesting, but for the link it leads to...

Here is the transcript of a speech delivered to an ADL meeting by Rev. Dr. Jay T. Rock, Interfaith Coordinator, Presbyterian Church (USA) back in February. I thought Abe Foxman's response (partially quoted in the article above) had some very good sections in it:

Continue reading "Foxman on Divestment"

What did they think they were going to see?

IranMania: EU military attaches walk out at Iran parade [via Regime Change Iran]

EU military attaches walked out in protest at a parade in Tehran Thursday after ballistic missiles were rolled past carrying vitriolic anti-US and Israeli slogans, diplomats told AFP.

"There was a common position among the European Union members that, if the military parade included any slogans that attacked our allies, we would leave," said a diplomat.

"The military attaches from the embassies of France, Italy, Greece and Poland were present at the parade, and when they saw the slogans they promptly left," said another diplomat.

At the parade, Iran showed off six of its Shahab-3 medium-range ballistic missiles sporting banners reading "Death to America", "We will crush America under our feet", "Death to Israel" and "Israel must be wiped off the face of the earth"...

Meanwhile, Russia and the EU are still dithering over the IAEA and the Security Council...

EU Abandons Call to Refer Iran to U.N.

The European Union has dropped a call to have Iran referred immediately to the U.N. Security Council for its nuclear activities in hopes of enlisting Russia's support for confronting Tehran, diplomats said Friday.

"There is no mention of the Security Council" being called on to get involved immediately in an EU resolution being prepared for a meeting of the International Atomic Energy Agency's board of governors, a diplomat said.

That would represent a reversal from earlier EU draft resolutions containing a call to report Iran immediately to the top U.N. decision- making body, where it could face possible sanctions...

Walking out on a parade is...something I guess, but what are they doing?

North Korea - Invisible Prison

There is a country where millions live in grinding poverty with insufficient nutrition and authorities who torture, imprison and murder dissidents, or just those who run afoul of the powers-that-be. Their regional neighbors enforce the borders of the prison-state they live in. Oddly, one will never see a banner at a major march carried on their behalf, though their cause is surely just.

The Marmot: On legs with no feet, N.K. defector reaches Thailand [Disturbing Picture Warning]

...According to the Chosun Ilbo, a North Korean woman, identified by her family name of Park, recently arrived in Thailand with her 19-year-old son and two North Korean women and is awaiting passage to South Korea. What makes Park’s story truly amazing is that this she made the trip without feet, having lost them thanks to torture she suffered at the hands of North Korean security authorities after she was repatriated to the Workers’ Paradise during a previous defection attempt...

Thursday, September 22, 2005

Things sure go downhill fast when you get out of the Ivy

Let's see...on the schedule recently at the Kennedy School of Government, we've had talks from Ban Ki Moon, Minister of Foreign Affairs and Trade, Republic of Korea, William Kristol, editor of the influential Washington-based political magazine, The Weekly Standard, and we've got upcoming talks featuring Sir David Manning, British Ambassador to the United States, Jack F. Kemp, Former Secretary, US Department of Housing and Urban Development, and Michael Ignatieff, Director Carr Center for Human Rights Policy.

And at DePaul University, we've got a talk sponsored by Students for Justice in Palestine delivered by Norm Finkelstein and another, later, appearance from...Ward...Churchill.

Now I wasn't an Ivy Leaguer myself, but even I have to admit, there sure can be a drop off...

ADL: Anti-Semitism in Arab Media

Synagogue to become Hamas museum

Why, I think they may not be respecting other people's religion!

YNet: Synagogue to become Hamas museum

Izz el-Din al-Qassam Brigades, Hamas’ military wing, plans to set up exhibit of the terror group’s ‘military industry’ in synagogue of evacuated settlement of Netzarim. On display: Suicide attack apparatus, missiles stones used to ‘abolish the Gaza occupation’ by Ali Waked

The destroyed synagogue in the evacuated Gaza settlement of Netzarim is expected to be converted into a temporary Hamas museum in the next few days.

On Saturday members of Izz el-Din al-Qassam Brigades , Hamas’ military wing, plan to set up an exhibit of the terror group’s “military industry” in what used to be a synagogue.

The exhibit is set to be on display for three days, and will be open to the public from 8 a.m. to 11 p.m.

The group said in a statement that “all of the tools used by Izz el-Din al-Qassam Brigades to abolish the Gaza occupation will be on display.”

Hamas promises that visitors will be able to see all of the weapons, “from stones to instruments used in suicide attacks and the ‘tunnel war.’” Missiles and rockets will also be on display, the groups said.

The decision to use the synagogue for the display was not coincidental. Immediately following the IDF’s withdrawal from Gaza senior Hamas members said, “The synagogues are not religious structures, as they were built illegally."...

Maybe it's time to consider retroactively destroying that one. Or perhaps it's better to let the Palestinian Arabs flaunt both their hatred and the PA's impotence simultaneously.

Take lots of pictures.

Also see: NY Sun: Hamas To Convert Synagogue to Weapons Museum

Ice Cream for Jihad

Ice cream shop owner found guilty of illegal money transmitting

NEW YORK -- A Yemeni immigrant ice cream shop owner was found guilty Wednesday of illegally funneling $21.9 million overseas in a case stemming from a major terrorism investigation.

Abad Elfgeeh, 50, was convicted of transmitting money around the world without a license from a dozen bank accounts linked to his tiny storefront in Park Slope, Brooklyn. Prosecutors said his business was used by a Yemeni cleric [Sheik Mohammed Ali Hassan Al-Moayad] convicted earlier this year of a scheme to fund al-Qaida and the Palestinian militant group Hamas. Elfgeeh was not charged, however, with any terrorism-related crime.

After less than a day of deliberations, the jury convicted Elfgeeh of conspiring to run an illegal money-transmitting business, running an illegal money business and structuring bank deposits to avoid reporting laws.

Elfgeeh, who could face 15 years in prison, looked stricken but did not move or speak as the verdict was read...

...After delivering the verdict, the jury said Elfgeeh should forfeit more than $22 million, a decision that would empty the defendant's frozen bank accounts if upheld...

That's one hell of a lot of double-scoop cones with jimmies.

No crackdown on Hamas

JTA: Abbas firm on no crackdown (no permalink)

Mahmoud Abbas rejected an international call for the Palestinian Authority to fulfill its commitments to crack down on terrorists.

“With regard to dealing with the Palestinian organizations, this is our affair,” the P.A. president told reporters Thursday, when asked about the demand leveled this week by mediators from the “Quartet” — the United States, European Union, United Nations and Russia — driving the “road map” peace plan.

Despite the requirements of the road map, Abbas has refused to disarm and dismantle Hamas and other Palestinian terrorist groups, preferring to coax them into a cease-fire.


Comrades! I am terrored!


Comrades!
I am terrored! A film has just arrived on the markets of Cameroon, this film the American Police Team or some name that is similar. My nephew, purchased this and asked me to watch because he said is had something to do with DPRK. The shock I see! The general, beloved general, Kim Jong Il is a puppet character in this film and speaking the most offending things! He swears in English, kills his interpreter, and turns into a small insect at the end. They make the Dear Leader to be evil man, and lonely man. They find risible the undying love of the Korean people? They think the leadership of DPRK and the revolution is a joke? Forgive me for saying but makers of this film are bastard people! I denounce them and curse them! Bastard people!
Can we not complain to someone about such slander? Why has not the KCNA denounced this piece of capitalist propaganda? To think that they make light of the general and debase his greatness!

Mick Hartley re-posts the above quotation from a [North] Korean Friendship Association forum. Says Mick:

What amazes me more than the fact that some poor Cameroonian sap is in thrall to Kim Jong Il is the fact that there are also UK commenters there who agree with him. What is it with these ultra-leftists that they can find anything remotely praiseworthy about Kim Jong Il's extended prison camp of North Korea?

And I would ask, What is it with these ultra-leftists, that not only do they have no sense when it comes to choosing all-powerful imperial overlords, but they fail even to recognize 2004's finest film release? Disturbing.

Perversely entertaining, or disturbing, depending on perspective is that yes, there is a "KFA," and yes, ernest people from around the world -- apparently literate and mentally functional -- post there. I found this thread, in which a renegade is chastized by the moderator for attempting to set up an "unofficial" KFA, to be...predictable, typical...what is the word?

Why are you trying to form a renegade "KFA" section in the USA? You should be part of the real, official section that already exists with a link on this site. Are you a splittist? I bet that you support Taiwan independence, too...

A Historical Gaff

The World is incredulous at the historical illiteracy of the French Foreign Minister...

Haaretz: Haaretz investigates French FM's faux pas at Yad Vashem

The French satirical magazine Le Canard Enchaine reported in its September 14th issue that during the visit of French Foreign Minister Philippe Douste-Blazy to the new Holocaust museum in Jerusalem's Yad Vashem on September 8, he asked - while perusing maps of European sites where Jewish communities had been destroyed - whether British Jews were not also murdered. Needless to say, Douste-Blazy's question was met by his hosts with amazement. "But Monsieur le minister," Le Canard quoted the ensuing conversation, "England was never conquered by the Nazis during World War II."

The minister apparently was not content with this answer, which, according to the magazine, was given by the museum curator, and persisted, asking: "Yes, but were there no Jews who were deported from England?"...

...One of the escorts confirmed on Sunday, on condition of anonymity, that the quotes in Le Canard were accurate, and that they caused great embarrassment. "It's a bit difficult to understand," the source said, "how an educated French person, who was serving in the French government during the huge celebrations of the Normandy landings, does not remember basic facts about the history of World War II, and especially Britain's role, especially in light of the fact, that France's great leader, General de Gaulle, led the operations of the Resistance from exile in London."...

Yet, perhaps not so difficult to understand coming from a Frenchman. At risk of exposing my own ignorance, but as I understand it, Vichy was never "conquered," yet still, they deported their Jews.

Wednesday, September 21, 2005

Posers

David Boxenhorn links the Second Draft site (you've watched the Pallywood film by now, I hope -- he also links the Egyptian brides story below, btw) and adds a personal anecdote with a couple of points I thought readers would find interesting:

In addition to the obvious points, I was struck by how well the Palestinians were dressed (note: it's a warm climate). No evidence of grinding poverty. And let me share a personal story: I was once touring the Negev with my parents and we happened upon a bucolic scene of a Bedouin boy tending a flock of sheep. We stopped to take a picture. The boy, obviously misconstruing our desires, obligingly picked up a rock and posed for us, as if he were about to throw it. Now where could he have learned to do that?

JPost: Egyptian brides smuggled into the Gaza Strip

Couldn't they just use mail-order catalogs like normal people?

On serious note, something in what we've been told doesn't quite add up here (see also this post, below). We're told the Gaza strip is one of the most miserable places on the planet, yet it seems the standard of living is higher there than parts of Egypt. Read on.

JPost: Egyptian brides smuggled into the Gaza Strip

Many Palestinian men who flocked into Egypt after the IDF evacuated the Philadelphi corridor have seized the opportunity to search for brides. Palestinian sources estimated on Tuesday that at least 100 Egyptian brides were smuggled into the Gaza Strip in the past week.

"Most of the brides came from the Egyptian part of Rafah and the town of Al-Arish, which were invaded by hundreds of thousands of Palestinians after the border was left wide open," one source told The Jerusalem Post. He said Palestinian men were encouraged to marry Egyptians mainly because of the low expenses involved, especially the dowry.

"When you compare the situation with the Gaza Strip, it's much cheaper to marry a woman from Egypt," said another source. Some of the men were already married and had decided to take a second or third wife after discovering that Egyptian families were eager to send their daughters to a relatively better life in the Gaza Strip, the source added...

...One of the brides, who identified herself as Samira, said she agreed to marry the man she met only hours earlier "because this was an opportunity that should not be missed." Samira, 28, lived with her family in Al-Arish.

"In Egypt, it's very difficult for a woman my age to get married because I'm considered too old," she said. "Moreover, the economic situation in Egypt is not as good as in the Gaza Strip."

Another bride from Al-Arish said that she always been dreaming of marrying a Palestinian. "Palestinian men are better than Egyptian men," the 27-year-old said. "They know how to look after their wives and provide for them a decent living." ...


From Ted and Jane, with regards...

A snippet from the FDD blog:

...Christopher Hitchens, the writer, told me about a visit he made to North Korea four years ago.

He took a tour of the enormous palace in the mountains that houses the gifts given to Kim Jong Il and his father - from the folks who suck-up to power.

A stuffed bear’s head from Ceausescu of Romania-fancy personal railroad cars from the Soviets. A large warthog from Mugabe of Zimbabwe.

All the gifts –except perhaps the warthog - which is now in a zoo- are labeled and arranged for display more than 60,000 of them.

On a table, Hitchens spotted a large silver box. It had initials engraved on the top. Three letters. Hmm. He picked it up. They read “C N N.” The tag said it came from Jane Fonda and Ted Turner. Nice...


Support for Romney

I missed this one from the other day:

NRO: Don’t Apologize, Governor Romney! by Andrew McCarthy (via FDD)

Monitoring radical mosques is exactly what we should be doing.

Radical mosques are the spark lighting the fuse that can kill Americans. That has killed Americans. That will kill more if we let it. Such killing sprees, moreover, are plotted by young, male, Muslim militants who often enter to the United States on student and other visas from places known to sponsor or export terrorism.

None of this is news. But it is cloaked in taboo. Thus, controversy was stoked last week when Mitt Romney, the Massachusetts governor and potential Republican 2008 presidential hopeful, did something that you should never do in this country. Not, at least, if you want to escape the caterwauling of civil liberties extremists and a cacophony of activist Muslim organizations whose knee-jerk approach to "opposing" terror is indignant spewing at every effort made to prevent it.

He told the truth...

Of course, today, the Globe is back to publishing apologetics:

Shahid Ahmed Khan: Romney's misstep with Muslims

...The incitement of political violence is abhorrent to Islam, and those who promote this tactic are rejected by the vast majority of Muslims, who want the same things as everyone else -- a future of peace and prosperity for ourselves and our families. And so, if there are indeed radical, potentially violent elements within our community, who better to expose and uproot them than we?...

Who better to help than the FBI? Are you treating them as a friend, or with suspicion?

You can send a message of support for Governor Romney through this web page, and this one.

Update: JRTelegraph has some comments on the Globe op-ed with some practical suggestions you should read.

Voice from Iraq

Jalal Talabani: We Need American Troops - Thank you for liberating my country. Please don't leave before the job is done

...Without foreign intervention, the transition in Iraq would have been from Saddam's bloodstained hands to his psychopathic offspring. Instead, thanks to American leadership, Iraqis have been given an opportunity of peaceful, participatory politics. Contrary to the new conventional wisdom, Iraq and the history of 20th-century Europe demonstrate that force of arms can implant democracy in the most arid soil.

The rapidity of the democratization and reform of Iraq is staggering. There was no German state for four years after the Second World War. By contrast, Iraq has moved from a centralized, one-man dictatorship to a decentralized, federal republic in half that time.

Inevitably, there have been stresses and strains. In Iraq these have been amplified by the terrorism of the remnants of the fascist Baathist dictatorship and our interfering neighbors. To contain these tensions, and to defend our young democracy, requires the support of American and other troops. Foreign forces are needed to train and equip the new Iraqi armed forces and to give Iraq its own counterterrorism capability. Only the United States and its closest allies are able to provide such assistance...

People are still yapping about illegal wars and bringing home the troops and apologizing to Muslims, but here is the President of Iraq begging us to stay.

FDD has a Blog

A Grassroots UCC Effort

Here is a grassroots effort by a member of the United Church of Christ to show dissent on an "in the pews" level to decisions made at the denominational level...a petition. This one's focused on marriage rights, but wouldn't it be interesting if some enterprising UCC'r or PC(USA)'r did something similar on divestment? If the system isn't working, go around it, or shame it into working properly.

Oh, loosely related, and found via the UCCTruths site, is this speech by Rabbi Harold Kushner, author of the best selling 'Why Bad Things Happen To Good People', who spoke at Wayzata Community Church (UCC). You might take some time to listen to it. Pretty good.

Romney Sticking To It

Mitt Romney isn't backing down (via LGF):

Romney stands by comments about Muslims

...While the Anti-Arab Discrimination Committee[sic] said Romney's remarks were "dangerous" and asked him to retract them, Romney told reporters that he stood by his comments.

"When it comes to protecting our citizens, there is no place for political correctness," Romney said at an unrelated press conference. "We should be doing more in terms of intelligence and counterterrorism in the state to protect ourselves from terrorists. We spend a lot of our resources thinking about response, but response can't protect us. We have to be able to prevent attacks."

Romney said that if U.S. intelligence officials have information that a person is "preaching messages of hate and terror," then there should be sufficient grounds to conduct surveillance on them in their places of worship.

"Surely, we have to recognize that some of this has gone on in mosques in the past," Romney said. "Most mosques are teaching doctrines of love and consideration, but there have been places of extremism where certain teachers have been identified as having been involved in or led to terrorist attacks. Let's not pretend that's not the case."...

Previous posts here and here.

Oh, and then there's this:

...[President of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee of Massachusetts Merrie] Najimy, who is Lebanese, said she does not think American society has "come a long way" since the attacks of four years ago...

American society hasn't come a long way???

Tuesday, September 20, 2005

One would never know...

You would think that the "Occupied Palestinians" must have the lowest standard of living on the planet, to hear the tales. The truth is something quite different, according to CAMERA:

Snapshots: U.N. SAYS PALESTINIANS FARE BETTER THAN OTHER ARABS

Palestinian Arabs living in the Israeli-controlled West Bank and Gaza Strip have fared better in terms of life expectancy, adjusted real income, and educational attainment than many fellow Arabs, according to the United Nations. The U.N.’s 2005 Human Development Report, released to coincide with this month’s opening session of the U.N. General Assembly, ranks the Arabs of what it calls “Occupied Palestinian Territories” at 102 out of 177 countries.

The Associated Press and other wire services filed dispatches mentioning the report’s general finding – that not enough is being done for the 40 percent of the world’s people who live on less than $2 a day. But a September 19 Nexis search showed no news coverage of the study’s ranking of Palestinian Arabs under “Israeli occupation” higher than Algerians (103), Syrians (106), Egyptians (119), Moroccans (124) and Yemeni (151). Based on data for 2003 – a period of frequent Israeli counter-terrorism responses to the “al-Aqsa intifada” – the Arabs of the West Bank and Gaza Strip also were not far behind Tunisians (89) and Jordanians (90).

Contradicting the story-line

A great deal of news media commentary, and not a little reporting, has portrayed the Palestinian Arabs as impoverished, and forced by Israel to endure substandard if not subhuman living conditions. The U.N.’s 2005 Human Development Report suggests otherwise, the Palestinian ranking of 102 falling into the “medium human development” listing...

...Israel ranks 23 in the U.N. report. The top Arab states are the oil-rich, population poor sheikdoms of Qatar (40), United Arab Emirates (41), Bahrain (43) and Kuwait (44)

Arabs' Self-Inflicted Woes

At first glance, the 2005 study might seem to conflict with the U.N.’s 2004 Arab Human Development Report, which asserted that the standard of living for 58 percent of the Palestinian population fell below the poverty line. But without the self-inflicted damage of the Palestinian’s 2000 - 2005 terrorism war against Israel, the territories – whose economies had grown markedly in the Oslo “peace process” years of 1993 - 2000 – likely would be listed even further ahead of Algeria, Syria, Egypt, Morocco and Yemen. As the under-reported 2004 study noted, much of what really ails the Arab countries, and the Palestinian Arabs, are “deficits of freedom,” including lack of Western-style political, religious, minority and women’s rights and the prevalence of corrupt, oppressive, unrepresentative governments...

For other demographic data, see this prior pointer to Martin Kramer's blog.

The Kosher Commodore

Neo-Neocon has an interesting post on the man behind the name of the Naval Academy's new Jewish Chapel, Commodore Uriah P. Levy. Levy served in the US Navy during the great age of sail back in the early 19th century -- a fascinating time as any reader of Patrick O'Brian's novels knows. Novelizations aren't necessary to derive enjoyment from reading about that era, however. Every time I've picked up a non-fiction book on the era thinking it might be dry I've been pleasantly surprised. I recently read The USS Essex: and the Birth of the American Navy, something I picked up at a Buck a Book thinking it would be a dry read. Wrong. It's tough to write about that era and make it boring.

Anyway, read neo's post. You may learn a thing or two.

Annapolis grad OceanGuy says "I'm proudly looking forward to my first visit to the Levy Center..."

DePaul's Albatross

Do you think DePaul University knew who Norman Finkelstein was before they hired him? If they did, they could have asked. Finkelstein has a wonderful resource on his own "issues" posted right there on his own web site. Apparently reposted from CampusJ, most people would re-post this stuff in order to respond to it. Finkelstein clearly feels no pressure to do so. Far-Leftists like Finkelstein wear this stuff as a badge of honor. Seriously. Dismissed from his previous jobs, he was recruited by DePaul. With the state of the Academy today, guys like this will always land on their feet.

The Committee to Expose Norman Finkelstein's Close Connections to Neo-Nazism, Holocaust Denial, and His "Big Lie" of an "International Jewish Conspiracy"

Wherein you can access various "top-ten lists," including:

The 10 Nuttiest Things "The Nutty Assistant Professor" Has Said
The 10 Most Devastating Things People Have Said About Finkelstein
The 10 Most Despicable Things Finkelstein Has Said About Others
The 10 Biggest Lies Finkelstein Has Been Caught Telling

Go ahead and take a look. Great stuff! My only question is, 'Only 10?'

JAT has an action item that's also a very good resource. I paste large portions of it here:

SUBJ: Anti-Semitism at De Paul University

In the past three years, De Paul university has:

* hired a notoriously anti-Semitic and unscholarly professor;
* fired a professor for advocating a factual approach to the Middle East; and
* sponsored an anti-Semitic art exhibit with "scholarly" captions that misstate history.

ACTION
---

Write to the President of DePaul University asking that he convene a panel of disinterested scholars from other universities to look into the situation at DePaul and to determine why the university has three times taken positions antithetical to the high standards of scholarly rigor expected of American Universities. And ask why in these three cases where Jewish issues were involved, the commitment to uphold evidence-based standards of fact was ignored.

I'm going to remove the contact info and suggested letter. No sense in posting it here. If you'd like it, subscribe to the JAT list and email the team. You can also email me.

The background on this is a very useful resource and continues in the extended entry below.

Continue reading "DePaul's Albatross"

If your enemy's going to walk off a cliff, why stop him?

I was all set to mock this H.D.S. Greenway column in today's Globe, but I'll be honest with you...I think he may be right. He acknowledges that Hamas is a terror organization...that's something...for the Globe. HonestReporting points out that Hamas's participation in the elections is an abomination, according to both the Roadmap and Oslo, but Greenway does what most have done...ignore that uncomfortable truth and pretend it doesn't exist. What else? No one is going to stop Hamas, and if the Palestinian Arabs want to elect a genocidal group to power...maybe we should let them.

Hands off the Palestinian elections

...Hamas could indeed win 40 percent of the vote. In the Middle East the man with the hardest line often wins in times of stress. That's how Sharon came to power, and that's how he could lose power to the opportunistic Benjamin Netanyahu on the right. But people change as circumstances change. Consider Sharon, father of the settlement movement, having the courage to give up Gaza. Given a chance for peace, Israelis and Palestinians have both shown that they can compromise and back away from extremism.

At one time, the entire Arab world refused to recognize the state of Israel and called for its destruction as Hamas does today. Yet Egypt and Jordan now recognize the Jewish state, and all the rest of the Arab League have committed themselves to doing so in principle if something approximating the 1967 borders can be restored...

Have Palestinians shown they can compromise for peace? I'd like an example of that. And it's instructive to note that Jordan and Egypt are two of the world's biggest sources of Jew hate.

OK, I'm going soft. There is no indication that Hamas getting what it wants will moderate them. In fact, the evidence is entirely the opposite. Sharon and the so-called "Jewish terrorists" were all democrats at heart. They fought for a democratic state. Hamas's goals are entirely different.

I don't see a bright outcome, however. Be real. Hamas is running. Let's see what percentage of Palestinians elect a genocide, terrorist hate-group to lead them. Take note.

Church of England Advisory Group Rejects Divestment

Some sectors of the Church of England are being silly:

Church of England offers to meet Muslim leaders to apologize for Iraq war

LONDON - The Church of England offered Monday to take the lead in reconciling with Muslims by apologizing to their leaders for the US-led war in Iraq if the British government fails to do so...

They ought to just start their own web site.

Anyway, other sectors of the CoE are somewhat surprisingly talking sense:

Press Release: CHURCH DECISION: NO TO DIVESTMENT

The Board Of Deputies Of British Jews today welcomed the decision by the Ethical Investment Advisory Group of the Church of England to reject calls for disinvestment from Caterpillar, suppliers of construction machinery to many countries in the Middle East.

Commenting on the decision, the Board's Chief Executive, Jon Benjamin said "The EIAG consulted with us, the office of the Chief Rabbi and others within the Jewish community, as well as with those who advocated economic sanctions. We are particularly pleased that this matter had a proper airing and that the decision was made on the basis of all of the facts and of the positive developments in the region."

He added "All too often, campaigns for divestment and boycotts have been driven by misinformation or by the most superficial assessment of the actual situation on the ground. When the true position is explained, the inappropriateness of economic sanctions is exposed."

Also here.

A Giant Dies

Simon Wiesenthal: "The Conscience of the Holocaust, Dies in Vienna" at 96

Simon Wiesenthal, the famous Nazi Hunter has died in Vienna at the age of 96, the Simon Wiesenthal Center announced today (September 20th).

"Simon Wiesenthal was the conscience of the Holocaust," said Rabbi Marvin Hier, dean and founder of the International Human Rights NGO named in Mr. Wiesenthal’s honor, adding, "When the Holocaust ended in 1945 and the whole world went home to forget, he alone remained behind to remember. He did not forget. He became the permanent representative of the victims, determined to bring the perpetrators of the history’s greatest crime to justice. There was no press conference and no president or Prime Minister or world leader announced his appointment. He just took the job. It was a job no one else wanted.

The task was overwhelming. The cause had few friends. The Allies were already focused on the Cold War, the survivors were rebuilding their shattered lives and Simon Wiesenthal was all alone, combining the role of both prosecutor and detective at the same time."

Overcoming the world’s indifference and apathy, Simon Wiesenthal helped bring over 1,100 Nazi War Criminals before the Bar of Justice.

Biographical info and links.

Zimbabwe Minister: White farmers are 'filth'

Minister vows to rid Zimbabwe of 'filth'

A leading Zimbabwean Cabinet minister vowed at the weekend to rid the country of the "filth" of white farmers. Didymus Mutasa, the Minister for State Security and Land Reform, said all remaining white farmers must be "cleared out".

About 400 white families are still farming in Zimbabwe, following the seizure by President Robert Mugabe's government of more than 4 000 farms.

Mutasa, one of Mr Mugabe's closest advisers, referred to Operation Murambatsvina ("Clean out the trash" in Shona) -- the campaign in which the government destroyed the homes of hundreds of thousands of urban poor.

"Operation Murambatsvina should also be applied to the land reform programme to clean the commercial farms that are still in the hands of white farmers. White farmers are dirty and should be cleared out. They are similar to the filth that was in the streets before Murambatsvina," said Mutasa, according to the state-controlled Sunday Mail newspaper...

Don't worry, though, President Mugabe's humanitarian bona fides are in tact:

...Meanwhile, Mugabe accused the United States and Britain of racism and double standards over human rights on Sunday, and said the UN housing agency should work with US storm victims, not Zimbabweans left homeless by government demolitions of slums.

Mugabe questioned why his government was criticised for demolitions that left up to an estimated 700 000 people homeless while Britain and Habitat, the Nairobi-based UN agency, remained silent about the US government's response to Hurricane Katrina...


The Law

I think Daveed Gartenstein-Ross is even better -- OK, let's say just as good -- on judicial matters as he is on terrorism.

Weekly Standard: Expanding Rights vs. Protecting Rights

JUDGE JOHN ROBERTS'S Senate confirmation hearings last week were only the opening salvo in a broader war over the future of the Supreme Court. Most observers expect Justice O'Connor's replacement to generate far more contention than Judge Roberts did, since that nominee could substantially change the Court's ideological composition. As the war for the Supreme Court heats up, it's important for conservatives to understand why the nominations matter. Many conservatives have seized on issues where the Court has played, or might play, a decisive role--such as abortion, gay marriage, or the separation between church and state. While these issues are important, they're only part of a broader trend: The left has been fighting the culture wars through the courts for more than three decades. Its agenda has been advanced not through sound legal reasoning, but through political philosophy masquerading as constitutional interpretation. Unless conservative jurists can change our country's legal trajectory, the left may win the culture wars through clever use of the least democratic branch of government...

No wonder outlets like the Boston Globe are writing articles like, Pressed on compassion, Roberts defers to law. I think they mean that as a bad thing.

Federal Money for Islam

Why is the Federal Government providing $145,000 to propagandize for Islam?

Boston Globe: Grant helps college teach Islamic diversity

...Middlesex Community College is now undertaking a broad initiative to try to change that attitude. The college, which has 4,500 day students on campuses in Bedford and Lowell, has received a $145,000 federal grant to teach about pluralism within Islam.

The goal is to broaden understanding of Islam so students feel less threatened by it and its followers -- and to erase those negative stereotypes they might have about Muslims.

''We don't have the most privileged students," Mitchell said. ''Some of them are going through life with certain attitudes."

If that prejudice persists, he said, it could lead those students to make poor decisions in the way they vote for president, spend tax dollars, or raise their kids.

Nearly two dozen faculty members from across the college will attend five seminars during the next two years so they can learn to teach about pluralism in Islam. The faculty seminars will focus on four Islamic societies: Egypt, India, Indonesia, and Saudi Arabia.

''Within each of these Islamic societies, as in Christianity, there is a whole spectrum of faith and political ideals," Mitchell said.

At the same time, the college is introducing beginning courses in Arabic, and will eventually add four other courses that will help students understand the religious and political differences that exist within Islam in various countries.

''It's the fastest-growing religion in the world," Mitchell said. ''It can be more progressive than Christianity in its treatment of women."...

Oh really?

Look, there's nothing wrong with teaching about Islam and learning Arabic. That's as it should be. Islam is diverse. That's true. But this article makes it clear that this is not learning for learning's sake, it's teaching for a political purpose. It's propaganda. Christian students undoubtedly get disrespected for their faith, especially here in the Commonwealth. Are the Feds going to pony up some dough to teach tolerance toward Christians? Is the college going to dedicate resources to that? I doubt it.

Teach the subject and let the chips fall. If it turns out that a study of the societies in question shows that Islamic societies are not so tolerant, democratic, free, or progressive toward women, will the instructors let that stand, or will they guide things so that a "proper" conclusion is come to? What if it's found that a rise in the population of "moderate" Muslims coincides with a rise in the incidence of good old-fashioned 1930's anti-Semitism, as Britain is in the process of finding out? Will students face the uncomfortable truth, or will that truth be sanitized and excused as just a reaction to persecution?

Study is good, but judging from these quotes, I wouldn't trust the teachers. Where is the federal oversight?

Finally, will the study of Islam in Indonesia include reading articles like this:

Indonesian radicals in aggressive mode

ARMED with sticks and stones, hundreds of Indonesian Muslim extremists descended on the Ahmadiyah, a small peaceful Muslim group in Bogor, West Java, in July.

The attackers set fire to the women’s dormitory and knock- ed down a gate fronting the Ahmadiyah complex as its followers looked on helplessly. Some 300 policemen were on guard but failed to prevent the attack.

Shortly after, Emilia Renita, 38, a Shia Muslim in Jakarta started receiving threatening messages on her mobile phone saying: "Shias are deviant. Their blood is halal."

"I was shocked. I am Muslim and yet I am threatened. What more for those who are non-Muslims?" she said.

The surge in radicalism was partly triggered by 11 decrees issued in July by the official Council of Indonesian Ulamas (MUI) which banned the Ahmadiyah, liberalism, pluralism and secularism as anti-Islam...

I think the college faculty is about to learn to teach the wrong people about pluralism...it's not college students that have the real problem.

(hat tip: Miss Kelley)

Update: A quote from the article as it appears in the Lowell Sun reveals the political agenda even more starkly:

...Mitchell said all of the grant-funded efforts are important “because we're at war, and the war was first sold to us as a kind of religious crusade. [nonsense. -Sol] That's an either/or idea of human cultures which breeds confrontation and confrontation is not the future of the planet,” he said.

Tell that to...well, you get the point.

Monday, September 19, 2005

Grassroots Christian Effort

This past week, the Presbyterian News Service was kind enough to remind us of the PC(USA)'s priorities by reporting on a PC(USA) press release "lauding" Israel for the Gaza pullout...and listing the Security Fence as a remaining impediment to peace...

Letter lauds Israelis for Gaza pullout

...They said the denomination will continue to push for the cessation of actions by both Israelis and Palestinians “that violate human rights and impede peace,” including terrorist attacks, settlement expansions, construction of the “separation barrier,” and home demolitions...

Still unmentioned by the Presbyterian News Service (and national staff), but something they may want to consider for the next list are anti-Christian pogroms and honor killings...

We've seen, however, that some grass-roots Presbyterians are moving while the higher-ups stand, arms akimbo. A group of Presbyterians in Bradenton, Florida have forwarded a set of four "overtures" to their presbytery (regional group). Among the four is:

Divestment (Mississippi Overture) This overture was approved unanimously by the Presbytery of Mississippi on May 17, 2005 On rescinding and modifying certain actions of the 216th General Assembly regarding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict The Presbytery of Mississippi respectfully overtures the 217th General Assembly (2006) to approve the following:...

...3. The 217th General Assembly (2006) believes that the Overture expressed as Item 12-02 (On Calling for an End to the Construction of a Wall by the State of Israel) is too broad in scope and does not further the cause of peace. Item 12-02 is a blanket condemnation of the security wall being built by the State of Israel. The 217th General Assembly does not believe that the Presbyterian Church (USA) should tell a sovereign nation whether or how it can protect its borders or handle matters of national defense. [There follows some business about the location of the Security Fence I do not necessarily agree with, but it's better than what came before I suppose. -Sol]...

...As a matter of conscience, the congregations comprising the Presbytery of Mississippi cannot support divestment as an economic sanction against American companies legally doing business in Israel and/or Palestine. The underlying purpose of divestment is to inflict economic hardship and harm on companies doing business in Israel or Palestine. In clear cases – like genocide or apartheid – such action can be justified. In the present situation, however, where there is justice and injustice on both sides, it is unjustified and inappropriate.

The price of phased selective divestment falls disproportionately on one party to this conflict, namely Israel. Such remedies do not make for peace. The use of economic sanctions as a weapon in peacemaking puts the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) in the position of a judge passing judgment and imposing a sentence rather than a partner for peace. To rank and file members of the church, it appears arrogant, condescending, and punitive. Such actions, however well intentioned, do not make for peace...

Finally, the Judeo-Christian Alliance's Dexter Van Zile has another excellent paper available for download. From the press-release:

The United Church of Christ and the Christian Church (Disciples of Christ) crossed the line from criticism to outright racism when they passed resolutions condemning Israel’s security fence this summer, according to the Judeo-Christian Alliance, a group formed to stop the defamation of Israel by U.S. churches.

“Racism is the only word to describe resolutions that portray the uprooting of olive trees, which can be replanted, as a bigger problem than the deaths of Israeli children who are gone forever,” says Dexter Van Zile, director of the Judeo-Christian Alliance and author of Walls of Indifference, Walls of Contempt, a report on two anti-“wall” resolutions passed by the deliberative bodies of the UCC and DOC in July.

The report details how the churches portray Israel’s security fence as the cause and not the result of Palestinian terror against Israelis. It also documents how the churches portray the inconvenience suffered by the Palestinians as a bigger problem than the loss of Israeli lives. The resolutions make no mention whatsoever of the Israeli deaths caused by terrorism, but describe in great detail the impact of the security fence on Palestinians, notes Van Zile, a member of the UCC.

“These churches could not be bothered to ask Palestinians to stop the terror attacks that made the barrier necessary,” Van Zile says...

The report is here [Warning: PDF]: Wall of Indifference, Wall of Contempt.

Haveil Havlim #37

Soccer Dad is hosting the 37th edition of the Jewish/Israel related blogging carnival known as Haveil Havlim. Lots of links, here.

Pierre Rehov

For the past few years, one French(!) filmmaker has served as sort of the anti-Michael Moore, a one man Second Draft of history for the Middle East. In fact, footage from one of his productions is used in the Pallywood production. If you're not already familiar with the work of Pierre Rehov, I'd recommend seeking it out. Here is a link to the entry I wrote after seeing his film The Silent Exodus.

Here is a link to a review of his latest and an overview in New York Press: COMING NO TIME SOON

If you're tired of the New York Times-NPR Slant on Israel and the Palestinians, here's good news: documentary filmmaker Pierre Rehov has been challenging prevailing myths since 2001. With six films already to his credit and another on the way, this serious, never boring, and above all else courageous documentarian is starting to make some serious waves.

Last week he screened Hostages of Hatred at the Spanish and Portuguese Synagogue on the Upper West Side. The film looks at how Arab states, the Palestinian elites and the United Nations have all been instrumental in keeping Palestinians festering in refugee camps since 1948.

It has been a mainstay of Arab propaganda since 1948 that the Jews kicked the Arabs out of Palestine. But Rehov presents Arab newspaper and magazine accounts from both before and after the war of 1948 documenting Arab leadership's many calls to Arab citizens of Palestine to get out before the impending war started.

Those citizens were assured that they would be able to return to their homes within two or three weeks, after the Jews had been defeated. It didn't play that way, of course, and unlike all the other refugees from wars of the 1940s, those who had fled have been kept in squalid, hatred–breeding refugee camps in Lebanon, Jordan, Syria and Gaza for more than a half-century.

The UN oil-for-food scandal pales in comparison to the United Nations Relief and Works Agency which was set up ostensibly to serve the Palestinian people but which has more than anything else become a work program for 22,000 permanent UN workers...


Horrors of the Occupation

You've heard the latest far-Left meme by now, I'm sure. New Orleans is now "occupied New Orleans" (according to sanitized friend Cindy Sheehan among others), and the city has been militarized...as though that's a bad thing. Good grief.

Army Paratroopers Keep Watch Over New Orleans Neighborhood

...the soldiers met Willie Patterson, a New Orleans Housing Authority employee. The soldiers' neighborhood patrols "have been a great help to us" in keeping down looting and other crime, Patterson said.

The soldiers conduct neighborhood-watch-like patrols in Algiers to assist local authorities to find out "how people are doing" after the storm, explained Army Capt. Kenton R. Barber, Battery A's 28-year-old executive officer...

...Alexcener Reaux, a 74-year-old townhouse resident on Murl Street who stayed on through the storm, said she's glad the soldiers are around. "I feel safer; I go to bed and sleep good," she said.

A helicopter came to evacuate her after the storm, but Reaux said she refused to leave because the aircraft scared her. Two days later, Reaux's daughter arrived to take care of her.

Pfc. Oliver D. Butler, 19, said he helps distribute food, water and other items during the day to Algiers residents at a local mission.

"It's a catastrophe that's happened in this area," Butler said. Helping Algiers residents get back on their feet "makes me feel good inside," he said...

'Muslims and the Holocaust'

Cathy Young writes about the disturbing overlap between moderate, mainstream Muslim thought and anti-Semitism. While blog readers are likely well-familiar with the stories she cites, I'd bet it's the only mention most Globe or other MSM-consumers have come across...if they read Young's column.

I take issue with her mocking the concern "right wing bloggers" have with the Flight 93 memorial -- a red crescent pointed toward Mecca...bad taste at best -- but aside from that, it's refreshing to see this in the Globe.

Muslims and the Holocaust

RECENTLY IN England, four Muslim-staffed committees appointed to advise Prime Minister Tony Blair and his Cabinet on issues related to Islam have come up with a recommendation: Get rid of an official event viewed as offensive to Muslims. What event would that be? A celebration of the Crusades, perhaps? No, Holocaust Memorial Day.

In the words of one committee member, ''The very name Holocaust Memorial Day sounds too exclusive to many young Muslims. It sends out the wrong signals: that the lives of one people are to be remembered more than others."

That ''one people," of course, are the Jews...


The Medievalist Who Is Watchdogging the Media

Richard Landes writes at History News Network:

The Medievalist Who Is Watchdogging the Media

...Since journalism likes to call itself "the first draft of history,” we call ourselves The Second Draft: Historians look at Journalism.

Our opening dossier – Pallywood – is an exercise in pointing out that the emperor is naked. Evidence we will make available to the cyber-public suggests that our news desks regularly receive staged scenes of fighting and injury filmed by Palestinian cameramen using Western equipment. Rather than delete them or fire the cameramen for gross violations of journalistic standards, editors cut the obviously fake parts and run a medley of plausible sight-bytes as real news.

If any graduate student in medieval history came with a draft that treated its sources as credulously as our media have done in this case, he or she would not make it through the first semester...

... What’s going on here? Is this a joke? Judging from the smiles of both the actors and the cameramen that follow successful “takes,” yes. And the joke is on us.

How long has Pallywood been going on? We cannot say, partly because, so far, the MSM will not re-examine their own rushes, nor let outsiders see them. But the material we have suggests a widespread and common practice that probably began in the 1980s and continues today.

Now, it is one thing for Palestinian journalists to behave in this manner. Many openly admit that the media represent a battlefield for them and they subordinate its values to their cause. But why would Western media clean up these fakes and present them as news?...

Update: Wretchard writes about The Second Draft:

...Landes uses the outtakes and a frame by frame analysis to show, convincingly in my view, that much of it was entirely faked. My favorite is the footage of a group of fighters setting up an empty room into which they will later be firing, supposedly in combat with the Israeli checkpoint, then watching the a clip of the same footage, sans the setup, as news. My next favorite scene is viewing the dozen 120 mm main tank cannon 'hits' that were allegedly inflicted on a Palestinian hospital and watching the journalist sagely record what may safely be called evidence of his ballistic ignorance on his own film. Most of it is funny, some of it outrageously so, like the dead men who fall from biers in staged funerals and climb back on again...

...Watch Pallywood. You will laugh, but you may also cry.


Saturday, September 17, 2005

Pallywood in the MSM

I'm overdue in sending a special shout-out to Boston Herald reporter and Hub Blog author Jay Fitzgerald for responding to my pointers on the launching of the Second Draft site and writing an article about the new web site for the print edition of the paper.

Some in the MSM are listening. Thanks Jay.

Boston Herald: BU prof using Web in bid to catch media's anti-Israel bias

Sleep and appease and all will be well

The Boston Globe, unsurprisingly, was not pleased with Governor Romney's statement concerning Mosques and visiting students, but what really gave me a laugh was this bit:

...Few students come from those few nations clearly linked to terrorists. Students from friendly nations such as Saudi Arabia, with influential extremist elements, need to be treated as potential allies and intelligence sources unless they show themselves to be adversaries...

And how, pray, will they "show themselves" as such? By standing in the middle of Kenmore Square and announcing they're here to film Green Line trains and monitor security opperations for a follow-on strike? Hellooooo...Globe Editors, is anybody home?

That's the trouble with certain elements of the left that wear civil liberties like a fashion statement -- their reality interface doesn't function on all cylinders.

Fear not, brave citizens, the Globe brings us a Harvard scholar to explain that it's really past time to sit down and make common-cause with al Qaeda -- after all, they're just against "the occupation" among a few other very easily granted requests -- unmentioned in the piece is that one of the occupations that AQ is against is the Spanish occupation of Andalusia, but who's counting?

Proof in print of Orwell's statement that “Some ideas are so stupid that only intellectuals could believe them.”

Time to talk to Al Qaeda? by Mohammad-Mahmoud Ould Mohamedou

...How can the war be brought to an end? Neither side can defeat the other. The United States will not be able to overpower a diffuse, ever-mutating, organized international militancy movement, whose struggle enjoys the rear-guard sympathy of large numbers of Muslims. Likewise, Al Qaeda can score tactical victories on the United States and its allies, but it cannot rout the world's sole superpower.

Though dismissed widely, the best strategy for the United States may well be to acknowledge and address the collective reasons in which Al Qaeda anchors its acts of force...

Mr. Mohamedou is "associate director of the Program on Humanitarian Policy and Conflict Research." I suppose when all you have is a hammer, every problem looks like a nail.

Update: More on Mohamedou's piece at the The Weekly Standard (linked at Campus Watch):

...it turns out that Dr. Mohamedou's Globe op-ed is merely the condensed version of "Non-Linearity of Engagement," a 30-page treatise he produced, on Harvard's dime, back in July. And "numbskull" doesn't begin to describe the thing. It seems that Harvard University's associate director of "humanitarian policy" and whatnot believes the United States should belatedly "acknowledg[e] the logic in which terrorism is used as a method of warfare, according to a principle of indiscrimination whose rationale is negation of the notion of innocence of the civilian population, and imputation of collective responsibility." As Osama bin Laden himself has observed, American foreign policy is effected by politicians whom Americans have freely elected. And in that respect, concludes our man in Cambridge, al Qaeda clearly claims "a valid jus ad bellum case" against any and every one of us--man, woman, or child.

In the end, Mohamedou says, "these 'terrorists' are de facto combatants, and justice . . . is what they are after." Which is the true source of bin Laden's strength. And the reason that "no leading Muslim intellectual or scholar has denounced him."

Not at Harvard, anyhow.


Selling the rope that hangs us

Reuters: Iran to announce proposal in nuclear standoff

...European diplomats said the three European powers that have been negotiating with Iran -- Britain, France and Germany -- had adopted a softer tone to be seen to be giving Ahmadinejad a chance and to win over waverers on the IAEA board.

But they said the United States and the EU believed they had the support of at least 20 countries on the 35-member board, which meets beginning on Monday. One option being discussed was to put forward a resolution but hold off a vote for two or three weeks to give Iran a final chance to halt uranium conversion.

Nuclear powers Russia, China, India and Pakistan are all reluctant to back a referral and diplomats say Iran, the world's second-biggest oil producer, is convinced it has the upper hand and has little to fear from the Security Council.

The council has the power to take action against Iran ranging from a verbal slap on the wrist to a total trade ban.

IAEA chief Mohammed ElBaradei has urged the Western powers to wait but the diplomats said delay would only embolden Iran to push on towards nuclear fuel enrichment having "got away" with the precursor phase of uranium conversion.

Besides, the diplomatic arithmetic would get tougher when more nonaligned nations join the IAEA board later this month...

If it weren't for oil, there isn't a nation on this planet that would stand for a terror state like Iran being anywhere near anything nuclear.

Chomsky in Drag

Martin Kramer checks the prognostication ability of Israeli moonbat academic and Noam Chomsky disciple Tanya Reinhart...and finds her wanting (big surprise). Reinhart assured us that Sharon wasn't serious about the pullout. I guess we know how that turned out. Kramer also provides some useful demographic analysis that, along with Kramer's entertaining prose, is worth taking a gander at.

Tanya Reinhart: The Moonbat Has Landed

...I don't believe that a truly bum prediction can be dismissed as the equivalent of a bad hair day. It's evidence of some fundamental misunderstanding or latent bias. And while academics aren't paid to make predictions, they make them anyway, often in support of some political agenda. So as long as academic oracles continue to issue predictions, I'll continue to collect them, test them against reality, and grade them. Today I offer a fine specimen of a failed prediction. Grade: "F."

The pseudo-oracle is Tanya Reinhart, a former student of Noam Chomsky's and an emeritus professor of linguistics at Tel Aviv University, who now teaches at the University of Utrecht. She writes an occasional political column for Israel's largest daily newspaper, and she's the author of a book entitled Israel/Palestine: How To End the War of 1948. To call Reinhart a post-Zionist, or even an anti-Zionist, doesn't do her justice. She has made the reviling of Israel an art form, on behalf of an appreciative audience who thrill to her every denunciation and condemnation. The late Edward Said called her book "the most devastating critique now available of Israel's policy toward the Palestinian people," and that says a lot...


'PA society: Destruction of Israel is desired and attainable goal'

I waited a few days to post about this latest Palestinian Media Watch report since that means it's now on the web and I don't need to re-post the whole thing here.

Palestinian national goals remain unchanged.

PA society: Destruction of Israel is desired and attainable goal

...Palestinian Media Watch finds it significant that PA TV would choose to air these programs the day before Israel withdrew its troops from Gaza. These programs reinforce the messages the PA educational system has been delivering for years - and teach Palestinian children to see the peace process as temporary and Israel's destruction as attainable and inevitable.

German Politicians Using American Servicemen's Caskets to Campaign On

Davids Medienkritik has the picture. The politician in question, first arrogant, has apparently since backed off. Sometimes even our "friends" need to be reminded that there are consequences for slapping America in the face...if not during the election, as that might have an effect on it that we can't predict, then after. Let Schroeder know that he or members of his party using these types of images during the election are not going to be forgotten as soon as it's over. Don't grant this guy, Schwanitz, a visa to visit. Don't grant him diplomatic courtesies. Let Schroeder know we hold him responsible.

I suppose the point will become moot at this point, but I'm not sure just disappearing the poster is good enough.

Friday, September 16, 2005

Extremists on British campuses

I thought this was worth posting, in light of the entry below.

JTA: Report: Extremists on British campuses (no permalink)

Extremist Muslim groups are active on university campuses throughout Britain, according to a new report.

More than 30 places of higher education are named in the study by Anthony Glees, director of Brunel University’s Centre for Intelligence and Security Studies, as having been infiltrated by “extremist and/or terror groups.” Radical groups Hizb ut-Tahrir and al-Muhajiroun, banned from university campuses because of their extremism and anti-Semitism, were found still to be operating under different names.

The report also detailed far-right and animal-rights groups. “This is a serious threat,” Glees told the Guardian newspaper. “We have discovered a number of universities where subversive activities are taking place, often without the knowledge of the university authorities.”


Repost: Thoughts on the Mosque

This post recycles a post I made last October -- almost a year ago.

Since this blog now has more eyes on it than it had in the past, I think it might be nice to repost some stuff from the archives on occassion. Long time readers can skip it...as can short time readers, but that's another issue.

I tend to do only occassional longer posts that sort of get stuff off my chest before then going on with shorter pointer-style entries that assume the reader is grounded in what I've said before -- obviously not always the case. In light of the below two posts on Mitt Romney, I thought this would be a good one to dredge up...

Thoughts on the Mosque

[originally posted Oct. 9, 2004]

I wanted to say a few more things about the Boston Mosque situation (most recently posted about here). It seems to me there are a few things that I might be taking for granted, but probably bear laying out.

Primary among those are the answers to questions like: Why does it matter? What business is it of anyone's? Why care? Why pay all this attention to the construction of a new Mosque, but not a new Synagogue or Church - or Buddhist Temple for that matter?

Starting from the last question first - because Buddhists, Jews and Christians aren't responsible for most of the world's terrorism, and because those groups aren't having their members arrested around the country for hatching terrorist plots. Those things concern me.

The Islamic World, and in particular the Arab Islamic World, is rife with some of the most hateful Judenhass (Jew-hatred) seen since the 1930's. And not by some fringe group. It is mainstream. It is commonplace. It is peddled on TV. It is peddled by Government and in newspapers. And it is peddled in Mosques.

I know what many people think, seeing people identifiably Jewish raising these questions, they're thinking, "Don't bring your Arab-Israeli conflict here. It's not our problem."

It's your problem. It's not just about Israel, and it's not just about the Jews (who are, need I remind, Americans, too) - it's about all of us. It's not just about Judenhass, but anti-Western and in particular anti-American hate and contempt. This is all of a kind. The people selling books "revealing" the ways in which Jews use the blood of gentile children to bake their matzoh also know that it's Uncle Sam pulling the Jew's strings.

I think we have a right, even a responsibility of prudence to check into what's happening in our community. I think we have a right to ensure that none of the above is riding in on the coattails of some folks' good intentions, and our own tolerance and inclusiveness.

Continue reading "Repost: Thoughts on the Mosque"

Riding a Political Tiger

Well, it didn't take long for Mitt to feel the backlash for his comments reported in the Globe yesterday suggesting that the FBI should be keeping a closer eye on Mosques and visiting students. The Muslim American Society held a press conference today at the State House calling on Romney to retract his statement.

On September 14th Governor of Massachusetts Mitt Romney suggested the need to wiretap and monitor Islamic Centers as well as follow foreign students attending Massachusetts Universities. Governor Romney's comments suggesting that any of these centers are engaged in teaching doctrines of hate and terror, is not only a lie, but unacceptable and does nothing more but create the same hate and fear against the Muslim Community that Governor Romney is suggesting the Muslim Community harbors.

On Friday September 16th at 11:30 AM MAS Freedom Foundation will hold a press conference at the State House, along with the Islamic Society of Boston, MIRA, ACLU, ADC, American Friends Service committee, and the Students of Northeastern University, Boston University, Harvard, MIT, Boston College, Tufts University, Salem State,Wellesley, and Suffolk University, to address the Governors comments.

Here we're going to see tested, up close, the ability of a free society to protect itself, and how we can handle what are admittedly very sticky issues. Romney is choosing to ride a political tiger, and I wish him luck.

Thursday, September 15, 2005

A tale of two maps

The World According to CAIR

This is making the rounds, but really, it's so bizarre, everyone deserves to see it. The Council on American Islamic Relations (CAIR) and their bad, bad photoshoppery is on display here (and here). You should look if you haven't seen it.

Hijabs! Hijabs for everyone!

Mitt Romney Speaks Truth to Power

On the front page of the Boston Globe today:

Wiretap mosques, Romney suggests

WASHINGTON -- Governor Mitt Romney raised the prospect of wiretapping mosques and conducting surveillance of foreign students in Massachusetts, as he issued a broad call yesterday for the federal government to devote far more money and attention to domestic intelligence gathering.

In remarks that caused alarm among civil libertarians and advocates for immigrants rights, Romney said in a speech to the Heritage Foundation that the United States needs to radically rethink how it guards itself against terrorism.

''How many individuals are coming to our state and going to those institutions who have come from terrorist-sponsored states?" he said, referring to foreign students who attend universities in Massachusetts. ''Do we know where they are? Are we tracking them?"

''How about people who are in settings -- mosques, for instance -- that may be teaching doctrines of hate and terror," Romney continued. ''Are we monitoring that? Are we wiretapping? Are we following what's going on?"...

Sounds pretty common-sense to me. We ought to be concerned about such suggestions, but we ought not to dismiss them out of hand. Our own Islamic Society of Boston was caught removing endorsements by Yusef al Qaradawi from its English language literature, but keeping them in the Arabic version. Extremists like Siraj Wahaj and Mahdi Bray are frequent guests at area Islamic events. Bray has moderated his rhetoric since 9/11 for the most part, but has he moderated what he says when he thinks he's before a friendly audience? Reports of speeches of a different color made for "internal" consumption are nothing unusual. It would be irresponsible of the FBI not to take an interest.

You'll excuse me, but some statements do not seem to require a multi-paragraph response:

...Elyes Yaich, president of the Islamic Society of Northeastern University, said that foreign students, especially those from Islamic countries, already face unfair scrutiny coming to the United States and that subjecting them to specialized monitoring would further invade their right to privacy.

''It's something that shouldn't happen," Yaich said. ''If they're going to do surveillance, why not do it for synagogues and churches, too?"...

Umm...duh.

Testing Gaza

George Bush has reportedly told Ariel Sharon that there will be no more diplomatic steps until Gaza is quiet. This is good news that indicates the Palestinian Authority's ability to prove it's a real government is being tested. I believe they will fail at this, as to date the idea that the PA is a real government is nothing more than a gentlemen's agreement amongst governments and pseudo-governments like the UN to share a delusion together.

Assuming Bush sticks to this, and the PA fails to show it has any worth at all, what then? I don't know. Maybe a further rationalizing of borders and a fait accompli on the West Bank, as what could have been a re-routed fence becomes permanent -- Israelis on one side of the fence on what will be their land forever and Palestinian Arabs on the other side left to accomplish whatever it is they can accomplish as history moves on without them.

JPost: Bush: No more steps till Gaza is quiet

Speaking to reporters at the United Nations in New York city, Prime Minister Ariel Sharon said Thursday night that Israel would not return its forces to the Philadelphi route, because such a move would be irresponsible towards IDF soldiers.

Earlier in the day US President George W. Bush told Sharon there will be no further steps in the diplomatic process if Gaza is not quiet.

According to Israeli officials who participated in the 45-minute meeting, Bush told Sharon that from the US perspective Gaza is a test ground, and for there to be any further progress the Palestinians must ensure quiet, security and proper governance.

Bush also told Sharon the US would press the Egyptians to take control of the Egyptian-Gaza border, which has been open since the IDF's withdrawal from Gaza on Monday. Bush said he would impress upon the Egyptians and the Palestinian Authority the need to take effective control of the border.

During the meeting, Sharon described the anarchic situation reigning in Gaza in general, and along the Gaza-Egyptian border in particular...

Also note this little bit of hand-shaking:

...At a reception for the leaders in the afternoon, the president of Senegal introduced Sharon to Pakistan's President Pervez Musharraf, who shook his hand and then introduced his wife to Sharon as well.

Israeli officials said that was the extent of the "chance" meeting that had been anticipated since Foreign Minister Silvan Shalom met his Pakistani counterpoint, Khursheed Kasuri, some three weeks ago in Turkey...

Oh, and don't miss this Washington Post editorial that actually blames the Palestinian Arabs and the Egyptians, not the Israelis, for the chaos in Gaza. As Meryl says, "Read it all. Print it out, frame it, and refer back to it from time to time. Hell, even the slap at Israel’s conservatives is a mild one."

Washington Post: Bad Start in Gaza:

ONLY DAYS after the final withdrawal of Israeli forces, the Gaza Strip is on the verge of anarchy. Despite promises to impose law and order, the Palestinian Authority has allowed mobs of looters and armed extremists to rampage through former Jewish settlements, where they have burned or bulldozed synagogues left standing by Israel. Many of the valuable greenhouses that, with the generous help of international donors, were saved for use by the Palestinians have been stripped of equipment as police stood by and watched. Despite a formal agreement with Israel to maintain security, Egypt has allowed thousands of Palestinians to illegally cross its border, including rifle-brandishing militants. If it is not quickly checked, the disorder will destroy Palestinian hopes that the Gaza transfer will become a step toward statehood...

Bush condemns Gaza synagogue burnings

Hey, this is a pretty good speech and not a bad read.

President's Remarks at National Dinner Celebrating Jewish Life in America

...Religious freedom is more than the freedom to practice one's faith. It is also the obligation to respect the faith of others. (Applause.) So to stand for religious freedom, we must expose and confront the ancient hatred of anti-Semitism, wherever it is found. (Applause.) When we find anti-Semitism at home, we will confront it. When we find anti-Semitism abroad, we will condemn it. (Applause.) And we condemn the desecration of synagogues in Gaza that followed Israel's withdrawal. (Applause.)...

A Year of Klocek

It's been a year to the day since DePaul Professor Thomas Klocek ran afoul of campus political correctness and not only dared to question the Palestinian National Fantasy but caused several students to feel less affirmed, delayed their self-actualization, rocked the foundations of their premature know-it-alledness, and altogether left them needing to be cuddled.

For these transgressions, his career at the university was cut rather short.

Amusingly, Hizballah fan Norman Finkelstein, whom DePaul actively recruited, continues in good standing and will be up for tenure soon.

Marathon Pundit has a review of the events to date.

Update: Well lookee there, Marathon Pundit informs us that Finkelstein will be having a book signing at a Chicago Barnes & Noble -- he's a celeb out there! -- and good old Ward Churchill will be taking a spin through DePaul as a welcome guest. I'm sure he can find a home there if the Colorado gig doesn't work out.

The Carnival Turns Three

Hitchens v. Galloway

TigerHawk has a lengthy report from the Galloway/Hitchens debate here.

Judith's report is here. (Following links via her post.)

Patrick Belton live-blogged.

D-sTPfW, or Douglas for short, was there and reports here.

A Harry's Place reader also reports.

Wednesday, September 14, 2005

Pallywood now available for download


The web site Professor Richard Landes discussed in our interview is now open for business.

I highly recommend you head over to The Second Draft and start having a look around. Like any brand new web site, there will be some rough edges, but the meat of the site is all in order. There's a ton of text to sift through, and perhaps most interesting, there's some very eye-opening video to download. The Richard Landes, Nidra Poller produced film "Pallywood" is available for download, and you can watch excerpts and other snips of video with or without overdubbed narration so you can form your own sense of things.

I had seen excerpts of this film at a presentation a year ago, and it's very exciting to know that a mass audience is now also going to get a look.

If The Second Draft doesn't start getting its bandwidth hammered by people downloading video and reading analysis it would be a real shame indeed. Some people are impervious to proof...or the obvious...but for most people who delve into this site, things will never be the same...at least we can hope. Pass the word.


Update: Daniel in Brookline is impressed. Honest Reporting's Backspin Blog reacts, as does Lynn B. Alan Forrester says, "Go now." I couldn't agree more. Mick calls it "Faking it" and culls an illuminating quote. Pieter also links the site and says thanks for the sneak peak. You're most welcome! (Yes, bloggers who accepted my invitation to link the original interview -- unless I missed their post -- were rewarded with an early peak of the Second Draft site as a thank-you.)

Tuesday, September 13, 2005

PA Ambassador: "We are confronting these Jewish tyrants"

Not HIM, of course. HE doesn't want to become the mother of a martyr, he's describing what the people he represents aspire to (or what he'd like them to aspire to).

MEMRI TV: PA Ambassador to the UAE, Salim Abu Sultan on the Jihad of Palestinian Mothers

...A woman wakes her son up, he takes a shower, she prays with him, and hands him his weapon, they are filmed together, and then she says to him: "My dear, I want you back as a martyr. I want to become the mother of a martyr."...

Gruesome George

Christopher Hitchens: George Galloway Is Gruesome, Not Gorgeous

...Can I convey the deep sense of delight that stole over me when I learned that George Galloway and Jane Fonda were to go on an "anti-war" tour together and that the idea of this perfect partnership had come from Eve Ensler, author of The Vagina Monologues?

The pure silliness and risibility of the thing would have been quite beyond one's power of invention. And, oh, just to be present when they finally meet. Jane can shyly tell George, who yells daily about the rape of Jerusalem by Zionism, of the brave days in 1982 when she and Tom Hayden went to entertain Gen. Sharon's invading troops in Lebanon. He can huskily and modestly discuss (he says he's a great admirer of her role in Barefoot in the Park) his long record as one of Britain's leading pro-life politicians, and his more recent outrage at the judicial "murder" of Terri Schiavo.

Jane Fonda, who the last I heard was in the throes of a post-orgasmic spiritual transfiguration, was a byword for ditziness even on the left when I was young, and she now issues apologies for her past politics almost as rapidly as Barbarella changed positions. Galloway, however, is nothing if not grimly consistent. Here, just for an example, is what he said as recently as July, after speaking at the Al-Assad Library in the Syrian capital of Damascus, about the host after whose foul dynasty that library is named:

We covered the whole world in 60 minutes. I was very impressed by his knowledge, by his sharpness, by his flexible mind. I was very, very impressed. … Syria is lucky to have Bashar al-Assad as her President.

Not that the Syrian people had any say in their good fortune, in being passed from the rule of a megalomaniac father to a feeble son. And not that anyone in Syria is permitted to disagree when Galloway comes to give one of his speeches. More serious still, it had been on the preceding Feb. 14 that Rafik Hariri, a former elected prime minister of Lebanon, was murdered by a bomb of military-grade force. The U.N. investigator of this odious crime, Detlev Mehlis, has since caused the arrests of four senior pro-Syrian Lebanese officers. This week, he travels to Damascus to pursue his inquiries to the source. Bashar Assad, who had been planning to fly to address the United Nations, has decided not to show his weak, slobbering face in New York after all. All or most of this was known or at the least seriously suspected when Galloway went for his asshole dialogue with Assad in July, and also delivered an asshole monologue of his own. Indeed, the outrage in Lebanon had already led to a Syrian "withdrawal," even though Syria still does not recognize the existence of Lebanon as a state. Galloway publicly deplored this withdrawal, saying that Syria's presence in Lebanon was "legal," which it was not after the Taif Accords of more than a decade ago, and adding that "the beneficiary from the absence of Syria is the US and Israel."...

(via Norm)

Hitchens is debating Galloway tomorrow (How's Galloway get into New York in the first place? Shouldn't he be on a terror watch list someplace?). It should be a hell of a show.

Monday, September 12, 2005

Bug Blogging

Here are some pics I took this afternoon of some really big bugs hanging out all over the mint flowers in my backyard. The wasps are way bigger than they look in the pictures. Scary lookin'. The pictures were taken with my Panasonic Lumix DMC-LZ2and have been reduced slightly (in size and quality) for posting. Click the thumbs for the bigger versions.

Here are two shots of what I believe are Great Black Wasps:

And here are four of what I think are Great Golden Digger Wasps (they're even bigger than the black ones):

Finally, one good old-fashioned Bumble Bee:

"There are no synagogues here"

Move along, move along...

PA, Hamas defend synagogue razing

The Palestinian Authority and Hamas on Monday defended the decision to demolish the synagogues in the Gaza Strip, saying they did not want to give Jews an excuse to ever think about returning to the area.

PA chairman Mahmoud Abbas visited the former settlement of Dugit in the northern Gaza Strip, where he declared that the Israel did not leave behind any synagogues. "There are no synagogues here," he said. [Well, not anymore there aren't. -Sol]

"Israel left behind some empty buildings which that are likely to collapse. All the public buildings they left are in danger of collapsing," he said...

Anyway, in a perverse way he's right, isn't he (see the comments in this post)? Thing is, I think it's a distinction lost on the people doing the burning (and probably Abbas himself, anyway) who are fully conscious in their own minds to the idea that they are burning "synagogues."

...Ismail Haniyeh, a senior Hamas official in the Gaza Strip, said his movement would not allow the synagogues to exist for fear that they would be turned in the future into "Wailing Walls" for Jews. "We won't allow any Wailing Walls on our blessed land," he said.

Defending the decision to raze the synagogues, Haniyeh said Israel was trying to keep them to put pressure on the PA to protect them in the future. "These synagogues were built for political, not religious, reasons. They were built illegally and should go away with the occupation."

Meanwhile, a number of armed groups in the Gaza Strip announced that they would continue to launch attacks on Israel until it withdraws from more territories.

The armed wing of Fatah announced that it was planning to launch attacks inside Israel "until all our lands are liberated." Muhamemd Hijazi, commander of one of the Fatah- affiliated militias in the Gaza Strip, said his men were planning suicide attacks in Tel Aviv, Jerusalem and Beersheba...

Burning

(Previous post on the subject here.)

The Age: Burning synagogue lights Gaza dawn

SOMEWHERE in the dark hours before dawn yesterday the last Israeli tank reversed out of its bulldozed position at Netzarim, or Elei Sinai, or Kfar Darom, and rolled out of Gaza, perhaps for good.

At 2am tracer bullets darted over Gaza City as Palestinian soldiers saluted the fires that were springing up against the southern sky. The settlements were burning; after 38 years of, at best, strained coexistence, the Israelis were gone.

In the first grey light before the dawn Ahmed Talalka was already exhausted. The unemployed 20-year-old sprawled by a path in what, until hours before, had been the Jewish settlement of Netzarim, an Israeli enclave inserted hard against the southern outskirts of Gaza City.

"When I got here it was 12.30 and already there was no one, so we went straight to the synagogue and set it on fire," he said.


Continue reading "Burning"

Those British Academics Are At It Again

Just when you thought it was safe to go back for another double chai latte in the student union (wearing your kippa)...

The British Association of University Teachers briefly passed, and then fairly quickly overturned, an academic boycott of certain Israeli Universities. But there's a bigger, badder, more sinister union, NATFHE...and it's going down the same path.

Adloyada has an excellent, comprehensive post. Don't miss it. I've a feeling we're going to be talking about this one for awhile.

Is it just that the news is in English, so we can focus on it more, or does Britain really have the particular problem it seems to?

(Hat Tip: Judith)

Jews and Freemasons -- Still in charge after all these years

You know, this could very well go into the "history repeats" file in a way. It so happens that during the lead-up to the First World War, the British Foreign Office was convinced that a cabal of Jews and Freemasons held sway over the Ottoman Government in Constantinople. British intelligence into the Sublime Porte left something to be desired.

How sad that the British have come under the influence of some of the same conspiracy theories nearly a century later, this time in imported form.

Telegraph: Jews and Freemasons controlled war on Iraq, says No 10 adviser

Tony Blair decided to wage war on Iraq after coming under the influence of a "sinister" group of Jews and Freemasons, a Muslim barrister who advises the Prime Minister has claimed.

Ahmad Thomson, from the Association of Muslim Lawyers, said Mr Blair was the latest in a long line of politicians to have been influenced by the group which saw the attack on Saddam Hussein as a way to control the Middle East.

A Government spokesman confirmed last night that ministers and officials consulted Mr Thomson on issues concerning Muslims but refused to be drawn on his views. "We talk to a lot of people, including many whose views we do not necessarily agree with," she said...

It may be fair to question if they need to pay them, however, if indeed they did pay for this insight.

Mr Thomson said: "Pressure was put on Tony Blair before the invasion. The way it works is that pressure is put on people to arrive at certain decisions. It is part of the Zionist plan and it is shaping events."

The "Zionist Plan" as recounted in the Protocols of the Learned Elders of Zion, no doubt.

Mr Thomson wrote a book in 1994 in which he said Freemasons and Jews controlled the governments of Europe and America and described the claim that six million Jews died in the Holocaust as a "big lie". In The Next World Order, Mr Thomson, a Muslim convert who was born Martin Thomson in Rhodesia, wrote: "When the majority of people in a predominantly Christian society cease to worship God, the result is fascism.

"When the people in a predominantly Jewish society cease to worship God, the result is either communism or capitalism. A predominantly Christian society is concerned primarily with establishing a political ideology, whilst a predominantly Jewish society is concerned primarily with establishing an economic system."

This, he suggested, led to the rise of Adolf Hitler. Mr Thomson, who was called to the bar in 1979, wrote: "The fascism of Hitler was the Christian element in the increasingly "Jewish" environment in which he and his followers found themselves."

He also wrote that the Jews have no right to live in "the Holy Land" because they are not a pure race and therefore not the true biblical Israelites and that Saddam was used as an excuse for US troops - "including thousands of Jews" - to occupy Saudi Arabia...

You know I'm seeing this all the time recently. Some of the same people who love to scream about "racist Zionists," then go on to justify themselves by promulgating one of the more bizarre race theories -- that "Ashkenazi Jews" have no right to live in Israel because they're not "real Jews" -- as determined by blood, of course.

It's fine to hear all views, but these are of the sort that the Prime Minister ought to actively distance himself from. Or would that be off-putting to Muslim constituents? And if so, what does that say?

Campus Truth and Whitewash

StandWithUs is producing a new documentary entitled Tolerating Intolerance: Hate Speech on Campus. If it's half as influential as The David Project's Columbia Unbecoming it should be a major hit and well worth seeing.

Sadly, the Mainstream Media can't be counted on to give us anything more than the barest of puff-pieces, as this post at Marathon Pundit points out by highlighting a Chicago Magazine feature on DePaul University which paints a rosy picture while failing to mention the names Thomas Klocek, Norman Finkelstein (who's sure to figure in StandWithUs' feature) or Aminah Beverly McCloud.

Burning Synagogues

The Boston Globe's coverage is interesting. The Arab burning of the synagogues comes off as something that just sort of happened as Palestinian Arabs celebrate. Imagine if those had been mosques. Never mind the Muslim reaction, do you think the Western press wouldn't have been all over it with judgement and scorn? You bet they would be.

Not that Israeli authorities don't have their own measure of responsibility. They should have removed the synagogues with the worshippers. The system failed in that regard.

Nevertheless, the vision of burning synagogues and the ho-hum reaction of the press is instructive.

Boston Globe: Palestinians assume control of Gaza Strip

GAZA CITY -- Palestinian troops and cheering crowds rushed early today into abandoned Jewish settlements -- areas that had been closed to them for decades -- as Israel sent its last remaining troops out of the Gaza Strip in convoys.

At dawn, cars waved on by smiling Palestinian policemen sped down a road that the Israeli Army had blocked for five years, to the former settlement of Netzarim. There, a woman loaded scrap metal from a demolished Israeli guard tower onto a donkey cart while Palestinian police in blue camouflage lounged under trees. Nearby, black-masked Islamic Jihad militants and teenagers on bicycles surveyed the smoking rubble as a bulldozer tore into the pillars of a domed synagogue which had been burned overnight.

''I'm happy," said Fares Wahaidi, 56, whose house stands yards from the gap in the barbed-wire fence leading to the settlement. ''I didn't sleep all night."

''Today is the day of liberation," said Ehab al-Baz, 21, a supporter of the Islamic militant group Hamas who lives in the neighboring refugee camp of Nusseirat. ''We must make a new Gaza, a free Gaza, an Islamic Gaza."...

I'd say they're off to a rather typical start in that regard.

Sunday, September 11, 2005

The Mythical Martyr in the strangest places

I just found this opinion piece lauding Nidra Poller's Muhammed al Dura expose in, of all places, the LA Times (via Snapshots). Is there hope yet? Naaahhhh...

LA Times: When pictures lie:

A 55-SECOND video report, produced in 2000 by a French TV station and distributed free of charge around the world, has caused untold injury and grief to Israeli civilians. This month, the French author Nidra Poller analyzes the evidence in Commentary magazine and shows that the video is a fraud — "an almost perfect media crime," the retired French journalist Luc Rosenzweig calls it. That Poller's piece is conclusive is merely my own judgment, of course. But we are all required to make such judgments, in the light of such reports.

There is a wider story here also. We are vulnerable to video lies. Against purposeful lies, truth has never been so helpless, so weakly defended.

More than 500 Israeli civilians have been killed in the intifada, the Palestinian uprising that began five years ago. They were ordinary people chatting on a bus, eating ice cream in a restaurant; suddenly, a bright flash. The next moment the walls are spattered with blood and the bomb's hellish odor fills the air. Some people are blinded, others are cut to pieces. Parents living the worst seconds of their lives cast about wildly for their children in the screaming, smoky chaos.

What explains such bestial crimes? The reported death of a Palestinian child, Mohammed Dura, in Gaza did as much as anything else to ignite the current uprising. In the short video segment produced on Sept. 30, 2000, and distributed immediately, a state-owned French television station called France 2 accused the Israeli army of deliberately shooting and killing the 12-year-old.

You may remember the footage: A man and boy crouch in fear. Shots hit a wall far from the pair; a final round of gunfire kicks up a dust cloud that hides father and son, who are "targets of gunfire from Israeli positions," says the voice-over. When the dust clears, the boy is stretched at the man's feet. The voice says that he is dead.

This version of the story was retold around the world — and it has figured in countless wall posters, an Al Qaeda recruiting video, an epic poem. Last June an aspiring suicide bomber was arrested on her way to a hospital — to kill Israeli children, she said, in memory of Mohammed Dura.

BUT, ACCORDING to the Commentary article, the video is a fraud. The footage itself is ambiguous, the alleged main event hidden by dust. The voice-over is what makes us understand what we are seeing. It comes from Charles Enderlin, a correspondent at France 2 (and a French Jew who became an Israeli citizen 20 years ago). Enderlin has never claimed to have been anywhere near the scene of the alleged shooting. His Palestinian cameraman told him the story...


Today

Michelle Malkin has an excellent round-up of links and images.

Two extracts from her post:

They jumped:

They celebrated.

And don't forget this Cox & Forkum illustration from a couple years back that still deserves to be in every newspaper in the country:

And don't miss their contribution this year.

The Flight 93 Memorial

You know, at first I thought all the hubbub over the shape of the proposed Flight 93 Memorial was just a lot of blogosphere creativity feeding on itself -- with maybe a dose of insanity and a dash of bigotry thrown into the mix. But after seeing that the memorial will be aligned in such a way as to orient visitors to face Mecca, I'm thinking there may be something to it. Is that map accurate? Is it an accident? Is it significant?

Muslim advisors to Tony Blair: Ditch Holocaust Day

What to say about this? Simultaneously shocking and predictable.

Tony Blair is to be advised that one of the things he is to do should he wish to ameliorate Muslim "grievance" in the aftermath of the July 7th bombings is to ditch Holocaust Memorial Day -- offensive to Muslims don't you know. Oh, and don't ban the extremist group Hizb ut-Tahrir, after all, they don't advocate targeting Britain.

If there were ever an indicator that the rising tide of Muslim immigration to Europe has brought along with it many evils, and that among those evils are what has become a deep and abiding Jew hatred -- a feeling of animosity toward Jews -- as one of the defining pillars of a culture, then this is it. There are undoubtedly many good Muslim citizens in Britain who are embarrassed by this. They must make their voices heard louder.

Instead we're hearing from people like Sir Iqbal Sacranie, who, along with his group, the Muslim Council of Britain, boycotted the remembrance earlier this year and welcomes the finding, and we're hearing all sorts of false equivalencies like "the mass murder of Muslims in Palestine, Chechnya and Bosnia" -- as though the existence of a Holocaust Memorial Day harms any other grievance group's issue, real or imagined.

This isn't a Jewish issue. Where are the rest of you? After the Saturday people, it will be the Sunday people's turn (or the no day people). Appeasement and appeal to the worst aspects of a community will just result in more and worse. This is something -- and whether the recommendations are adopted or not, they are reflective of a very serious and disturbing truth -- that all people, regardless of faith (Christian, Jew, Muslim, Atheist, Hindu, etc...), should be disturbed by.

Times Online: Ditch Holocaust day, advisers urge Blair by Abul Taher

ADVISERS appointed by Tony Blair after the London bombings are proposing to scrap the Jewish Holocaust Memorial Day because it is regarded as offensive to Muslims.

They want to replace it with a Genocide Day that would recognise the mass murder of Muslims in Palestine, Chechnya and Bosnia as well as people of other faiths.

The draft proposals have been prepared by committees appointed by Blair to tackle extremism. He has promised to respond to the plans, but the threat to the Holocaust Day has provoked a fierce backlash from the Jewish community.

Holocaust Day was established by Blair in 2001 after a sustained campaign by Jewish leaders to create a lasting memorial to the 6m victims of Hitler. It is marked each year on January 27.

The Queen is patron of the charity that organises the event and the Home Office pays £500,000 a year to fund it. The committees argue that the special status of Holocaust Memorial Day fuels extremists’ sense of alienation because it “excludes” Muslims.

It doesn't exclude Muslims. Muslims exclude themselves from it.

Robert Spencer comments:

Instead, these learned experts want to create a Genocide Day that would pretend, and force Britons to pretend, that the continent-wide genocide of European Jews, who had committed no aggression, was no more heinous than three localized conflicts in which Muslims perished -- all three of which are highly doubtful as genocide and all of which contain significant elements of jihad aggression.

This is great: the task force on how to combat extremism recommends, "More dhimmi groveling and appeasement."

The rest of the Times piece, which is a highly recommended and short read, is in the extended entry as Times articles expire quickly as I recall.

Continue reading "Muslim advisors to Tony Blair: Ditch Holocaust Day"

Katrina Slide Show

Saturday, September 10, 2005

A Baby Step on the Road to Civilization

And only because they're being pushed.

Does this mean they'll have to just deal with the paper cups now, or is that asking too much?

JPost: Saudis partially lift boycott on Israel

Saudi Arabia has agreed to lift certain aspects of its boycott against Israel in attempt to satisfy US demands regarding the Saudi request to join the World Trade Organization (WTO). An agreement between trade representatives of US and Saudi Arabia was signed last week. As part of this agreement, the Saudi government declares it will not enforce a boycott against American firms that have trade relations with Israel.

The Saudis also commit themselves to obeying WTO trade rules in regard to all member countries of the organization, including Israel. This does not mean that Saudi Arabia is abandoning the Arab boycott against Israel, but it does limit the scope of the boycott.

"This [agreement] represents progress for Saudi Arabia, the US and the WTO", said a statement put out Friday by US trade representative Rob Portman.

One of the conditions set by the US for signing a trade agreement with Saudi Arabia was abandoning the boycott against Israel and the final wording of the agreement is a result of lengthy negotiations on this issue.

A group of 47 US congressmen sent a letter to president Bush, calling upon him not to sign a new agreement with Saudi Arabia before the boycott issue is resolved. The lawmakers also said the US should use this moment to demand Saudi actions in the fields of human rights and religious freedom...

Hey, let's not get crazy!

EU-funded Palestinian "human rights" group sanctions terror

Here's the latest update from Palestinian Media Watch, in full, as it is not yet online.

None of the report is very surprising, but certainly still bears repeating. No Palestinian NGO, even those which have co-opted the term "human rights," is going to be able to operate without hewing to the Palestinian National Narrative which supprots "resistance" and honors the concept of martyrdom. That's why they have all refused to sign agreements that their funding won't be used for terrorism. They can't, because then they'd be left with nothing.

This isn't blockquoted for better ease of reading, but everything below here is quoted text.

EU-funded Palestinian "human rights" group sanctions terror and murder of Israeli civilians

By Itamar Marcus and Barbara Crook

The Palestinian Centre for Human Rights (PCHR) presents itself as a legitimate human rights organization. Indeed, it is perceived as such internationally, and receives funding from the EU's European Commission, Ireland, Denmark, Norway, the Ford Foundation and others (see listing below).

However, Palestinian Media Watch's examination of PCHR's statements has revealed an alarming pattern of defending terrorists and their activities. Two recent press releases, both this week and last month, chide terrorist groups for their carelessness in implementing terrorism against Israel - but only because their military activities targeting Israeli civilians have been carried out from Palestinian civilian populated areas, resulting in Palestinian civilian casualties.

Worse still, PCHR goes beyond the impropriety of ignoring the Israeli casualties from these often-deadly terror attacks - which have killed three Israeli children under the age of four and other civilians in the last year. PCHR expressly supports the idea of the "military activities" continuing, even though these attacks have been targeting Israeli civilians, as long as the terrorists pick their launching spots to avoid Palestinian casualties.

Last month Palestinian terrorists launched rocket attacks aimed at civilians in the Israeli city of Sderot. These terror attacks failed: One rocket hit a Palestinian hospital and another hit a home, killing a Palestinian child and injuring nine others.

In response, the PCHR issued a lengthy press release, criticizing the terrorists - not because they launched rockets at Israeli civilians, but because of their "repeated mistakes;" that is, hitting Palestinian civilians instead of Israeli civilians.

Continue reading "EU-funded Palestinian "human rights" group sanctions terror"

Mutual Trust

YNet: Dichter slams Palestinian lies

Speaking in Jerusalem, former Shin Bet chief says Palestinian Authority failed to live up to even one agreement reached during past five years, provides examples of lies uttered by PA leaders...

...“We must not accept their culture of lies, but we must be familiar with it,” he said. “They are our partners for better or for worse. Lately, it was more on the ‘worse’ side.”

When asked to provide concrete examples for his charges, Dichter shared two stories.

“In October 2001 we sat with the Palestinians in the presence of CIA Director George Tenet and Egyptian Intelligence Chief Omar Suleiman. We submitted a list of 114 terrorists who were in Palestinian prisons and but were released when the intifada started. Jibril Rajoub (currently the PA’s national security advisor), who was in the meeting, knew the details were accurate, but his colleague, Yasser Abed Rabbo, insisted that all of them were still in jail. As the argument continued, I suggested that Abed Rabbo put down a 100 dollar bill for every name of the list that’s in jail. Abed Rabbo replied: ‘I don’t occupy myself with money.’”

“Another, more serious example, was when Yasser Arafat pledged to President Bush that an activist who fired mortars was detained…I arrived at a meeting and heard the news from the Palestinians: ‘Avi, you can be certain, the man is in prison,’ Abu Ala (Palestinian Prime Minister Ahmed Qureia) told me. PA negotiator Saeb Erekat added: ‘definitely.’

“The thing is, Jibril Rajoub attended that meeting, and he knew the man wasn’t in jail, he knew that I know that the man isn’t in jail, and he knew that I know that he knows the man isn’t in jail. When he was asked whether the man was detained he replied ‘sort of’ – covering the entire range between yes and no. The next day, that man reached heavens after a missile hit his car in Bethlehem.”...


The casual anti-Semitism of the Arab press

Is Scott Speicher really still living?

Officially, he may be, although, to be honest, it seems awfully remote.

Navy: Iraqis know missing pilot's whereabouts

WASHINGTON (AP) -- A Navy pilot shot down over Iraq in January 1991 may have been captured by Iraqi forces, and members of the former Iraqi government "know the whereabouts" of the officer, the Navy has concluded.

A Navy board of inquiry concluded that there is no credible evidence that Capt. Michael "Scott" Speicher is dead, and it reaffirmed his official status as "missing/captured," according to the board's final report.

The board also recommended that the Pentagon work with the State Department, the U.S. Embassy in Baghdad and the Iraqi government to "increase the level of attention and effort inside Iraq" to resolve the question of Speicher's fate...


Friday, September 9, 2005

Clueless in Danbury

I don't know how many people read the Jewish Ledger, but it's nice to see someone in the print press pick this story up -- the print press still tends to take reports of their own malfeasance more seriously when it appears in other print publications rather than blogs.

Diana Muir recounts the story you read about here in Palestine Day in Connecticut - Part 2 and Palestine Day in Connecticut - Part 2:Update -- in which young ISM dupe Chris Towne writes home from a field trip in "Palestine," courtesy of a puff-piece article in the Danbury News-Times, to regale us with tales of all the evil the Israelis have been perpetrating on innocent Palestinian widows and orphans, and the paper defends its decision to cast fact-checking to the wind.

Clueless in Danbury

The Danbury News-Times recently published a disturbingly inaccurate and one-sided article about Israel in its Perspectives pages. (Aug. 28) "One Summer in Gaza," a news story by a member of the paper's staff, violated the newspaper's basic covenant with its readers: to insure that apparent statements of fact are really true. As readers objected, the paper's response was, in many ways, even more disconcerting than the original article.

The story featured a young man named Chris Towne who had just returned from four weeks in the Palestinian territories under the auspices of the International Solidarity Movement (ISM), in a program called the Palestine Summer Encounter. But the News- Times' failed to meet journalistic standards when it described the ISM program as providing an opportunity to "work with Palestinian non-profit organizations."

In fact, Palestine Summer Encounter participants are political activists in an organization that endorses terrorism and the destruction of the Jewish State. They spend their time in aggressive demonstrations involving such "actions" as dismantling security barriers and impeding police searches for bomb factories and the arrest of known terrorists.

Young Mr. Towne returned from his summer experience imbued with hatred for Israel, and "unabashed" in his enthusiasm for the Palestinian cause. The News-Times printed the Palestinian propaganda Towne gave them as straight news, even though it included many half-truths and a number of outright untruths...

By the way, since returning home, Chris has found a comfortable place at the table (in this case literally) with other members of the "Smash Israel Society." If you're anywhere near the Unitarian Church (I'm trying not to blame the Unitarians for this, they'll rent a room to anyone.) in Manchester, CT next Wednesday, you can attend a potluck and panel discussion entitled, "Palestine & the Anti-War Movement" featuring Chris as well as

Dr. Mazin Qumsiyeh, author of Sharing the Land of Canaan
Stanley Heller, founder of the Middle East Crisis Committee
Haidar Abushaara, of the Palestine American Congress
Additional Panelist To Be Announced.

I can't wait to see who the "panelist to be named later" will be. Both Qumsiyeh and Heller are officials of Al Awda, and Qumsiyeh you may remember as the Yale professor last seen doing mischief with the email system there. Yale Herald: Prof's email sparks controversy

... After many students had already left for the summer, Qumsiyeh sent an email to all Yale Coalition Peace (YCP) members, an anti-war group, in which he linked Jewish support of Israel with support for the then current war in Iraq.

In the email, Qumsiyeh wrote that "the U.S. occupation of Iraq illegal and immoral (sic)" and that the YCP should "continue to challenge the hegemony of the U.S. on the Arab world." Although such opinions are certainly acceptable and even welcomed at a university that encourages the exchange of ideas, Qumsiyeh closed his email with a chilling statement: "I include here the list of members of Yale Students 'for Democracy,' the pro war cabal . . . I think you will find the list informative. Note that there is significant overlap of this list with the 'Yale Friends of Israel' listserve."

Qumsiyeh then listed the Yale email addresses of 64 students, which contained students' full names, whom he claimed belonged to Yale College Students for Democracy (YCSD), a group that supported the war in Iraq.

However, the people he listed belonged not to YCSD, but to the Yale Friends of Israel (YFI) itself...

Fine company. My advice is that if you want to be taken seriously as an individual or group that truly supports peace, try associating with individuals or groups that at least make a passing show of supporting a two-state solution.

Appeasing Christians

Relative to the post below, Burning Villages, Christian Indifference, comes this article in London's Telegraph via Nannette in the comments:

'Islamic mafia' accused of persecuting Holy Land Christians

Christians in the Holy Land have handed a dossier detailing incidents of violence and intimidation by Muslim extremists to Church leaders in Jerusalem, one of whom said it was time for Christians to "raise our voices" against the sectarian violence.

The dossier includes 93 alleged incidents of abuse by an "Islamic fundamentalist mafia" against Palestinian Christians, who accused the Palestinian Authority of doing nothing to stop the attacks.

The dossier also includes a list of 140 cases of apparent land theft, in which Christians in the West Bank were allegedly forced off their land by gangs backed by corrupt judicial officials.

From the birthplace of Christ at Bethlehem to the site of his Crucifixion in Jerusalem, Christian Church leaders have long been desperate not to upset the delicate ethnic and sectarian balance in the region by blaming either Jews or Muslims for the decline of their once robust religious community.

That self-imposed silence now appears to be crumbling...

They have no choice. They're getting hammered, and having their most vocal and visible leadership come in form of Naim Ateek and Sabeel's globe-trotting blame Israel rhetoric isn't helping. Sounds like trying to appease the dominant culture isn't resulting in much benefit. It's just emboldening evil...a not unfamiliar pattern.

Inconvenient Lives

Dexter Van Zile exposes the hypocrisy of Protestant demands that Israel remove the security fence. He articulates well what I have been noting for some time: that in a contest between Arab convenience and Israeli lives, life wins.

Walling off the Jews from the rest of humanity

The day after suicide bombers killed 52 people on London's subways and buses, the leaders of two American churches, the United Church of Christ and the Disciples of Christ, sent a joint statement of solidarity to England's United Reform Church whose offices were close to the attack. The statement was a natural and human response to a terrorist attack on innocent civilians and stands in stark contrast to the churches' attitude toward previous victims of terrorism -- the Jews of Israel.

This summer, the UCC and the DOC passed resolutions insisting that Israel stop building a fence around the West Bank, dismantle portions already constructed, and pay reparations to Palestinians whose lives have been impacted by its path. The resolutions did not ask Palestinians to end the suicide attacks that made the barrier necessary; indeed they make no mention whatsoever of the Israeli deaths these attacks have caused. The churches offer words of condemnation to Israel for building a barrier to stop terror attacks, which when perpetrated in London, elicit words of comfort.

To these churches, attacks against Israelis are tolerable; attacks against Londoners are not. Palestinian hardship weighs more than Jewish lives...


Noisy Russians

Congratulations to our friends at the Jewish Russian Telegraph who have made a splash today on the pages of Opinion Journal, with The Russians Are Coming - The newest Jewish immigrants vote Republican. A snip:

Pity Larry Lowenthal. His job as executive director of the Boston branch of the American Jewish Committee (AJC) includes finding and training leaders from among the 700,000 Russian Jews who have immigrated to the U.S. in the last 30 years. Mr. Lowenthal has fared well: Today there are Russians helping to guide a number of major Jewish organizations, like the one called Boston for Israel. But now these immigrants turn out to be . . . oh no! Republicans!

To judge by his public statements and writings, Mr. Lowenthal's idea of a faithful Jew is someone who opposes the nomination of Judge John Roberts to the U.S. Supreme Court, supports gay rights, abortion and euthanasia, and demands a strong separation of church and state. After all, as Mr. Lowenthal concluded approvingly in a July op-ed for the Jewish Advocate, Jews are "the most liberal" and "the least religious people in America."

Imagine his consternation when an avalanche of emails from Russian Jews began to pour in to the Web site of the Jewish Russian Telegraph, a daily blog, in response to his article. About 100 people wrote to say that Mr. Lowenthal needed to stop making "outrageous statements" on behalf of people whom he doesn't represent.

Alex Koifman, who arrived in the U.S. from Belarus in 1978, and whom Mr. Lowenthal trained for his position as a board member at the Boston AJC, criticized his old teacher for overstepping his bounds, saying: "Since when are these concerns [abortion, gay rights, and church-state separation] concerns that are specific to the Jewish community? These are the Left's concerns."...

Background posts at JRTelegraph are here, here and here.

Now personally, I'm not in favor of bashing Larry Lowenthal -- a person who I'm sure has given a great deal to the community -- on a personal level, but if this kerfuffle helps serve as a wake-up call to mainstream Jewish groups that they ought to broaden their horizons a bit and start treading very, very lightly when it comes to taking positions on divisive domestic political issues of no particular "Jewish" interest, then so much the better.

A lot of immigrant groups are bringing entirely fresh looks at what used to be "package deals" on issue stances. They don't have the default party loyalty that some American groups have been used to for decades and they're going to be applying an entirely fresh coat of paint to the marketplace of ideas. That can only be to the good.

Hopefully at some point in the future, the AJC and the Russian Community will have a long sit-down to talk and break-bread together. I'm predicting a lot of borscht in Larry Lowenthal's future.

High Def

Our approximately 12 year old 32" Toshiba TV finally started biting the dust a few months back and it started to become clearer and clearer that it would need to be replaced. A few weeks ago we finally did so, replacing it with a Sony 42" rear-projection LCD model. It's a pretty sweet TV. The only thing left to do was get our Dish Network service upgraded to HD enabled, for which I had to wait for the new box to arrive. It did the day before yesterday, hence the lack of posts yesterday, as I went home and immersed myself in the world of HDTV.

Results are mixed, but positive overall. A big TV is great, of course. Regular definition actually looks slightly crappier than on the old TV, probably in large measure due to the size of the screen which expands all the flaws (the newer Dish box did make a difference, even on regular non-HD channels). High definition programming is very cool -- especially in low-motion scenes. High-motion tends to produce a lot of pixelization. The big problem is that there just isn't much HD programming yet. You get about a dozen extra "high def" channels through Dish, but most of them seem to show either fairly useless stuff -- like one channel that seems to be the 24 hour runway modeling channel -- or old movies and programming that clearly wasn't filmed in HD, so it doesn't make much difference. Who cares about some old movie played so that it fills all of the 16:9 screen? That's hardly what I would hope for for "HD."

There were a few good shows on the DiscoveryHD channel -- The Jeff Corwin show, and something called "Insectia" were very cool, and that second one is perfect for the HD format. Also, watching a Panda give birth in HD was...an experience. The thing is I'll bet they play a lot of the same stuff over and over again, like in the early days of MTV. Still, there is a lot of promise there.

Dish Network does not provide the local stations' high def broadcasts, so if you want them, you need to get out the old-fashioned rabbit ears. Depending on where you live, that can work out OK, since the signal is digital, once you have it strong enough there's no worry about fiddling. I watched parts of last night's Patriots game in HD through the over the air transmission and it was very cool.

DVD's are great on the big screen, but the resolution isn't HD yet (that's coming), so Fellowship of the Ring, for instance, is actually slightly disappointing depending on expectations.

Anyway, ttfn for my HD report.

Wednesday, September 7, 2005

Burning Villages, Christian Indifference

You've probably read already about the attack on an Arab Christian village in the West Bank by their Muslim neighbors. It started as a typical disgraceful story of depraved tribalism (you heard me) as a family murdered their daughter.

JPost: Muslims ransack Christian village

...The incident began on Saturday night and lasted until early Sunday, when Palestinian Authority security forces interfered to disperse the attackers. Residents said several houses were looted and many families were forced to flee to Ramallah and other Christian villages, although no one was injured.

The attack on the village of 1,500 was triggered by the murder of a Muslim woman from the nearby village of Deir Jarir earlier this week. The 30-year-old woman, according to PA security sources, was apparently murdered by members of her family for having had a romance with a Christian man from Taiba.

"When her family discovered that she had been involved in a forbidden relationship with a Christian, they apparently forced her to drink poison," said one source. "Then they buried her without reporting her death to the relevant authorities."...

..."More than 500 Muslim men, chanting Allahu akbar [God is great], attacked us at night," said a Taiba resident. "They poured kerosene on many buildings and set them on fire. Many of the attackers broke into houses and stole furniture, jewelry and electrical appliances."...

..."It was like a war, they arrived in groups, and many of them were holding clubs," said another resident.

"Some people saw them carrying weapons. They first attacked houses belonging to the Khoury family [looking for the man who had the affair with the women, not realizing he had already fled the village.] Then they went to their relatives. They entered the houses and destroyed everything there...

Honest Reporting calls it an Anti-Christian Pogrom in the West Bank, and says that " For years, media outlets have largely refused to report one of the most troubling aspects of the Mideast conflict -- Muslim intimidation and violence against Christians in Palestinian-controlled areas." Here's one example they include as a reason for the shifting tide of fortune against Arab Christians:

In 1995, Bethlehem was 62% Christian, but today is less than 20% Christian. Before 1995, Bethlehem had a majority-Christian municipal council, but when the Palestinian Authority took over the town, Yassir Arafat replaced the municipal council with a predominately Muslim council, and Christian Arabs fled Bethlehem in droves after a radical Islamic wave began inciting against them.

I have mentioned these issues any number of times on this web site. You can't always look to the Palestinian Christians themselves for an honest explanation of their plight to outsiders, though. Arab Christians are a Dhimmi people, a dwindling minority at peril to life and limb in an unfriendly sea efficient at punishing those who violate a national narrative and tribal norms if nothing else. Those living under such oppression don't always need to be kept under wraps by their jailers -- they keep themselves convinced...true-believing double-thinkers adept at displaying loyalty to the dominant culture. So adept that many have convinced themselves.

Even for those who are not convinced, criticism of Israel and Jews is free and can be used to curry favor, while criticism of the Palestinian Authority or the dominant Muslim society may be repaid with death...even to the point that their own society is choked away to the sound of their own silence.

I assure you, the Palestinian Christians Yahoo email group I subscribe to is consistently filled with the most freakish Jew hatred and smash Israel rhetoric of any I monitor.

Who will stand with those who are willing to speak and think freely? Rarely is it their co-religionists in the West, a great number of whom accept this incubated and exported turnthink uncritically.

Continue reading "Burning Villages, Christian Indifference"

An odd invitation

Terry Waite thinks it would be a good idea to invite the families of the perpetrators to the memorial service for the July 7 victims. Ken Livingstone concurs:

Terry Waite, who was held hostage by Islamic extremists for four years, stoked controversy over a memorial service for the London bombings yesterday by calling for relatives of the bombers to be invited.

The former Archbishop of Canterbury's envoy suggested that close relatives of the four suicide bombers should sit alongside the families of the 52 victims at the special service in St Paul's Cathedral.

His comments were echoed by Ken Livingstone, the London Mayor, who said that it would be "offensive" if relatives of the bombers were turned away from the service on Nov 1.

Mr Waite, who was held hostage in Beirut from 1987 to 1991, said in an interview on BBC Radio 2: "The parents definitely should be involved in the service because in a different way they are victims themselves."...

Yes, a very different way. I would sincerely doubt that it's a usual thing for a murderer's family to attend the victim's memorial service. Doesn't seem appropriate does it? Seems it would cause a lot of stress for various reasons and that the families of the perps, if they were truly remorseful, would want that as the last thing they would want to do. In fact, it strikes me as rather cruel to "put it on them" (the families of the victims) to accept the perpetrators loved ones there if they didn't want them.

There is some sense out there, however:

...A spokesman for the cathedral said: "Although neither of us attaches any blame to the families of the London bombers, our first responsibility is to the families of the victims."

Brian Coleman, the Tory deputy chairman of the London Assembly, labelled the idea of bombers' families attending as "political correctness gone mad".

(Via Norm and D-STP)

I can't help myself

I have a viscerally negative reaction to this woman. It's all I can do not to start typing horrible expletives into this post.

Fonda Puts Brakes on Bus Tour By Roger Friedman

Jane Fonda told me yesterday she's scrapped plans for an anti-war bus trip next March.

Fonda will also be making only two appearances this month on another tour with controversial British politician George Galloway, not eight appearances as was widely misreported in the press yesterday. [oh gee, that matters...not]

Why the change of plans? Certainly, Fonda is still very much against the war in Iraq and in favor of helping our troops there. But she said that she didn't want to distract people from Cindy Sheehan's bus trip, which is already under way and gathering support...

...Fonda will appear with Galloway - who is vehemently anti-George Bush - in Madison, Wis., on Sept. 18 and in Chicago, Ill., on Sept 19. She told me that "what the right wing has done to Sheehan is despicable."

Her own decision not to stage a bus tour came because she wants Sheehan to succeed without messages being mixed.

"I would be a distraction," she said, "and the vacuum has been filled. That said, I plan to speak out and write some op-ed pieces, but no bus tour."...

Hey Roger, Galloway isn't just "anti-George Bush," he's been anti-American since before he knew who George Bush was, and anyone who would appear with him shouldn't get the benefit of being able to say they "support the troops" -- not when they're supporting a guy who's recently been travelling around the Arab World encouraging them to "liberate" Baghdad and Jerusalem.

I saw Fonda on TV not long ago being interviewed by Diane Sawyer I think. She was bitching about her horrible family life and the melancholy of getting old. This from a woman who's lived the lifestyle of the rich and famous from birth, has had more selective plastic surgery than any ten average burn victims and who's closet is bigger than my house. In spite of all she's invested in it, her face isn't worth spitting in, as I understand someone did not long ago. Is it possible to get a lot of people together to monopolize the tickets to her events and spend the evening laughing at her?

Tuesday, September 6, 2005

A Better Quote

Another quote from The Foundation for the Defense of Democracies by a guy who's observations are a bit more worth paying attention to than Mr. Findley's:

"[W]e suffer for our lack of clarity in this war. Unwilling to call our enemies fascists, afraid to condemn the brutal aspects of Iraqi and Arab culture, we have allowed the narrative to slip out of our control. Truth is made, not found, in Iraq. Gradually, in the war of ideas, the US became the evil occupier, opposing the legitimate wishes of an indigenous 'resistance.'"
(12/01/2004) Steven Vincent, Independent Journalist

Which reminded me of this quote from Vincent (in reaction to my review of his book), from a private email that no longer has any reason to stay private:

...I particularly appreciated the excerpts you chose from the book. Not many people seem to have noted my unironic use of the word "evil"--I was wondering if maybe readers thought I was using the word only for effect, or as a general metaphor. But no, as you noted, I meant it. Evil. I note you have the image of the WTC on your site. I don't know where you live, of course, but I'm glad people have not forgotten what happened that day...

Not exactly great analysis

A quote from The Foundation for the Defense of Democracies:

"Outsiders do not seem to recognize that bin Laden is one of the pre-eminent heroes of Afghans, occupying a role similar to the Marquis de Lafayette, a Frenchman who fought at the side of the Colonials during America's Revolutionary War."
(08/01/2001) Paul Findley, Former Member of Congress from Illinois

You might remember Paul Findley. We last saw the President of his group, Council for the National Interest, Eugene Bird, giving speeches on behalf of Cindy Sheehan's Crawford Peace House. (Where did she go, anyway?)

Guest Blog: Unremarkable People

Unremarkable People

by Tom Glennon

I am filled up and maxed out with the whiners, finger pointers, blame throwers, and professional victims who are featured on the daily newscasts, and in most of the print media. So many of the people we have put in positions of responsibility and authority have failed to live up to our expectations, and seem to diminish further even as we watch. At a time of national need, in the wake of Katrina and all that she wrought, we seem to have found an amazing number of unremarkable people.

We seem to have become a nation where no one takes responsibility for their own actions, anything that goes wrong is someone else's fault, every tragedy is the result of some misguided policy, and scoring political points for your party is more important than the welfare of our fellow citizens. The flood waters in New Orleans were still rising when those who should know better began hurling unfounded and wildly inaccurate accusations at anyone they could think of, rather than offering substantive assistance. Charges of racism, political pay back, and deliberate malfeasance were flying while our fellow citizens were clinging to life on rooftops. Excuses for looters taking appliances, guns, and jewelry were being made while residents in three states were wilting under extreme heat, with no water to drink. While children were looking for their parents, politicians were calling for inquiries, or demanding resignations. The only person thus far who has not been criticized in the very able General Honore. I suspect, from what I have seen of him, that no one has the guts to launch any spurious comments at the good General. He seems more than capable of correcting anyone who casts aspersions on him.

Continue reading "Guest Blog: Unremarkable People "

PMW: PA gets $50m from US, then calls for terror against US soldiers

This is not on the web yet, so here is Palestinian Media Watch's report in full [I'm not blockquoting the whole thing to maintain readability, but everything below here is quoted text]:

PA gets $50m from US, then calls for terror against US soldiers
By Itamar Marcus and Barbara Crook

Palestinian Authority hatred of the United States is so deeply ingrained in its ideology that it continues to openly promote vicious anti-American hatred - even right after signing a deal to receive $50 million in direct aid from the US.

Radio and television sermons by senior PA religious officials in the past week have presented the US as foremost among the "heretical" countries, and as an enemy trying to dismantle the Islamic world.

In the presence of PA Chairman Mahmoud Abbas, one religious leader called for Iraqis to intensify terrorist uprisings against American soldiers.

The timing of these anti-US sermons is particularly significant - and not just because they come on the heels of the $50-million grant from the US. The PA has received considerable worldwide criticism for the hatred and calls for violence in its official sermons. In recent months, it has been reported that the texts of these sermons are now presented to PA officials for approval before the public broadcasts.

The following is the report of the recent signing of an agreement for $50 million in US aid to the PA, followed by the two Palestinian Authority sermons of September 2, 2005.

Continue reading "PMW: PA gets $50m from US, then calls for terror against US soldiers"

Pallywood in the Boston Globe

Here's a timely article from the Boston Globe featuring the cynicism (growing?) of many Arabs in the Gaza Strip toward the cult of martyrdom that surrounds them. There are several very interesting things here. One is that the featured cynic is none other than Jamal al-Dura, father of Mohammed al-Dura, who's tired of being the propaganda mouth-piece for the violence of the intifida (at no small cost -- not only has he aquired fame, but fortune as well...a wealthy sheik built the family a $100,000 home, for instance). Second is the mention of our own Professor Richard Landes and Pallywood. Finally, we read in the article about at least a few (a small minority, no doubt) Gaza residents who are openly expressing their cynicism toward the terror groups.

To the Globe's credit, they are careful not to assign blame in the death of al-Dura, saying he died "in a hail of bullets," but not saying who's bullets they were -- even making the point that the responsibility for the death is a matter of controversy.

Boston Globe: Some shunning the Palestinian hard stance

BUREIJ REFUGEE CAMP, Gaza Strip -- After his 12-year-old son died in a hail of bullets in 2000, Jamal al-Dura became the public face of Palestinian suffering as the second intifadah began. He traveled across the Arab world, standing as a symbol of perceived Israeli brutality and growing wealthy from the largesse showered upon him.

Nearly five years later, however, Dura says he has tired of mouthing the counterproductive mottos of Palestinian hard-liners. Instead, with Israel's withdrawal from the Gaza Strip last month, he has turned to building a grand new home for his eight surviving children and he has forbidden his eldest son from joining any militant movement, at least until he finishes university.

''One martyr from this family is enough," Dura, 43, said at his home in Bureij...

...The Palestinian Authority had promised to restrain militant factions and make sure the Israelis didn't pull out under fire. But, according to the Israeli military, Palestinians opened fire 18 times during the disengagement, lightly wounding two soldiers. They also launched two Qassam rockets and fired 10 mortar shells, while Israel foiled three separate planned bombs...

...''Celebrate the achievement of your martyrdom," thundered Hamas official Subhi Rasheed, the imam at Friday prayers in Jabaliya, a refugee camp north of Gaza City. ''The Jews will never stop assassinating you unless the Islamic nation is strong."

Such rhetoric has long been the staple of places like Jabaliya, which is nicknamed ''The Citadel of the Martyr Warriors" because its youths have long fed the factional Palestinian militias, mostly Hamas and Fatah.

''Citadel of fools is more like it," declared Jamal abu Nasser, the owner of a taxi fleet whose dispatch center is across the street from the main Hamas mosque in Jabaliya...



Continue reading "Pallywood in the Boston Globe"

Monday, September 5, 2005

Tribes

I took Labor Day off from thinking "blog," but don't miss Bill Whittle's newest essay: Tribes.

Sunday, September 4, 2005

Livingstone, Qaradawi and the Foreign Office

Nick Cohen in the Observer:

...Livingstone appears to be the greatest hypocrite in modern politics: a 'left winger' who ducks the challenge when faced with misogyny, homophobia, theocracy and the slaughter of innocents. But he probably believes he is being consistent.

Livingstone comes from the far left and recruited nearly all his advisers from a minuscule Trotskyist faction which gathered around the Socialist Action newspaper. They were 'third worldists', as we used to say, activists who had despaired of the British working class ever obeying the orders of their Leninist betters and therefore supported any movement in the Third World, however barbaric, as long as it said it was socialist.

What is new is that since the death of socialism, they are prepared to indulge the extreme religious right as long at it is anti-American. The reflex is essentially the same, as is the delusion that these are in some way 'progressive' forces.

Now it seems the fantasy has spread to the Foreign Office. Documents obtained by this newspaper show that the mandarins have been preparing for an accommodation with radical Islam...

...The leaked papers show FO mandarins in a land of make-believe. Running through this thinking is an aching need to believe that Qaradawi is a liberal, a peculiar liberal, no doubt, but still a man with whom Britain can do business. The Foreign Secretary may remember the negative media storm when Livingstone last brought the priest to Britain, the civil servants tell Jack Straw. He should ignore it. The accusations came from tainted Jewish sources, 'the Board of [Jewish] Deputies' and the Israeli monitoring site Memri, which is 'regularly criticised for selective translation of Arabic reports'.

This simply isn't true. Qaradawi's extremist views haven't been spread by scheming Jews but are well documented on his very own website...

Via Mick Hartley

Update: Melanie Phillips has more on the British Foreign Office appeasement insanity.

Court Power

It's amazing what good writing can do in few words. It can explain concisely and hammer home a point that the more verbose failed to deliver. This piece is an example of good writing. I must admit, for whatever reason, Will puts across a good explanation of the 'conservative' view of judicial interpretation that I 'knew' but maybe for whatever reason didn't fully 'get.'

George Will: Questions for Sen. Schumer

...The federal government's powers supposedly are limited because they are enumerated. As James Madison said in Federalist 45, "The powers delegated by the proposed Constitution to the federal government are few and defined." For seven decades, however, Congress has treated the commerce clause ("Congress shall have power . . . to regulate commerce . . . among the several states") as a license to do what it wants to do.

But in 1995 the Supreme Court ruled 5 to 4 that the Gun-Free School Zones Act of 1990 was unconstitutional because what the act criminalized -- possession of a firearm in or near a school -- was purely intrastate in nature and its effect, if any, on interstate commerce was negligible. The principal dissent, by Justice Stephen Breyer, argued that a gun might produce violence that would affect the economy by, among other things, injuring the learning environment, resulting in a less productive citizenry.

Do you, Sen. Schumer, support that reasoning? If so, does not Congress have the power to promote a healthy and productive citizenry by requiring flossing and regulating homework? Does it matter to you that the original intent of the commerce clause was to ensure the free movement of goods and services among the states? Do you think that Madison, the foremost Framer of the Constitution, misunderstood the Constitution?...

Update: I started getting hits from the Washington Post after posting this and noticed that they've got a Technorati powered "Read what bloggers are saying about this" box accompanying the column. Very interesting. Good for the Post, and sorry I didn't have more to say about it.

Saturday, September 3, 2005

Security

It's been an interesting couple of days to listen to the radio if you can stand it. The talk shows seem to fall into two categories: Either they're "blame Bush" shows, or they're "blame the Mayor (and the Governor)" shows. Now mostly, I think anyone who's too sure about who's "fault" things are at this point is probably talking out their behind for the most part. It's going to take some time to sort things out and assign blame -- if there is even any real blame to assign.

Personally, what I've come to be reminded of is, yet again, what a miracle a functioning civil society is, how delicate it can be, how held together by common consent, and how irresponsible those who encourage disrespect in it are.

If a bomb goes off in a large, crowded room, what's the bigger danger, the bomb, or the panicked crowd? You can apply that same principle to a whole city.

There are some interesting bits in this DoD press conference concerning the New Orleans response: Defense Department Briefing on Ongoing National Guard Response to Hurricane Katrina


Hurricane Katrina evacuees await departure from New Orleans, La., onboard a C-17 Globemaster III on Sept. 3, 2005.
The security situation in New Orleans continues to improve. The most contentious issues were lawlessness in the streets, and particularly a potentially very dangerous volatile situation in the convention center where tens of thousands of people literally occupied that on their own. We had people that were evacuated from hotels, and tourists that were lumped together with some street thugs and some gang members that -- it was a potentially very dangerous situation.

We waited until we had enough force in place to do an overwhelming force. Went in with police powers, 1,000 National Guard military policemen under the command and control of the adjutant general of the State of Louisiana, Major General Landreneau, yesterday shortly after noon stormed the convention center, for lack of a better term, and there was absolutely no opposition, complete cooperation, and we attribute that to an excellent plan, superbly executed with great military precision. It was rather complex. It was executed absolutely flawlessly in that there was no violent resistance, no one injured, no one shot, even though there were stabbed, even though there were weapons in the area. There were no soldiers injured and we did not have to fire a shot.

Some people asked why didn't we go in sooner. Had we gone in with less force it may have been challenged, innocents may have been caught in a fight between the Guard military police and those who did not want to be processed or apprehended, and we would put innocents' lives at risk. As soon as we could mass the appropriate force, which we flew in from all over the states at the rate of 1,400 a day, they were immediately moved off the tail gates of C-130 aircraft flown by the Air National Guard, moved right to the scene, briefed, rehearsed, and then they went in and took this convention center down...

...The real issue, particularly in New Orleans, is that no one anticipated the disintegration or the erosion of the civilian police force in New Orleans. Once that assessment was made, that the normal 1500 man police force in New Orleans was substantially degraded, which contributed obviously to less police presence and less police capability, then the requirement became obvious and that's when we started flowing military police into the theater...

Q: General, you mentioned a disintegration of the New Orleans Police Department. Do you know how many officers are still on duty?

GEN. BLUM: I would rather not say. I think you'd be better to refer that question to the mayor of New Orleans. I have my own estimate. I would say they are significantly degraded and they have less than one-third of their original capability.

...

Q: What happened to the other police, general?

GEN. BLUM: Again, that can be best addressed, but what was told to me by the Mayor day before yesterday is many of them lost their homes, many of them lost ability to get to the precinct, many of them who did show up found what they were dealing with so overwhelming and dangerous or threatening to them as an individual that they made the personal decision to not risk their life until the situation made more sense to them. That was an individual decision, it was not the police chief's decision or the mayor's decision. I think that the mayor and police chief are working right now to reconstitute the New Orleans Police Department, but that question would much better be addressed to them for detail...

Update: Thanks to Yehudit for getting this post an amazing amount of notice by posting a link in an LGF thread (Spicoli and his keg cup!). I'm glad to see the info spreading. [Update2: Big thank you to Michelle Malkin for noting this post.]

Why Palestinians Still Live in Refugee Camps

I thought this recent CAMERA report was very much worth highlighting:

- Why do Palestinians in Gaza still live in refugee camps? Did the Israelis force Palestinians to stay in the squalid, overcrowded camps?

Palestinians still live in refugee camps, even when the camps are in Palestinian Authority controlled areas, because the PLO opposes and prevents refugee resettlement. As the PLO slogan goes, A Palestinian refugee never moves out of his camp except to return home (ie, to Israel).

While the PLO has done its best to keep Palestinians in refugee camps, Israel has done its best to move Palestinians out of the camps and into new homes. Israel even started a heavily subsidized “build-your-own-home” program for Palestinian refugees. According to an early description of the program:

Nine new residential schemes have been built so far, housing some ten thousand families that have chosen to vacate the camps. Each family was given a plot of land with full infrastructure...

The new neighborhoods were built on state land within municipal areas near the camps, and each had an electricity network, water and a sanitation system ... a road system, paved sidewalks and developed surroundings. Public buildings were constructed in each neighborhood such as modern schools, health clinics and shopping centers, and land was allocated for mosques.

... As soon as his house is built, the refugee becomes the full property owner, and in due course his property is registered in the Land Register. (Judea, Samaria and the Gaza District, 1967 – 1987; Israel, Ministry of Defense, 1987)

The vacated homes in the refugee camps were taken down with the goal of eventually creating enough open space so that the camps themselves could be rebuilt as further new neighborhoods for the refugees.

It’s not surprising that the PLO vehemently opposed this program – after all, former residents of a refugee camp, now living in a nice home in a new neighborhood, would have a stake in supporting peace and opposing violence, exactly the opposite of the PLO’s strategy.

What is perhaps surprising is that the United Nations also opposed the program, and passed harsh resolutions demanding that Israel remove the Palestinians from their new homes and return them to the squalid camps. For example, UN General Assembly Resolution 31/15 of Nov. 23, 1976:

Calls once more upon Israel:

(a) To take effective steps immediately for the return of the refugees concerned to the camps from which they were removed in the Gaza Strip and to provide adequate shelters for their accommodation;

(b) To desist from further removal of refuges and destruction of their shelters.

Similarly, UNGA Resolution 34/52 of November 23, 1979 declared that:

measures to resettle Palestinian refugees in the Gaza Strip away from their homes and property from which they were displaced constitute a violation of their inalienable right to return;

1. Calls once more upon Israel to desist from removal and resettlement of Palestinian refugees in the Gaza Strip and from destruction of their shelters;

Perhaps thanks to this support from the UN, the PLO began threatening to kill any refugee who would move out of the camps. After a few such attacks, the build-your-own-home program died, and that is why there are still Palestinians refugee camps in Gaza...

Palestinian Arabs are still refugees in "camps" because they're being kept that way by their fellows and their aidor/abettor/panderers in the international community in the vain hope, another fantasy in the land of a thousand fantasies, that they'll be the vanguard of an army that finally destroys Israel -- the one that finally succeeds...hostages held to create a vision of pity for a purpose that doesn't deserve it.

Will the Gaza withdrawal be the beginning of the end for the excuses keeping the refugees in camps? There were excuses before there were settlers. It won't change without outside pressure.

Update: Orson Scott Card has a good piece on the Gaza Withdrawal here: Gaza and the Israeli Settlers.

Crime or Politics?

I haven't commented much, if at all, on the case against two former AIPAC employees and a Pentagon analyst. Why? Because I just don't know enough about the case, and I don't think anyone does. I'm not going to sit here and pose, trying to establish my own "more American than thou" bona-fides by selling out a couple of what may be completely innocent people, nor am I going to start screaming about politically-motivated prosecutions, when I can't say I know that's true, either.

Anyway, here is a data point. The article calls into question the motivations for the prosecution in view of two factors: One, that there's an official in the Administration that was also involved in the events who has not been prosecuted, in fact, he's been promoted, and two, that the sort of horse-trading for low-level classified information that's alleged here goes on all the time in Washington. It's de rigeur.

JTA: New revelations in AIPAC case raise questions about FBI motives

... The fact that Satterfield is not a target of the case and was allowed to take a sensitive position in Iraq has raised questions about the severity of the information allegedly given to AIPAC officials, as well as about the government’s motives for targeting Rosen and Keith Weissman, a former AIPAC Iran analyst, neither of whom had classified access.

The defendants and AIPAC supporters see the new revelations as evidence that federal prosecutors are targeting the powerful pro-Israel lobby for simply conducting the normal Washington practice of trading sensitive information. Officials inside and outside government privately acknowledge that classified information routinely changes hands among influential people in the foreign policy community and that the exchanges often are advantageous to diplomats.

“If, in fact, Satterfield passed on classified information that other people should not have had, then they should all be guilty of the same thing,” said Malcolm Hoenlein, the executive vice chairman of the Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations. “The fact that Satterfield hasn’t been prosecuted suggests that’s not the case.”...


Peeved Palestinians

Further on the Pakistan/Israel talks mentioned below, Musharaff is firm in assuring us that he is not recognizing Israel, he is not recognizing Israel, he is not recognizing Israel -- in case there was any doubt. And, as to be expected, the Palestinians are warning Pakistan they'd better be careful:

Israel-Pakistan talks peeve Palestinians

...The Palestinian Committee For Resisting Normalization With Israel denounced the decision as a "black day and a mark of disgrace" for the Pakistani government.

The committee said in a statement that Pakistan's decision was tantamount to "a stab in the back of the Palestinians and their national struggle to liberate their lands, first and foremost the Aksa Mosque, and to achieve the right of return for all refugees." ...

Of course, the Aksa Mosque is in Muslim hands, and has been since its capture in 1967, but the land around it is ruled by a majority Jewish state, and that is not an acceptable state of affairs for a Dhimmi people to be in.

A slight change in emphasis

Robert Spencer (thanks to the emailer who pointed it out) points to the Muslim American Society press release on their hurricane relief efforts. Note the bolded portion:

The press conference will be held in front of the Holiday ! Inn across from the Houston Astrodome at Reliant Park, 8111 Kirby D rive, Houston, TX, at 3:00 p.m.

Also attending the press conference will be Muslims who were evacuated from New Orleans and the surrounding area.

"There are three basic components to our work," stated MAS Freedom
Foundation Executive Director Mahdi Bray.

"To encourage Muslims to open their mosques and homes to victims as well as adopting a family and renting an apartment for displaced families. Second, to collect and assist with the distribution of food and other consumable necessities to shelters and other temporary lodging facilities. And lastly, to insure that Islamic Relief has the resources to provide the high caliber assistance that they have provided throughout the years to victims of natural catastrophes here in the United States and abroad."

"It is critical that we all pull together to help the thousands of Muslims and their neighbors who have been devastated by Katrina," concluded Bray.

Says Spencer:

...Imagine the outcry that would ensue if any charitable organization declared, "It is critical that we all pull together to help the thousands of Christians and their neighbors who have been devastated by Katrina," or "It is critical that we all pull together to help the thousands of Jews and their neighbors who have been devastated by Katrina." Other groups help everybody they can, without asking about their religion first. But not Good Old Mahdi's MAS.

I noticed it myself, but didn't think too much of it -- how can you say much without going through all the other charities' press releases and comparing them? But it is interesting to note that someone at MAS took note and changed the quote, which now reads:

“It is critical that we all pull together to help the thousands who have been devastated by Katrina," concluded Bray.

Hmmm...I wonder what he really said? Anyway, significant? You can decide. I doubt the victims care much, anyway.

Friday, September 2, 2005

Lizard meets Camel Spider

Condi -- Writing the screenplay for Oslo 2 or not?

Lynn B has an analysis of Condi Rice's recent remarks -- and attitude -- that were mangled recently by the New York Times. Lynn isn't quite so ready to let Condi off the hook for what looks like her pushing Israel to a repeat of the Oslo disaster. While the Times undoubtedly used Rice's remarks as a tool to project their own editorial slant (what else is new?), that doesn't mean that Rice's other comments are really anything to be excited about.

I try not to hang on every word of the diplomatic give and take, so I have something of a "we'll see" attitude, but Lynn does assemble some evidence that gives cause for concern.

UN Official Arrested

CNN: FBI 'arrests second U.N. official'

The chair of a powerful United Nations budget committee was arrested by the FBI Thursday on money laundering charges, a federal law enforcement official said.

Vadim Kouznetsov, who heads the General Assembly panel that oversees the U.N. budget, was the second Russian U.N. official to be arrested by the FBI for alleged money laundering in recent weeks.

The charges were contained in a sealed grand jury indictment. Kouznetsov was to be arraigned Friday in Manhattan Federal Court.

The official, who spoke only on the condition of anonymity because the indictment is sealed, said the charges involve money laundering and are only remotely connected to the U.N. oil-for-food program in Iraq that is the target of numerous corruption investigations...

Why there are scare quotes in the title, I've no idea.

Thursday, September 1, 2005

Department of Defense Briefing on Able Danger

The DoD held a special briefing on their Able Danger investigation today. People following the story may find it interesting. Here is the transcript. A few interesting tidbits:

...Media: Does that mean that because it was a classified operation a lot of documents including the chart could have been destroyed and that's why you can't find it?

Down: There are regulations. At the time how they were interpreted, very strictly pre-9/11, for destruction of information which is embedded, I guess is the way I would say it, that would contain any information on U.S. persons. In a major data mining effort like this you're reaching out to a lot of open sources and within that there could be a lot of information on U.S. persons. We're not allowed to collect that type of information. So there are strict regulations about collection, dissemination, destruction procedures for this type of information. And we know that that did happen in the case of Able Danger documentation.

Media: So it's possible then that this is how the chart cannot be found. Along with other documents, they could have been destroyed and that's why you can't corroborate what these people are saying or say it's wrong.

Down: Correct.

Media: What is the definition for U.S. person?

Down: I wish we had our lawyer here.

Chope: A U.S. citizen or someone who is in the country legally.

Media: So a tourist is a U.S. person.

Chope: Can be.

Media: Under what circumstances?

Chope: For instance on a work visa. I think it's more than just a tourist, on a work visa or something like that...

...Media: Has anything changed about the way that U.S. persons who get sucked up in a data mining operation would be handled today as opposed to how they might have -- completely independent of this. Say if my name gets sucked up into a database tomorrow morning would it be handled differently today than it would have before 9/11?

Down: My understanding is that the same procedures are in place. We may exercise some flexibility, but I have to be careful here because the same procedures, the same regulations, they are still accurate. We have to be very careful of what we protect against U.S. persons...

...Media: All these questions about Able Danger seem to sound like how could you possibly have missed Mohammed Attah did this, but I'm wondering if Mohammed Attah came in under the same circumstances at the same time tomorrow, he would still be of the same class. Wouldn't they get ditched, thrown out? Not that that's what happened with this, but if you were to tag him as a U.S. person wouldn't he automatically be thrown out of the data base tomorrow just as --

Chope: I don't know...


Continue reading "Department of Defense Briefing on Able Danger"

Pakistan and Israel Talk

Well, Musharaf is set to address the American Jewish Congress (AJC), and that's significant. And the Pakistani and Israeli Foreign Ministers have met in Turkey, and that's also highly significant. This is clearly payback for the Gaza pullout, which is good, but of course it's still contingent on some sort of normal "Palestinian" state coming into existence, and that puts the ball back into the Palestinian court, and the cynic in me tells me that nothing scares the Palestinians more than that, and they'll do anything possible to screw it up. No longer being the Arab world's pet people, losing the patience of their patrons who begin to move on, setting grievances aside...setting grievances aside? What will they have left?

Not in our lifetimes.

Focus on the Silent Exodus

This strikes me as an interesting political move that will, if played politically smart -- and it sounds like they are -- shine attention on the "silent refugees" and provide a bit of political capital with which to...hope upon hope...start trying to dry up the support for the Palestinian refugees in perpetuity...by making it less profitable.

JPost: Iraqi Jews to demand compensation

Leaders of the Iraqi Jewish community from around the world are to meet soon in London to plan a strategy to demand compensation for lost assets, potentially in the billions of dollars, from the Iraqi government, The Jerusalem Post has learned.

Two meetings have been scheduled for September 18 and 19 to discuss the demands of the Jews from Arab countries and to bring to the forefront a political swap.

Iraqi-born Jew Mordechai Ben-Porat, chairman of Israel's Center for the Heritage of Babylonian Jewry, organized the first meeting.

"The Jews left behind hospitals, schools, cemeteries, shopping markets," said Ben-Porat, who had been a leader of the Zionist underground movement in Iraq from its inception in 1942 until he immigrated to Israel in 1945...

...The goal of the project is political and for that reason, Professor Heskel Haddad of THe World Organization of Jews from Arab Countries (WOJAC) maintains support for the cause.

"It will help Israel in the peace negotiations," he said. "The idea is to make an exchange. Arab countries will not compensate Jews who left Iraq and Israel will not compensate the Palestinian refugees."

The Iraqi Jewish community was among the largest Jewish Diaspora communities in the Arab world, numbering some 140,000, but most of the community left Iraq between 1950 and 1952, after the creation of the State of Israel. They left behind homes, businesses and large pieces of land. Most of those assets were frozen, some were taken by the government and some were sold...

I'm not sure it's a matter of "not compensating Palestinian refugees." If it were just a matter of compensation that wouldn't be a big obstacle at all.

Sweden will suffer in the name of Allah

Don't look at me, I didn't say it. The Jihadis are threatening Sweden, now. They're even blowing up innocent trees to make their point.

YNet: Sweden threatened with jihad

A group using the name of Iraqi jihad group Ansar al-Sunnah has released videos showing what it claims are members training for terror attacks in the Swedish countryside.

In one video, dated August 8 2005, the group says that viewers are about to see a “demonstration of the high explosives device, that we will use in the name of Allah.

This was recorded somewhere in Sweden,” says a message on the video in yellow letters against military camouflage colors.

A large explosion is then seen in a heavily wooded area. While it is not possible to verify the location of the explosion, the scenery does appear to be northern European.

A second video by the group, which is dated August 29, contains images of men with blurred out faces setting off mock suicide explosives and roadside car bomb attacks...

...One user on the site, who identified himself as 'Dehex,' warned that “Sweden will suffer in the name of Allah.”

Referring to a well known Swedish reverend, Runar Soogard, who is reported to be under police protection after offending Muslims with a speech about Islam’s prophet, Muhammad, Dehex wrote: “Runar Soogard had a very bad and nasty speech about our greatest prophet Mohamed.”...


An incredible tragedy

Wow.

Stampede in Baghdad Kills Over 800 Shiite Pilgrims

...Rumors of a suicide bomber sowed panic among thousands of Shiite Muslim pilgrims Wednesday on a bridge over the Tigris River in Baghdad, triggering a stampede in which many jumped into the turbid river or fell to their deaths on sidewalks and a children's playground below.

The Iraqi Health Ministry on Thursday put the death toll at 843. The Interior Ministry said 953 people were killed and 815 injured, the Associated Press reported. Bodies of victims had been taken to many hospitals, mosques and private homes, making an accurate count difficult...


California Petition

Scholars for Peace in the Middle East is looking for signatures on this petition addressed to the Governor of California on the enormous problem of virulent anti-Israelism and anti-Semitism on California college campuses.

Read the letter, then sign the petition.

Also, see this article written by some banana slugs (UC Santa Cruz professors) on the difficulties involved in arguing for a balanced presentation on the Middle East: Faculty Efforts to Combat Anti-Semitism and Anti-Israeli Bias at the University of California, Santa Cruz

...Although these speakers presented important information about the new anti-Semitism, our efforts to educate the campus community in this way met considerable resistance from both students and faculty. Flyers for many of the talks were pulled down, occluded, or defaced with statements such as "Zionism is racism" and "Occupation is murder." One UCSC professor was even caught in the act of tearing down a flyer advertising Itamar Marcus. As noted, few students and even fewer faculty members attended these talks...

Hurricane Blogging

I haven't been doing it. Frankly, I haven't been in front of a TV much the past few days to see the images, and I've been fairly busy on other things, but some other bloggers have very comprehensive round-ups of charities you can look into. See: LGF, Instapundit, Michelle Malkin.

Latest Carnival of the Vanities

The latest collection of self-pimpage from around the blogosphere is up at Incite (where my blog name is spelled wrong again -- I should be happy I've been getting linked sufficiently, and having the name misspelled sufficiently often, not to care to bother to ask for it to be corrected...I think I need to consider a blog name change again).

Anyway! Go on over and find much to serve your reading pleasure.

Palestine Day in Connecticut - Part 2: Update

Here's another entry I wanted to bump up and emphasize. In Palestine Day in Connecticut - Part 2, I berated a Danbury, Connecticut paper, The News-Times for printing a completely uncritical story about an International Solidarity Movement terror dupe, Chris Towne, which probably contains not a single factual paragraph.

The response a reader got from The News-Times' Managing Editor (included in full in the comments of the original post) is stunning, though at this point, it shouldn't be. The Editor believes that since the piece appeared on what's something of an opinion page, the facts don't really count, and further, that really, since everyone has their own opinions...the facts don't really count. Besides, it's not his problem. A snip:

...About the only thing beyond dispute is that learned people on both sides of this epic conflict have wildly different views of the facts and of reality. I'm not prepared to silence voices simply because I dispute their view of reality. As I said before, my job is to allow as many viewpoints as possible in the paper, even those that you and I might find personally odious. In a democracy, a newspaper is a marketplace of ideas. Readers can accept the ones they like and reject the others...

But readers can't be expected to do the primary research necessary to always separate fact from fiction. We expect some level of gate keeping from our information providers, especially when no measure of skeptical voice is provided in the presentation. I don't believe the average reader understands the level of skepticism they need to bring to their news consumption. They have a right to expect some level of fact-checking, and they are left completely exposed when that doesn't occur.

It reminds me of much of what I discussed in my interview with Richard Landes below':

..."The point is that objectivity is a trap. There have to be judgments. We have to pay attention to different narratives and so-on, yes. I'm post-modern in that sense, but I don't think that because there's no objectivity, there can't be any honesty.

And honesty is what's gone out. The radical-relativists say, 'Hey, the Palestinians have their story.' Well I say, sure they have their story, and by all means listen to it. But how accurate is it? Just because you need to listen to it, doesn’t force you to believe it."...

But fear not, The News-Times provided space to follow-up letter responses -- one from a Rabbi critical of the article, and one from someone who states that Israel started the war in 1967. But hey, at least it's balanced...

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Search


Archives
[an error occurred while processing this directive] [an error occurred while processing this directive]