July 2006 Archives
Monday, July 31, 2006
Quick Check-In
Sorry for the lack of posting today, busy here at work, and...well, if my cat decides to wake me up at 2am, 4:30am and 6am again I'll be looking for recipes.
Let me give you something to look forward to, though. I'm currently collecting photos, video and testimonials from some folks, including our friend Seva Brodsky, who attended the "Justice for Lebanon" rally at Copley Square, Boston last Friday. I think you all will be very interested in the resulting post. Let's just say that some people have trouble keeping their bodily fluids to themselves.
Sunday, July 30, 2006
A Lebanese Shia explains how Hezbollah uses human shields
At Judeoscope:
I lived until 2002 in a small southern village near Mardshajund that is inhabited by a majority of Shias like me. After Israel left Lebanon, it did not take long for Hezbollah to take have its say in other towns. Received as successful resistance fighters and armed to the teeth, they stored rockets in bunkers in our town as well. The social work of the Party of God consisted in building a school and a residence over these bunkers! A local sheikh explained to me laughing that the Jews would lose in any event because the rockets would either be fired at them or if they attacked the rockets depots, they would be condemned by world opinion on account of the dead civilians. These people do not care about the Lebanese population, they use them as shields, and, once dead, as propaganda. As long as they continue existing there, there will be no tranquility and peace.
Dr. Mounir Herzallah
Berlin-Wedding
[h/t: Andrew Bostom]
Project Runway: Season 3, Episode 3
Another week, another Project Runway post (previous Runway posts here). This week: Smelly dogs. (I'm not a dog person)
I'm very late on this, but I figured I better get this up or the next episode will be upon us already.
As always, read Tim's Take. I agree with his assessment on everything and it's a good overview of the entire episode.
This week, the designers each selected a little dog which they were to use as their muse -- develop a story and design an outfit for their model...and the dog.
Three worst: Katherine (eliminated), Vincent and Angela (pictured). All of the others were very good and potential winners (but what the hell do I know?).
Angela came up with some cockamamie rambling story to justify her design...something about a Paris art gallery owner something or other. Judging from what she came up with, she should have said, "I looked at this dog and thought, 'This dog is a ho, and not only is the dog a ho, so is my model.'" That would have matched what she came up with. Time for her to take her nostrils and go...and take Ivanka Trump's chipmunk cheek implants with you.
But that will have to wait for a future episode.
The real meat this week was the preview of next week's episode -- where someone gets kicked off for breaking the rules of the show. I'm rating the odds for who it is as follows, from most likely to least: Keith (although since the show is known for bait and switch, and they have been showing Keith as the bad-boy of the group, this may be less likely than it seems), Laura, Vincent, Angela, Jeffrey...all the rest equally unlikely (so it will probably be one of them).
Remembering Steven Vincent
This post is my contribution to Kesher Talk's blogburst to commemorate the murder, one year ago this August 2nd, of journalist Steven Vincent. I will probably bump and update this post at that time.
My review of Steven's excellent book, In the Red Zone, is here.
Some of my thoughts after his death are here: Still thinking of Steven
I had the pleasure of meeting his wife, Lisa Ramaci, back in November, and she informed me that Steven read this blog on a daily basis (presumably when he wasn't traveling in Iraq).
Steven was one of those folks who watched the towers fall (literally -- he was on the roof of his New York building watching when they fell) and changed forever. He was one of those valuable folks who came to understand that there was real evil in the world, and that good people needed to stand up to it, or failing that, at least recognize and name it. From an email he sent me shortly after happening upon my review of his book:
Steven managed to write a nuanced book while not losing himself and his principles in the details and the confused introspection as so many so-called intellectuals seem to do. A year ago true evil caught up to Steven following that near miss on 9/11. The world is poorer. We still needed him.
Video from Kfar Qana -- A War Crime on Tape
Here is must-see video of Hizballah firing rockets from behind a civilian structure in Lebanon:
Israel does not intentionally target or jeopardize civilian lives -- unlike Hamas and Hizballah who make a living from it. To the extent that there are civilian casualties, war crimes like this are part of the reason why.
Update: Very good questions of timing at PowerLine, here and here.
Hezbollah is our enemy, too
Jeff Jacoby in today's Globe: Hezbollah is our enemy, too
Has nothing been learned from that experience?
Hezbollah's barbaric assault on Israel -- kidnapping soldiers who weren't engaged in hostilities, firing waves of missiles into cities and towns, packing rockets with ball bearings designed to maximize suffering by shredding human flesh -- is part and parcel of the radical Islamist jihad against the free world. Nothing to do with the United States? It has everything to do with the United States. Hezbollah hates Americans at least as implacably as Al Qaeda does, and rarely misses an opportunity to say so.
``We consider [America] to be an enemy because it wants to humiliate our governments, our regimes, and our peoples," railed Sheik Hassan Nasrallah, the leader of Hezbollah, at an enormous rally in February 2005. (Video of Nasrallah's speech, which was broadcast on Hezbollah's Al-Manar TV, can be seen at www.memritv.org.) ``It is the greatest plunderer of our treasures, our oil, and our resources. . . . Our motto, which we are not afraid to repeat year after year, is: `Death to America!' "
And from tens of thousands of Hezbollah supporters came the answering cry: ``Death to America! Death to America! Death to America! Death to America!"
These are anything but empty threats. Prior to 9/11, Hezbollah was responsible for more American casualties than any other terrorist organization in the world. Among its victims was Army officer William F. Buckley, the CIA station chief in Beirut who was abducted by Hezbollah in March 1984 and who died after 15 months in captivity of torture and illness.
And the young Navy diver Robert Stethem, singled out during the 1985 Hezbollah hijacking of TWA Flight 847 and brutally beaten before being shot to death...
More.
Andrew Bostom on BookTV today at 1:30 Eastern
Our friend Andrew Bostom, author of The Legacy of Jihad: Islamic Holy War and the Fate of Non-Muslims, will be on C-Span's BookTV in just a short while:
CAIR Spokesman grabs camera at Hizballah Support Rally

Do NOT miss ciaospirit's video report on a CAIR-sponsored rally in Ohio: CAIR (Council on American-Islamic Relations) Rally Against Israeli War on Lebanon and Palestine -a report by ciaospirit
No condemnations of Hizballah, no admission that Hizballah is a terrorist group...but plenty of camera grabbing.
Ciaospirit,
You have given me the privilege, once again, to bestow an award for actions above and beyond what anyone would ask a person to do, The Order of the Pest of Zion:

[via LGF]
Local Bagmen for the Mullahs
How often are local "charitable donations" used to fund terrorist groups? Often. Here is an alarming local effort to make an "emergency cash transfer" direct to Lebanese Palestinian (and undoubtedly "resistance controlled") refugee camps:
We are all receiving requests for donations to help Lebanon. I urge you to contribute.
Those who will not be receiving help are the Palestinian Refugee camps in Lebanon. They were “degraded” long before the present crisis, and their situation is now worse. NONETHELESS, THEY ARE TAKING IN LEBANESE REFUGEES FROM THE SOUTH AND OTHER HEAVILY BOMBED AREAS.
Naseer [A] and Elaine [H] are trying to get some funds to them immediately. We have no tax exempt organization that can receive these funds. Your contribution will not be tax deductible. However, we are assuming that this will not be a factor in this emergency situation. We are asking you all to send Elaine your checks in whatever amount – every dollar helps – payable to Elaine [H] who will coordinate the effort. She will cash the checks immediately, add them together, and try to do a bank transfer. Her bank – Cambridge Savings Bank – has informed her that they can try to do a bank transfer. It is still allowable apparently, but it may not get through on the other end. If it doesn’t work, the bank will return the funds. They would then be delivered by a wife/husband couple (Lebanese and Palestinian) who teach at AUB and who are waiting to get word as to when they can return. They are presently waiting it out in Boston area. They are a couple who have worked in the camps and know the heads of the programs in there. We have known them for years when they were both students at MIT. I would trust them with my life. Elaine’s address is: [redacted]. If you want to reach her by phone for any reason, call [redacted]. Please act now. Also send your email address with your check so Elaine can acknowledge your donation upon receipt. A final accounting will be sent to all donors.
Thank you in advance for responding to this urgent request.
Naseer [A] and Elaine [H]
These are the pictures that damn Hezbollah

Adelaide Now has the pictures and the story -- note that such pictures must smuggled out of Lebanon:
A stream of images, obtained exclusively by the News Ltd, depicts how the extremists are using high-density residential areas as launch pads for rockets and heavy calibre weapons.
Dressed in civilian clothing so they can quickly melt back into suburbia, the fighters carrying automatic assault rifles ride in on trucks laden with cannons.
The photographs from the Christian area of Wadi Chahrour in the east of Beirut were snapped by a visiting journalist caught in the midst of the war, then smuggled out by a friend...
...Images and footage of Hezbollah activities taken by local newspapers and TV crews are routinely seized by the group's fighters at road blocks.
But in our images, taken clandestinely, a group of fighters are preparing to fire truck-mounted anti-aircraft gun just metres from an apartment block with sheets drying on the balcony.
Others show a Hezbollah fighter armed with nickel-plated AK47 rifle guarding no-go zones after Israeli blitzes.
Another depicts the remnants of a Hezbollah Katyusha rocket in the middle of residential block, blown up in an Israeli air attack.
The Melbourne man who smuggled the shots out of Beirut told yesterday how he was less than 400m from the block when it was obliterated.
``Hezbollah came in to launch their rockets, then within minutes the area was blasted by Israeli jets,'' he said.
``Until the Hezbollah fighters arrived, it had not been touched by the Israelis. Then it was totally devastated.
``After the attacks they didn't even allow the ambulances or the Lebanese Army to come in until they had cleaned the area, removing their rockets and hiding other evidence.
``Two innocent people died in that incident but it was so lucky it was not more.
`
`The people there were horrified and disgusted at what Hezbollah were doing.''
The fighters used trucks, driven into residential areas, as launch pads for the rockets, he said...
Look at the men in those photos and consider how long it would take a military target (them) to be transformed into "civilians" after the bombs fall -- probably no time at all since all that is required is for their guns to be blasted out of the hands...voila, instant civilian casualty.
Meanwhile, this article at The Guardian inadvertently shows how Hizballah is trained to blend into the civilian surroundings: As the shells fall around them, Hizbullah men await the Israelis
...For the last five years he has been finishing his theology studies in Tehran. A month ago, he was asked by Hizbullah to return to southern Lebanon. He arrived a week before the fighting began....
...All over the hills of south Lebanon hundreds of men like Sayed Ali and his comrades are waiting - some in bunkers, some in farm houses - for the Israeli troops to arrive. Sayed Ali and his men spend most of their time in the building where his apartment is, moving only at night.
"We stay put and we don't move till we get our orders, and this is why we are not like any other militia. A militiaman will fire whenever he likes at whatever he likes," explains one of the men, who says he has been involved in firing Katyusha rockets into northern Israel. "We have specific orders. Even when we fire rockets we know when and where [to fire] and each of the men manning the launchers runs to a specific hiding place after firing the rockets."
He says Hizbullah fighters expect the site of a rocket launch to be hit by an Israeli airstrike or shell within 10 to 15 minutes.
Another of the men, who says he is Sayed Ali's brother, explains how Hizbullah teaches its fighters patience: "During our training we spend days in empty buildings without talking to anyone or doing anything. They tell me go and sit in that building, and I go and sit there and wait."...
...The fighting force of the organisation is divided into two: the "active" group, whose task is to serve in Hizbullah, and the reserve, or Ta'abi'a, as it is known in Arabic. The active fighters get monthly pay. The reserves are called on only in time of war, and receive bonuses but no regular pay. A third section, the Ansar, comprises people who support or are supported by the organisation...
More on this issue, here.
Update: Also, see Kevin Sites: Guns in the Closet - At home in a town in southern Lebanon, a Hezbollah fighter waits to be called to action.
Then, from the corner of the closet, next to some shirts on hangers, he pulls out an American-made M-16 assault rifle and places it on the mattress in the room next to the ammo belt. He goes back to the closet and from the same corner reaches for a rocket-propelled grenade launcher and two canvas shoulder bags. He places these on the bed as well.
I ask if nearly every house in the neighborhood has a stash of small arms like this.
"Some have more"...
Watch the video.
Update2: Another must-see video along this same line: Video from Kfar Qana -- A War Crime on Tape.
Saturday, July 29, 2006
Extra-judicial Murder
Anton Efendi notes this story: Israeli 'spies' executed
Passengers on board an evacuation ship told medical doctor Boris Buck from the German city of Munich that they had seen members of the Lebanese Shi'ite Hezbollah group or their sympathisers killing 18 Lebanese people during the night.
The victims were suspected of helping the Israeli air force pick out targets...
But this is the clearest example, the most tragic and disturbing example, of what Hezbollah had in mind, and how it saw itself, the Lebanese government, and the Lebanese people. When stupid Hezbollah groupies in the West regurgitate the party's "romantic" line that it is akin to the French resistance, this is what they are justifying: extrajudicial martial law by a non-state actor, in the full presence of a state and its institutions!...
More.
Solidarity With Israel Rally, San Francisco, July 23, 2006
Yes. Zombie has lots of pictures and video. Note presence of anti-Israel Green-Rainbow Party.
And in the other corner, see: Hezbollah Supporters In Birmingham, UK
Experience at Union Square
Mike happened upon a "Support Lebanon, Palestine and the UN" Rally the other day in New York and describes events:
Here's how it begins:
On one corner of the square there was a "Pro-Lebanon/Pro-Palestine/Pro-UN" rally with speakers and pamphlets etc... a mixed crowd but mainly but mainly left wing hippies and Americans with lots of time on their hands. About 50-100 people checking it out at that area.
By the time I parked and walked over the rally was over and the cops removed the barricades etc.. but there was still people around passing out materials sponsored by the "Int'l Answer Coalition"
The main pamphlet spoke about how Israel (of course only) murdered UN workers. And support "Palestine and Lebanon" and anti US and Israeli "Colonialist" Message...
Here's how it ends:
* "Where do they get all their time from, after work, family etc.. we don't have anytime to waste on anything like making signs etc.."
They pretty much couldn't stand the "Peacenicks"
Maybe memories of the "Anti-war/Peace rallies" a few years back where the "peacenicks" smashed in store windows and punched and kicked cops... very "peaceful"
Demonization
More of the same, this time by cartoonist Antonio Neri Licon of Mexico’s El Economista:

...From Honest Reporting's Backspin.
Update: At Anglicans for Israel, an article noting the trend in EU newspaper cartoons to equate Jews with Nazis: The EU’s Cartoonish Rage against the Jews
Note that it is not fear of giving deep offence to others that prevents cartoonists from "expressing themselves," as most of these papers wouldn't publish the Muhammed cartoons -- it is, instead, fear of bodily harm to themselves which curbs them...something they do not fear from Jews, Israelis or their supporters, because such people are not, in fact, anything like Nazis.
For a disturbing read, note some of the comments to this previous post.
Thanks to the Watcher's Council...
...who chose Mayhem at the Defend Hizballah Rally! as their non-Watcher's blog post of the week.
Obsession on Google Video
Honest Reporting's film on radical Islam, Obsession, is available in full on Google Video. Just watching it now. Looks like a must-see. [via Atlas]
Update: I watched it. Do NOT miss it.

'[A]ll Jews are not the same. The good ones become Muslims, the bad ones do not.'
That's a quote from Muhammad Sayyid Tantawi, Grand Imam of Al-Azhar University, foremost authority in the Sunni world. Andrew Bostom explains.
Confirm the Walrus, Damnit!
Alan Dershowitz: A public advocate for the United States
On the basis of his performance, I have become a Bolton supporter. He speaks with moral clarity. He is extremely well prepared. He is extraordinarily articulate. He places the best face on American policy, particularly in the Middle East during this crucial time...
...Were he not to be confirmed as U.S. ambassador to the United Nations at this crucial juncture it would send a powerful message to the international community that Senate Democrats do not stand behind our policy in the Middle East. It would be seen as undercutting American policy toward Israel. Even if that were a misunderstanding, it would have a devastating impact on the world's perception of America's solidarity with Israel.
...The senators have had a year to observe and evaluate Mr. Bolton directly on his performance as our ambassador. They can intelligently vote based on what he has done at the United Nations and not based on documents related to his role as undersecretary of state for arms control and international security.
What remains of last year's nomination battle, though, is what I suspect to be the real reason that some Democrats oppose the Bolton nomination. That is, they felt uncomfortable with Mr. Bolton's oft-expressed and blunt skepticism over the United Nations' legal and moral authority. Mr. Bolton can even, at times, come off as "contemptuous of the U.N.," in Sen. Barbara Boxer's words.
But Mr. Bolton is right to be skeptical, and all the great U.S. ambassadors to the United Nations — from Adlai Stevenson to Arthur Goldberg to Pat Moynihan to Jeane Kirkpatrick — have shared that skepticism. Mr. Bolton is absolutely justified in pushing for reform of the notoriously corrupt and inefficient bureaucratic structure in Turtle Bay. As he once said, "If member countries want the United Nations to be respected ... they should begin by making sure it is worthy of respect."...
[h/t: isirota1965]
Suez
Very, very interesting article on a past crisis and a decision of the Eisenhower Administration that's shaped American/French relations to the present day: Weekly Standard: A Man, A Plan, A Canal by Arthur Herman (here's a snip but read it all)
But they, and their allies the French and British, had not reckoned on the United States. President Eisenhower and his secretary of state, John Foster Dulles, were preoccupied with the Cold War. Like their Democratic predecessors, they were reluctant to support any move that smacked of "colonialism," no matter how justified. And Eisenhower, in Stephen Ambrose's words, was "uncomfortable with Jews" and never understood the threat Israel faced from its Arab neighbors. So the Americans refused to endorse the Suez invasion. "We do not want to meet violence with violence," Dulles said--words that have a disturbing echo today. Then the Americans went further. If the British and French attacked Egypt, Eden was told, the United States would not back them up in the United Nations.
Finally, in late October, after weeks of hesitation and prevaricating, the British, French, and Israelis struck. The British and French Operation Musketeer was a stunning success; in the face of the Israeli attack, Nasser's army collapsed. French paratroopers and tanks were poised to roll into Cairo. But then, with American encouragement, U.N. secretary general Dag Hammarskjöld became involved.
To this day in elite circles, his name is treated with pious reverence second only to Gandhi and Martin Luther King. After his death, his face even graced an American postage stamp. In fact, Hammarskjöld was arguably the worst secretary general in the history of the United Nations. He was certainly the most devious. He was the bleak prototype of another U.N. apparatchik, his fellow Swede Hans Blix...
[h/t: isirota1965]
Walid Jumblatt -- Mountain Man
Michael Young interviews the Druze leader in his home. Some very interesting tid bits: The leader of Lebanon's Druze talks about the Syrian threat This thing isn't going to truly end without regime change in Damascus...and beyond.
The United States is not thinking about such a scheme, Mr. Jumblatt tells me. And that's why he plainly feels that American ambitions are likely to crash against the reality on the ground. If Hezbollah refuses to disarm (and it does), "then we enter a phase of all-out war, endless war, with the possibility that this will weaken the Lebanese state. Let us also remember that the Syrians a few days ago promised the Americans they would help them fight al Qaeda. This was, in fact, a backhanded warning that Syria could use al Qaeda to kill innocents in Lebanon."
(Mr. Jumblatt sounds even less confident a day later. I call him up for a reaction to the early-morning address by Hezbollah's secretary-general, Hassan Nasrallah, in which he promised to bomb deeper inside Israel. Our conversation takes place amid reports that the Israelis have suffered heavy losses in fighting for the town of Bint Jbail. "Even if Nasrallah loses positions, Hezbollah's fierce rearguard is making it increasingly difficult to set up something afterwards. I doubt we will see a multilateral force if this continues. If Nasrallah comes out victorious, he will dictate his conditions to the Lebanese state--if he still accepts the state.")...
What would we do without Ramsey Clark?
We'd be down one traitor, I suppose. (Not a word I use often, but in Clark's case it seems to apply fairly well.)
Ramsey Clark Plans 'Emergency March' to Stop Israel
Clark claimed that U.S. funding to Israel, which is battling Hizballah terrorists in southern Lebanon, is grounds for impeaching President Bush. "If we'd acted on impeachment before now, Lebanon wouldn't be subjected to this misery," said Clark at the National Press Club Thursday. "If we fail to act now, who is next?"
The National Council of Arab-Americans, Partnership for Civil Justice, Muslim American Society Freedom Foundation, and the ANSWER Coalition are partnering to show their dissent of U.S.-Israeli policy in a march planned near the White House on Aug. 12...
Voices for Israel
A song from these folks.
[h/t: isirota1965]
The Jihad Comes Home...Again
Six shot, one killed at Seattle Jewish federation
Police spokesman Rich Pruitt said there was one shooter, who was apprehended without incident outside the Jewish Federation building at the corner of Third Avenue and Virginia Street.
"We believe it's a lone individual acting out his antagonism," said David Gomez, who heads the FBI's counterterrorism efforts in Seattle.
Authorities did not release many details, but the FBI said the alleged shooter was between 30 and 40 and agents were investigating the incident as a hate crime. When asked at a news conference if that meant the alleged shooter was Muslim, Seattle Police Chief Gil Kerlikowske said: "You could infer that."
One woman was killed in the attack, police said.
Harborview Medical Center spokeswoman Pamela Steele said five victims were taken to the hospital, all women ranging in age from the 20s to the 40s. Each suffered gunshot wounds to the abdomen, knee, groin or arm. Three were in critical condition. Two were in satisfactory condition.
One of the women in satisfactory condition is about 20 weeks pregnant and was shot in the arm. Doctors believe she will be OK...
Hatred hits home: 6 shot at Jewish office
Three of the women were in critical condition late Friday.
A law-enforcement source identified the arrested suspect as Naveed Afzal Haq, 30, who until recently had lived in Everett, and said Haq apparently has a history of mental illness. Court records show Haq has a charge of lewd conduct pending against him in Benton County.
The shooting came a day after the FBI had warned Jewish organizations nationwide to be on alert after Hezbollah leaders in Lebanon and al-Qaida's second in command urged that the war raging in the Middle East be carried to the U.S. However, the law-enforcement source, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said there is no evidence Haq was involved with any group.
"He said he hates Israel," said the source, who is part of the Seattle Joint Terrorism Task Force, which was called in to help investigate the shootings...
CAIR condemned the attack quickly, with none of their usual "buts."
Michelle has lots of links here and here, and at LGF here and here.
Friday, July 28, 2006
Rockets in the Garden
Israeli Strike on Hizballah rocket launcher that hides in a residential home after firing:
I posted this one earlier, but it's worth checking out again, of a strike on a launcher set up amongst civilian structures:
[h/t: Joaquim]
Note: Some users at YouTube have been trying to make these videos more difficult to see by flagging them as adult material and placing them behind an annoying registration process. If the videos do not work, let me know and I will seek them at other sources.
Update: 7/30: Here is video from today's post, Video from Kfar Qana -- A War Crime on Tape. I am adding it in here as I know a lot of people are hitting this post directly.
What became of Little Albert?
He's posing for photographers now I guess.
Sick.
Maybe the "art community" needs to develop some ethics, but then I suppose nothing can stand between an artist and...themselves.
Anglican Bishop Abu El-Assal on the Stump for Hamas and Hizballah
The Bishop Who Honored the Suicides, Anglican Bishop Riah H. Abu El-Assal, is back, and this time, he's doing propaganda for Hamas and Hizballah: Bishop Riah, the Anglican Bishop in Jerusalem, on the current crisis in the Middle East
For the past forty years we have been largely alone on this desert fighting a predator [how dehumanizing] that not only has robbed us of all but a small piece of our historic homeland, but threatens the traditions and holy sites of Christianity. We are tired, weary, sick, and wounded. We need your help.
We have seen and we have been the recipients of the generosity of our American and British friends. We cherish the support of everyone throughout the world who stands with us in solidarity. Daily, I hear from many of them who express outrage at the arrogant and aggressive positions of President Bush, Secretary Rice, Senator Clinton, and Prime Minister Blair. I am saddened to realise just how much the deserved prestige of the United States and Britain has declined as a result of politicians who seem to devalue human life and suffering. And, I am disturbed that the Zionist Christian community is damaging America’s image as never before. [Thank God for the Christian Zionists.]
Little more than a week ago, we were focused on the plight of the Palestinian people. In Gaza, four and five generations have been victims of Israeli racism, hate crimes, terror, violence, and murder. [ah, ah, ah...love thine enemy Bishop] Garbage and sewage have created a likely outbreak of cholera as Israeli strategies create the collapse of infrastructures. There is no milk. Drinking water, food, and medicine are in serious short supply. Innocents are being killed and dying from lack of available emergency care. [Except for all that humanitarian aid they've been letting in.] Children are paying the ultimate price. Even for those whose lives are spared, many of them are traumatised and will not grow to live useful lives. Commerce between the West Bank and Gaza has been halted and humanitarian aid barely trickles into some of the neediest in the world. [Stop shooting rockets and training the suicide bombers you think are such heroes...things will get better.]
...The strategy of ethnic cleansing on the part of the State of Israel continues [Fortunately, the strategy of ethnic cleansing promised by your friends in Hamas and Hizballah is held at bay for the moment.].
This week, war broke out on the Lebanon-Israeli border (near Banyas where Jesus gave St. Peter the keys to heaven and earth). The Israeli government’s disproportionate reaction to provocation was consistent with their opportunistic responses in which they destroy their perceived enemy. [see, viewed a different way, Hizballah rockets and kidnappers are your friends.]...
Enough of that crap, read the rest on your own if you want.
Maybe the Rt. Reverend will visit the families of these Lebanese when he visits, and speak out for them when he returns (to Israel, where he operates freely): Christians Fleeing Lebanon Denounce Hezbollah
But for some of the Christians who had made it out in this convoy, it was not just privations they wanted to talk about, but their ordeal at the hands of Hezbollah — a contrast to the Shiites, who make up a vast majority of the population in southern Lebanon and broadly support the militia.
“Hezbollah came to Ain Ebel to shoot its rockets,” said Fayad Hanna Amar, a young Christian man, referring to his village. “They are shooting from between our houses.”
“Please,’’ he added, “write that in your newspaper.”...
...Many Christians from Ramesh and Ain Ebel considered Hezbollah’s fighting methods as much of an outrage as the Israeli strikes. Mr. Amar said Hezbollah fighters in groups of two and three had come into Ain Ebel, less than a mile from Bint Jbail, where most of the fighting has occurred. They were using it as a base to shoot rockets, he said, and the Israelis fired back.
One woman, who would not give her name because she had a government job and feared retribution, said Hezbollah fighters had killed a man who was trying to leave Bint Jbail.
“This is what’s happening, but no one wants to say it” for fear of Hezbollah, she said...
...a person affiliated with the United States Embassy arrived in Yaroun and shouted for everyone to join a convoy that the Israelis had promised safe passage...
Body Worlds Video
Here's a video report (requires IE) of the controversial Body Worlds exhibit now on display at Boston's Museum of Science.
I take issue with the museum director claiming that it's mostly people who fear death and the religious who are against the exhibit. I do not believe you need to be particularly religious to have concerns about this thing (see "controversial" above).
MDA STATION IN SAFED, AMBULANCE HIT BY KATYUSHA ROCKETS
From American Friends of Magen David Adom:
Also:
Evidence of Cultural Imperialism in Tikrit, Iraq!
Pacifying the Sunni Triangle, one Night House Bright House at a time.
'Your email has been gassed and burned.'
An update to the MrModChips saga (see below for part 1: All the kid wanted to do was mod his Gamecube). That bit in the title is what people are receiving as an automated response to emails inquiring about Israel. [h/t: isirota1965]
Dearbornistan
A credible account of an incredible event right here in the USA from Debbie Schlussel: What I Saw in Dearbornistan
...The Bint Jebail Cultural Center was founded in 1994. Incredibly, American taxpayers subsidize this "cultural center," since it has 501(c)(3) tax-deductible status. In 2004, the year of its last tax return on file, the club spent over $85,000 on "cultural and religious seminars and lectures," most of them extremist. The decor of the club is elaborate, if you like the Saddam Palace/Donald Trump Apartment style of gaud. The extremists who founded the club apparently think paradise looks like Liberace-land.
While it operates mostly as a banquet facility, the Bint Jebail Cultural Center is also used as a frequent meeting place for Hezbollah supporters and a locale for pro-Hezbollah rallies that frequently feature anti-American and anti-Christian hate, not just anti-Semitism...
...Among the many speakers, several things were in common: multiple statements about the Jews, cheers for the total destruction of and end to Israel, and support for Hezbollah, the Mujahideen, and the Martyrs.
A very religious Islamic event, I sat with the many bitter-looking, hijab-encrusted women in black (the women were relegated to separate seating in the back). Every imam of every Shi'ite mosque in town was there, white turban et al. That includes Imams Hassan Qazwini of the Islamic Center of America and Mohammed Ali Elahi of the Islamic House of Wisdom--heads of the two largest mosques in North America. (I've written extensively about Elahi's connections to Iran and Hezbollah.) Also there, Imam Husham Al-Hussainy of the Karbalaa Islamic Institute. At a Dearborn rally in memory of Yasser Arafat, he held a poster of his hero, Ayatollah Khomeini. Both Qazwini and Al-Hussainy were hugged by President Bush in media photo ops when he came to town upon Iraq's liberation.
Haj Mohammed Turfe (AP incorrectly called him Mohammed "Torfah"), Founding Chairman of the Bint Jebail Cultural Center, gleefully and repeatedly spoke of how "only a few thousand Jews will survive Armageddon." This mantra, repeated often throughout the event, got raucous, deafening applause and cheers. Well, for once--I thought--extremist Muslims have respect for Christianity...when they can twist it to suit their fascist hopes and dreams...
Al-Hayat Columnist: 'Israel's present political and military leaders are the grandsons of Nazi killers rather than Jews'
The following are excerpts from the article: [1]
"Is it Logical for the Survivors of the Holocaust and Their Descendants to Do What the Nazis had Done to Them?"
"Ehud Olmert's government perpetrates definite Nazi practices against the Palestinians and the Lebanese. He is a young Führer, and his generals, like Dan Halutz and Moshe Kaplinsky, are commando generals. The question now is: Is it logical for the survivors of the Holocaust and their descendants to do what the Nazis had done to them?
"There is a psychological explanation for this: the victim impersonates the torturer. However, I have another explanation.
"Historically, six million Jews died in the Holocaust, and 97.5 percent of the Polish Jews were killed in the gas chambers, and by other means. My explanation is that the number of the Jews who were killed might be higher. All the Polish Jews might have been killed, too, and the Nazi political and military leaders might have realized since 1944 that defeat was imminent and, therefore, assumed the identity of Jews and then fled to Palestine as Jews who had survived the Holocaust.
"If this explanation is true, Israel's present political and military leaders are the grandsons of Nazi killers rather than Jews persecuted for centuries at the hands of Western Christendom."
"I know that my explanation may be implausible, but I cannot find any other logical reason for Israel's Nazi-like practices. The phrase 'Israeli Nazism' is exactly an oxymoron, as if we say, for instance, 'Sharon is a man of peace.'"...
Why, yes, yes it does sound implausible. But, sadly, not surprising.
DoS
Sorry if you've had trouble leaving a comment, or accessing the site in any way. I was the subject of what amounts to a minor-league denial of service attack this morning that basically filled my disk quota and screwed my email up. I've taken steps and all should be well (for now). If you sent an email and think I might have missed it, send again. Please be sure to use only the exact email address on my contact page, others may not work.
Update: Well, sorry for the lack of updates so far today -- spent the morning sorting this out and that kind of took the wind out of my sails a bit...and there's real work to be done.
BTW, if you're looking for web hosting, I can't recommend Hosting Matters highly enough. Though I sorted this issue out myself, they have been excellent at keeping the site up and letting me go beyond my allocated storage and bandwidth without saying a word about it (/knock on wood). They also respond to support tickets quickly. Word to them.
Thursday, July 27, 2006
Watch Hannity & Colmes Tonight!
Our friend, Seva, star of Mayhem at the Defend Hizballah Rally!, will be on some time around 9:20 Eastern to talk about the incident.
Update: Bump. They just showed some of the video during the intro.
Update2: Nice job Seva! You're a pro. I'll try to get the video transferred tomorrow (need a new VCR).
[Aside: Now I know what Drudge always says "Must credit Drudge report." Heh.]
Update: Many thanks to the folks at TerrorFreeOil for getting the video of Seva's appearance up already.
It's also at the Fox News site here.
Hizballah's Attacks on the UN Ignored
Charles has been doing an excellent job following this: Hizballah Attacked UNIFIL Twice This Week
From the UN’s own press releases:
24 July 2006:
One unarmed UN military observer, a member of the Observer Group Lebanon (OGL), was seriously wounded by small arms fire in the patrol base in the Marun Al Ras area yesterday afternoon. According to preliminary reports, the fire originated from the Hezbollah side during an exchange with the IDF. He was evacuated by the UN to the Israeli side, from where he was taken by an IDF ambulance helicopter to a hospital in Haifa. He was operated on, and his condition is now reported as stable.
Notice: in this instance, the UN observer was injured badly enough to be evacuated to an Israeli hospital. Where they saved his life.
Not a word of condemnation from Kofi Annan for Hizballah. And not a word of gratitude for Israel, for saving a UN peacekeeper’s life...
More.
Update: More.
Video Diary - HonestReporting UK Heads North
No Oslo...No Intifada

It was never about building a nation. It was all about the final goal...Fatah...Conquest...
Distributing Hizballah Flags in the Iranian Parliament

More at IranPressNews.
Syrian Deputy Minister of Religious Endowment Muhammad 'Abd Al-Sattar Calls for Jihad and Says Jews Are the Decendants of Apes and Pigs

Vicious racist Jew-hatred from a Syrian Imam and Minister on Syrian TV, courtesy of MEMRI:
Muhammad 'Abd Al-Sattar: "Jihad is now incumbent upon each and every Muslim, Arab, and Christian. The time has come for the duty of Jihad."
[...]
"Who occupied the Al-Aqsa Mosque? Who attacked the prophets? Who killed the prophets? Even the Koran depicts the people of Israel in a very sinister and dark way. Allah did not curse any people, not even the polytheists, not even the idol worshippers. The Koran did not curse any of these. The only ones who were cursed are those murderous criminals."
[...]
"The Koran used terms that are closer to animals than to humans only with regard to those people. Look at the bestiality they demonstrate in the destruction of the Arab, Lebanese, and Palestinian people. This is why the people who were given the Torah were likened to a donkey carrying books. They were also likened to apes and pigs, and they are, indeed, the descendants of apes and pigs, as the Koran teaches us."...
Pictures of Hizballah-love in Montreal
Mainliners Respond to War
Dexter Van Zile has a run-down on some of the pronouncements made by the mainline Protestant denominations. It's not always pretty: Mainline Christian Churches Respond to Hamas and Hezbollah Aggression
- An attempt to portray Israeli use of force solely as an overreaction to kidnappings (by themselves and act of war) without acknowledging the hundreds of rocket attacks against Israeli civilians launched by Hamas since Israel’s withdrawal from Gaza and the rocket attacks that preceded the Hezbollah’s kidnapping of two Israeli soldiers;
- A failure to acknowledge that Hezbollah has, with Syrian and Iranian support, stockpiled weapons for use against Israel;
- A failure to acknowledge the fundamental difference between the motives of the warring parties. Israel uses force to protect its citizens; Hamas and Hezbollah use force in an effort to destroy the Jewish State;
- A failure to acknowledge the fundamental difference between the practices of the warring parties. Israel works to avoid civilian casualties by warning people to leave areas before attacks; Hamas and Hezbollah target civilians while hiding amongst their own civilians, guaranteeing civilian casualties. Hezbollah has also used checkpoints to prevent Lebanese civilians from fleeing combat areas; and
- A failure to acknowledge that Israel was attacked by territory from which it had previously withdrawn from in the pursuit of peace.
It is also important to note that the organizations that offered these statements offered little if any criticism of Hamas and Hezbollah’s provocative actions before Israel responded. Criticism of Hamas and Hezbollah’s misdeeds typically serves as an adjunct to statements primarily focused on condemning Israel...
Australian FM warns of UN 'suicide mission' to Lebanon
Australian FM warns of UN 'suicide mission' to Lebanon
But Downer, in Kuala Lumpur for a regional foreign ministers meeting, said that Australia would not withdraw its UN observers from the troubled region.
"Well I think there is no point in sending an international peacekeeping mission on a suicide mission," Downer said when asked about the prospects of UN peacekeepers going to Lebanon...
...Downer said a ceasefire could only happen when Hezbollah stops firing missiles into Israel and Lebanese government takes control over southern Lebanon from the militia.
"In the situation where Hezbollah are firing missiles from southern Lebanon into Israel, it is not realistic to accept that Israelis will just sit in their villages and towns and receive their missiles and die," he said...
(Via the comments at LGF)
More details on the Pakistani Honor Killing
Miss Kelly has a few more details on the Pakistani honor killing I pointed to earlier (see: URGENT - Honor Killing, Pakistani Woman Needs Help):
After the search of three months she was found & separated by her forced husband. At that time due to interference of her father & few other tribes men she was been saved by killing, but her brothers & cousin were in search of a suitable time to kill her.
Her father placed her in a "madrasa" in Rawalpindi. On 6th or 7th of July she was brought back to her native home as she was not feeling well due to small pocks. Her uncle who is a milliner businessman in UAE forced his son Haroon age 20 to kill Ghazala age 18. He did so with the help of his local cousins on 19th July 2006 & left for UAE.
Now the parents & other family members with the help of police made this a suicide Case. No authorities are taking this as a cruel act. I on behalf of the people of town appeal the human rights activists to reopen this issue & make the justice to her poor mother & small sisters which are also threatened to be killed by the Cousin...
More info in Miss Kelly's post.
All the kid wanted to do was mod his Gamecube
And this is the reply he got back from the company he ordered the chip from:
Of course the kid lives in Israel.
The company, with a web site in the UK is actually in Thailand. And I've always liked Thailand...
Hizballah with Civilians
By now everyone has seen this story, but forgive me if I'd like to get it on the record here, as well: UN humanitarian chief blasts Hizbullah
Jan Egeland spoke with reporters at the Larnaca airport in Cyprus late Monday after a visit to Lebanon on his mission to coordinate an international aid effort. On Sunday he had toured the rubble of Beirut's southern suburbs, a once-teeming Shi'ite district where Hizbullah had its headquarters.
During that visit he condemned the killing and wounding of civilians by both sides, and called Israel's offensive "disproportionate" and "a violation of international humanitarian law."
On Monday he had strong words for Hizbullah, which crossed into Israel and captured two Israeli soldiers on July 12, triggering fierce fighting from both sides.
"Consistently, from the Hizbullah heartland, my message was that Hizbullah must stop this cowardly blending ... among women and children," he said. "I heard they were proud because they lost very few fighters and that it was the civilians bearing the brunt of this. I don't think anyone should be proud of having many more children and women dead than armed men."...

Here's a short video of an IDF strike on a Hizballah rocket launcher ensconced in a civilian neighborhood.
Also, here's a PowerPoint presentation on Hizballah used by the IDF that dates to early 2004, though it's still interesting.
Finally, TigerHawk reminds us of a recent Hizballah policy statement: "Death to America is not a slogan. Death to America is a policy, a strategy and a vision."
A Soldier of Israel
There's been an image making the rounds that makes a point, and a good one, but it's a little low-res. Here's a little nicer picture -- original source unknown -- sent in by Tom Glennon:

Wednesday, July 26, 2006
Notes from CENTCOM
IRAQI FORCE RAID TAKES DOWN 'DEATH SQUAD' CELL IN BAGHDAD
As coalition force advisers looked on, Iraqi forces raided an objective in southwest Baghdad consisting of four separate buildings and captured the cell leader and five other key members of an insurgent ‘punishment committee.’
Iraqi forces also seized two AK-47 assault rifles, one pistol, and one set of body armor.
The operation occurred without incident; there were no Iraqi or coalition force casualties.
IRAQI SOLDIERS, MARINES RESCUE THREE HOSTAGES, RECOVER LARGE WEAPONS CACHE
The three were personal assistants and bodyguards to Dr. Rafa Hayid Chiad Al-Isaw, an Iraqi government official in Baghdad.
“We are extremely pleased we were able to recover these three Iraqi citizens,” said Col. Larry D. Nicholson, commanding officer for RCT-5. “The safety of Iraqi citizens to move freely about their own country without fear is a priority for U.S and Iraqi forces and we will continue to assist the Iraqi Army and Iraqi Police in ensuring their citizens have a future that is free of terrorism.”
The three were held captive by al-Qaeda insurgents in a spiderhole complex for 27 days. The hostages were beaten with electrical cords, bitten and threatened with their lives at gunpoint by their captors. They were treated by Coalition Forces medical personnel...
Afghanistan: ENEMY FIGHTERS ATTACK COALITION UNIT, SEVEN EXTREMISTS KILLED
There were no Coalition casualties in the fight. The Coalition unit received small arms, rocket-propelled grenade, machine gun and sniper fire from a group of extremists. The Coalition force returned fire, killing five insurgents.
Later in the same area, insurgents fired small arms at an Afghan National Army mortar team, with a Coalition embedded tactical training team attached. The combined unit responded with machine gun fire and killed the remaining two insurgents.
“If enemy extremists fire upon Coalition forces, we will respond with deadly accuracy,” said Lt. Col. Paul Fitzpatrick, Combined Joint Task Force -76 spokesman. “If they attack Afghan civilians, we will respond just as forcefully. We remain committed to engaging any threats to the peaceful future of the Afghan people.”...
Cool Military Pic of the Day
Click for the hi-res version:
Shin Bet issues warning to families of terrorists ahead of strikes
Haaretz: Sources: Shin Bet issues warning to families of terrorists ahead of strikes
According to the sources, Shin Bet agents have contacted members of various armed organizations over the last few days and warned them that Israel plans to attack their houses. The houses in question are being targeted because Israel believes that they are being used to store or manufacture weapons, including Qassam rockets and rocket-propelled grenades.
Before dawn yesterday, the Israel Defense Forces bombed two such houses - one belonging to an Islamic Jihad operative in Gaza City and one belonging to a Hamas operative in Rafah, on the Gazan-Egyptian border. According to the army, both houses served as weapons factories.
In addition, the IDF has interrupted local radio broadcasts in several parts of Gaza in recent days, overriding the scheduled programing with warnings about planned attacks on houses that serve as arms caches. The interrupted broadcasts have included some by Hamas' Radio Al-Aqsa...
The War Against Israel -- and on that UN outpost...
Melanie Phillips has two great posts you should check out: The war against Israel Part 1, Part 2:
Buried at the end is this very interesting update concerning the bombing of that UN outpost:
[via Israpundit]
Some other interesting thoughts on that here.
Update: A comment in the post below:
Update 2: LGF has audio of the Canadian General Melanie Phillips quoted above. Excellent. Really, listen to it. On one of the UN soldiers killed:
More concerning Hizballah using UN positions for cover in this post.
An interesting new addition to the Shoebat Foundation
Just got this from Walid Shoebat's people:
Kamal Saleem was born in Lebanon to a prominant Muslim clerical family, and out of sympathy to the Palestinian cause joined the PLO Fatah movement as a child. Later on he joined the PFLP. While being an active terrorist from the age of eleven years old Kamal was involved in rioting and open gun battles with the IDF on the Lebanese-Israeli border.
While in America Kamal participated in islamic missions work to convert young Americans to Islam, in order to then have them recruited for Jihad in America.
In 1985 Kamal went through a spiritual journey and converted to Christianity and has already spread his message of reconciliation to many Christians. Now he believes he needs to speak to a wider audiance and fulfill G-ds blessing on the Jewish people and Israel.
It is our honor and duty to promote Kamal in the media, because of his background can join us in the current fight for the rights of Israel to defend itself against the evil of Hezbollah terrorists and the media who holds Israel to a different standard.
I'm sure that was the "spiritual striving" version of Jihad that he came to America originally to promote.
All we are saaaaying...
...is give Jihad a chance...
I love sing alongs.
URGENT - Honor Killing, Pakistani Woman Needs Help
Miss Kelly has received a disturbing email. I am going to practice bad blogger-ettiquette and paste her entire post below:
If there is any way to help this woman, please contact or leave a comment with Miss Kelly. Sadly, this is not an uncommon story.
Tuesday, July 25, 2006
The UN is repairing roads in Hizballah territory
While the war is going on. I'm speechless.
Netanyahu on Sky
Bibi does a good interview with Britain's Sky News, giving some pretty good responses: video here. Take a look.
He doesn't address it, but the reporter asks, "Hasn't Israel made its point?" Made its point? Israel isn't making a point, they're fighting a war. Does Europe think Israel should be engaged in some sort of game of counting coup?
'I believe that the first person to warn against the Iranian-Syrian alliance was me, Walid Jumblatt'

MEMRITV: Lebanese Druze Leader Walid Jumblatt Accuses Hizbullah, Iran, and Syria for Lebanon Crisis
..."Today, the Lebanese state has become a kind of Red Cross. If tomorrow a cease-fire is reached - even if the state is represented formally on the issue of the prisoners - the Lebanese state would still be incapable of [fulfilling] all its plans - to spread its sovereignty to South Lebanon and to the refugee camps, and especially with regard to the weapons outside the refugee camps."...
..."A cease-fire between who? [Israel] and the Lebanese state? Will Hizbullah recognize the Lebanese state?"...
..."Will the weapons of Hizbullah be incorporated into the defensive system of the Lebanese army, and I emphasize the word 'defensive?' Or will there be a cease-fire, and then the first article on the agenda will be that we should liberate the prisoners. Then he will say to you: 'We want to liberate the Shab'a Farms, and I need to keep my weapons in order to liberate Shab'a.' Then he will tell you that we should implement Resolution 194 - the return of the refugees to Palestine. In such a case, Lebanon will become an open battlefield for the Syrian and Iranian regimes."...
There's much more. Very interesting. Not all perfect -- he supports a "right of return," and of course he would, since that would be a way to get the Palestinian Arabs out of his country -- but still interesting.
More on the anti-Zionism/anti-Semitism Nexus
Here's an interesting post by someone from the Simon Wiesenthal Center that looks at that study that examined the nexus between anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism. The author of the post is also one of the authors of that excellent Wiesenthal Center response to the UCC's John Thomas (which he also mentions): Anti-Zionism Equals Anti-Semitism. A snip:
It is noteworthy that fewer than one-quarter of those with anti-Israel index scores of only 1 or 2 harbor anti-Semitic views (as defined by anti-Semitic index scores exceeding 5), which supports the contention that one certainly can be critical of Israeli policies without being anti-Semitic. However, among those with the most extreme anti-Israel sentiments in our survey (anti-Israel index scores of 4), 56% report anti-Semitic leanings. Based on this analysis, when an individual’s criticism of Israel becomes sufficiently severe, it does become reasonable to ask whether such criticism is a mask for underlying anti-Semitism...
'The real question is not whether Israel's counteroffensive is disproportionate but whether it's working'
Certified Bush-hater Jonathan Chait demonstrates well that support for Israel isn't just on the right (especially in the US): Israel's Justifiable Use Of Force. [requires free registration -- also in the forum]
Second, as the Israeli government rightly points out, no country operates on the principle of responding to aggression with no more force than was originally used against it. During World War II, Germany sunk a lot of American ships and declared war on us, and in return we flattened its cities, killed or captured hundreds of thousands of its solders and occupied its land. That was hardly a proportionate response.
Now, it is true that Israel's counteroffensive has taken the lives of several hundred Lebanese civilians (many entirely innocent, others who sheltered Hezbollah rockets) and displaced perhaps half a million more. Every innocent death is a tragedy.
But the brutal fact is that civilian deaths are Hezbollah's strongest weapon. As Sheik Hassan Nasrallah, the leader of Hezbollah, once said: "We have discovered how to hit the Jews where they are the most vulnerable. The Jews love life, so that is what we shall take away from them. We are going to win because they love life and we love death."
Thus, Hezbollah places its rockets and other potential targets in homes, knowing that Israel cannot hit back without creating collateral damage. This does not relieve Israel of the burden of minimizing civilian casualties as best it can. The point is that if Israel has to operate under a code of ethics that renders civilian deaths unacceptable, then it automatically loses. The ramifications would be dire and ultimately aid the cause of Islamic radicals in such a way as to bring about many more innocent deaths over the long run.
The real question, then, is not whether Israel's counteroffensive is disproportionate but whether it's working...
[h/t: isirota1965]
Boston: "Justice for Lebanon" Rally
For those who asked when other events might be happening: There is a "Justice for Lebanon" rally this Friday, the 28th at 5PM at Copley Square, Boston. The flyer is here. [PDF]
The note that came with the email on the Muslim American Society list:
I'm betting they do a better job of staying "on message" this time. If you decide to go and check it out, remember that you should always conduct yourself in a scrupulous and humble manner (remember how bad some of the people who confronted Seva looked). You're not the show and shouldn't go with the idea of creating something. If something interesting happens, great, if it doesn't, let it drop down the memory hole.
Access from Terror Groups
Lesson #3000000 in never trusting news coming out of fear societies...whether the news people are ours or theirs: CNN's Robertson Now Admits: Hezbollah 'Had Control' of His Anti-Israel Piece
Back on July 18, Hezbollah took Robertson and his crew on a tour of a heavily damaged south Beirut neighborhood. The Hezbollah “press officer” even instructed the CNN camera: “Just look. Shoot. Look at this building. Is it a military base? Is it a military base, or just civilians living in this building?”
In his original story, Robertson had no complaints about the journalistic limitations of a story put together under such tight controls, and Robertson himself at one point seemed to agree with the Hezbollah propaganda claim that Israeli jets had targeted a civilian area: “As we run past the rubble, we see much that points to civilian life, no evidence apparent of military equipment.”
Challenged by Reliable Sources host (and Washington Post media writer) Howard Kurtz on Sunday, Robertson suggested Hezbollah has “very, very sophisticated and slick media operations,” that the terrorist group “had control of the situation. They designated the places that we went to, and we certainly didn't have time to go into the houses or lift up the rubble to see what was underneath,” and he even contradicted Hezbollah’s self-serving spin: “There's no doubt that the [Israeli] bombs there are hitting Hezbollah facilities.”...
Gee, I hope CNN doesn't lose any of its "access" over this admission.
Cohen redeems himself
Don't Israel's critics usually call proportionality a "cycle of violence?" Richard Cohen makes up a bit for his recent column calling Israel a "mistake" with this one: . . . No, It's Survival
The list of those who have accused Israel of not being in harmony with its enemies is long and, alas, distinguished. It includes, of course, the United Nations and its secretary general, Kofi Annan. It also includes a whole bunch of European newspapers whose editorial pages call for Israel to respond, it seems, with only one missile for every one tossed its way. Such neat proportion is a recipe for doom...
...The dire consequences of proportionality are so clear that it makes you wonder if it is a fig leaf for anti-Israel sentiment in general. Anyone who knows anything about the Middle East knows that proportionality is madness. For Israel, a small country within reach, as we are finding out, of a missile launched from any enemy's back yard, proportionality is not only inapplicable, it is suicide. The last thing it needs is a war of attrition. It is not good enough to take out this or that missile battery. It is necessary to reestablish deterrence: You slap me, I will punch out your lights...
...I know Israel's imperfections, but I also exalt and admire its achievements. Lacking religious conviction, I fear for its future and note the ominous spread of European-style anti-Semitism throughout the Muslim world -- and its boomerang return to Europe as a mindless form of anti-Zionism...
...These calls for proportionality rankle. They fall on my ears not as genteel expressions of fairness, some ditsy Marquess of Queensberry idea of war, but as ugly sentiments pregnant with antipathy toward the only democratic state in the Middle East...
'Don't ever think of retreating'
Reformed Lebanese terrorist Zachariah Anani on Fox with John Kasich [link to video].
According to the Walid Shoebat Foundation [from email]:
This is outrageous and what message does this say to our free society? That the courts in Canada would put into foster care a child of the victimized parent of intimidation, because of Islamic hatemongers. Surely, if the court was so fearful of harm to his child then the protection of Zak and his family by the law enforcement officers at the expense of the tax payer is a prequisite for a free society and not to imprison and separate the innocent because of evil Islamists. This is political correctness and appeasement gone mad...
Buggery
I've been enjoying the book Mayflower: A Story of Courage, Community, and War by Nathaniel Philbrick, and have found much of general intellectual interest. I was going to share some of those things with you (like the fact that the Pilgrims' food economy was moribund until such time as they stopped collective farming and were each given their own piece of land to work and own, whereupon productivity took off), but I just can't resist relating this selection:
Poor bugger.
My how times have changed in Massachusetts. Today he'd be forced to marry the menagerie.
I just wonder how they compiled the list. Did the turkey file a police report?
Interesting Power Point Presentations
Via email:
(please be advised that some people may find the pictures disturbing)
The second link is an IDF presentation containing information regarding humanitarian assistance in Lebanon.
Seva on Hot Air
Today's Vent with Michelle Malkin features the video of our friend Seva's experience in action photography. Don't miss it.
Monday, July 24, 2006
My son died for freedom
Hat tip to isirota1965 who titles his email "The anti-Cindy Sheehan":
CBC: My son died for freedom: soldier's father
George Gomez said his son, 44-year-old Cpl. Francisco Gomez, loved being in the military.
Gomez and Cpl. Jason Warren, 29, were killed Saturday by a suicide bomber driving a vehicle packed with explosives.
Gomez, 44, never married or had children. His father said he joined the army as soon as he graduated from high school.
"This is Francisco in the airborne," the father said, pointing at a picture in his Edmonton home. "And he really loved jumping out of a plane."
Francisco Gomez did several peacekeeping tours and had almost completed his six-month tour in Afghanistan.
"We expected him to be back in another week or so," George Gomez said.
"We were looking forward to him coming and visiting and so were the little grandchildren because he plays with them."
Gomez said his son died fighting for freedom, something he says is a worthy cause...
Iranian War Dead Flown to Iran
NY Sun: War Dead Flown to Iran
Israeli and Egyptian security officials confirmed the news, which follows a report that first appeared in The New York Sun, that Iranian forces posted to southern Lebanon have been aiding Hezbollah terrorists in their attacks against Israel, including helping to fire rockets into Israeli population centers.
The Lebanese sources said between six and nine dead Iranian Revolutionary Guard soldiers were brought in trucks last week into Syria for a flight back to Iran. They said the bodies were transported along with the tens of thousands of Lebanese civilians fleeing to Syria...
...Israeli officials said Iranian Revolutionary Guards directed the firing two weeks ago of a radar-guided C–802 missile that hit an Israeli navy vessel off the coast of Lebanon, killing four soldiers. Israel says Iran acquired the missile from China.
The officials said the Iranian soldiers' duties include keeping custody of long-range missiles within Hezbollah's arsenal, including Zalzal rockets that are said to have a range of 125 miles, placing Tel Aviv within firing range.
...Jordanian officials told the Sun they are "100% sure" Iranian Revolutionary Guard soldiers have fired rockets into Israel. They also said the Syrian army has provided Hezbollah with intelligence information on the locations of strategic Israeli targets to aid in Hezbollah rocket fire.
A Baath Party official operating out of the Golan Heights told the Sun he has information that Iranian soldiers have been firing rockets into Israel.
It would be "very logical" if Iranian Revolutionary Guard soldiers were helping Hezbollah fire the rockets, a senior Egyptian security official told the Sun...
...At times, Revolutionary Guard soldiers have been seen operating openly at Hezbollah outposts in plain view from the Israeli side, military officials say.
Earlier, an Israeli Foreign Ministry spokesman, Mark Regev, said Israel has information that Hezbollah was trying to transfer the two soldiers it kidnapped to Iran.
Yes, America Remembers Hizballah
By Robb Hensley [posted in full with permission]:
19 U.S Armed Forces personnel killed in a bombing. Government holds Hezbollah responsible.
It's not a headline from today-but from 1996-a little over 10 years ago to the day.
The bombing occurred at the Kobar Towers in Saudi Arabia. The U.S. held Hezbollah responsible. In fact, indictments against Hezbollah members were issued in U.S. Federal Court. Louis Freeh, the Director of the F.B.I. at the time of the bombing, wrote an editorial in the Wall Street Journal after he left the F.B. I., holding Hezbollah responsible for the Kobar Towers bombing. Director Freeh criticized the Clinton administration for not taking clear, decisive, action. (2)
It was not the first time Hezbollah killed U.S. forces directly. In 1983, 17 Americans were killed at the U.S. Embassy in Beirut. A Hezbollah affiliated group claimed responsibility. (3)(4)
This short list doesn't even include other events; such as the kidnapping and torture of a C.I.A. station Chief, or the U.S. Marine bombing at the Beirut Airport-which Hezbollah probably had a role in. ( F.B.I. Director Freeh held Hezbollah responsibility for this bombing as well.)
Why should we forget this?
We should help Israel. If you kill or citizens or Servicemen you will be punished. Not forgotten. Would you exercise restraint if it was one of your family members that died?
Sources:
Rally for Israel in London
I've often been very negative toward the status of the Jewish Community in the UK on this blog, so it's with pleasure that I point to these pictures and a description of a very successful-sounding rally in London yesterday. [h/t: Jerusalem Posts]
Judy also has a lengthy examination of the event. Well done.
Letter from an Israeli Soldier
Sent in by his mother:
In Lebanon, you must understan that Hizbollah is not a "faction" it is part of the government. As we have seen lately as the puppet Lebonese government has come out and declared itself as defenseless aganist Hizbollah. However, that is not the case. Civilians in Beirut are handing out cakes and cookies as a celebration of the 8 dead Israeli soldiers and the two kidnapped ones.
WND: 'Man says his life threatened at protest demonstrating support for Hezbollah'
Seva's story of intrepidity and audacity in the face of adversity has been the subject of a blog-swarm of record proportions for these parts (he's also appeared on two radio shows..oh, and I think readers may enjoy Michelle Malkin's Vent tomorrow). WorldNetDaily has now interviewed Seva and built a story around it: Muslims attack Jew at U.S. Islamic rally - Man says his life threatened at protest demonstrating support for Hezbollah
"I have never been physically attacked before. I've had slurs thrown at me, got into heated debates, but what was amazing was that I was actually physically attacked," Seva Brodsky said. "Since they were the majority, and felt invincible, they threatened to kill me!"
Brodsky, who recently returned from nearly six months in Israel, captured some of the confrontation on video, available at the weblog Solomonia.com.
The event Friday at Boston's City Hall Plaza was the Muslim American Society's "Justice for Palestine and Lebanon Protest." Participants brought signs, including one calling for "victory" for the terrorist group Hezbollah and the "Palestinian Resistance."...
Many thanks to WND for the extensive credit and linkage.
Support Israel Petition
A petition:
Dear Mr. Secretary-General,
In light of the violence affecting the people of Israel and Lebanon, we respectfully ask that you join us in clearly and immediately reaffirming the right of Israel to defend its citizens and ensure its security in the face of relentless attacks, killings and kidnappings by Hezbollah.
We urge you to do everything in your power to help secure the release of Israel's abducted soldiers and to implement UN Security Council Resolution 1559, which requires establishing Lebanon's sovereignty and the authority of its government throughout the country; the disbanding and disarmament of all militias; and the deployment of the Lebanese army along the border with Israel.
Thank you for your attention.
Can religious movements be crushed?
Yes, although the means are not always pretty. Diana Muir at History News Network: So Hezbollah Can't Be Crushed?
The Czech Hussites earned the condemnation of the Church in 1415 for adherence to doctrines that the Church called heresy, and which historians call proto-Protestant. They successfully defended an independent Czech Hussite state against large Catholic armies for twenty years, before agreeing to strike a compromise with the Church. Large numbers of devoted Hussites rejected the political compromise. Many were killed in battle with a combined Czech/Catholic army near Prague on May 30, 1434. Surviving “Warriors of God” were eliminated in a series of small battles, captures, and hangings.
On February 5, 1597, Shogun Toyotomi Hideyoshi decided to crush Christianity in Japan. He considered the rapid increase, geographic concentration, and intense devotion of Christians to be threats to the state. The newly introduced religion had over 300,000 adherents, of whom between 5,000 and 6,000 were executed, many by crucifixion. Christianity as a movement was eliminated from Japan.
I could multiply examples of large populations united by intense religious commitment that have been crushed by the state power. Not obliterated – remnants of Japanese Christianity survived underground, for example – but crushed to the point where a movement no longer existed.
I am certainly not defending the morality of Hideyoshi’s actions, or the crushing of the Cathars, Hussites, or Zanj. I am simply pointing out that popular religious movements can be forcibly destroyed...
Sunday, July 23, 2006
Mayhem at the Defend Hizballah Rally!
This past Friday, the Muslim American Society held their "Justice for Palestine and Lebanon Protest" at Boston's City Hall Plaza referred to at the end of this post. The Boston Globe has its report here: Muslims, Christians protest bombardment of Lebanon
Participants carried signs such as ``Free All Palestinian and Lebanese Political Prisoners," ``End the Israeli Occupation," and ``Stop Aid and Weapons." At times during the nearly three-hour rally, which included a prayer service and was sponsored by the Muslim American Society, they chanted ``Free, Free Palestine," and then ``Free, Free Lebanon." A police officer at the scene estimated the crowd at 2 p.m. to be 500.
Around 1:30 p.m., hundreds gathered in tidy eastward-facing rows of about 50 people each, to pray to God. Most kneeled on prayer rugs. Others improvised with newspapers. Some took off their shoes. Usually, at that time of the week, they would have gathered in a mosque. Assam Omeish, president of the Muslim American Society, led the prayer.
Caline Jarudi, executive director of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee of Massachusetts, said that holding the rally was a big step among Muslims, who often are apprehensive about publicly vocalizing their views because they can face discrimination. ``The rally was about justice and hopefully there is no consequence," she said.
During the rally, many thought of loved ones in Lebanon or the disputed territories in Israel...
"Disputed territories." Very good.
Oh, but that's not the full story. No, no, my friends. You see, freelance operative Seva Brodsky was in the house, camera in hand -- and there was much jostling, grabbing, profanity and threats of violence directed toward our intrepid defender of Israel and America. The remainder of this post is either submitted by, or based on descriptions from, Seva. The pictures and video are his. Any asides from me are placed in brackets, Mr. Brodsky's submission is below in pull-quote format. The description of events is his. Most of the visuals are in video format, with only a few original still-shots, although I have pulled some stills out of the video for illustration (so that is why most of the photos are in a fairly small size). Stick with us, gentle readers, for this shall be worth it. Seva:
Having arrived from Israel several days ago, where I had just spent almost six months, I got right back into my regular Zionist activities. While riding the subway on Thursday, July 20, 2006, I read in the Metro that there was going to be a political rally the very next day (Friday the 21st) at Boston City Hall Plaza. That article, titled Lebanon/Israel cease-fire rally set for tomorrow, by Laura Dannen, could be found in the lower left hand corner of page 2. Following is a short snip:
BOSTON — Calling for an end to the “indiscriminate” loss of life in Lebanon, more than 1,000 members of Boston’s Muslim community are expected to rally on City Hall Plaza tomorrow afternoon.The protest, organized by the Boston branch of the Muslim American Society’s Freedom Foundation, will call for an immediate cease-fire to the fighting between Israel and Hezbollah, now entering its second week, said Omar Abdala, the rally’s organizer.
“It’s unacceptable to indiscriminately kill innocent civilians,” Abdala, 25, said of the Israeli attack on Lebanon. “We’re calling for an immediate end to violence and for Israel to pull back.”
The demonstration, taking place from noon to 3 pm on City Hall Plaza, is part of a larger series of protests around the country this week. More than 2,000 Boston-area Jews and supporters of Israel gathered peacefully in Brookline on Tuesday, demanding peace and security for Israel, an end to terrorism and the safe return of two captured Israeli soldiers...
My interest was piqued, so I decided to check it out. I showed up at City Hall Plaza at about 2 pm, in black dress slacks and striped blue and white shirt, looking like a lawyer on a lunch break. I had a small backpack with the Canon digital photo/video camera in it. As I was approaching the crowd, which appeared to number several hundred people, I took it out and turned the video on.

As I approached the crowd I was confronted by Noah Cohen, [who's Marxist screeds are legend, and who feels Noam Chomsky isn't sufficiently anti-Zionist], who is the husband of Lana Habash [a physician who was quoted as stating that the bombing of Jerusalem Bus#19 was a justifiable act of resistance -- Together, Cohen and Habash run the New England Committee to Defend Palestine, whose goals we have gone over before and which boasts Andover High School's Ron Francis as a booster] and my old nemesis. He tried to harass and intimidate me, but I wouldn't give in. So he tried to impede my video recording by blocking me with his body. As I had a swivel monitor on the camera and was taller than him, I raised the camera above my head and continued filming that way.

However, he is not the type to give up too easily -- being resourceful, he raised a large white banner he had with him on a foam board, thereby creating a new, more formidable obstacle for my probing lens. This precipitated a cat-and-mouse game, which I did not mind engaging in. He was really annoyed by that and started calling for back up. A little crowd started gathering around me, threatening and verbally abusing me.
Some rather short and skinny woman, screaming hysterically at me, grabbed my camera and left arm:

In the ensuing commotion, I suddenly noticed that Noah Cohen grabbed my camera and was quietly trying to break off its swivel monitor. This really stunned me -- I didn't expect he would go to such length and engage in criminally punishable behavior, but I guess, he figured he could afford to do so and get away with it, being surrounded by his comrades-in-arms with no police in sight. At this point, indignant and even outraged, realizing that I was entirely on my own and no help was forthcoming, I yanked the camera from his grip and a scuffle ensued which seemed to cool off his zeal substantially.
More people joined the melee, shouting and threatening me. Unfortunately, by this point my camera was off, so I did not capture what had transpired then. One man told me that the police would not help me, as they were going to hunt me down and kill me (he can be heard on the video repeatedly commanding me not to take pictures):

Eventually the police, a man and a woman, showed up and questioned me, asking me if I wanted to press charges since I knew the name of the perpetrator. I said that I did and they told me where the nearest police station was, so I eventually did proceed there, but not before the Arab "witnesses" were screaming to the cops that I had attacked an innocent woman.
"In the Arab world it is understood that hospitality is given freely to friend and foe alike, that the blessings of family and religion are to be cherished above all else, except possibly money, that what is said is not necessarily what is meant at all because, in the richness and imagery of the Arabic language, style counts more than substance." Pp. xii-xiii of the Introduction to "The Arabs, Journeys Beyond the Mirage"; Vintage, 1988, by David Lamb, an American journalist and author, who is quite sympathetic to the Arabs.
The female officer went to talk to someone, returning several minutes later and telling the male officer that my version of the story got corroborated and checked out in the end.
[Here is the short video, from the time when Seva approached the rally to the point where his camera was grabbed and he stopped filming -- "He's a Zionist! He's profiling people!":]
Upon return from the police station, I continued my video recording activities. More insults and threats followed, and another conversation with the same two police officers, who then suggested I also go to a particular courthouse, as there was still enough time left in the day to also file my complaint there. I got into an interesting discussion with them, and the male cop suggested that I write about the incident to a paper, such as Boston Phoenix, and I replied that I intended to.

[Say, remember micro-Larry Bird? Well he and friend were back, and had a few choice words for Mr. Brodsky (that's his voice -- more of him later -- WARNING: contains profanity):]
[Another encounter with Noah Cohen, another guy who threatens to smash Mr. Brodsky's camera, and a beleaguered -- though it must be said, well-meaning -- Rally Marshall, who informs Mr. Brodsky that he can't guarantee his safety:]
I continued recording the event, moving across the street and observing it from a distance:
[Chanting: "When people are occupied, resistance is justified..."]
[Another encounter: "The Zionists must hate this"...and again with our basketball friend, or as perhaps we should call him, "Gorgeous"...note the Palestine water-bottle accessory:]
All this commotion begs several questions:
1. Why is it that I was the only pro-Israel person who was there out in the open? Where were others? If they were there, did they take notes, pictures, and videos?
2. Was the FBI there? Their field office could have had a field day, and I hope they did -- the proportion of Muslim clerics and Arab as well as hard-core leftist extremists there was quite staggering.
3. Why did the police not come to my rescue right away, and why were there so few of them? I only saw one parked wagon with two cops in it, and the two officers that I talked to. Given the size of the crowd, and the content of speeches, slogans, and banners, I would expect a battalion of security forces there. [This is remarkable. At every pro-Israel event, even family-oriented events, there has been an extensive police presence along with private security. At this event...almost nothing. Draw your own conclusions. -S]
4. Why is it that when we Jews have our demonstrations and rallies, we behave overwhelmingly in a civilized manner in the face of the opposition, and if one of us steps over the line of propriety, the rest admonish such a person? Why do we see such a drastic difference between our behavior and that of our opponents and enemies?
Seva,
For actions far above and beyond what anyone would ever ask you to do, it is my honor to present you with this award and ribbon to be worn on your uniform [described by you as, "black dress slacks and striped blue and white shirt, looking like a lawyer on a lunch break"] at whatever events you deem appropriate. The Order of the Pest of Zion:

Wear it with pride.
Update: 7/24 7:15am -- Seva is on WRKO Boston right now!
Update 2: Nice job Seva! Thanks to Scott Allen Miller for having Seva on. Also welcome to Michelle Malkin, LGF readers, Freepers and others.
Update 3: Seva will be on the Michael Graham radio show (listen live at the link) at about 3:15 Eastern-- that's a few minutes from now. Done. Great job Seva! You sounded great.
Update 4 7/27: Seva will be on Hannity & Colmes at around 9:20 Eastern tonight to talk about the incident!
Update 5: Video of Seva's H&C appearance can be found here. BTW, for a good web site for keeping in step with the Russian-Jewish community in Boston, try Jewish Russian Telegraph.
Update 6: Part 2 of this story is HERE.
Did you enjoy this post? Please consider making a donation: Paypal Donate, Amazon Donate, Amazon Purchase.
Saturday, July 22, 2006
Brigitte Gabriel: 'my Lebanese citizenship will be revoked'
Not all was so "great" for Brigitte Gabriel after her stunning CNN appearance. Daily Scorecard quotes:
Many supporting letters from her fellow Lebanese follow.
US Supports Israel -- CAIR stomps feet
The US is expediting bomb re-supply to Israel, and the voice of Hamas and Hizballah in the United States, the Council on American-Islamic Relations, is seething:
Something you would never catch CAIR's friends doing: |
![]() |
"Israel continued to drop leaflets warning residents of southern Lebanon to leave their homes" (AP Photo) |
In a statement, CAIR Board Chairman Parvez Ahmed said:
"It is unconscionable that our government would rush weapons to a state engaged in vicious and indiscriminate attacks on the civilians and civilian infrastructure of a friendly nation. Thousands of our nation's citizens also remain in Lebanon facing death or injury from these American taxpayer-supplied weapons.
"The baffling decision to assist in the destruction of a nation that has been held up as a model of democratic reform can only serve to harm our long-term interests in the region. Aiding attacks on civilian targets in Lebanon also calls into question our nation's commitment to fighting terrorism in all its forms.
"America must disengage its Middle East policy from the self-serving dictates of the pro-Israel lobby. Failure to do so will allow Israel to once again drag our nation into its self-perpetuating cycle of hatred and conflict."
[Or else.]
Friday, July 21, 2006
Proportionality...how soon we forget.
Ben...Stein...excellent: Out of Disproportion
Was it disproportionate? Well, no. The Nazis had bombed our allies, the British, in terror raids for years. They had started a world war. They had created a genocide unspeakable in human history. So, yes, there was horrible killing, but is anyone now saying it was disproportionate? Maybe a few, but not many.
The Japanese bombed exactly zero U.S. cities except for a few stray bombs on Honolulu. We firebombed every city we could find and used the atom bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Was this disproportionate? No, because the Japanese had started a world war and caused unspeakable suffering through Asia and the Pacific. Bombing was what it took to end the war in both Europe and the Pacific.
Now, Israel is bombing Beirut. The Lebanese have been sheltering Hezbollah killers who have been rocketing and bombing Israel for ten years almost every day. The Lebanese have admitted the terrorists into dominant positions in their government. In every way, Lebanon has made itself a haven for terrorists bombing civilians day in and day out in Israel. Is Israel finally standing up and saying enough "disproportionate"? Yes, if you think Israel and Jews should be permanent victims who suffer, bleed, and die in silence the way the Nazis preferred. No, if you believe Jews have the same rights as other people to defend themselves...
[via Boker Tov, Boulder]
Keith Completes Training
Tom Glennon brings us the final installment of Nephew Keith's training experiences before shipping out to Afghanistan (previous entries): LETTERS FROM A SOLDIER #4
Keith, thanks for what you are doing, good luck, and give 'em hell.
Tom, thanks to you and the rest of Keith's family, too.
Defending Israel from the Left
Two very good entries at this Progressive blog, ZioNation:
First, Doni Remba, the President of the Chicago chapter of Peace Now has an in-depth look at the question of whether Israel is guilty of "war crimes" in the current conflict: Are Israel's Military Operations in Lebanon Proportional? Is Israel Guilty of War Crimes? - What International Law Really Says
The answer, which he gives full and deep examination to, is no:
Then there's this, about Ada Aharoni, a founder of "Four Mothers" -- a movement to get Israel out of Lebanon in the late '90's. She supports the current action (though opposes a ground invasion).
PJ Coverage
Well, in case you were wondering (probably not), my affiliation with PJ Media hasn't come with any strings attached (that I've felt). They don't send down directives from on high insisting we link certain things or take certain positions -- other than the (very) occasional "Hey, if you would consider linking this, that would be great..." to be ignored or not at my discretion...pretty much the same as when anyone else sends me such messages. Tonight was one of those nights, as Pajamas has sent out a press release congratulating themselves for their excellent coverage of the current Middle East situation and I'm happy to give it a pointer. Point. Their coverage really has been very good. The fact is, if you're only watching TV or reading the paper, you're not even getting half of the story. PJM and the rest of the blogosphere has really given this situation a play that was impossible to come by previously.
Props to Bill Maher
I figured I was never going to link either Bill Maher (annoying), or the Huffington Post (they spam me), but here goes. He deserves props for this post: I Love Being on the Side of My President (Sorry for the lenghty pull-quote, but I doubt the Huff-Po cares about the extra hits from little old me.)
But I digress. I really wanted to say that, for all those who accuse the likes of myself and the birthday girl of being unpatriotic, or hating America first, the feeling I've had watching Israel defend herself and a US president defend Israel (a country that is held to a standard for "restraint" that no other country ever is asked to meet, but that's another story) just reminds me how wrong that is. I LOVE being on the side of my president, and mouthing "You go, boy" when he gets it right. He just, outside of this, almost never does...
I know the feeling. I felt that way about GWB on September 11, although I never left.
[h/t: isirota1965]
Christians Making Sense
Speaking of Christians for Fair Witness on the Middle East, this just in from them as they apply a "Just War" standard: An Open Letter to American Churches Regarding the Escalating Conflict in the Middle East
Rev. Peter Pettit, Director of the Institute for Jewish Christian Understanding at Muhlenberg College says, "In light of the amount of collateral damage, especially in Lebanon, Christians will understandably raise questions regarding proportionate response. This is not fundamentally anti-Israel, but grows out of the 'just war' tradition. Legitimate military objectives must be pursued with every effort to limit collateral damage and cannot include actions that in any way amount to collective punishment."
"Coming to a reasoned conclusion to this question requires an understanding of the history and nature of Hezbollah," says Sr. Ruth Lautt, National Director of Fair Witness.
"Hezbollah, which operates with Syrian and especially Iranian backing, supports the destruction of the state of Israel and co- operates with other militant Islamic organizations such as Hamas in order to promote this goal," says Sr. Lautt. "It has been designated as a terrorist organization by the United States, the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia and the European Parliament, and has repeatedly taken credit for attacks against Israeli military and civilian targets. Hezbollah also presents a serious threat to legitimate Christian interests in Lebanon."...
..."A distinction must be made as to how the different armies are dealing with civilian populations. There has not been a single report of damage done to an Israeli army base, airport, power station, bus station, refinery or factory. With two exceptions, every Hezbollah rocket has been aimed at civilian targets. On the other hand, while Hezbollah operates from civilian areas, making it impossible to avoid civilians entirely, Israel has specifically targeted legitimate military objectives, and has leafleted areas prior to bombing, warning civilians to get out of harm's way."
All of these "on the ground" realities must be considered in determining a proportionate and morally acceptable response by both the Lebanese government and Israel to Hezbollah at this time...
While we're on this track, don't miss this description of the "Night to Honor Israel," sponsored by Christians United for Israel: What a ‘Night to Honor Israel:’ The CUFI Washington Summit Dinner in DC
By the way, for much of the story behind some of the characters of CUFI -- a roll-call that contains some names that tend to send many American Jews into an irrational tizzy -- I highly recommend the book Standing with Israel: Why Christians Support the Jewish State by David Brog.
The Bishop with bad timing...and bedfellows
More on Episcopal Bishop Thomas M. Shaw -- and the people working within the church to challenge what he represents -- today in the NY Sun: A Bishop's Voice
Bishop Shaw previously made news on the international front less than one month after the September 11th terrorist attacks, when he last caused a furor here by protesting in front of the Israel's consulate. Since then, he has come out against the move to get the Episcopal Church to divest itself from companies doing business with Israel – a position praised by the local Jewish community – shuttled himself back and forth to Israel and the West Bank more than a half dozen times, and attempted, to an extent, to stay out of the headlines.
Until last week. In a case of what may be extraordinarily bad timing, Bishop Shaw chose Wednesday afternoon as the moment to publicly protest Israel's strike on Gaza in the wake of the Hamas kidnapping of Corporal Gilad Shalit. That was after hostilities with Gaza had begun but before Hezbollah's Katyushah rockets began raining down on Israel's North...
And in the other corner, Christians for Fair Witness on the Middle East:
"They were considering bad resolutions," says Dennis Hale, a Medford, Mass.-based Episcopalian who traveled to Columbus with Sister Lautt's group. "We testified against these resolutions, and they were amended."
Even so, Sister Lautt and Mr. Hale, an associate professor in political science at Boston College tell a disturbing story of their treatment while manning a booth for the group at the convention's exhibition hall."We were at first treated like pariahs," says Hale, who began to reconsider his Episcopalian affiliation given the negative reception he received.
Yet along with the criticism and sharp words came quiet expressions of support, and Hale's moment of spiritual doubt passed. Now Mr. Hale and Sister Lautt believe they can reach the middle of the moderate churches, if they can just get their message out...
HTH.
Update: In the extended entry below you will find an op-ed by Dexter Van Zile, first published in the LA Jewish Observer, that describes the incident alluded to in the story above. Amazing...
Continue reading "The Bishop with bad timing...and bedfellows"Judge rules Islamic Society suit can proceed
Another half-step on the way to court in Boston: Judge rules Islamic Society suit can proceed
The suit alleges that the Boston Herald, Fox25, The David Project, Citizens for Peace and Tolerance, and others orchestrated a media campaign to stop the Islamic Society's attempts to build a mosque in Roxbury. The suit alleges that stories in the Boston Herald and on Fox Television in 2004, which asserted links between society officials and terrorist groups, were aimed at halting the project.
The nonmedia defendants, who have continually denied those assertions, argued the suit should be dismissed under a 1994 statute designed to protect private citizens who bring suits against developers.
Judge Janet L. Sanders ruled that the statute does not apply to the defendants in the defamation lawsuit. The ruling is a major victory, said Howard Cooper, attorney for the Islamic Society.
``For many months since my clients simply sought to file a lawsuit and redress their rights in court, all we heard was that we were attempting to intimidate people and we would end up having to pay hundreds of thousands of dollars in attorneys' fees," he said. ``The court has now rejected the defendants' arguments in their entirety and ruled that the ISB filed its lawsuit appropriately."
Jeff Robbins , attorney for some of the nonmedia defendants, said the denial of his request to dismiss the case was not a setback. He said he will appeal the judge's decision, but that if the case proceeds, his clients will welcome the opportunity to call the Islamic Society of Boston to answer their allegations in court...
Here is the Boston Herald's (one of the defendants in the suit) story: Judge permits defamation suit: Hub Islamic Society can proceed vs. media
Supporting Israel in Sharon, Mass! (Updated)
Here are some pics of a Support Israel rally in the town of Sharon, Massachusetts this past Wednesday the 19th. I wasn't there, so if anyone who was would like to tell us about it, have at the comments. Oh, there's a guy on stilts! (Click the thumbnails for larger versions.)
[Update: I've been informed the name of the event was: "South Area Israel Action Team & Friends -- Standing for Israel in Sharon"
From the Sharon Advocate:
The grassroots South Area Israel Action Team (SAIAT), organized the event which was originally intended to be a smaller vigil. Remarked the groups co-founder Andrew Warren: "We were really not expecting this kind of turnout. We came prepared with placards and tributes to all the Israeli (Jewish & Arab) victims of the Hezbollah and Hamas missles, but people really wanted to be much more vocal." Warren later indicated: "I think part of the motivation is the sense that most major media outlets are not telling the full story. We don't here anything about the devastation of Israeli's northern towns and their victims. Over a half-million (500,000) people have had to flee their homes and another half-million (500,000) are in bomb shelters. Since Israel left southern Lebanon (it’s buffer zone) in 2000, the U.N. has turned a blind-eye to the Hizbollah build up of 13,000 rockets and past firings on northern Israeli communities. People feel the Hizbollah attack and kidnapping of two Israel Defense Force (IDF) soldiers, from the Israeli side of the border (UN acknowledged), was the last straw. We are are now seeing the unfortunate results for the whole region ultimately from Hizbollah's utter rejection of the Jewish State." -- Shirley Miller Stein
All hail...
...the woodpecker:
Oh my.
Photos from Haifa
Nicely done Powerpoint presentation at Paula Says.
Demonstrating for Peace in Madrid
Fausta has pics and a video of a lone pro-Israel demonstrator being hounded off the streets of Madrid.
And of course there's this:

From an (admittedly pretty poorly written and presented) article at YNet: In Spain, anti-Semitism is new leftist trend
By the moment the Benarroch couple had left the table to express their regrets, Zapatero was explaining his lack of surprise about the Holocaust: according to the people present, Zapatero claimed to understand the Nazis...
Can that be true? David Bernstein at Volokh also has a link to this story, with a brief accusation of anti-semitism from the opposition.
War Fair
Michael Walzer on the ethics of battle:
The most important Israeli goal in both the north and the south is to prevent rocket attacks on its civilian population, and, here, its response clearly meets the requirements of necessity. The first purpose of any state is to defend the lives of its citizens; no state can tolerate random rocket attacks on its cities and towns. Some 700 rockets have been fired from northern Gaza since the Israeli withdrawal a year ago--imagine the U.S. response if a similar number were fired at Buffalo and Detroit from some Canadian no-man's-land. It doesn't matter that, so far, the Gazan rockets have done minimal damage; the intention every time one is fired is to hit a home or a school, and, sooner or later, that intention will be realized. Israel has waited a long time for the Palestinian Authority and the Lebanese government to deal with the rocket fire from Gaza and the rocket build-up on the Lebanese border. In the latter case, it has also waited for the United Nations, which has a force in southern Lebanon that is mandated to "restore international peace and security" but has nonetheless watched the positioning of thousands of rockets and has done nothing. A couple of years ago, the Security Council passed a resolution calling for the disarming of Hezbollah; its troops, presumably, have noticed that this didn't happen. Now Israel has rightly decided that it has no choice except to take out the rockets itself. But, again, how can it do that?...
...When Palestinian militants launch rocket attacks from civilian areas, they are themselves responsible--and no one else is--for the civilian deaths caused by Israeli counterfire. But (the dialectical argument continues) Israeli soldiers are required to aim as precisely as they can at the militants, to take risks in order to do that, and to call off counterattacks that would kill large numbers of civilians. That last requirement means that, sometimes, the Palestinian use of civilian shields, though it is a cruel and immoral way of fighting, is also an effective way of fighting. It works, because it is both morally right and politically intelligent for the Israelis to minimize--and to be seen trying to minimize--civilian casualties. Still, minimizing does not mean avoiding entirely: Civilians will suffer so long as no one on the Palestinian side (or the Lebanese side) takes action to stop rocket attacks. From that side, though not from the Israeli side, what needs to be done could probably be done without harm to civilians...
Anti-Zionism/Anti-Semitism
Diana Muir with an academic link:
Kaplan and Small ask whether individuals expressing strong anti-Israel sentiments, such as the statement by Ted Honderich, Emeritus Grote Professor of the Philosophy of Mind and Logic at University College London, that “those Palestinians who have resorted to necessary killing have been right to try to free their people, and those who have killed themselves in the cause of their people have indeed sanctified themselves,” are more likely than the general population to also support in such old-style anti-Semitic slurs as “Jews have too much power in our country today.”
The correlation was almost perfect. In a survey of 5,000 Europeans in ten countries, people who believed that the Israeli soldiers “intentionally target Palestinian civilians,” and that “Palestinian suicide bombers who target Israeli civilians” are justified, also believed that “Jews don’t care what happens to anyone but their own kind,” “Jews have a lot of irritating faults,” and “Jews are more willing than others to use shady practices to get what they want.”
The study’s other interesting finding was that only a small fraction of Europeans believe any of these things. Anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism flourish among the few, but those few are over-represented in Europe’s newspapers, its universities, and its left-wing political parties.
For Americans who do not read the European press, the level of raw anti-Semitism in European intellectual circles can be shocking...
Note commenter Bradley Smith who laments his burden in having to deal with the accusation of anti-semitism ever since he "stopped believing in the first great WMD fraud, the German gas chamber story." Ever since then it's "been just one thing after another..."
Well, I'd imagine it would be.
Unwilling Martyrs
Over a century ago, a man named Karl Lueger was elected (repeatedly) as Mayor of Vienna on an anti-Semitic platform. Not incapable of showing kindness to individual Jews, he responded to criticism by remarking, "I deicde who's a Jew."
That's what sprang to mind when I read this story of Hassan Nasrallah deciding that the Israeli Arab kids killed by his missiles were now "martyrs."
Nasrallah: Nazereth kids are martyrs
The Hizbullah leader offered his condolences to the family of the two brothers in an interview with Al-Jazeera television...
The family must feel so much better.
[h/t: David Boxenhorn who remarks: "Hizballah proves that it is racist, not just nationalist."]
Thursday, July 20, 2006
Wiesenthal Center responds to UCC's John Thomas
The Simon Wiesenthal Center has issued a "stunning rebuke" to United Church of Christ President John Thomas (see: John Thomas of United Church of Christ Hits Bottom, Digs). Must read. UCCTruths has the letter from the Wiesenthal Center to Thomas [emphasis mine]:
We appreciate the clarity of your “Pastoral Letter to Palestinian Friends and Partners.” You have made the sides abundantly clear. On one side are Israel, the United States, the G8, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Jordan, Kuwait, and the United Arab Emirates. All of these faulted the unprovoked murderous cross-border attacks and kidnappings by Hezbollah that have led to suffering of the citizens of both Israel and Lebanon. On the other side are Hamas, Hezbollah, Iran, Syria, the UCC and John Thomas, who see things differently. We also understand why your remarks during this week of death and misery addresses only the suffering of your Palestinian friends. History teaches that silence is admittance and your silence over innocent Jewish victims speaks volumes...
And this...
At least you are honest. You used to rail about the pressure from the “pro-Israel lobby.” You’ve dropped the code language. It’s Jews you’re talking about, as you admit in your current letter. Your irritation is puzzling, though. You have done a near perfect job keeping those pesky Jews from your offices, and from your convention floor when resolutions about the fate of Israelis came up. If we didn’t know better, we would think you simply don’t like outside interference and pressure. But you have no problem with the pressure from organizations like Sabeel and Al-Awda, both of whom reject the legitimacy of a Jewish state, and both of whom have either partnered with the UCC, or have been listed as a resource. And you don’t mind twisting a few arms yourself, do you? Remember the infamous “midnight meeting” at your General Synod in 2005, when you didn’t like the committee recommendation to the floor, so you substituted your own language, without anyone realizing it and had delegates adopt a resolution different from what they thought they were approving?...
Read it all. It's pretty vitriolic isn't it? Well, there's a war on, and the players aren't an abstract, they're a known quantity each with a history and clear goals. Hizballah and Hamas's genocidal goals and inhuman methods are well on the record. Criticism is possible while standing with friends, on the right side of the line -- but when it came time to speak clearly and show where he stood, John Thomas made the location of his feet quite clear, if couched with a pious tongue.
And in Norway...
WIESENTHAL CENTER PROTESTS USE OF NAZI IMAGERY IN ANTI-ISRAEL CARTOON PUBLISHED IN NORWEGIAN PAPER
In a letter to Kurt Vollebaek, Norway’s Ambassador to the United States, Rabbi Abraham Cooper, associate dean of the Wiesenthal Center, acknowledged Norway’s right to free speech, but called on their government to publicly denounce this “antisemitic attack that manages simultaneously to denigrate the victims of the Nazi Holocaust and incite hatred against Israel and her supporters in your country.”
Rabbi Cooper also protested the timing of the cartoon’s publication citing that “hundreds of Israelis have been killed and injured by unprovoked cross-border attacks by terrorist organizations.”
Cooper expressed hope that in light of this controversy, the Norwegian government will support UN Security Council Resolution 1559 which would end the “Hezbollah threat that has wreaked such suffering on innocents on both sides of the Israeli/Lebanese border.”...
Another Cartoon from Moderate Qatar
Ah yes, the hook-nosed Jew, drinking the blood of the gentiles...where else but in a paper published in that paragon of moderation, Qatar? Perhaps this fellow could get a gig with the Guardian...
From the ADL. Previous cartoons from Al-Watan here, here and here.
George Bush not enough of a cowboy
So says Max Boot: Let Israel Take Off the Gloves
It's hard to know what accounts for this Israeli restraint, for which, of course, it gets no thanks. It may just be a matter of time before the gloves come off. Or Olmert may be afraid of upsetting the regional status quo. The American neocon agenda of regime change is not one that finds favor with most Israelis (ironic, considering how often the rest of the world has denounced neocons as Mossad agents). The Israeli attitude toward neighboring dictators is "better the devil you know." That may make sense with Jordan and Egypt, which have made peace with Israel, but not with Syria, which serves as a vital conduit between Tehran and Hamas and Hezbollah.
Iran may be too far away for much Israeli retaliation beyond a single strike on its nuclear weapons complex. (Now wouldn't be a bad time.) But Syria is weak and next door. To secure its borders, Israel needs to hit the Assad regime. Hard. If it does, it will be doing Washington's dirty work. Our best response is exactly what Bush has done so far — reject premature calls for a cease-fire and let Israel finish the job.
Of course, Israel does get credit for the way it conducts itself, and should never forget it, though it may feel good in the short run to truly "take the gloves off," in the long run it would be a mistake. Hit hard, but hit righteously.
Dershowitz: Arithmetic of Pain
Alan Dershowitz makes the simple observation that international law is simply behind the time (if it was ever with them): Arithmetic of Pain
While Israel does everything reasonable to minimize civilian casualties — not always with success — Hezbollah and Hamas want to maximize civilian casualties on both sides. Islamic terrorists, a diplomat commented years ago, "have mastered the harsh arithmetic of pain. . . . Palestinian casualties play in their favor and Israeli casualties play in their favor." These are groups that send children to die as suicide bombers, sometimes without the child knowing that he is being sacrificed. Two years ago, an 11-year-old was paid to take a parcel through Israeli security. Unbeknownst to him, it contained a bomb that was to be detonated remotely. (Fortunately the plot was foiled.)
This misuse of civilians as shields and swords requires a reassessment of the laws of war. The distinction between combatants and civilians — easy when combatants were uniformed members of armies that fought on battlefields distant from civilian centers — is more difficult in the present context. Now, there is a continuum of "civilianality": Near the most civilian end of this continuum are the pure innocents — babies, hostages and others completely uninvolved; at the more combatant end are civilians who willingly harbor terrorists, provide material resources and serve as human shields; in the middle are those who support the terrorists politically, or spiritually...
Worth emphasizing: "This chorus of condemnation actually encourages the terrorists to operate from civilian areas." One thing that I have found recently (OK, not even so recently) is that the term "war crime" can be applied as a term of art to almost any activity that even inconveniences a civilian population. I would submit that this devalues and causes contempt for the term, thus weakening it.
Here is a Human Rights Watch FAQ on the current conflict. If one were to edit out HRW's own possibly tendentious conclusions and stick to the principles laid out, instead using your own judgement to measure things up, Israel's actions seem to stand it in good stead. But when one reads something like this...
"...it is illegal under international humanitarian law, as noted below, to use military force to squeeze the civilian population, to enhance its suffering, or to undermine its morale, regardless of the ultimate purpose..."
...one realizes just how much of a term of art these things become, and how easily twistable they are. You can't even "undermine its morale"? That's an awfully broad canopy -- especially in a day and age where civilian populations are actually electing terrorists, and terrorists are existing among civilian populations. Surely there must be some price to pay.
A Letter from Israel
Miss Kelley posts a letter from a friend: E-mail from Haifa, Israel / "Our Heads Are Up"
Project Runway, Season 3, Episode 2
Due to the success and interest expressed in my previous Project Runway post (I'm quite serious), here is installment #2. I tried to post this last night after the episode aired, but the Project Runway site was getting hammered so I couldn't get in to get the links. So most of this was written right after the episode ended. Those looking for war and politics can move along...nothing to see here...
For the rest...
Continue reading "Project Runway, Season 3, Episode 2"Leading Saudi Sheik Pronounces Fatwa Against Hezbollah
Surprising but true, and reflective of the divisions below the surface of the Arab/Muslim World that belie the posing for the cameras.
NY Sun: Leading Saudi Sheik Pronounces Fatwa Against Hezbollah
The day after Hezbollah abducted two Israeli soldiers on July 12, Sheik Hamid al-Ali issued an informal statement titled "The Sharia position on what is going on." In it, the Kuwaiti based cleric condemned the imperial ambitions of Iran regarding Hezbollah's cross border raid.
The surprising move demonstrates that Sunni Muslim fundamentalists in the Middle East are deeply divided over whether Moslems should support Hezbollah, Iran's Shiite proxies in the war raging in Lebanon.
While the Gulf's ascetic Wahhabi sects, who are closer to the ethnic fighting between Sunnis and Shiites in Iraq, have opposed Hezbollah in its stand against Israel's forces, other Sunni fundamentalist groups, such as the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood, have pledged their solidarity. On Friday, the brothers will host a rally in support of Hezbollah at Cairo's most influential mosque, Al-Azhar.
The profound division between the most violent Muslim enemies of America and Israel may be one reason Arab capitals have not yet exploded in rage about Israel's bombardment of Lebanon. The White House has already pointed to Jordanian, Egyptian, and Saudi government condemnation of Hezbollah.
The latest Arab Israeli war presents a conundrum for many Sunni Jihadists. On the one hand, a chance to join in the resistance against the Jewish state presents a rare opportunity for zealots who revere the Palestinian Arab martyrs that have sacrificed their lives to kill Jewish civilians. But the main group doing the fighting, and instigating the war this time in Lebanon, are supported by the same Shiite state that supplies and funds the militias killing Sunni civilians in Iraq...
That sort of logic has rarely resonated before, or the US would be recognized as the savior of Muslims it has often acted as, but it's good to see it works on occasion. [h/t: Jerusalem Posts]
Wednesday, July 19, 2006
Gratuitous Military Pic of the Day
Images for the British Public
DIGG and del.icio.us
Well, everyone else is doing it, so it must be right. I've added DIGG and del.icio.us links to each entry so you may now, if you choose, submit them to those services. They are both ways of sharing links with others [and, in the case of del.icio.us, with yourself between computers]...and ways of driving traffic this way. We'll see if it has any effect.
Finish the Job This Time
Oceanguy remembers his time with the Navy off the coast of Lebanon in the early 80's. Must read. It's time to finish the job.
Mimi 4 Governor
Not that I know anything about her mind you, nor am I familiar with her body of work...not the whole body...nevermind...but the name Mimi Miyagi...did ring a bell (guys talk, you hear things...). The former porn star is running for Governor of Nevada and John Hawkins of Right Wing News has "scored" an interview.
Mimi Miyagi: I am an avid supporter of bearing arms since 2001....I love the people in the (Republican Party). I have been to some of the Democratic parties here and there, but the positivity, the upbeat attitude of the Republicans was more for me.
John Hawkins: So, you kind of thought the Democrats were pessimistic and negative?
Mimi Miyagi: ...I don't like all the mudslinging and a lot of the things they say about the Republicans really (aren't) true. The Republican Party is about individualism, it's about freedom, it's about lowering taxes. That is something I truly believe in...
Brigitte Gabriel on CNN
How great is it to see Brigitte Gabriel on CNN? Great.
Some pro-Israel rally pics and a podcast
There are pictures of an impressive pro-Israel rally in Australia, here.
There are a couple of pictures of a pro-Israel rally in Italy, here.
Roger Simon interviews the seventeen-year-old blogger from Live from an Israeli bunker, here.
The war of images
Judy has the back story on some inflamatory images currently making the rounds.
How Soon We Forget
Frequent guest-blogger and father with a son and a nephew on active duty comments on the current situation:
If we, as Americans, had any sense of loyalty to our own dead and crippled, we would be cheering Israel for taking this long overdue action, while offering any assistance they may request...
More.
John Thomas of United Church of Christ Hits Bottom, Digs
Not everyone is supporting Israel. UCCTruths reports on a Pastoral Letter sent out by UCC President John Thomas: UCC President John Thomas hits new low. From the letter [no permalink but that link should last as long as the post is on the front page -- thanks James]:
Making this situation even more burdensome is the recognition that there are many in the United States, including many Christians, who see only Israel's need for security, who focus only on a few terrorist acts which you yourselves condemn. In doing so, they largely ignore the systemic oppression of an entire people in what increasingly amounts to a virtual prison in which almost every aspect of Palestinian life is controlled by Israel. Many in our own churches are subject to intense lobbying by Jewish groups demonizing the Palestinian community in general, and many of you in particular. Even some of our denominational gatherings of ecumenical partners here in the United States sound what may seem to you to be an uncertain voice.
In the face of such suffering and the temptation for despair, I write to assure you of the prayers and solidarity of the United Church of Christ. I am grateful that this is being signified personally by Peter Makari's presence in the region this summer, accompanied by several of my colleagues...
Peter Makari is one of the central figures behind the divestment movement.
It's quite amazing that even now, with bombs exploding in Israel and open war with Hizballah and Hamas, Thomas is still obsessing over the security fence. Yikes. "Every aspect of Palestinian life controlled by Israel" indeed. You'd never know that Palestinians were once again given a chance to show they could build something for themselves by a complete Israeli pull-out from Gaza. Complete. Instead those former Jewish homes were turned into rocket launching pads.
...It is sincerely sad to see the leader of our denomination implode in such an irrational and public way. We can only feel sorry for him.
At least the Presbyterian Church(USA) is only issuing fairly boiler-plate condemnations of "disproportionality" -- a yawner by this point. John Thomas's letter is a more singular document.
Update: I'd like to hear John Thomas's take on this: Rockets kill 2 children, aged 8 and 3, in Nazareth. I'm sure he's against it, of course. Perhaps he'll write a letter.
Tuesday, July 18, 2006
Rally for Israel -- Brookline, Mass.
This afternoon I attended the Rally to Support Israel in Brookline, Massachusetts, just outside Boston. It was an urban setting with plenty of sun and temperatures in the 90's. Sweat abounded.
What a great event. The attendance was measurable in the thousands, no question. Folks were stacked up and down the block and on both sides of the street. It was a sea of blue, white and red.
The messages were not hateful, and the speakers routinely expressed regret for violence and sympathy for innocent victims on all sides while asserting Israel's obligation to self-defense in the face of attack and terror. It was a diverse ideological crowd to judge from some of the faces I reognized, but all came together to support Israel. Although it may look a little "elderly" from the pictures around me, it was a very mixed-age gathering. I was sort of in the center of the crowd so I may have missed them somewhere out on the periphery, but the "usual suspects" -- the hateful pro-terror crowd -- were absent. There were only a small handful (less than a handful, acutally) of clueless youths in opposition.
Mayor Menino couldn't attend due to travel obligations, but he sent his support, and there was also a very strong letter of support for Israel and her actions read to the crowd signed by the Massachusetts Congressional Delegation -- including, it must be stated, Senators Kerry and Kennedy. If I can come up with the text I will post it.
Here are some photos (click thumbs for full-sized versions) and some video.
First, here's some video of something you won't see at any of the anti-Western (International ANSWER-sponsored) rallies. The crowd sings the Star Spangled Banner and HaTikva (starts late because it got going before I had the video ready).
Let me introduce you to Reverend Hurmon Hamilton, Presbyterian Minister from Roxbury. Some may remember him as a man who fought divestment within his denomination. Here's his great speech:
Here's Peter Meade, formerly of Catholic Charities and current ADL Board Member:
The podium:
Continue reading "Rally for Israel -- Brookline, Mass."Support Israel Rallies
Lots more in the comments to this post. I can't keep up.
Update: Here's a report with pics from Chicago.
And oh, OK, here's a list from Stand With Us:
TUESDAY, JULY 18
BOSTON, MA
Date: Tuesday, July 18
Time: 6pm
Venue: Kehillath Israel, 384 Harvard Street, Brookline
Phone: 617-457-8657
http://www.bostonisraelaction.org
WEDNESDAY, JULY 19
Brooklyn NY
Date: Wednesday July 19th
Time: 8:30 p.m.
Venue: Manhattan Beach Jewish Center, 60 West End Ave, Brooklyn NY
Contact: 718-891-8700
DETROIT, MI
Date: Wednesday, July 19
Time: 7:00 p.m.
Venue: Congregation Shaarey Zedek, Eleven Mile Road west of Lahser Road, Southfield
Contact: 248-642-4260 - Rebecca Starr (ext. 531) or Dale Rubin (ext. 208)
GAINESVILLE, FL
Time: 11:00am - 2:00pm, Wednesday July 19
Venue: Turlington Plaza
Phone: 352.514.7744
Email: amgatorschai@yahoo.com
LOS ANGELES:
Wednesday, July 19, 4-6 pm
Join StandWithUs, American Jewish Congress and others as we Counter Protest the A.N.S.W.E.R Anti-Israel Demonstration Israeli Consulate: 6380 Wilshire Blvd, LA Come with signs that say: Free Lebanon from Hezbollah or get ideas from our website at:
http://www.standwithus.com/ click on SIGNS at the top of the home page We are continually adding new signs Bring American and Israeli Flags
PLANTATION, FL
Rally at Ramat Shalom in Plantation on Wednesday, July 19, 2006 at 7:00 PM.
Co-sponsored by ADL and the United Jewish Community of Broward County and the Broward Board of Rabbis (additional participants to be announced).
WASHINGTON DC
12 Noon, Wednesday, July 19
Rally at Freedom Plaza
Pennsylvania Avenue NW between 13 and 14th Street Metro - Metro Center Co-sponsored by JCRC and Jewish Federation of Greater Washington DC For more info, email jweingrad@jcouncil.org
THURSDAY, JULY 20
RALLY in CHERRY HILL, NJ
Date: Thursday, July 20
Time: TBD
Venue: TBD
Contact: JCRC of South NJ - 856-751-9500 x202 (Robin)
PHILADELPHIA
7:30 PM, Thursday July 20
Congregations of Shaare Shamayim
9768 Verree Road, Philadelphia, PA 19115 Sponsored by Congregations of Shaare Shamayim, Bnai Brith, Zionist Organization of America Greater Philadelphia District, PhillyIsraelim
FRIDAY, JULY 21
ARLINGTON TEXAS
7:30pm Friday, July 21
Congregation Beth Shalom
1211 Thannisch Drive
Arlington, Texas
For more information, contact Janet Aaronson, executive director at
817-860-5448
or janetaa@bethshalom.org
SUNDAY, JULY 23
LOS ANGELES, CA
Date: Sunday, July 23
Time: 4:00 pm
Venue:in front of the Federation Building, 6505 Wilshire Blvd.
MONDAY, JULY 24
PHILADELPHIA, PA
Date: Monday July 24
Time: 12-2pm
Venue: Ritten House Square (by 18th & Chestnut)
Contact: 215-832-0549 (Asaf)
TUESDAY JULY 25
BALTIMORE, MD
Date: July, 25
Time: 12PM
Venue: Holocaust Memorial, 500 East Lombard
Contact: THE ASSOCIATED and The Baltimore Jewish Council
Richard Cohen says Israel is an honest mistake...
Able reaction and round-up at Yourish, and Soccer Dad. Worthwhile smack-downs at Kesher Talk and Captain's Quarters. Much more using the Washington Post's own Technorati feature.
Words for the day: 'Indiscriminate' and 'Ethnic Cleansing'
Presented by Juan Cole. Reacted to by TigerHawk and Jeff Goldstein.
Monday, July 17, 2006
'They view us as if we were a headache. We view them as if they are a cancer...'
"...And this is why there will never really be any peace in the middle-east."
Olmert's Address to the Knesset
He lays out the goals quite clearly (important!):
- A complete cease fire.
- Deployment of the Lebanese army in all of Southern Lebanon.
-Expulsion of Hizballah from the area, and fulfillment of United Nations Resolution 1559.
We will not suspend our actions.
Pro-Israel Event in New York
Pamela has an excellent report with video, here.
Here is a link to the New York Times story on the same event, but don't bother clicking there, I will tell you what it says:
"Hillary Clinton rocks for Israel! Hillary is awesome. She's great and she supports Israel. New Yorkers, Hillary is significant and important and is strong against "terror" and for Israel. OMGOMG! Some other people may have been there, too."
If you're in the Boston area, remember that there is a rally in Brookline tomorrow.
Thanks, and New Contacts
First a big thank you to those who have hit the tip jar recently. You know who you are. Every bit is appreciated (even the person who sent me $1, from which I cleared a big $.67). Contributions are anonymous unless you tell me. Also, don't forget that cash isn't necessary. If you make your Amazon purchases by using that little Amazon Purchase link on the right, I get a small percentage and it doesn't cost you anything extra. Why let "the man" get all your cash?
Email is still the best way to make contact, send pointers, etc...but I have added identities on MSM and AIM. MSM is the same as my email: solomon =at= solomonia =dot= com and my AIM handle is SolomoniaBlog. I think most people use one of those two, no?
Also, I'm experimenting with setting up a chat room. I was trying to set up an IRC channel, but the trouble is that unless I can run a bot to hold the channel when I'm not there (which I can't do), there's not much point to it since I can't idle 24/7. (If that sounds like Greek to you, don't worry, IRC users will get it.)
I have set up a simple PHP-based chat room for the moment. You can join in by clicking here[never mind, it was fun, but not that useful]. Don't worry if you chat and I don't answer. I may just not be sitting at the computer.
Michael Oren: Why Israel Should Bomb Syria
Michael Oren in TNR: Why Israel Should Bomb Syria
But one Arab state did not want peace. Syria, then as now under the rule of the belligerent Baath Party, wanted war. Having tried and failed in 1964 to divert the Jordan River before it crossed the Israeli border--IDF jets and artillery blasted the dams--the Syrians began supporting a little-known Palestinian guerrilla group called Al Fatah under the leadership of Yasir Arafat. Using Lebanon as its principal base, Al Fatah commenced operations against Israel in 1965 and rapidly escalated its attacks. Finally, at the end of 1966, Israeli officials felt compelled to retaliate. But, fearing the repercussions of attacking Soviet-backed Syria, they decided to strike at an Al Fatah stronghold in the Jordanian-controlled West Bank...
And thus began a series of events that culminated in the '67 war. Oren's prescription for the current crisis? Punish Syria now, demonstrate that there's a price to be paid for supporting terror.
The answer lies in delivering an unequivocal blow to Syrian ground forces deployed near the Lebanese border. By eliminating 500 Syrian tanks--tanks that Syrian President Bashar Al Assad needs to preserve his regime--Israel could signal its refusal to return to the status quo in Lebanon. Supporting Hezbollah carries a prohibitive price, the action would say. Of course, Syria could respond with missile attacks against Israeli cities, but given the dilapidated state of Syria's army, the chances are greater that Assad will simply internalize the message. Presented with a choice between saving Hezbollah and staying alive, Syria's dictator will probably choose the latter. And the message of Israel's determination will also be received in Tehran...
I disagree that it's so sure that Assad will "internalize" the message. It's just as likely that absorbing a blow without at least a face-saving counter would in itself spell the end of the Assad regime. Isn't that how things work in the Middle East? That's not to say that it would be the wrong thing, or the right thing to do, but an attack on Syria would not be cost free.
[h/t: isirota1965]
Kuwaiti Journalist: 'The operations of Israel in Gaza and Lebanon are in the interest of people of Arab countries and the international community.'
Arab Times: No to Syria, Iran agents by Ahmed Al-Jarallah
...Without mentioning Hezbollah by name Saudi Arabia blamed certain “elements” inside Lebanon for the violence with Israel and said “it is necessary to make a distinction between legitimate resistance and uncalculated adventures adopted by certain elements within Lebanon without the knowledge of legal Lebanese authorities.” While reiterating its support for Palestinian and Lebanese resistance against Israeli occupation, Saudi Arabia has clearly said it is against irresponsible adventures undertaken by certain elements in the region without consulting the legal authorities putting all Arab nations at risk. The Kingdom has also said “these elements must take responsibility for their irresponsible actions and they alone should end the crisis created by them.”
This angry response from Saudi Arabia has politically isolated Hezbollah and Hamas besides holding them responsible for their actions...
One for the rumor bin...Israeli soldiers held in Iranian Embassy
The Lebanese Foundation for Peace (based in Jerusalem) is saying that the two kidnapped Israeli soldiers are being held in the Iranian embassy in Beirut.
They are secretly being held at the Embassy of Iran in Beirut, under direct Iranian security guards supervision.
You'll have to measure the reliability of that yourself. It's obviously plausible, as are a lot of possibilities.
The Grump on the Gumps
Spengler is doing an "I told you so..." in The Gumps of August. Reading Spengler can make you want to put a gun to your head. His world is one of only bad options. Always interesting, I'm not quite as impressed with Spengler as Spengler is impressed with Spengler. It seems to me that it doesn't take an Edgar Cayce to say that there are bad times ahead, and there's no way to test his thesis -- you can always say things are worse because of the choices not made...it's utterly untestable.
So here's a prediction: Bad times ahead, regardless of choices made. Bright future. Be strong, self-assured...just don't get cocky.

[h/t: mal]
Politics Central
Pajamas Media has opened their (still beta) Politics Central site. It's quite slick looking. As their first bit of content, they've got a podcast interview with Israeli Ambassador Daniel Ayalon. Listening now...
Sunday, July 16, 2006
The Greens have a Problem
Pity the Greens. Seems the Green-Rainbow Party of Massachusetts is in serious jeopardy of not getting any of their candidates on the state-wide ballot. This in an email from former Gubernatorial candidate Jill Stein:
The concern is we have only three and a half weeks (8 weekend days) left to collect signatures. Rain could easily cut petitioning days by 25-50%. A major commitment all around is needed if we are to securely qualify all four candidates for statewide office. The repercussions for the party will be very serious if we do not qualify. If we do not pull out all the stops starting now, we fear there is a real risk we will not...
...truth to tell, having our campaigns stop because we do not get on the ballot is a drop in the bucket compared to the incredible leap backwards - and loss of credibility - this would mean for the party and what we are fighting for!...
How sad...and pathetic. In fact they weren't even sure they could get a quorum for their own meeting. Jill Stein was actually at the podium in the debates with Mitt Romney and the others last time through. My how the almost noticeable have fallen.
Perhaps part of the problem is a GRP identity crisis as the group has been hijacked by a group of single-issue obsessives [hint: It's not the environment they're obsessed with] who have helped further marginalize a group with very little margin to spare (see previous: Greens, a High School Teacher and a City Councillor United in Hateful Protest, Talk, Walk, Rock for Israel -- Report with Pics, Green-Rainbow Party Suffers Backlash After anti-Israel Endorsement, One Note Greens in Michigan -- and Mass. Greens Lose Another One and Classroom Credit to Support Terrorism?)
Shame on Jill Stein for not speaking out. Unless, of course, she agrees with what's been going on...then shame on her twice.
Jokes the local moderates enjoy
Circulated earlier on the Muslim-American Society/Islamic Society of Boston moderated email list was this email purportedly from Howard Shultz of Starbucks, originally posted at the wildly anti-Semitic web-site, Ziopedia. The part that labels it a "parody" was snipped off. Even the commenters at the site recognize it as "fake but accurate" -- close enough for our local moderate Muslim groups.
Having the bigger picture in mind, Starbucks have donated a store to the US army to help in the “War on Terror”. I cannot emphasise enough, how vital the “War on Terror” is for the continued viability and prospering of the Jewish State...
Must Read Letter from a Marine
At Atlas Shrugs. A snip:
More reason that Walt & Mearsheimer are wrong.
Good for Condi
YNet: Rice rejects diplomatic solution for Hizbullah
Rice also said during the interview that this is not the time for it, and there is need to impose UN resolution 1559 that calls for disarming all the militias in southern Lebanon. (Yitzhak Benhorin, Washington)
Via the excellent coverage at PJM where there's a ton more stuff.
The Palestinian YMCA/YWCA
Have a look around this Palestinian YMCA/YWCA web site and remind yourself to make sure that any support you give to that organization is only used for domestic branches.
The Lobby Again
The Washington Post has a lengthy piece focusing on Walt/Mearsheimer, AIPAC and the "Israel Lobby": A Beautiful Friendship? In search of the truth about the Israel lobby's influence on Washington
While the folks at LGF are rather upset about it, aside from a somewhat fawning opening, I'm quite sure that this is not an article Walt & Mearsheimer would have written had they had the choice. On reading the whole thing, the picture that emerges is that a) the "Israel lobby" is powerful because its goals and the interests of the United States are congruent, and when they're not, the lobby is comensurately less powerful, b) it's pretty well like any other lobby in that regard, c) W&M are somewhat sloppy and not very convincing.
As to point A:
No need to go too deeply here. Americans understand that in the "clash of civilizations," Israel is our friend and the people who danced in the streets on 9/11 are our enemies. "Changing sides" would be a betrayal of our own values and principles. We know who our friends are.
From later in the piece:
Since 9/11, Americans have increasingly come to accept the idea that Israel and the United States share not just values but enemies. A Gallup Poll in February reported 68 percent of Americans have a favorable opinion of Israel with 23 percent unfavorable, and that Americans support Israelis over Palestinians by 59 percent to 15 percent.
Recent electoral victories by Islamic radicals in Iran and the Palestinian territories have only heightened the sense of us vs. them. With his sweeping condemnations and threats against the United States and Israel, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, Iran's radical new president, has quickly joined the pantheon of bad guys, alongside Osama bin Laden and Saddam Hussein. "Ahmadinejad is worth every penny," says Morris Amitay. "He says amazing things, and the scary part is he really means it."...
Criticism of Israel isn't enough to guarantee political death, but Americans don't like people they see as crossing over the line into actual anti-Semitism, like Paul Findlay and Pete McClosky:
Continue reading "The Lobby Again"9/11 Pentagon 3D Simulation
Don't miss this computer simulation of the 9/11 attack on the Pentagon. Very interesting. Some people will never accept it, of course.
All roads lead to Iran
Jeff Jacoby walks it back:
Four days later, Hezbollah terrorists staged a raid across Israel's northern border, kidnapping two Israeli soldiers and killing eight more. Over the next day, more than 120 rockets rained down across northern Israel. Among the communities struck was Haifa, Israel's third-largest city and home to its busiest port and a large oil refinery. It was the first time rockets fired from Lebanon had penetrated so far into Israel; Haifa was thought to be out of Hezbollah's range.
Israel replied to Hezbollah's artillery barrages and hostage-taking with a military invasion, much as it did in Gaza last month in response to incessant rocket fire and the Hamas kidnapping of Gilad Shalit. In short order, Israel's warplanes struck Beirut's international airport, Hezbollah's offices, and two Lebanese army bases; the Israeli navy put Lebanon under a blockade.
And so Israel finds itself at war again, this time on two fronts against two of the most lethal terrorist forces in the world. Except that the real enemy confronting it is not Hamas and Hezbollah. Terrorist organizations cannot function without state sponsorship, and no state anywhere sponsors more Islamist terrorism than Iran...
He's a cruel man, but fair...
First the Washington Post gave space to Hamas's Ismail Haniyeh in his own words, now it's Hizballah's Hasan Nasrallah in Robin Wright's: Inside the Mind of Hezbollah
The challenge for any piece that purports to display the point of view of a nefarious character is in trying to give a real and honest protrayal while not justifying and apologizing for a monster. It ought to be fairly uncomplicated on the op-ed page where opinions and viewpoints are encouraged, but I can't help but feel Wright fails. Utterly.
"We have ministers, we have members of parliament, we have municipal council members, leaders of unions and syndicates," he boasted as we sat on faux French brocade furniture at his now-bombed headquarters. "If we are maintaining our arms until now, this is due to the fact that the need for it is still there, due to the permanent or constant Israeli threats against Lebanon. Whether we keep on with the resistance or stop the resistance, we are effectively now a full-fledged political party."
The outskirts of Beirut are known as the dahiya , Arabic for "suburbs." It has come to mean the poor, dense and sometimes dangerous maze of slums that is also Hezbollah-land. Its dirty alleys are crammed with concrete-block shanties. Gnarled masses of wire run from one building to the next, illegally tapping into electrical, phone and television lines. While lights burn brightly in trendy downtown Beirut, the dahiya is often eerily dark because of sporadic electricity.
Hezbollah has become an enterprise in the dahiya, often outperforming the state. It runs a major hospital as well as schools, discount pharmacies, groceries and an orphanage. It runs a garbage service and a reconstruction program for homes damaged during Israel's invasion. It supports families of the young men it sent off to their deaths. Altogether, it benefits an estimated 250,000 Lebanese and is the country's second-largest employer.
In the dahiya, Nasrallah is an icon, famed for his oratory and revered as a champion of Lebanon's long-dispossessed Shiite minority...
Ah, social services from the champion of the poor. Bleh. Next time, maybe we can get some questions designed to provide insight on scenes like this:

Rockets Kill 8 in Haifa
This Washington Post article is actually pretty decent in laying the facts out, although the logic behind Israel's actions isn't really presented: Israel Batters Lebanese Seaports, Roads; Hezbollah Rockets Kill 8 in Haifa
A barrage of rockets pounded the northern Israeli city of Haifa in the worst strike on Israel since violence broke out along the border with Lebanon last week. One of the rockets hit a storage room at the train station, killing eight people, Israeli police said. Many more people were wounded.
Some of the rockets landed near an oil refinery and gas storage tanks. Rockets also hit the northern towns of Acco and Nahariya, and residents were told to head to bomb shelters...
Friday, July 14, 2006
Project Runway Season 3
And now for something completely different. This one's for isirota1965 who hates when I post on this.
Project Runway Season 3 launched on Wednesday night and it's looking to be another great (and aggravating) season. They selected a very interesting cast of characters with differing backgrounds and design takes. From the teasers for episode 2 (episode 1 was a two-hour intro), it looks like someone gets kicked out for doing something nasty. I can't wait.
The first challenge was for the contestants to go back to their appartments and rip the place to shreds using anything they could get their hands on to make a design from -- bed sheets, seat covers, shower curtains, chandeliers... The results were mostly amazing. The only one I didn't like at all was "rocker guy" Jeffrey's design which just looked like a mess to me (much better in that picture than it looked on the runway). It way too early to tell, but Jeffrey is the early candidate for least-likable. We'll see. (Wonder if he's the guy getting kicked out.)
Winning design was by Keith (pictured), who's only past experience is in men's wear -- a disadvantage on this show. He has immunity for the next challenge.
Be sure to read Tim Gunn's blog for a run-down on the performances of each of the contestants (Does Tim check his referrer logs like a mental patient as all newish bloggers do? Hi Tim!). Tim is the coolest dude on the show for sure, next to Michael Kors, of course.
Bonus for heterosexual males this season: the models are much better looking this time than on season 2.
Previous Project Runway posts.
Rallying for Israel (Updates)
In Boston:
In Chicago:
In New York:
Any others? Send them in and I'll update.
Update: Another in New York:
Update: In Los Angeles:
In Gainsville, FL:
In Denver:
Wasn't Napoleon the last guy to speak like this?
Or was it someone else? World lines up against ferocity of Israel attack
"One may well ask if there isn't today a kind of wish to destroy Lebanon -- its infrastructure, its roads, its communications, its energy, its airport. And for what?
"I find honestly -- as all Europeans do -- that the current reactions are totally disproportionate," he said in a live television interview on France's national Bastille Day...
Krauthammer: Why They Fight
Krauthammer's excellent. Charles Krauthammer: Why They Fight
Over the past six years, Hezbollah has launched periodic raids and rocket attacks into Israel. Israeli retaliation has led to the cessation of these provocations — until the next time convenient for Hezbollah. Wednesday was such a time. One terror base located in fully unoccupied Arab territory (South Lebanon) attacks Israel in support of another terror base in another fully unoccupied Arab territory (Gaza).
Why? Because occupation was a mere excuse to persuade gullible and historically ignorant Westerners to support the Arab cause against Israel. The issue is, and has always been, Israel's existence. That is what is at stake.
It was Yasser Arafat's Palestine Liberation Organization that convinced the world that the issue was occupation. Yet, through all those years of pretense, Arafat's own group celebrated its annual Fatah Day on the anniversary of its first attack on Israel, the bombing of Israel's National Water Carrier — on Jan. 1, 1965.
Note: 1965. Two years before the 1967 war. Two years before Gaza and the West Bank fell into Israeli hands. Two years before there were any "occupied territories."...
Judge widens review of city mosque deal
Bad news for the Boston Mosque project:
The Jewish Advocate: Judge widens review of city mosque deal by Ted Siefer
The case against the City of Boston and a Muslim group over a controversial mosque project in Roxbury could get stronger, after a judge admitted new documents raising questions about the city’s conduct in the deal.
“This is a significant step forward,” said Evan Slavitt, the lawyer representing James Policastro, the Mission Hill resident who originally filed a lawsuit against the city and the Islamic Society of Boston in October 2004. The suit charges that the city’s sale of public land at a significant discount for the construction of a mosque in exchange for a package of benefits, including an Islamic lecture series, violated the separation of church and state...
...In issuing her decision late last month, Judge Regina Quinlan rejected the Boston Redevelopment Authority’s claim that only materials it submitted as part of an administrative record of the deal could be reviewed. Policastro’s claims, the judge wrote, were of “constitutional dimension” and other documents that have recently come to light could be used to support the case.
Among the documents the BRA did not include in its administrative record was an opinion from the BRA’s legal counsel in the early stages of the project warning that discounting the sale price of the land for a religious group could pose constitutional problems. An Ethics Commission opinion also noted that the close involvement of a Muslim BRA official, Muhammad Ali Salaam, could create the appearance that decisions were “unduly influenced by personal loyalties.”
Other documents indicate that Ali Salaam was intimately involved in many aspects of the deal, traveling to the Middle East on a fund-raising trip with ISB officials and writing letters on behalf of the ISB on BRA stationary.
Slavitt said that he now plans to file a motion that would compel BRA and ISB officials to provide testimony. So far they have refused to comply.
Citing the litigation, BRA officials also refused to participate in a public hearing on the deal called by a Boston city councilor in May.
Slavitt said that it’s too early to say what the outcome of the lawsuit will be but, he said, it could ultimately invalidate the transaction, meaning that the ISB would “have to tear down the establishment.”...
Ouch.
What humanitarian crisis?
Via email from the IDF, dated yesterday:
Over 30 containers and 140 trucks containing:
- 1080 tons of various grains
- 800 tons of sugar
- 140 tons of dairy products
- 520 tons of flour
- 420 tons of fruit
- 169 tons of oil
- 120 tons of salt
- 160 tons of rice
- 40 tons of eggs
- 100 tons of meat and fish products
- 7 trucks containing medicines and medical equipment
- several heavy duty generators
- 25,000 liters of chloride
- 350,000 liters of diesel
- 50,000 liters of petrol
- 100 tons of cooking gas
It is important to note that the water and electricity supply from Israel to the Gaza Strip remains uninterrupted.
What other country would allow this into a hostile population without a way to assure it wouldn't be used by combatants?
Thursday, July 13, 2006
Self-Restraint is Fatal
Great post at Seraphic Secret. A snip:
On June 29, 1938 Ben Yosef was hanged on the gallows by the British authorities. His last words in a conversation with friends were, "Havlagah" (self-restraint) is fatal."...
Proportionality and Retribution
Yossi Klein Halevi makes some good points here, at TNR: Battle Plans
The goals of the war should be the destruction of the Hamas regime and the dismantling of the Hezbollah infrastructure in southern Lebanon. Israel cannot coexist with Iranian proxies pressing in on its borders. In particular, allowing Hamas to remain in power--and to run the Palestinian educational system--will mean the end of hopes for Arab-Israeli reconciliation not only in this generation but in the next one too.
For the Israeli right, this is the moment of "We told you so." The fact that the kidnappings and missile attacks have come from southern Lebanon and Gaza--precisely the areas from which Israel has unilaterally withdrawn--is proof, for right-wingers, of the bankruptcy of unilateralism. Yet the right has always misunderstood the meaning of unilateral withdrawal. Those of us who have supported unilateralism didn't expect a quiet border in return for our withdrawal but simply the creation of a border from which we could more vigorously defend ourselves, with greater domestic consensus and international understanding. The anticipated outcome, then, wasn't an illusory peace but a more effective way to fight the war. The question wasn't whether Hamas or Hezbollah would forswear aggression but whether Israel would act with appropriate vigor to their continued aggression.
So it wasn't the rocket attacks that were a blow to the unilateralist camp, but rather Israel's tepid responses to those attacks. If unilateralists made a mistake, it was in believing our political leaders--including Ariel Sharon and Ehud Olmert--when they promised a policy of zero tolerance against any attacks emanating from Gaza after Israel's withdrawal. That policy was not implemented--until two weeks ago. Now, belatedly, the Olmert government is trying to regain something of its lost credibility, and that is the real meaning of this initial phase of the war, both in Gaza and in Lebanon.
Still, many in Israel believe that, even now, the government is acting with excessive restraint. One centrist friend of mine, an Olmert voter, said to me, "If we had assassinated [Hamas leader] Haniyeh after the first kidnapping, [Hezbollah leader] Nasrallah would have thought twice about ordering another kidnapping." Israel, then, isn't paying for the failure of unilateral withdrawal, but for the failure to fulfill its promise to seriously respond to provocations after withdrawal...
I would argue that what we're watching is part of that promise, if a bit belated [the rest of the piece is in the private forum if you have trouble with the TNR site].
There's been too much going on to analyze in any sort of useful way without writing a book, but I did want to make a couple of (possibly) disjointed, reactionary comments.
First, this business of "proportionality" is starting to make my eyes cross. As I said in a comment at Seawitch's blog, anyone who starts yammering about “proportionality” in a war should immediately be written off as a fool or a charlatan. They are issuing prescriptions for others they would never in a million years imbibe themselves. When you go to war you go full-bore with overwhelming force or you do…not…go. Got that? If I never hear that hypocritical word again it'll be too soon.
Second, my heart truly goes out to those many Lebanese and other Arabs who would like nothing more than to get rid of Hizballah but feel powerless to do so. The fact that they are caught in the middle here is heartbreaking. Unfortunately, they live in a country that can't control its borders and can't control a member party of its government. So the Israelis have ruined tourist season by a blockade to prevent moving the kidnapped soldiers out of the country and, more probably, to prevent easy military resupply and put pressure on the Lebanese to do something. Letting Hizballah export war south while Lebanese sit comfortable in Beirut is no longer an option. If we hurt, you hurt. It's not nice, but that's war. (I think, btw, that the efficacy of this strategy is dubious, but that's another issue. I do understand it, however.)
It would be nice (not the right word, but you get the point) to see some direct action against the Syrian regime (no more flyovers without a delivery), as they also need to feel the pinch, which they should have felt long ago, for being Hamas's hosts. Action against Iran is a bigger nut to crack, and one that I don't want to tackle right now, but it looks like that's coming soon anyway, especially as they've said they'll fight if Syria is attacked. (Ignore threats of a general Jihad against Israel at Iran's command -- the rest of the Arab World will be content to say, "OK, you first" as they always do.) On the other hand, it could very well be that the Israelis have taken the measure of the Syrians and have decided they're nothing but chumps in all this. They're saving their punches for Iran.
Update: A very good indication that Iran is the man behind the curtain.
Protesters, Counter-Protesters and Bishops as Useful Idiots
In Boston yesterday, anti-Israel protesters were met by a significant number of counter-protesters outside the Israeli Consulate. The Globe has the story: 2 sides face off at Gaza protests - Israeli official plans to meet with Christian leaders
``We pray for Israeli soldier Corporal Gilad Shalit and for an immediate and peaceful halt to the hostilities raging for the past two weeks in the Gaza Strip and for the peaceful coexistence of Israel and Palestine," Shaw said. He called for the end to the Gaza occupation and to terrorism against Israel.
About 50 pro-Israel demonstrators held blue-and-white Israeli flags and signs reading ``We Support Israel" and ``End the Missiles." Nancy K. Kaufman , the executive director of the Jewish Community Relations Council, asked why the protesters hadn't demonstrated when Israelis were killed, and said: ``There needs to be an end to terror. That is what we pray for."
At several points, protesters started shouting at one another. While Shaw was speaking, an Israel supporter stopped his Toyota Camry in the street, jumped out, and started shouting ``Israel! Israel!" A pro-Palestinian protester shouted ``Fascist!" in response.
The two sides began arguing vociferously at the entrance to the building housing the consulate, and the police officers called for backup.
The police asked the two groups -- who were standing on both sides of Park Plaza, separated by Hadassah Way and by the entryway to the Statler building -- to stop using bullhorns to communicate, saying that such action requires a permit. The arguments then quieted down.
On both sides, passions were running deep. Susan Allen , a protester from Brookline, accused Israel of ``bulldozing the homes of innocent children," and an organizer of the protest, Sharif Fam, said, ``if you support war crimes, you unfortunately will become a target."
A counterdemonstrator, Dexter Van Zile , accused the Episcopal Church of ``defamation of the Jewish homeland" and said ``Episcopalians should be ashamed of Bishop Shaw's presence here," while Andrew Tarsy , the regional director of the Anti-Defamation League, said ``it's a sad day when legitimate social action merges with the extremist fringe, and that's what's happening here."
Eventually, heavy rain began to fall, and the demonstrators dispersed...
The story behind Shaw's presence is here: Episcopal chief to again protest Israeli actions
He sounds like a man at pains to tread a virtuous path (though I disagree with it), but if he wants to be taken seriously, he makes a big mistake associating with the groups involved in these anti-Israel protests.
Successful ABM Test
White Sands missile test phenomenal
"This was phenomenal," said U.S. Army Col. Charles Driessnack, the project manager for the Missile Defense Agency's THAAD program. "It performed as expected."
The test demonstrated the THAAD's ability to "completely destroy that warhead so that no chemical or nuclear residue would contaminate areas" below the explosion, Driessnack said.
During the test firing, the airspace above the 3,200-square-mile missile range was cleared, including orbiting satellites, said Jim Eckles, a spokesman for the missile range.
Also, roughly 80 to 90 families were evacuated from surrounding ranch land during the test and traffic was halted on area highways.
The target — a Hera missile that closely mimics the characteristics of the more infamous SCUD missiles — was launched shortly after 5:17 a.m. Wednesday. It took to the skies from a location on the far northern reaches of the bombing range's territory, about 100 miles north of the Organ Mountains, 25 miles north of Highway 380.
It carried a canister of inert material to simulate chemical or biological elements that could be mounted on an enemy missile, Driessnack said. The target missile rose roughly 200 miles above the Earth before beginning the final stage descent toward land.
The THAAD was launched close to the southern end, on the east side of the Organ Mountains. The object of the THAAD missile is to provide a weapon to intercept incoming missiles during the "terminal" phase, when only seconds remain before it would strike an intended target...
Faster please.
Time to Bolt
Michael Graham's effort to get rid of Pike Chairman Matt Amorello have taken shape: Tell Matt Amorello "It's Time To Bolt!"
Well, if Matt Amorello can't take a hint, then it's up to us to send him a clear message: "It's Time To Bolt!"
That's why I'm asking you to grab a bolt out of your toolbox or utility closet--perhaps like the one in this photo from the Big Dig--drop it in an envelope, write "Matt, It's Time To Bolt!" and send it to The Chairman's office at the Turnpike Authority...
Address and more at the link.
War in the Middle East
As we watch things spiral in the Middle East (down or up depending on your viewpoint), some blogs are doing a very good job of covering the moment-to-moment. Start with the Pajamas Media roundup here and get to surfing.
BTW, that's pretty much what I'll be doing. Feel free to leave comments.
Who the hell is Stan Papi?
If you're a Red Sox fan of a certain age, the words "Bill 'Spaceman' Lee" bring back a smile and some fond memories. Those were the days when hating the Yankees wasn't just a chant, it was black eyes and dislocated shoulders. Lefthanded junk-baller Bill Lee was one of the heroes of those salad days.
So I watched with great interest last night when NESN broadcast a one hour version of a new documentary on Lee called Spaceman: A Baseball Odyssey. The show featured a quick overview of Lee's controversial career and then followed him on a baseball tour of Cuba -- Lee was the only former professional among the Americans.
As I said, for those of us of a certain age, there were some special moments watching some of the old footage, seeing some of the interviews with Fred Lynn, Luis Tiant and Bernie Carbo, and at one point when Lee starts naming the guys who used to be on the field with him...Rice, Lynn, Evans, Doyle, Burleson, Hobson, Yaz...those were the days.
I guess no hero is perfect though, especially the closer you get, and maybe a trip to Cuba with an old hippie is a bit too close. The shots of the ballgames in Cuba were interesting, if somewhat poorly put together -- maybe the full length version will do it better, but for a movie centering around the game of baseball, the story of the games themselves is almost completely absent. What were the scores, anyway?
But worst of all was watching Lee leave his manor house in Vermont to fly to Cuba (a trip he has apparently made numerous times) and admire the pristine, clean lives the people live there. Watching Lee fawn over conditions in the worker's paradise was...well somewhat nauseating to tell you the truth. It would have been been more nauseating if Lee had a reputation as a serious person rather than a goofball, but nonetheless...
Listen Bill, you know why things are so clean and natural there, and the people live so simply? Because they're so poor they virtually have to eat dirt because that's the condition their dictator keeps them in. Lee laments that the day will come when it won't always be this way because after all, "Castro can't live forever." Well thank the Lord for small miracles.
Ironically, a loudmouthed iconoclast like Lee would be in jail in Cuba, or perhaps one of those who'd be trying to escape to America on a boat made out of stapled together banana peels if they could afford the staples. Instead, due to a quirk of fate, Lee enjoys Cuba as a safari destination while fantasizing about bringing down boxes of spark plugs to heroically distribute for all the 1950's era automobiles the Cubans have running without wondering why they have all those old cars and if that really the way the Cubans want it. Thank you bwana!
On all the Castro and Che "art" covering the walls: Well, you know, sure, that's what "we would call propaganda," but actually, the Cubans really love and respect those guys. Good grief.
Oh well, no sense in taking it all too seriously, we'll always have our memories.
Oh, and just who the hell is Stan Papi? Some people are still asking. Well, I'm sure he's a fine fellow, but he was also the guy who the Red Sox traded Lee for at the end of the 1978 season just to get rid of him. Papi was a nobody who came to Boston in exchange for one of the most popular players on the team.
Wednesday, July 12, 2006
Who is Samir Kuntar?
Roger L. Simon notes that one of the terrorists that Hizballah wants released is "Samir Kuntar, jailed in Israel since a 1979 attack in the northern town of Nahariyah, in which he entered an apartment and murdered three family members and an Israeli police officer..." Who is Samir Kuntar? Read this and remember what's behind some of the names of the people that Arab terrorists are now demanding be released: The World Should Know What He Did to My Family By Smadar Haran Kaiser A snip, but read the whole thing:
... Outside, we could hear the men storming about. Desperately, we sought to hide. Danny helped our neighbor climb into a crawl space above our bedroom; I went in behind her with Yael in my arms. Then Danny grabbed Einat and was dashing out the front door to take refuge in an underground shelter when the terrorists came crashing into our flat. They held Danny and Einat while they searched for me and Yael, knowing there were more people in the apartment. I will never forget the joy and the hatred in their voices as they swaggered about hunting for us, firing their guns and throwing grenades. I knew that if Yael cried out, the terrorists would toss a grenade into the crawl space and we would be killed. So I kept my hand over her mouth, hoping she could breathe. As I lay there, I remembered my mother telling me how she had hidden from the Nazis during the Holocaust. "This is just like what happened to my mother," I thought.
As police began to arrive, the terrorists took Danny and Einat down to the beach. There, according to eyewitnesses, one of them shot Danny in front of Einat so that his death would be the last sight she would ever see. Then he smashed my little girl's skull in against a rock with his rifle butt. That terrorist was Samir Kuntar.
By the time we were rescued from the crawl space, hours later, Yael, too, was dead. In trying to save all our lives, I had smothered her...
It would have been more humane to have executed Kuntar years ago so that he no longer served as a gravity for violence. Truth.
A Fitfully Sleeping Dragon
Jules Crittenden comments on the dragon that's been sleeping only somewhat fitfully of late: Dawn Over Tokyo
Japanese officials said Monday they believe negotiations may not be the answer to the Korean problem. Dawn over Tokyo.
"If we accept that there is no other option to prevent an attack ... there is the view that attacking the launch base of the guided missiles is within the constitutional right of self-defense. We need to deepen discussion," Chief Cabinet Secretary Shinzo Abe said.
"It's irresponsible to do nothing when we know North Korea could riddle us with missiles," said Tsutomu Takebe, secretary general of the ruling Liberal Democratic Party. To legally allow such an attack, he said, "We should consider measures, including legal changes."
Japan's military currently remains on a defensive footing, and would at best be strained by the execution of such a plan. A Japanese ramp-up to offensive capability probably could be achieved in relatively short order, once legal issues are resolved. Japan may then also have to tackle the issue of whether to go nuclear, as an added defensive measure in a bad neighborhood that includes two aggressive nuclear players -- China and North Korea. These are not only reasonable steps for a mature democracy to consider in that kind of environment, they are vital to stabilizing a region where the United States has not only had to provide security but is regularly blamed for creating tensions it is there to defend against...
Letters from a Soldier #3
Tom Glennon has posted installment 3 in his series of letters from Nephew Keith describing his training in the lead up to Keith's deplyment to Afghanistan: LETTERS FROM A SOLDIER #3 It's quite heartening to read about the good preparation these guys are getting before they get sent overseas. A snip:
The war is over. Why not let a new future begin?
Dear Palestinian Arab brethren:
The war with Israel is over.
You have lost. Surrender and negotiate to secure a future for your children.
We, your Arab brothers, may say until we are blue in the face that we stand by you, but the wise among you and most of us know that we are moving on, away from the tired old idea of the Palestinian Arab cause and the "eternal struggle" with Israel.
Dear friends, you and your leaders have wasted three generations trying to fight for Palestine, but the truth is the Palestine you could have had in 1948 is much bigger than the one you could have had in 1967, which in turn is much bigger than what you may have to settle for now or in another 10 years. Struggle means less land and more misery and utter loneliness...
Leaflets over Gaza
The IDF has been dropping these:
The objective of the operation is to determine the whereabouts of our abducted soldier, Gilad Shalit, to bring about his release, and to ensure the safety of Israel citizens.
For your safety, and as we want to prevent any harm to civilians, who are not involved in attacking our forces, you should stay clear of areas where the IDF is operating and adhere [sic] to IDF forces.
People who try to disrupt the IDF's activities, which are meant to ensure the safe return of our soldier, are doing so at their own risk.
In Olmert's Own Words
I received a transcript of Ehud Olmert's responses to questions from the international press from the other day (don't have a link) and thought it worth reposting some of the more interesting answers:
On demands for "proportionality":
On Hamas lawmakers:
The foe behind the friend's handshake
Jeff Jacoby on Putin's retreat from democracy:
So it goes in Putin's Russia, where the stifling of independent media voices is now routine. Since coming to power in 1999, Putin has seized control of the country's major TV channels, all of which are now under the thumb of the government or its allies. Local media outlets rarely challenge local governors, most of whom are Kremlin loyalists -- especially since Putin abolished the popular election of regional officials two years ago.
A bill now before the Russian Parliament would broaden the crime of "extremism" to include media criticism of public officials. If convicted, journalists could be imprisoned for three years and their publications closed. Yet crimes already on the books are not always prosecuted zealously: Since Putin became president, 12 journalists have been murdered in contract-style killings, including American Paul Klebnikov, the 41-year-old editor of Forbes Russia. To date, no one has been brought to justice in any of the murders.
The rollback of press freedoms is of a piece with Putin's deepening authoritarianism. Nearly all serious opposition to Putin has been broken or marginalized. Prominent businessmen unwise enough to oppose him have been prosecuted and imprisoned, or forced to flee the country. Neighboring countries have been outrageously bullied. Putin has even gone out of his way to defend Soviet-era crimes like the occupation of the Baltic states in 1941.
"Just as in the old days," Garry Kasparov, the chess champion and Russian democracy activist, wrote in a New York Times column on Monday, "Moscow has become an ally for troublemakers and anti-democratic rulers around the world. Nuclear aid to Iran, missile technology to North Korea, military aircraft to Sudan, Myanmar and Venezuela, and a budding friendship with Hamas: These are the West's rewards for keeping its mouth shut about human rights in Russia."...
Arab blogs that fight for reform
Frida Ghitis writes in the San Francisco Chronicle about some of the blogs that account for the "minority report" amongst Arab opinion: Arab blogs that fight for reform
However, buried below the furious, raging surface, a different sort of commentary flowed through the Internet.
In Arab blogs and deep inside the Web comment pages of some major news organizations, a few people dared to disagree. In fact, some Arab advocates of political and social reform saw recent events in the Palestinian territories as ammunition with which to criticize the dictatorial regimes they want to change in their own countries...
...Many -- though not all -- in the Arab blogosphere sharply criticized Israeli actions as excessive, but they saw in the fury of the Israeli government something lacking in their own: concern for the life of a single citizen. "They will turn the world upside down to get that soldier back," wrote Sandmonkey, who describes himself as 25-year-old Egyptian living in Cairo. "I kind of envy how much they care about their own." The sentiment was echoed by Isis, at BigPharaoh.com, wishing that "our government had half the respect" for its citizens' lives "that the Israelis have for theirs."
Lebanese bloggers found bitter irony in the failure of their leaders to accomplish very much and yet find the time to rhetorically blast Israel. Lebanonesque (lebanonesque.blogspot.com) printed a local news item about a meeting of the country's National Dialogue, which "failed to solve any of their own country's problems ... but they did manage to agree that the international community should step in to halt Israel's offensive in the Gaza Strip." A contributor noted sadly that "Arab 'leaders' are following in the grand tradition of posturing and emitting hot air while unable/unwilling to deliver bread to their own people."...
[h/t: Jeff Jacoby]
Reminds me of this post at Iraq the Model which notes that Iraqi opinion on the Shalit kidnapping was often at odds with other Arabs in a comment thread at the BBC Arabic edition: Singing out of the flock.
Hizballah Rockets Israeli Towns, Kidnaps Soldiers (Updates)
Escallation on the northern border: PM Olmert declares Hizbullah attack 'act of war' by Lebanon
Prime Minister Ehud Olmert declared the attack as an "act of war" and not terror. During a press conference with Japanese Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi Wednesday afternoon, he called it an unprovoked assault by a sovereign nation and held Lebanon, where Hizbullah has a minister in the government, fully responsible.
"Israel's response will be restrained but very, very, very painful," Olmert added.
The Defense Ministry confirmed early Wednesday afternoon that two IDF soldiers had been kidnapped by Hizbullah. IDF ground troops had been sent into Lebanon to search for the two. IAF jets, helicopters and UAVs were also flying above Lebanon searching for the soldiers. Several jets were flying patterns above Beirut, Channel 10 reported. Simultaneously, Navy gunboats and artillery along the border were shelling Hizbullah targets in Lebanon.
The army has destroyed 17 targets as well as Hizbullah outposts and three bridges since the beginning of the operation.
Hizbullah's Al Manar TV broadcast earlier Wednesday that the organization had kidnapped the two soldiers. A senior Hizbullah official said that at least one of the allegedly kidnapped soldiers was still alive. A senior IDF officer landed Wednesday afternoon in the northern Druse village of Kfar Yanuh apparently to inform a family there that their son had been kidnapped.
Hizbullah launched a heavy barrage of Katyusha rockets and mortar shells at IDF positions and communities along the northern frontier on Wednesday morning starting about 9:15 a.m. One rocket scored a direct hit on a house in Shtula. Magen David Adom said they had treated six people so far. Both soldiers and civilians have been wounded. The wounded were being evacuated to Nahariya hospital...
The IDF is calling up the reserves:
Earlier, Israel rejected a cease-fire request made by the Lebanese government via the UN after IDF troops entered its territory to rescue two soldiers captured by Hizbullah earlier Wednesday.
A very high ranking military officer said that if the soldiers were not returned in good condition, Israel would turn Lebanon back 20 years by striking its vital infrastructure...
World leaders decry Hizbullah assault -- but don't worry, just wait until Israel's response sinks in. Most of 'em will condemn that, too. Palestinian Arabs are handing out sweets in celebration.
Update: Sites with lots more infor (via LGF): Mere Rhetoric, Israel Matzav, Dave Bender, Israellycool, Lawhawk
Big link round-up at Pajamas Media
Tuesday, July 11, 2006
Wilson, Plame, Novak and Who's Who
WizBang brings things up to date: Novak finally spills his guts on Plame
Tumbling Ceiling - Third World in the First
The talk shows today in Boston have, understandably, been covering the news of the piece of tunnel ceiling that fell this morning and killed a person: Section of ceiling tumbles in tunnel
The entire Big Dig is a shocking embarrassment not only to Massachusetts but to the entire nation. This is what happens in Third World countries where there's too much corruption and incompetence to get major public works projects done. Shameful! Too many hands out, too many special interests, too many unaccountable HACKS, too many politicians who think their job is done once they bring the bacon home...
Lots of commentary at mAss Backwards.
Cadaver Art
I'd like to see this (but not participate in it):
Traveling cadaver show wants you - Body exhibit seeks donors in Boston
He hopes to add to that list when his traveling show reaches Boston later this month.
``Think of it as an alternative to being eaten by worms or going up in smoke," von Hagens said by phone from his Institute for Plastination in Heidelberg, Germany.
A donor might wind up as an exotic medical specimen (sliced, for example, into 1-millimeter-thick translucent body ``sheets") or as a featured whole-body exhibit in his occasionally condemned but wildly popular road show, Body Worlds 2, which opens July 30 at the Museum of Science in Boston.
``My aim is to illuminate and educate through the beautiful arrangement" of bodies, he said. The 61-year-old physician, university lecturer, and anatomist-cum-artist's exhibitions of plasticized, partially dissected bodies -- an expectant mother cross-sectioned to reveal her unborn child, a man peeled to his musculature, carrying his skin like an old raincoat -- hover somewhere between the sublime and the unspeakable.
The Body Worlds exhibitions have attracted more than 18 million visitors on three continents and grossed an estimated $200 million, according to organizers. They also have been controversial: Police and prosecutors in at least four countries have investigated allegations -- none proven -- that von Hagens has purchased cadavers from grave robbers, prison wardens, bribed medical examiners, and other unsavory purveyors...
Reminds me of the body viewing software I posted about way back in this post: The yearning to gaze outward...and inward...
SOS Racisme comedy show -- too Jewish?
Comedians have been pressured to pull out of a comedy show co-sponsored by a group called "SOS Racisme" because the show was..."too Jewish"...
Nestle stands up to the Arab boycott
Not that they expect it to amount to anything, but this is good to read: Nestle’s Israel activity brings Arab boycott threat
In response, Nestle issued its own press release the next day on July 5, saying that it had no intention of capitulating to the Arab boycott. The company added that has 253,000 employees in over 100 countries, was not involved in politics, but in business, and also invested heavily in Arab countries.
Nestle stated, “Nestlé is regularly attacked by various Arab and Islamic circles for doing business in Israel. In the latest such moves, on 4 July 2006, the Damascus-based Arab League Central Boycott Office (CBO) added Nestlé to the list of companies to be boycotted because of links with Israel, although it seems likely that the decision will be ignored by most Arab League member states...
...Radical pro-Arab organizations in the UK, including an organization called “Friends of al-Aqsa” are calling for a boycott of Nestle products in the UK because of the company’s activity in Israel. This organization is also calling for boycotts of other international companies active in Israel. No company, including Nestle and L’Oreal Paris, have suspended their activities in Israel, either because of previous calls for a boycott or the present call.
Osem managing director Gad Propper told “Globes” today, “Nestle does not capitulate to boycotts. The fact that somebody in Syria decided to boycott Nestle does not mean that he has any influence on the company. I’m sure that it will not surrender, which is seen in the company’s official response.”
“Agence France Press” (AFP) reports that many Arab countries, including “most members of the Arab League” will probably ignore the call for a boycott.
Regardless, the Arab League Central Boycott Office has added Nestle to its blacklist of companies trading with Israel, and issued an ultimatum to the company to halt trade with Israel...
[h/t: isirota1965]
So that's where all the extra traffic is coming from
I've been noticing a lot of extra traffic coming by the blog today, but there's no indication of a referrer which means a bunch of people decided to add me to their favorites or type in the link to this site directly all of a sudden. But why? I finally discovered that Lucianne put one of the posters from this post on her page today. Since the poster contains the url to here, I guess some folks are stopping by.
Welcome!
Photo essay of anti-Israel protest
Here's a very nice photo-essay of an anti-Israel rally with counter-protest in LA on the 7th. Pics, description and video. Take a look: Modern Conservative: Photo Essay: Anti-Israel protest and the counter protest Los Angeles, July 7th, 2006 (videos too!)
At least 135 dead in Mumbai
Some very familiar pictures of trains opened up like sardine cans, and what's likely to be some very familiar perpetrators: Bombs hit trains in Mumbai, at least 135 dead
There was no immediate claim of responsibility for the evening rush hour attacks, the worst in the city for more than a decade.
But suspicion was likely to center on Muslim militants fighting New Delhi's rule in disputed Kashmir, who have been blamed for several bomb attacks in India in the past.
City Police Commissioner A.N. Roy told Reuters 135 people were killed while Chief Minister Vilasrao Deshmukh, the state's top elected official, said 300 people were injured in the blasts, which took place in the space of around 10 minutes...
Update: A round-up of links here, at Captain's Quarters. Giant-sized round-up at Pajamas Media.
There's always space for terror
One of the more surreal reading experiences I've had in awhile is this op-ed by the leader of Hamas, a group dedicated to Israel's destruction, complaining that Israel and the US aren't being respectful of the Palestinian Arabs' choice of leadership. Astounding. That a major newspaper would publish such a thing as-is without response is...sadly not surprising, actually. Print space for terrorists to spread lies and propaganda...no, not surprising at all.
Washington Post: Aggression Under False Pretenses by Ismail Haniyeh
The current Gaza invasion is only the latest effort to destroy the results of fair and free elections held early this year. It is the explosive follow-up to a five-month campaign of economic and diplomatic warfare directed by the United States and Israel. The stated intention of that strategy was to force the average Palestinian to "reconsider" her vote when faced with deepening hardship; its failure was predictable, and the new overt military aggression and collective punishment are its logical fulfillment. The "kidnapped" Israeli Cpl. Gilad Shalit is only a pretext for a job scheduled months ago...
Update: Haniyeh's piece is what's called "ripe for fisking," and Captain's Quarters does an outstanding job of it, here: We Know The Truth -- And That's The Problem [h/t: Grantman]
And Meryl responds, here. Did Haniyeh have help?
Monday, July 10, 2006
The true face of Hamas
Benny Morris reviews a new book about Hamas by Matthew Levitt. The whole piece is worth reading in full, but here are a couple of (lengthy) snips: The New Republic: Alms and Arms
In this thicket of deceit, Islamists present Muslims always as victims, never as perpetrators. (When has there ever been a community with such a litany of grievances?) And they have read the West well, especially Western Europe, with its gnawing discontents, its guilty conscience over a colonial past, its burgeoning Muslim populations, its thirst for oil, its distaste for war, and, yes, its anti-Semitism. The Islamists, perhaps accurately, see the West as weak--and they exploit every fissure and crevice, every greed and appetite, every self-flagellating impulse. And as they privately snicker in their back rooms, they are busy taking the West for a ride: they laugh as the West beats itself over every dead Iraqi (the vast majority of the killings in Iraq are committed by Muslims against fellow Muslims, not by Westerners), and over every impoverished Afghan or Palestinian child (impoverished because their societies and economies have failed to develop, largely for internal reasons, beyond opium production and living on U.N. handouts), and over every human rights abuse to which some Muslims are subject in Guantánamo and Britain and the United States (when these pale in comparison with those perpetrated in every hour of every day in Sudan, Egypt, Syria, Yemen, Iran, and Saudi Arabia)...
...the dawa's terrorism-related activities are not limited to indoctrination and propaganda, though these have been crucial in raising a generation of Palestinian suicide-murderers. In his interrogation by Israeli security men in summer 2002, Mustafa Amjad, a doctor at al-Razi Hospital in Jenin, confessed to helping terrorists enter Israel. He was recruited by Hamas and worked for a hospital affiliated with a Hamas charity. In a Hamas kindergarten in the Shati refugee camp in Gaza, Palestinian security men found hidden thirty-two kilograms of explosives, according to Palestinian security chief Jibril Rajoub. Two members of a Jenin charity organization board, Jamal Abd al-Shamal Abu Hija and Ibrahim Hassan Ali Jaber, helped to plan terrorist attacks and to transport terrorists into Israel, according to Israeli authorities cited by Levitt. Another man, Nahed Rashid Ahmed Attalah, the director of food supplies for Gaza refugees with UNRWA, confessed to using U.N. vehicles to transport arms and terrorists. The Hamas-linked Charity and Contribution Committee of Ramallah-al-Bireh regularly provided funds for the families of suicide bombers, while Abd al-Khaliq al Natsheh, who headed the Hebron Islamic Charitable Society, was jailed for recruiting terrorists. The Hamas-affiliated Jihad Mosque in Hebron had a soccer team that carried out five terrorist operations in the first half of 2003, before the scorers (shooters?) were apprehended.
A similar duplicity informs much of Hamas's overseas fund-raising, which is ostensibly earmarked for good works among a needy population but is in fact also a channel for funding Izz al-Din al-Qassam operations. Terrorist attacks, as Levitt notes, are often expensive. An M-16 A2 assault rifle costs $6,642; bullets for an AK-47 cost $2.20 apiece; a stolen vehicle costs $656 to $1,550. Salah Shehadeh once estimated that operations cost $3,500 to $50,000 each. The bombing at the Hebrew University cafeteria in July 2002 was said by a Jordanian Islamist to have cost $50,000. So a parallel "economic jihad" was necessary to provide the funds. Levitt provides many details of the charitable organizations that raised the money, mainly in the West, and the mechanisms through which it was moved to the occupied territories. He also details the contributions of and from the various Arab states (mainly Iraq, Sudan, and Saudi Arabia).
A great deal of this charity-bound money reached Hamas fighters' families (those of Fatah seem to have done rather poorly), thus helping to motivate young Palestinians from poor families to carry out attacks. The Ramallah-al-Bireh branch of the Islah Charitable Society, a Hamas front, in November and December 2000 paid out $4,990 to martyrs' families, $16,257 to prisoners, and $17,275 to prisoners' families, according to documents captured by Israel and cited by Levitt. Follow-up monthly stipends for the families are also standard practice, apparently. And there are special one-time dispensations on holidays...
Democracy is not a suicide pact
Arab MK: 'I Advised PA to Kidnap Soldier'
MK Zevulun Orlev (National Religious Party), who last week submitted a bill to negate Knesset membership to MKs who support terrorists, said that Taha's "traitorous" remarks are further proof that Israeli democracy must protect itself.
According to a report in Maariv newspaper on Sunday, Taha told surfers on Thursday that he repeatedly advised the PA Arabs to stop shooting and targeting civilians, and to concentrate on IDF targets. An English translation of Maariv's Hebrew translation of Taha's Arabic words:
"We told them more than once that the Palestinians, who are subjected to murder and ongoing crimes on the part of the Israeli army, have two options: One is to explode and kill civilians - and these are much easier operations. The second option is the military option, in the framework of which a military unit from the resistance [i.e., terrorist infrastructures - ed.] is established in order to break into a military camp, clash with the soldiers and battle them and take them and the conquest into captivity."
Taha also had words of advice for the PA on the publicity front, saying that the kidnapped soldier Gilad Shalit should not be called "kidnapped" but rather "imprisoned" or "captive." Taha said, "Kidnapping is an act carried out by gangs, terrorists, and the like. But 'captive' means that [it is carried out by] an organized, legitimate group that makes decisions. Israel is trying to present our resistance as something less - as terrorism, murder, and kidnapping - in order that the diplomatic circle will be closed to it."
Asked by Arutz-7's Uzi Baruch if Taha condemns the abduction of Corp. Gilad Shalit, the MK's aide said, "We do not condemn actions against IDF soldiers, we condemn actions only against innocent civilians."...
North Korean missiles bought by South Korea (and you and me)
The Marmot points out that South Korea has, in effect, been subsidizing North Korean weapons programs (as have we).
Statute of Limitation runs out on Rushdie's Japanese Translator
15 years ago, Hitoshi Igarashi, the Japanese Translator of Salman Rushdie's The Satanic Verses was found murdered -- the culprit was never apprehended. The statute of limitations on the crime has now run: Statute of limitations expire on 'Satanic Verses' murder
With the expiration of the statute, prosecutors technically is no longer able to indict the killer of Hitoshi Igarashi in July 1991, but the police said they will continue to investigate the case. On July 12, 1991, Igarashi, 44, a researcher of Islamic studies and an assistant professor at the University of Tsukuba, was found dead with multiple stab wounds to his neck and face in a hallway of a building in the university's complex in Tsukuba, Ibaraki Prefecture.
You've come a long way, Aisha

JPost: Aksa Brigades announce female suicide bomber unit
Imagine announcing such a thing?
A woman who identified herself as Um al-Abed told reporters in Gaza City that so far about 100 women had expressed their desire to carry out suicide attacks against Israel. She claimed that she was a spokeswoman for the Aksa Martyrs Brigades, the armed wing of Fatah.
The Aksa Martyrs Brigades, she added, recently established a secret military unit for female suicide bombers from the West Bank, Gaza Strip and Jerusalem. "We have so far recruited 100 women for the new unit," Um al-Abed said as she sat next to several masked women who identified themselves as members of Fatah.
"We are expecting more female suicide bombers. The new unit is now preparing to launch attacks against Israel in response to the Israeli aggression and crimes against our people in the Gaza Strip."
Since September 2000, Palestinian women have carried out seven suicide bombings inside Israel in which 37 people were killed and more than 250 injured. The most serious attack was launched in October 2003 by Hanadi Jaradat, an Islamic Jihad woman from Jenin, who detonated herself at the Maxim Restaurant in Haifa. The attack left 21 civilians dead and 48 wounded.
Four of the female suicide bombers belonged to Fatah, one to Hamas and two to Islamic Jihad.
Um al-Abed also hinted that the group was planning to target Hamas members who are responsible for attacks on Fatah activists. She pointed out that a senior Fatah militiaman, Haitham Rai, was killed over the weekend in Gaza City apparently by Hamas gunmen...
A sickness that claws at its own society.
Free Gilad Shalit
Atlas has excellent coverage of the rally in New York including video: FREE GILAD NOW! NY RALLY!
Propaganda for Hamas in the Boston Globe
What a disgrace. Unadulterated propaganda from Hamas in the person of a Gazan physician screaming "woe is me." No mention of the hundred of Palestinian rockets that Palestinians have launched on Israel (something most Palestinians support), offers of humanitarian aid (declined by the Hamas government), that the "women and children" being held in Palestinian prisons are there on terrorism charges...this is a new low even for the Globe.
My life in Gaza by Mona El-Farra
I am already starting to lose track of days and nights, of how many bombs have dropped. Since the main power plant was destroyed, we have had to live with no electricity. What we do get is patchy, and barely enough to recharge our mobile phones and our laptops so that we do not lose all touch with each other and with the outside world...
Sorry Mona, you don't choose war then cry victim.
This crud is more like something that should be published on fringe sites like Electronic Intifiada or Counterpunch, not a major metropolitan newspaper.
Sunday, July 9, 2006
'Civilians'
A rather typical Gaza or West Bank scene:

Is the man carrying the rocket a military target? You betcha. If he's shot, how many seconds do you suppose it takes to grab the rocket and the gun and turn him into a "civilian?" Three? How many civilians, even kids, are in danger around him? Lots. Are enemy soldiers supposed to stand with their arms at their sides and allow this man to shoot them therefore? No.
Snapshots has an entry (from which, this photo) looking at how Palestinian Arab youth are sometimes even coerced into running cover for "gunmen," and civilians are intentionally put in harm's way: A Revealing Look at Palestinian Casualties
Israel Needs to Explain Itself
Dear PM Olmert:
One of the things that those of us who supported (and still support) the Gaza pullout hoped would happen would be that future conflict would be "rationalized" somewhat -- no more little skirmishes over vaguely defined territory that are difficult for the outsider to understand and contribute to the misperception that all the violence is some sort of tit-for-tat prodding where the killing of innocent Israelis looks more like murder (where individuals are perceived to be at fault and punishable) than acts of war (where an entire government is responsible). By setting a border, who is at fault in any situation should become easier to discern -- "you did that to us, so we are going to do this to you."
That's what's been frustrating about the current Gaza situation. Even after the "disengagement," this whole process just looks like more of the same, because the Israeli government just hasn't (as usual I'm sorry to say) done an effective job of explaining what's going on in straightforward terms to those who'd like to know but weren't necessarily previously informed.
Look, I admit I'm not the greatest internet searcher in the world, so maybe they've already done this, but then that's the point, this thing should be front and center on the Ministry of Foreign Affairs web site and any other site it would be vaguely appropriate, like the Permanent Mission to the UN -- places where the public would never miss it and the press could never ignore it.
What this should be in effect is a Declaration of War. Now I'm not a lawyer, so I don't know all of the implications of an official "Declaration of War," but that's the idea -- that'll do here in the court of common sense. We need to know: The grievance, the goal and the means we can expect you to use to achieve it. By stating what started this episode and defining what will end it, you will rationalize the entire process in the minds of much of the world and as a result find support for you soar. Better yet, if your opponents do the same thing, the public can "compare balance sheets" as it were, and see who has the better case. You won't win over everyone, but I guarantee you will win over all the people that matter. Guaranteed.
To that end, below I have provided a brief brainstorm on the outline that such a document should take along with some guidance on the answers. By necessity, the final document will be more detailed than even something like the United States' Declaration of War on Nazi Germany was, and you should remember that this is for public consumption -- not a court of law. If you go and turn to some staff International Law expert, you've already lost -- though they should be consulted. Total length of the final document should not exceed the equivalent of two double-spaced type-written pages with wide margins. You really should have released this before the tanks rolled into Gaza.
Oh, and while you don't want to be overly formal, you do need to make sure your facts and logic are as bullet-proof as it's humanly possible to be. Write it like you're trying to frame one of your three wishes to an evil genie who's just waiting for his chance to twist your wish for "a million bucks" into a million antelope running around your back yard. Know what I'm saying?
Anyway, here you go...it should go something like this:
1) The Grievance: [Why are you taking action now? Give us some background. Why so angry? The following words and phrases will probably appear in this section: rockets, cross-border, kidnapping, act of war. Speak in general terms, but provide some specific examples as well, so long as you make it clear these are representative samples chosen for brevity and not an exhaustive list. Talk about deaths, particularly of children caused by rockets and mention the sacrifices you have already made. Talk about the enemy's war crimes, their use of human shields, child soldiers, hiding among civilian populations, fighting out of uniform, their own choice of targeting civilians and their general indoctrination of hatred among their people.Oh, and if you find yourself typing the number "1948" in anywhere in this section, hit back-space immediately. Don't go back further than two years. Everything else is ancient history for our purposes here. No one cares about that. You have to show you've moved on and it's the other guy who won't let history rest.]
2) The Goal: [What are you trying to achieve? Make sure this goal is rational and achievable. Be fairly modest if possible. Be specific here and don't include anything abstract or unquantifiable. Is it just to get a soldier back? Stop rocket attacks? Regime change?]
3) The means you will use to achieve the goal: [What will you target? What and who will you not target? Are Hamas law-makers targets? (Say yes.) What weapons and tactics will you use and what won't you use or do (in general terms)?]
4) Thank everyone for reading and ask for their support. [Seriously]
Just doing the above will put you on the moral and rhetorical high-ground by making you into the rational actor in the conflict.
Now to show you how this might stand you in good stead in contrasting you with your enemy, I'm going to fill out a similar sheet, very, very briefly on behalf of the Hamas/Palestinian Authority Government. This is somewhat tongue-in-cheek, of course, but the answers such as they are are dead-accurate and plausible. (It's in the extended entry below.)
Continue reading "Israel Needs to Explain Itself"Saturday, July 8, 2006
Uh Oh, Johnny Hart in trouble again
B.C. comic strip creator Johnny Hart is going to be in hot water with CAIR again.

Another Swipe at Islam in 'B.C.' Comic?
In the comic, Hart shows his turtle character asking: "What makes a bite that's shaped like a crescent moon?" The bird standing on the turtle's shell answers: "A lunatic." A star is drawn near the turtle's "finger" to illustrate the location of the bite.
A star/crescent moon is a symbol of Islam. There's also the possibility that Hart was making a "luna tick" pun instead of, or in addition to, making a negative reference to Islam.
An executive at Creators Syndicate, which distributes "B.C.," could not be immediately reached for comment today...
The comic that raised a "stink" previously can be seen here.
'I'm goin' to Pali tommorow, anyone dying for anything from there? Besises maybe a yahoud's left thumb'
A look at the mediators
Miss Kelly has a look at the make-up of the interfaith mediating panel that's looking into and hoping to resolve some of the lawsuits surrounding the embattled Islamic Society of Boston and their Boston Mosque project: More on ISB and Interfaith Mediation
CAIR Recommended the Firing of DePaul's Klocek
Marathon Pundit has the story of the fact that CAIR-Chicago recommended DePaul University's Thomas Klocek be fired.
In other DePaul news, don't miss his other post on marginal scholar and friend to Holocaust deniers everywhere, Norman Finkelstein: DePaul's Norman Finkelstein vents on Klocek and Irshad Manji, "a Salman Rushdie wannabe"
Quoting Manji:
Only one person emailed a disconcerting message. A gentleman named Norman Finkelstein wrote to say, "Is there a petition supporting the death threats?" Maybe he's just a researcher.
Boy Toys

The new F-35 Joint Strike Fighter was unveiled yesterday, and given its name, the Lightning II. Story: Lockheed Martin Unveils F-35 Strike Fighter. Pictures: Exclusive first photos of Lockheed Martin F-35 JSF ahead of official roll-out.
Its namesake:

[Links via The Flea]
Big Hair on Drums
Friday, July 7, 2006
Andover High's Resident Terror-defender to be on Radio
Busy, busy, busy today so I haven't had any chance to post, but I did want to note that Ron Francis will be a guest on Michael Graham's radio show on 96.9FM Talk in Boston at about 4:15 today. Don't miss it. There's a link to listen live at the web site.
Update: Well that went very, very well, I thought.
Thursday, July 6, 2006
Use of the cross as a weapon
Harkening back to the Catholic Church's Nostra Aetate as noted in the comments to this post:
The crucifixion was a gift to humanity and a "fountain of grace"...never a weapon with which to bash your fellow man. The Catholic Church affirmed that in 1965. I may stand to be corrected, but I feel confident in saying that virtually every major Protestant sect has also done the same (along with repudiating the concept of "replacement" -- that God's covenant with the Jews has been abrogated in favor of those who accepted Christ).
Yet here is a typical cartoon appearing in a Palestinian-Arab paper:

Not only is, to my knowledge, most of the Christian establishment silent in directly condemning this stuff, but some, such as Anglican Rev. Naim Ateek have actively employed it.
Palestinian Media Watch has a look at how the Palestinian Authority has been using this type of imagery: Jesus the Palestinian In Palestinian Authority ideology

[Al Quds July 6, 2006]
Palestinian historical revisionism
Historical revision is a backbone of Palestinian political and academic behavior, as the leaders attempt to create a separate "Palestinian Arab" history and identity for themselves, distinct from the general Arab and Islamic history. "Palestinian" Arabs are a very recent creation, and did not exist before the advent of PLO terror in 1965. Note, for example, that under UN resolution 194 in 1948, refugees were not called "Palestinian Refugees," relating to a national identity, but were called "Palestine Refugees," referring to geography - from where they came.
Jesus was Palestinian, the Palestinians are Jesus
One aspect of this attempt to create a Palestinian history is to present Jesus, who according to Christian scriptures was a Jew (Judean) living in the land of Judea-Israel, as a Palestinian. (In fact the name was changed to Palestine 136 years after Jesus' s death as part of Rome's plan to cut the Jews' ties to their Land of Israel.)
Jesus has even been presented by Palestinians as the "the first Palestinian Shahid – Martyr for Allah," [Al-Hayat Al-Jadida, January 17, 2005] applying to Jesus Islamic theology that evolved centuries later. On a culture program on Palestinian TV, a Palestinian artist depicted Israeli soldiers arresting Jesus, and explains that Jesus symbolizes the Palestinians...
More here.
No More Yale Taliban
Good.
No rest for the weary on Somerville Divestment
Here's the story in The Jewish Advocate concerning the next round in the never-ending saga of Ron Francis's Somerville Divestment Project: Here we go again, yet again
One question would direct the state representative for 27th Middlesex District to vote for any resolution calling for the selling of “investments [the state holds] either in Israel bonds or in companies that supply military equipment to Israel.”
The other would instruct the representative “to vote in favor of a nonbinding resolution calling on the federal government to support the right of all refugees, including Palestinian refugees, to return to their land of origin.”
The number of signatures required to get the question on the state ballot, 200, represents a much lower barrier than the roughly 4,000 petitions required to get a referendum on the municipal ballot. The SDP’s effort to do so last fall failed after a judge ruled that the petition forms it had used were invalid. To get on the state ballot, the SDP must submit the 200 signatures for each question by July 5.
Of nine proposed public policy questions for the November ballot, the SDP’s are the only two that address foreign policy, according to Election Commissioner Nicholas Salerno...
...Ken Brociner, a member of the Somerville Coalition for Middle East Peace, which took to the streets last year to counter the SDP’s anti-Israel message, said that he wasn’t surprised that the SDP was making another go of it.
“Due to SDP’s ideological fanaticism, it was entirely predictable that they would, once again, do everything they can to delegitimize Israel’s very right to exist,” he said, adding that the group “will have a very hard time fooling people into believing their rhetoric about being concerned about universal human rights.”...
Enemies Within
This essay starts with a look at Presbyterian divestment:
Rabbi Yitzchak Adlerstein was one of two representatives of the Simon Wiesenthal Center in Birmingham lobbying for rescission. He had expected a large Palestinian presence there as well, given the importance of the issue.
The Palestinians, however, were largely absent. They were not needed. In their place were dozens of Jews lobbying in favor of retaining the divestment resolution: Tikkun, Machsom Watch (the organization in which Prime Minister Ehud Olmert’s daughter Dana is active), Jewish Voice for Peace. Norman Finkelstein, who has been dubbed the Jewish David Irving, and whose book The Holocaust Industry was called by a New York Times reviewer a new variation on the Protocols of the Elders of Zion, was there as well, generously offering his latest screed against Israel to every delegate.
Dr. Yehuda Pearl, father of slain Wall Street Journal reporter Daniel Pearl, who identifies himself as a man of the Left, was stunned by the vitriol heaped on Israel by these Jews. His voice quivering with passion, he asked them: If you consider Israel’s behavior too harsh, why don’t you go to Israel and demonstrate at IDF headquarters, where you might have some effect. But the only beneficiaries of retaining the divestment resolution here will be those who killed my son.
Fortunately, the Jewish haters of Israel did not prevail. A new resolution passed, which not only apologized to the Jewish community [Not exactly, but close enough. There is, BTW, a very useful FAQ on the divestment issue in the PC(USA) here (PDF).] for the hurt caused by the earlier resolution and termed the process by which it was adopted deeply flawed, but removed any mention of divestment. (To be sure the new resolution was far from perfect; it called for Israel to dismantle the security fence beyond the 1967 borders, which it called Palestinian land.)
THE LEAD ROLE PLAYED BY JEWS in the attack on Israel was part of a larger pattern...
It then goes on to detail some of that pattern, including a look at Haaretz, and academics like Neve Gordon.
On the side of the ACLU
There's a disturbing story circulating that makes me grateful that the label of "conservative" has become the "big tent" it has in recent years, because I'm sure I'm not adopting the stereotypical "conservative" line on this one. I actually agree with the ACLU. If they stayed with issues like this (assuming the facts are as they appear), and away from the marginal cases (that keep pushing the margins) like microscopic crosses on state seals and Constitutional civil rights for foreign head-choppers, some of us might not be so hostile. Well, broken clocks and all...
Bartholomew has the story's background, here, about the Delaware public school that seems to have been a Christian school rather than a school populated by Christians and the harrassing out of town of the ACLU plaintiffs in the case. I don't think every last vestige of religion needs to be banished from campus, but this school does sound like it was more than a bit over the line. Judith examines the issue, along with the internet's role in the whole mess, here.
Wednesday, July 5, 2006
Classroom Credit to Support Terrorism?
There's an excellent article in The Valley Patriot -- a paper distributed in nine communities north of Boston -- exposing Ron Francis, the Andover High School physics teacher who supports Hamas and its goal of destroying Israel. They have picked up some of my photos for the article. The article quotes a Green-Rainbow Party member disgruntled with the dark alley Francis and his followers have taken the GRP, as well as a former student.
“Ron Francis’ politics, statements and actions are anti-Semitic,†says Eric Danis, a graduate of Andover High School. “Both his Somerville Divestment Project and the Green-Rainbow Party are suggesting boycotting and divesting from only one country in the entire world - the Jewish state of Israel,†adds Danis.
The controversy behind Francis began when he posted a letter on the Web site of the Somerville Divestment Project, defending the terrorist group Hamas and stating that Israel commits far more terrorist activities than the Palestinians. The letter was titled “Media Bias on Hamas,†where Francis says that the silver lining was with Hamas’ electoral victory. Francis also calls for “One Palestine.â€
The divestment project was intended to convince the city of Somerville to stop investing in Israeli bonds. The project failed, but Francis continues to place himself in leadership positions like becoming co-chair of the Green-Rainbow Party, to continue his fight against Jews and Israel.
INVESTIGATE FRANCIS/Classroom Credit for Spreading Hatred
A letter written June 20th to David Driscoll, Commissioner of Education, by Concerned Citizens from Somerville, asked that an investigation be held. They specifically refer to literature from Francis’ Somerville Divestment Project and the Green-Rainbow Party’s “anti-Jewish articles and event notices which are shocking in their blatant incitement to Jew-hatred.†The letter and a packet of information were also sent to the Andover School Committee and Andover school administrators.
The letter begins: “As residents of Somerville, we are all too familiar with the hate-filled anti-Semitic propaganda that Mr. Francis and his organization (the Somerville Divestment Project) injected into our community.â€
Francis recently sent an e-mail to members of the Green-Rainbow Party Administrative Committee to arrange for Andover High School students to receive academic credit for serving as interns with the Green-Rainbow Party. So far, the Andover School Committee is not investigating this matter. Not surprisingly, the Andover Teachers’ Union president, Tom Meyers, is defending Francis.
Francis admitted in another Andover Townsman article that he paid four Andover students to canvas in Somerville for the Somerville Divestment Project...
Much more, here.
As far as I am aware, Andover parents remain silent, content to utilize Francis's connections (he's an MIT grad) for their own kids while he has exported his anti-Jewish activities to other towns. At the same time, they continue to pay his salary. Perhaps now that it is being exposed that he has been indoctrinating some of the kids in Andover as well, they will recognize their responsibility to speak up.
French Court Dismisses Malicious SLAPP 'Libel' Suit against Finkielkraut
Israpundit reports good news:
Interviewed in 2003 on the French Jewish radio RJC about Eyal Sivan’s film, “Route 181, fragments d’un voyage en Palestine-Israel” (Road 181, Extracts from a Palestinian-Israeli journey), which was broadcast on a TV station, Finkielkraut called the film maker “one of the actors of today’s particularly hard and frightening Jewish anti-Semitism”.
The philosopher criticised Sivan for having made a link between the Israeli treatment of the Palestinians and the Holocaust.
“But those who are sewing a Star of David on our chest want to claim the yellow star for themselves,” Finkielkraut said at the time.
Eyal Sivan, a leftwing militant, decided to sue Finkielkraut for his “slanderous words which constitute an infringement to my honour and consideration”.
In the past, Eyal Sivan has supported actively the boycott of Israeli products in order to denounce Israeli policies towards the Palestinians.
Israeli professor and former ambassador to France Eli Barnavi testified in court for Alain Finkielkraut while two other Israeli professors, among them Haim Bresheeth, testified in favour of Sivan...
...Finkielkraut, who also received the support of Claude Lanzmann, director of the famous film “Shoah”, said that he reacted to the “violent unilateral character” of Sivan’s movie which represents the history of Israeli-Palestinian relations “as the aggression of one people crazed by the Shoah against a profoundly peaceful people.”
“I don’t know why this man is indignant about being called anti-Semitic, that’s what he is,” Lanzmann said when he testified in favour of FInkielkraut...
New U.N. Human Rights Body Singles Out Israel
As long as the UN is full of unaccountable tyrannies, we'll have to put up with this sort of thing. The best we can do is mitigate the damage.
New U.N. Human Rights Body Singles Out Israel
The council did not pass specific resolutions on the deteriorating situation in Sudan or violations of rights in any other country. On the last day of its inaugural session, however, it voted to condemn alleged Israeli violations. It also decided to extend indefinitely the mandate of the special rapporteur there. And as soon as the session ended, the council immediately decided, with the support of more than the required third of its membership, to convene the emergency session that will begin today.
"The council's singling out the Occupied Palestinian Territories for special attention is a cause for concern," Human Rights Watch's Peggy Hicks said in a statement. "The human rights situation in the Occupied Palestinian Territories deserves attention, but the new council must bring the same vigor to its consideration of other pressing situations."
On the other hand, Amnesty International, according to a statement on its Web site, "welcomes the Council's decision to convene a Special Session on human rights in the Occupied Palestinian Territories and calls for concrete action to address the gross human rights abuses currently taking place there."...
...The emergency session's resolution proposal is sponsored by mostly Arab and Islamic countries, including Sudan. A draft, seen by The New York Sun, is presented by Tunisia, which currently holds the presidency of the Arab group, and is co-sponsored by 13 Islamic and Arab countries, as well as Cuba. In addition to Sudan, the signatories include Saudi Arabia, Syria, and Egypt. The proposal is widely expected to pass by a sizable margin...
Hillel Halkin: Don't Be Cowed
A sad, but probably accurate, assessment of Israel's prospects in Gaza. Most is hidden behind subscriber registration, but here's the bottom line:
In the 1985 exchange with Ahmed Jibril's Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, for example, Israel swapped 1150 convicted terrorists for three of its soldiers. In the 2004 exchange with Hezbollah for kidnapped Israeli businessman Elhanan Tannenbaum, 460 Lebanese and Palestinians were let go. In both of these cases, a large number of those released returned to a life of anti-Israel violence. Gilad Shalit's captors have publicly declared their intention of freeing similar numbers of their brethren from Israeli prisons.
For Israel to give in to such demands now could have catastrophic consequences for the future. There would not be an Israeli at home or abroad who would not be the next potential victim of an abduction. The only way to reduce the price of extortion is not to pay it.
Does this mean that, if Israel is to behave responsibly toward itself and its own citizens, Gilad Shalit's life may have to be forfeit? The awful answer is: Yes. Corporal Shalit was a soldier, two of whose comrades were killed in the same action he was taken prisoner in. If their lives, like that of all combat soldiers, were considered to be riskable in the service of their country, his may have to be also.
Not to be cowed by Palestinian extortion - to put an end to the rocketing of Israeli settlements - to make Hamas realize its limits: These are all legitimate aims of Israel's current incursion into Gaza. Any one of them may have a better chance of succeeding than does freeing Gilad Shalit.
Tuesday, July 4, 2006
Keith's Second Letter
Tom Glennon's nephew Keith checks in with another note home describing his training before shipping out to Afghanistan (previous, here): Keith Letters Home #2
We started our final phase of training and started off with TCP, or Traffic Control Point Operations. The purpose of a TCP is to, obviously, control traffic, but it is used more as a check point. The task was to establish this check point and control the flow of contraband in and out of not only our check point, but also the nearby village that was populated with role players. The training lasted for 3 days with the last day consisting of a practical exercise. From the moment we established the check point the scenarios started. I was assigned as the NCO in charge of the entry point nearest the village, and I loved it. It gave me a chance to use my brain, which the Army doesn’t always allow you to do. It was our mission to handle the “villagers” as they approached asking for assistance, taking photographs, trying to steal our supplies, and smuggle weapons or explosives through our point. Luckily, we were able to stop the influx of all contraband, much to the dismay of our instructors. Finally, they “killed” me by sniper fire in an attempt to disrupt our operation, but it didn’t work. Another member of our detachment, who is also a cop, took over and we moved right along.
At the conclusion of our training the instructors advised us that they had been trying to “kill” us all day long, but we weren’t giving them the opportunity. All in all it was good training and I enjoyed it very much. I especially enjoyed the chance to interact with the role players and have to think on my feet and adapt to the situation...
Playing with fireworks
Mediating the mosque dispute
An "interfaith panel" has stepped in to try to mediate the legal disputes over the construction of the embattled Boston Mosque.
Boston Globe: Mediating the mosque dispute
The 40-member panel of ministers, priests, rabbis, and laymen has talked with both sides in the battle: a Jewish group that accuses the mosque's developers of anti-Semitic views and terrorist sympathies, and the Muslim group building the mosque, which has sued the Jewish group and several of its allies for defamation and conspiracy.
Each side presented its case to the panel and was told that court was not the place to resolve the dispute, according to participants in the reconciliation effort.
The religious leaders fear that the acrimony and public posturing that have accompanied complex legal maneuvers will poison interreligious relations in the wider community and create resentment that will endure even if the disagreements are resolved in the courts.
A subcommittee met Thursday to plan further steps. Members of the panel include the Rev. Raymond G. Helmick, who has been involved in high-level mediation efforts in Northern Ireland, the Balkans, and the Middle East, and Rabbi Harold S. Kushner, author of the bestseller, ``Why Bad Things Happen to Good People."
Panel members say they hope to create a more civil environment around the mosque issue and to encourage direct communication between the two sides.
``They are very angry," said Helmick, a Jesuit priest on the theology faculty of Boston College. ``Anger is not a very good basis for conduct or for policy. . . . We are really anxious that this [mosque project] not become a community-destroying thing. There are a lot of people on both sides anxious to see some reconciliation."
Kushner said the mediators would suggest to the two sides that, if they continue their court fight, ``this will not be a matter of somebody winning and somebody losing, but of everybody losing. . . . Victory for one side will just leave the other side aggrieved."
The Islamic Society of Boston, the Cambridge-based organization designated by the Boston Redevelopment Authority to build New England's largest mosque on a 1.9-acre site in Roxbury Crossing, presented its view of the conflict to members of the interreligious center May 11. The David Project, a Jewish leadership center, made its presentation on June 12...
It frankly sounds like a lot of feel-good, "let's keep talking," bullshit that will lead nowhere to me. But you never know.
Happy Fourth of July!
Click the image above to go to the National Archives page. I particularly like this page with the original rough draft showing cross outs and corrections made by John Adams and Benjamin Franklin.
What a great day to remember what a great country we live in! I remember arguing with a Swede over the concept of patriotism. He was contemptuous of the idea, of course. After all, he had nothing to be proud of since his presence in his country was just an accident of birth, as it is with most of us. But that misses the point -- of course no one today was alive when the nation was founded and so we share only limited credit -- but the point is not to screw it up! It's our job to keep it going, pass it on to the next generation, and exercise a little civic responsibility -- something that encompasses a practical collection of stuff from not littering to loving they neighbor. [All this excludes those serving in the military, who certainly do contribute even more directly to the perpetuation of the ideal...but try explaining that to the average Swede -- with apologies to any extraordinary Swedes who may read this.]
I'm off to a cookout.

Update before I scram: Michelle has a round-up of links, from which, this:
'How sweet is the fragrance of the earth, its thirst quenched by the gush of blood, flowing from the youthful body'
The Palestinian Authority is in full child-recruitment mode, recycling their old Muhammed al Dura clips to gear the kids up to die. Sick stuff.
Now, after nearly three years, the PA has suddenly started rebroadcasting the Al Dura in Paradise video. The clip features a child actor playing Muhammad Al Dura, whose death in a crossfire in 2000 was broadcast to the entire world, calling on children to join him in Paradise. In Child-Martyr Paradise, Al Dura is playing with kites and Ferris wheels, presenting an ideal children's world that is designed to attract young naive children. And it opens with the words from Al Dura to the living children: "I am waving not to part but to say: 'Follow me'."
There are numerous reasons for the sudden encouragement now of children to seek heroic death. The PA, has its image blackened by the kidnapping of soldier Gilad Shalit, the killings of soldiers and the continuous missile barrage on southern Israel. Certainly the PA wants to reposition itself as the victim, something that they successfully achieved in the past by sending children to combat zones, and achieving their goal through dead and injured Palestinian children to report to the media.
As Israel re-enters the Gaza Strip to search for terrorists and the kidnapped Israeli soldier, the sudden encouragement of children to seek death indicates the PA is in all likelihood returning to this previously successful tactic of using children as human shields for terrorists. It makes it more difficult for Israeli soldiers to fight terrorist, and it creates ideal photo opportunities of children armed only with stones, "bravely" confronting heavily-armed soldiers.
Children are taught that the short cut to both glory and fun is to follow Al Dura to heaven. Some of these children inevitably will be caught in the crossfire, PA leaders will rush to the media to publicly mourn the children they have so deceitfully sent to their deaths, and Israel will once again be condemned...
The following is the text of the Al Dura in Paradise clip:
"How sweet is the fragrance of the martyrs,
how sweet is the fragrance of the earth,
its thirst quenched by the gush of blood
flowing from the youthful body."
Caption: "And so he went..."
Choir: "Goodbye to the boy Muhammad"...
Richard Landes comments here: Al Durah's Back: Watch out for MDPH
Then of course there's this, from Egyptian TV:

A pair of appalling MEMRITV clips posted at LGF: Egyptian Cleric Teaching Death Cult Ideology to Kids
Where is Human Rights Watch? Where are the churches? Where are all the peace and justice NGO's while children are being indoctrinated to this kind of hate? If the Israelis or, God forbid, Americans ever broadcast propaganda like this, imagine the uproar.
Sunday, July 2, 2006
Nazis and Islamo-Nazis
WILLisms has a look at the connections:
Sounds like something Osama bin Laden would urge, doesn't it? Actually, this quote was uttered long before bin Laden was even born, by Amin al-Husseini, (1895-1974) Grand Mufti of Jerusalem. The biography of Husseini reminds us that the term 'Islamofascism' is no mere neologism aimed at extreme Muslims in the wake of 9/11 - it is also a reminder of the Nazi roots of extreme Muslim anti-semitism that still rages today...
[via TigerHawk]
A timely post since I happen to be most of the way through Bernard Lewis's, Semites and Anti-Semites: An Inquiry into Conflict and Prejudice -- a highly readable account of the way in which traditional European-style anti-Semitism wended its way into the Middle East. Did you know, for instance, that in the 1960's the Arab League actively lobbied the Vatican not to absolve the Jews of the sin of deicide at the Second Vatican Council, for instance?
Lewis notes, "The gentle threat in the last sentence was made clearer in more popular publications." It should be a threat that sounds familiar even today.
Readers with a few minutes on their hands may be interested in my write-up of a lecture Lewis delivered on the subject two years ago at Brandeis, here: Report on the Lecture by Bernard Lewis - "The New Antisemitism, First Religion, Then Race, Then What?"
Has Israel lost the spirit of '76? (Update)
Those of us who met him on Thursday knew Jeff Jacoby's subject for today's column would be "Gaza," and today we get to see the result. Although I was (and am) a supporter of the Gaza withdrawal, Jacoby's column is a good one. Has Israel lost the spirit of '76?
So more terrorism followed. ``In just the past two weeks," I wrote last September, ``a Palestinian knifed a Jewish student to death in Jerusalem's Old City, an Israeli policemen was stabbed in the throat by an Arab in Hebron, Kassam rockets were fired from Gaza into the southern Israeli town of Sderot, a suicide bomber blew himself up in Beersheba's crowded bus station, a Katyusha missile launched from Lebanon exploded in the Israeli village of Margaliot, a firebomb was thrown at an Israeli vehicle on a highway outside Jerusalem, and a 14-year-old boy from Nablus was caught with three bombs."
In the months since then, the Palestinian war against Israel has continued without letup. All that changed was the frontline -- with the Jewish settlements and soldiers gone, it moved right up to the border, making it easier than ever for attacks to penetrate Israeli territory. The Gaza security fence has been no panacea. Sderot and other towns in southern Israel have been bombarded by hundreds of rockets fired over the fence. The gunmen who abducted Shalit and killed two of his comrades entered Israel by tunneling under the fence...
I don't think, by the way, that the Israelis have lost the spirit of '76, I just think a jaded and myopic world, particularly the world press, won't cast them in the heroic role they once did. I realize it's not exactly Jeff's point, but the heroes are still there.
Update: As an example of how things have changed, take a look at this Life Magazine cover from 1967.
Saturday, July 1, 2006
Hamas: 'No Matter What, the Violence Will Never Stop'
Absolutely must-read interview with Hamas second in command, Mousa Mohammed Abu Marzook, in Der Spiegel: "No Matter What, the Violence Will Never Stop" [via LGF] Excerpts:
SPIEGEL ONLINE: Israel has accused the political office of Hamas of organizing the abduction of Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit. Was this kidnapping ordered by Damascus?
Abu Marzook: No, that is not true. Israel has often falsely accused us in similar instances. It is not our task to make such decisions: They are made by the military wing. The military and political wings work independently of each other.
SPIEGEL ONLINE: That means that the political leaders are not consulted prior to an action?
Abu Marzook: We are no experts here on military issues. We never know in advance about military actions, when or how they take place.
SPIEGEL ONLINE: That would indicate that there is no coordination between the wings of Hamas.
Abu Marzook: But of course there is, because our actions relate to the same strategy, under which everything is organized. And that strategy is to resist the occupation of Palestine. A part of Hamas pursues this goal politically, and another pursues it militarily.
SPIEGEL ONLINE: Now, Hamas has approved the so-called "Prisoners' Paper," which recommends a two-state solution. Does that mean that Hamas is now prepared to recognize the state of Israel?
Abu Marzook: With this agreement, we have primarily agreed to strengthen the resistance in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank. Aside from that, we have agreed on the goal of establishing a Palestinian state in these areas.
SPIEGEL ONLINE: Doesn't that mean that Hamas inevitably accepts the Israeli state in the rest of that area?
Abu Marzook: The paper does not say that at all. It is purely about the future of our people and about how a government uniting all Palestinian factions can work on building their independent state.
SPIEGEL ONLINE: And does Hamas also believe that an Israeli state can exist alongside a Palestinian state?
Abu Marzook: Hamas has always said clearly: We will never accept the occupation, because it is not legal, not correct and not just...
...SPIEGEL ONLINE: It is hard to imagine that approach would ever bring an end to reciprocal violence.
Abu Marzook: No matter what, the violence will not stop. We are on the weaker side and we do whatever we can. The Palestinians have no other choice.
SPIEGEL ONLINE: The Palestinian head of government Ismail Haniyeh, also from Hamas, recently showed himself to be more diplomatic than the political leadership in Damascus. That suggests a certain lack of unity in Hamas.
Abu Marzook: No, there is no split, just various approaches. The government, the military wing and the political office all follow the same strategy, but each one works in a manner appropriate to his tasks...
Of course, I don't know why I'm telling you all this, but on the off chance someone who doesn't already understand the above should stop by...
Oh, and remember, when Hamas says they want a Palestinian State: it doesn't mean they accept another state on the rest of the land west of the Jordan, and when they say they have a right to fight "the occupation," it's all the occupation.
Pictures of Crazy
Atlas was at an International ANSWER sponsored moonbat convergence in front of the Israeli Consulate in New York City last night. There's video. Don't miss it: Pali Hate Protest Against Israel NYC
Oh, and she's also got an exclusive essay by Nidra Poller writing from France.
One Note Greens in Michigan -- and Mass. Greens Lose Another One
The Green-Rainbow Party of Massachusetts isn't the only branch of the organization having trouble with the Middle East obsessives in its midst driving out other members (see previous: Greens, a High School Teacher and a City Councillor United in Hateful Protest and Green-Rainbow Party Suffers Backlash After anti-Israel Endorsement). The Ann Arbor, Michigan branch (why is it not surprising?) is experiencing the same phenomenon: Local Green Party pushes divestment from Israel
Henry Herskovitz, a member of Jewish Witnesses For Peace And Friends, said he is considering running for the City Council in the 5th Ward and his platform will be divestment from Israel. His group has been protesting outside Beth Israel Congregation synagogue before Saturday services every week for the past several years.
"If I have to run for City Council office to get that message out, I will do that,'' Herskovitz said...
... Herskovitz said he joined the Green Party in April. He said four others from his group are members of the Green Party. The Huron Valley Greens caucus is July 12. At that time, the party would have to announce its candidates for the Nov. 7 general election. The deadline has already passed for major party candidates to file, but so-called minor political parties have until July 20.
Marc Reichardt had been the face of the local Green Party for several years, as well as the former state chairman of the political organization, but he said he is no longer active in the party. He blamed a combination of burnout and frustration with the "tunnel vision'' of the pro-Palestinian activists.
"Anyone not helping them with their single issue is some kind of heretic,'' Reichardt said.
Pete Schermerhorn, the Michigan organizer for the Green Party, said it's partially true that the pro-Palestinian activists have taken over the party.
"Some joined recently,'' he said. "Some have been members for years. They've definitely perked up the energy level and, to some degree, redirected it.''...
The trouble for the Greens is, of course, that since they are already a fairly fringe party with a small membership, it makes them ripe for the picking by even more radical groups with even smaller, highly motivated memberships. It only takes a handful of people to insert themselves into positions of influence and use their like-mindedness to co-opt and redirect the organization, driving out others and accelerating and cementing the process -- political parasitism.
One current City Councilor is bemused:
"We deal with issues such as water and sewer rates, parks and street maintenance and downtown development,'' Lowenstein said. "Relations with foreign countries doesn't fit it to what our charter says we should do.''...
We can't blame Ann Arbor for this completely. We in Boston have been exporting our problems to them:
Smith moved to Ann Arbor 1 1/2 years ago. She said she joined the Jewish Witnesses For Peace And Friends shortly after arriving in town and has attended the protests at the synagogue...
Aimee Smith is the nutty protester with the potty mouth in this post from two years ago: Boston for Israel Rally - Jerusalem Bus #19 - Report with Pics [Part 1], and I believe that was she in this year's protest (pic - the one with the "Colonial Conquest..." sign). The occasionally arrested Smith is a former candidate for Cambridge (Mass.) City Council. Say, you think these folks pay for their own travel?
Meanwhile, back here in Massachusetts, Ron Francis's GRP has lost another one:
Gettysburg
The Battle of Gettysburg began 143 years ago today. Director of the Civil War Institute at Gettysburg College, Gabor Boritt, recommends his top five books on the battle.
Gaza from Egypt
Interesting post by the Ranting Sandmonkey on Gaza.
LibraryThing
This is neat (via Martin Kramer): LibraryThing
It's basically your own virtual bookshelf. You register an account (nothing more to do than creating a username and password -- not even an email required), then you start plugging your books in. Not only does it save your books for you, complete with cover graphics if available, but you can see who else on the service has the same books you have -- kind of neat for those rare books you figured you were the only person to own. If you have a lot of books it's pretty time-consuming to put your list in -- I'm only about 15% through my shelves and I hope I don't lose interest before I finish, but I think it will be useful once I'm done. My shelf so far.